The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland



The Red Squirrel Papers 78

Posted on March 23, 2014 by

Earlier this week we noticed the curious lack of media coverage of the “Devo Nano” report. As the document spelling out Labour’s “more powers” offer to Scotland in the event of a No vote, its release was ostensibly the most important milestone so far in the independence debate, so we found it very strange to see it get such a muted reception, particularly from the Daily Record.

1888

Two days later the explanation arrived, in the form of the so-called “Red Paper”. Described by some journalists as a “mini-manifesto”, it was a 64-page uncosted wishlist of vague feelgood notions like reducing child poverty. (A brave, daring and controversial step there to be sure.) And this time the papers were all over it.

Read the rest of this entry →

A small exaggeration 103

Posted on March 20, 2014 by

The SNP has made hay with the damning appraisal of Scottish Labour’s “Devo Nano” plans which was delivered this week by charity think-tank Reform Scotland, and in particular its rejection of Labour’s claims that the proposals would mean Holyrood raising 40% of its own budget.

(As we’ve noted before, we’re not very sure why anyone’s meant to find that exciting anyway. You don’t make a difference to society by changing the address of the tax office, you make it by changing what you spend your money on.)

Because it looks, not for the first time, as if Labour’s got its sums wildly wrong.

Read the rest of this entry →

More powerful microscope required 73

Posted on March 20, 2014 by

All this week we’ve been mockingly referring to Scottish Labour’s devolution proposals as “Devo Nano”, nano- being a mathematical term meaning “one billionth”. The implication there is that the amount of actual power being devolved would be very very small. We’re not subtle. But as we dig down into the full 298-page report, it’s beginning to look as though our sarcastic description is in fact somewhat over-generous.

Read the rest of this entry →

The long and the short of it 77

Posted on March 20, 2014 by

Labour’s full Devo Nano policy document is now available, at an artery-clogging 298 pages. We’ll be having a good old wade through it today, because despite Johann Lamont’s comprehensive explanation of its contents on telly on Tuesday night, we still have a couple of minor queries over the precise details that we’d like to get definitively cleared up, and this should do it.

Read the rest of this entry →

Distraction strategies 56

Posted on April 16, 2013 by

It’s gone midnight and we don’t normally do speculation, but as it’s already showing up in our incoming searches we’ve spent the last little while trying to work out what’s gone on between SNP MP Angus Robertson, Labour MP John Mann and the Herald in the last 24 hours. So first let’s establish the known facts, then have the attempted deduction, and hopefully by the morning read the official clarifications.

Read the rest of this entry →

Labour policies finally revealed 31

Posted on March 18, 2013 by

skw1

Read the rest of this entry →

  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,778 Posts, 1,220,112 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • agent x on Holiday Relief: “” Swinney continued: “Today, you’ve heard something of my answer, something of my ambition for Scotland. “It is a vision…Jun 17, 14:37
    • Jim Thomson on Holiday Relief: “You do realise that you’ve gifted JK (no, not the Harry Potter one) with his next slur piece? It’ll be…Jun 17, 14:37
    • 100%Yes on Holiday Relief: “Grok, might even get into conversation with our people, what a thought. A real AI wanting to communicate and discuss…Jun 17, 13:58
    • sam on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “After you, Clod. I’ll buy you a ticket to a “bottomless pit of hell, money and despair”. Do stay for…Jun 17, 13:48
    • Eric on Holiday Relief: “An attempt by Redactable John to avoid being Jilted John. Has he ever delivered anything noteworthy? “Reach” sounds very subjective.…Jun 17, 13:32
    • Peter McAvoy on Holiday Relief: “The national online today reports that another block of student flats has been approved. When will somebody tell the local…Jun 17, 13:12
    • Lewis Moonie on Holiday Relief: “Within reach? I wish. Depends how long his arms are I suppose.Jun 17, 13:09
    • PhilM on Holiday Relief: “I’ve got to say I’m feeling bereft today. I had great expectations for Walter White look-alike John Swinney but reading…Jun 17, 12:47
    • Jim Bo on Holiday Relief: “Impressive AI summary that. Are you sure you didn’t write it Stu?Jun 17, 12:39
    • auld highlander on Holiday Relief: “A bowl of cold porridge has more charisma.Jun 17, 12:25
    • Peter S on Holiday Relief: “John – bless him! – is either fibbing or deluded (or both!)Jun 17, 12:15
    • MaryB on Holiday Relief: “It was far more useful and positive to talk about the evils of nuclear waste dumping on the last thread.…Jun 17, 12:11
    • Ian on Holiday Relief: “I, for one, welcome Grok over Scotland as our new overlord.Jun 17, 12:06
    • Hatey McHateface on Holiday Relief: “And remember, whatever you do, don’t mention the war.Jun 17, 12:04
    • James Barr Gardner on Holiday Relief: “John Swinney up there in the charisma stakes with Blair Jenkins……….remember him……lol…Jun 17, 11:44
    • Ian McCubbin on Holiday Relief: “Sorted enjoy your walk Stu.Jun 17, 11:43
    • MaryB on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “I wrote this earlier but it’s not been posted. So I’ll try again. There’s long been a conspiracy of silence…Jun 17, 11:26
    • robertkknight on Holiday Relief: “Swinney…not waving, but drowning.Jun 17, 11:05
    • TURABDIN on Holiday Relief: “«VISION….modern, dynamic and forward looking» …flatliningly dull AI text for sure. Its all in the training. YOU THINK SWINNEY BORING?…Jun 17, 11:04
    • Xaracen on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “Aidan, there was no automatic rejection of Scotland’s petition. The JPTI submissions specific to Scotland were acknowledged at the 2025…Jun 17, 10:59
    • joolz on Holiday Relief: “‘Sitcom punchline’indeed. Perfect analogy.Jun 17, 10:57
    • agent x on Holiday Relief: ““In a proposed keynote speech, Swinney said: “It is only by taking charge of our own destiny, with our own…Jun 17, 10:56
    • Anthem on Holiday Relief: “So true.Jun 17, 10:47
    • Dave on Holiday Relief: “‘Holiday Relief’ ‘We’re off for a wa*k.’ ‘Sounds about right to us.’ 😉Jun 17, 10:44
    • duncanio on Holiday Relief: “It’s all about visions for Swinney. Blurred vision that is. There is nothing about HOW independent statehood will be realised…Jun 17, 10:31
    • Captain Caveman on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “@Hatey Using gas engines (e.g. Jenbachers) to generate electricity is hardly new (and also, potentially, hot water for CHP -…Jun 17, 09:57
    • MaryB on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “Insider I used to know the area well and I used to hear all the local gossip that didn’t get…Jun 17, 09:41
    • Hatey McHateface on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “Geoffrey Clifton-Brown, the Tory MP who chairs the PAC. “When visiting the site, it is impossible not to be struck…Jun 17, 09:40
    • Southernbystander on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “You’d get terrible indigestionJun 17, 09:05
    • diabloandco on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “Add on Hunterston and it’s well documented leaks and the several ‘wee’ accidents at Faslane and Coulport, also well documented…Jun 17, 08:53
  • A tall tale



↑ Top