The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland



The not-so-straight debates 168

Posted on January 15, 2013 by

Writing a site like this is in one sense an exercise in idealistic cognitive dissonance. No matter how often the opposite turns out to be the case, you always sort of hope, deep down, that if you highlight someone’s occasional failings in a calm and factual manner they’ll say “Oh well, that’s a fair cop”, and even if they don’t change their ways they’ll at least acknowledge the validity of legitimate, honest criticism.

But as we say, it rarely turns out that way. Last night we picked up on what was at heart a fairly minor semantic quibble with high-profile Scottish-politics commentator David Torrance, arising from the evening’s edition of Scotland Tonight. He got in touch with us on Twitter almost immediately to object in rather strong terms to our views, and an exchange went on until around 2am when everyone seemingly went to bed.

We thought no more of it, although we hoped this morning that there might be some answers to some questions that Mr Torrance had explicitly invited during the debate. Instead, to our surprise (we know, still) and dismay, not only were none to be found, but the entire discussion – at his end, anyway – had completely vanished.

Read the rest of this entry →

Making new friends 75

Posted on November 19, 2012 by

Wowsers. We’re really feeling the love today, readers. There’s currently – as there always is – a debate going on about those dreadful cybernats and how they’re solely responsible for all the horribleness on the internet. Here’s an extract from it.

For those of you joining us late, that’s one Scotsman writer, one Green Party PR person and two loonies ranged against us, “Ergasiophobe” being our much-missed former comment troll “Longshanker”. (And we’ve just noticed our old pal Kate Higgins sticking her oar in too. Just one missing for the full set.)

What with the constant threats of defamation action from people we haven’t defamed and the open stalking from people threatening to reveal mysterious “info” about us, we’re getting pretty intimidated now. We’ll almost definitely stop. (Mr McColm, in another tweet, says “i have learned enough to stop him”, which might save us the bother.) Or maybe, on the other hand, we won’t. Who can tell?

We got a birthday card! 89

Posted on November 01, 2012 by

It’s got flowers on it and everything.

Gemma Fox is a rather strange lady who makes Lego dioramas of Royal Marine Commandos and who we had a childish but enlightening recreational argument with on Twitter last night. (Funnily enough after a long and tiring day visiting the Fleet Air Arm Museum in Yeovilton.) James Mackenzie is a Green activist and one of the editors of the once-popular and increasingly-ironically-named Better Nation blog.

(Mackenzie threw an impressive hissy fit earlier this week when we very politely challenged him to support a seemingly-baseless allegation about another blogger, even going so far as to claim “harassment” on the basis of someone responding civilly to comments made in an open public forum. Presumably, as a Better Nation editor he’s just not used to people answering him back without being able to censor them.)

Ms Fox generously warned us last night that we had until “2000 hrs” this evening to delete unspecified tweets from our account, and that we should also “warn yer pals”. (We’re not quite sure who that means, but it might be you, so we thought we’d better let you know.) If we vanish suddenly at 8.01pm under legal action – the threat of which we’re sure is real and serious, and definitely not just the mad rantings of a delusional internet lunatic – speak kindly of us when we’re gone. We had a good run.

