The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Newsnight Scotland, 7-11-11

Posted on November 08, 2011 by

A fairly in-depth lead piece on the "devo max" conundrum, including an interview with referendum expert Dr Matt Qvortrup who, under very determined and persistent questioning from an unhappy Glenn Campbell, offered the professional opinion that a notional two-question poll where Q1 was "Do you want more powers for the Scottish Parliament?" and Q2 was "Do you also want full independence?" would be both legitimate and fair, and also that in his view, a vote of 51% for independence in such a scenario would mean independence for Scotland, regardless of whether the "devo max" question received a higher vote.

The unambiguous clarification of Dr Qvortrup's position was welcome given the strenuous attempts by the Unionist parties to misrepresent it last week, after the First Minister gave what turned out to be an entirely accurate summary of Dr Qvortrup's views, but one based on an erroneous source. Dr Qvortrup confirmed that he'd spoken to the First Minister and accepted his "misquote" was an honest error rather than an attempt to portray his views inaccurately.

The episode also featured a piece on whether the Scottish Conservatives can recover from the divisions caused by their leadership contest, in which party donor John McGlynn called for a change in direction.

Comment - please read this page for comment rules. HTML tags like <i> and <b> are permitted. Use paragraph breaks in long comments. DO NOT SIGN YOUR COMMENTS, either with a name or a slogan. If your comment does not appear immediately, DO NOT REPOST IT. Ignore these rules and I WILL KILL YOU WITH HAMMERS.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,993 Posts, 1,253,912 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Captain Caveman on How To Succeed In Scotland: ““It really is incumbent on all of us, CC, to continue to expose what clings to the Scottish Indy movement,…” Nov 16, 14:46
    • Captain Caveman on How To Succeed In Scotland: ““They’ve lived under illegal sanctions for decades” “Illegal” sanctions you say – how precisely are they supposedly illegal? On the…” Nov 16, 14:41
    • Lorncal on How To Succeed In Scotland: “I know, 100%, that the SNP leadership and so many of those that fawn around it, are irredeemable and should…” Nov 16, 14:11
    • Lorncal on How To Succeed In Scotland: “The ‘gender’ thingy was never a distraction, Geri. It was the vanguard of a huge ‘woke’ – post modernist/cultural Marxist…” Nov 16, 13:57
    • Hatey McHateface on How To Succeed In Scotland: ““I’m terrified and despairing” Naw, sarah, you’re not. Genuine question. If anybody knows of a more self-pitying, hysterically over exaggerating…” Nov 16, 13:39
    • Hatey McHateface on How To Succeed In Scotland: “I guess, Alf, we have to learn to separate Memmi’s “objective of the coloniser” from the common sense “objective of…” Nov 16, 13:32
    • sarah on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Yes indeed. We are all completely at the mercy of international profit-makers who have no concern for our welfare. Does…” Nov 16, 13:08
    • Alf Baird on How To Succeed In Scotland: ““make it even harder for us to break away and become independent” Some here appear to be doing a good…” Nov 16, 13:01
    • Hatey McHateface on How To Succeed In Scotland: “I’m certainly smart enough to understand that if it’s the will of the Scottish people (it’s certainly the will of…” Nov 16, 12:37
    • Hatey McHateface on How To Succeed In Scotland: ““They’re considerably better off than you are” There you go, CC, that’s you been told. Told by somebody who would…” Nov 16, 12:22
    • Hatey McHateface on How To Succeed In Scotland: ““she stuffed every seat in Holyrood with fuckwits” Inexplicable you don’t have one. Then again, maybe you do. Your inability…” Nov 16, 12:13
    • Hatey McHateface on How To Succeed In Scotland: ““The British Bulldog with no teeth, bad legs, failing eyesight living on ever more meagre rations is there for all…” Nov 16, 12:07
    • Geri on How To Succeed In Scotland: “They’ve lived under illegal sanctions for decades. Imposed on them by Colonisers unable to accept they’ll not bend the knee.…” Nov 16, 12:00
    • Hatey McHateface on How To Succeed In Scotland: ““Colonisers are on their way out” Oh dear, Geri. Poot’s nae gonna like ye saying that.” Nov 16, 11:59
    • Geri on How To Succeed In Scotland: “The English are colonised by America. The dumbos on the street just haven’t cottoned on yet. They sold the family…” Nov 16, 11:40
    • Captain Caveman on How To Succeed In Scotland: “@Geri Your blaming the domestic atrocities and suffocating lack of freedoms in modern “I” – fully half a century after…” Nov 16, 11:32
    • Geri on How To Succeed In Scotland: “SNP have deliberately styled themselves as new labour. Sturgeons intake was to quash any notion of independence. She made sure…” Nov 16, 11:19
    • willie on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Couldn’t help but reflect on the nuclear submarine that’s just come back after being at sea for six months. When…” Nov 16, 11:18
    • Geri on How To Succeed In Scotland: “All in hand, shit face. Events, dear boy, events. Colonisers are on their way out. Dumb placemen are too. Tho,…” Nov 16, 10:03
    • Hatey McHateface on How To Succeed In Scotland: ““In any other walk of life they’d be run tae fuck out of town” It would be highly popular, Geri.…” Nov 16, 09:27
    • Hatey McHateface on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Organ harvesting, Geri. You forgot to rant and rave about organ harvesting. Oh, and industrialised baby farming for food. You…” Nov 16, 08:16
    • Geri on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Well, Shit face, we certainly wouldn’t have ended up with them as anti social neighbours! A blight on this island…” Nov 16, 00:41
    • Hatey McHateface on How To Succeed In Scotland: ““decided to come down & mate with the womenfolk instead” Crivens, Geri, if only you had been on hand, how…” Nov 15, 22:04
    • Lorncal on How To Succeed In Scotland: “You may be right, H McH. I also acknowledge that you are right about the SNP voters, but, while all…” Nov 15, 21:47
    • Hatey McHateface on How To Succeed In Scotland: ““Who am I to burst yer wee delusional bubble” Now you’re getting metaphysical, Geri. Can one delusional bubble burst another?…” Nov 15, 21:39
    • Geri on How To Succeed In Scotland: “I’ve been watching some of those documentaries about the Book of Enoch. Fascinating stuff. So apparently, the watchers were sent…” Nov 15, 21:22
    • Geri on How To Succeed In Scotland: “The atrocities the English have committed around the globe is FACT & It is current. It didn’t end with the…” Nov 15, 20:50
    • Hatey McHateface on How To Succeed In Scotland: ““It’s also a FACT that the most brutal dictators around the globe, including the ex shah of I – were…” Nov 15, 20:24
    • Hatey McHateface on How To Succeed In Scotland: ““Every self-respecting Scot should be ashamed and very, very angry” If we define an ashamed and angry self-respecting Scot as…” Nov 15, 20:12
    • Geri on How To Succeed In Scotland: “You know, Cappy, You’ve zero self awareness. The English are the biggest terrorists in the world & personally responsible for…” Nov 15, 19:57
  • A tall tale



↑ Top