  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,776 Posts, 1,219,821 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Dunx on The Grand Tour: “The Barrhead Boy article just reads as a wish list. He treats UDI as an end in itself. There’s nothing…Jun 12, 17:10
    • James Barr Gardner on The Grand Tour: “Scotland’s power requirement is under 5GW…… There must be a dale/tarn or two in Ye Merry Olde Engalunt that would…Jun 12, 17:07
    • agent x on The Grand Tour: “Hatey McHateface says: Rev Stu won’t live forever. ————————————— Is that what the polls say?Jun 12, 16:45
    • Insider on The Grand Tour: “Stuart… Give up son ! Hatey can swat away a dozen wannabe wee trolls like you in the blink of…Jun 12, 16:44
    • Hatey McHateface on The Grand Tour: “Couldn’t agree more, other than with not wanting a re-run soon. Let’s have the re-run, lance the boil, and Scotland…Jun 12, 15:56
    • sam on The Grand Tour: “Thon Caveman needs his erse skelpit. A ganch, skite or slabber. Shilpit.A wee scrunt, couldnae screeve. Anyone know the Sprachle…Jun 12, 15:26
    • Rob on The Grand Tour: “There is no block to independence through the SP is folk genuinely want it. It just takes a party standing…Jun 12, 15:17
    • Hatey McHateface on The Grand Tour: ““This is what more Scots, all Scots, should be made aware of” But when NC? The most momentous event in…Jun 12, 14:51
    • sarah on The Grand Tour: “@ Wally Jumblatt “If only high quality, non-party candidates were to step forwards.” Your wish has been answered. Liberate Scotland…Jun 12, 14:30
    • robertkknight on The Grand Tour: “Northcode… Couldn’t agree more!Jun 12, 14:07
    • Breastplate on The Grand Tour: “John Main, you can project (whine) all you want but you do well to avoid answering how Norway would fare…Jun 12, 14:03
    • Wally Jumblatt on The Grand Tour: “excellent and thorough work as ever, and as objective as possible I would think. What I suggest, however, is that…Jun 12, 13:56
    • Northcode on The Grand Tour: “This is what more Scots, all Scots, should be made aware of: “Scotland’s political and constitutional status aligns with the…Jun 12, 13:45
    • Breastplate on The Grand Tour: “I agree Alf, of course what Scotland is subject to is not any sort of partnership, as I think that…Jun 12, 13:27
    • Hatey McHateface on The Grand Tour: ““what if we were to ask ourselves what Norway would look like now if it were under Westminster rule for…Jun 12, 13:22
    • Hatey McHateface on The Grand Tour: “Two thoughts, BP: 1) Read Alf’s post above. The UN will be handing Scotland Independence any day soon. So retire…Jun 12, 13:12
    • Alf Baird on The Grand Tour: “Recent legal advice on the subject confirms there was no ‘Union’ and that what occurred in 1707 was the annexation…Jun 12, 12:50
    • Breastplate on The Grand Tour: “As you have pointed out, Scotland is in a complete mess because of Westminster’s priorities. A culmination of a complete…Jun 12, 12:22
    • Stuart MacKay on The Grand Tour: “So, you’re a Sovereign Scot that is happy to hand all decisions to another country. How does that work, Nora?Jun 12, 12:06
    • Hatey McHateface on The Grand Tour: “Thanks for the Guardian thingy. I don’t think the idea of Scots standing on our own two feet is despicable.…Jun 12, 11:22
    • Hatey McHateface on What We Don’t Know Now: ““It’s clear that English, although unable to scale the glorified heights of eloquence we see in Scots or Latin. is…Jun 12, 11:09
    • agent x on The Grand Tour: “Many of the most advanced pumped storage projects are located in Scotland, where the topography is better suited for large-scale…Jun 12, 11:03
    • Hatey McHateface on The Grand Tour: “Meantime, back on Planet Earth, Reeves has just announced a package of measures that will affect each and every Sovereign…Jun 12, 11:01
    • Ian Stewart on And No Great Mischief Should They Fall: “That’s a great analysis and a clever approach to achieving independence. Farage would maybe go for it. So Scots seeking…Jun 12, 10:52
    • Stuart MacKay on The Grand Tour: “Oh Anne, don’t you know that Hatey is the Guardian of Truth and Justice. Shining a light into the dark…Jun 12, 10:52
    • Breastplate on The Grand Tour: “As long as Scotland allows another country to make our decisions for us, we can expect more of the same.…Jun 12, 10:51
    • McDuff on The Grand Tour: “O/t A friend of mine text me a message to say that I should look at the synopsis of the…Jun 12, 10:50
    • Ian Stewart on The Jokers: “I’m rather proud of the voters in the place of my youth issuing a big FU to the election forecasters.…Jun 12, 10:29
    • Robinov Cybernat on What We Don’t Know Now: ““……and extrapolating a uniform national swing from it is a fun exercise for politics nerds but a fool’s errand as…Jun 12, 09:41
    • James Barr Gardner on The Grand Tour: “O/T British Hydropower Association Head Office, Sheffield. England has no pumped storage, none in Northern Ireland, Wales has 2 sites…Jun 12, 08:55
  • A tall tale



↑ Top