The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Stretch goal

Posted on February 18, 2014 by

If we should be fortunate enough to exceed the target in our imminent fundraiser, readers, we promise we’ll use any extra money to try to make this happen.

sillarsmcleish

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

85 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Andrew Morton

Brilliant!

X_Sticks

Count me in!

Morag

Can we not just do a straight swap? We take Henry and they can take Jim?

Les Wilson

That would be an interesting one, Sillers could question McLeish about his part in ceding 6,000sq miles of Scottish seas to England. That would bring out his true allegiances.
He is walking a middle roll, call it hedging his bets.

Do not forget he is a close friend of Gordon Brown, who he meets fairly often. So while we can maximise anything that could be construed as Pro Independence for our own purposes, we cannot assume he is on our side. He is on his own side only, just very sneaky how he presents it. Do not trust this man.

I doubt he could stand up to Sillars, and would not want such a debate.Whether you agree with Sillars or not, I personally question his timing to be negative all the time with the SNP, there would be no referendum without them.

He is however, very passionate about a YES vote, and would slay McLeish. It would be good though.

Murray McCallum

What a fantastic idea.

Maybe have it as a retrospective debate after 18th September though – “the campaign that never was” – to avoid the BBC having a bumper crop of anti-independence soundbites.

Seasick Dave

Reporting for duty.

balgayboy

Waste of time and money, these two have had plenty of air time voicing their obscure agenda.

Any extra cash could be spent on highlighting what WOS has excellently exposed the BT & MSM lies through billboarding throughout Scotland or at least advertising it’s website to get the truth.

More opportunity for YES votes with that than listening to two yesterday men squabbling.

Hetty

By ‘side’ presume they mean Labour. To work towards and support an Independent Scotland whatever their politics would be a better cause, for future generations, its whats important really.

Older people should be talking to the young and encouraging them to engage in the ‘debate’, maybe that’s what they mean is wrong, with a no vote they would be denying the younger generation a future.

Bill McLean

O/T – getting “error 503” on all but the last two posts! Attack ongoing – so much for British democracy!

Bill McLean

apologies – now back on air!

patronsaintofcats

Hmmm, where’s my gravitar?

Steve B

Actually I think this debate would server a couple of useful purposes (apart from being entertaining).

1.Showing Jim Sillars in would help illustrate and publicise the fact that a Yes vote is not all about Alex Salmond and the SNP – a line which Better Together and their allies push at every opportunity. It would show that there are alternative visions for Scotland after independence:

2. Showing Henry McLeish would also help to demonstrate very ably that although many have aspirations in relation to the so-called “Devo Max” that option will not be available before or after the referendum. It will also show a Labour politician who can at least try to think and offer reasoned argument outside the party line and thus illustrate the bankruptcy of the present Labour and Better Together “leadership”.

Hetty

Maybe by ‘wrong’ they mean that a no vote would be denying the younger generation a future. Perhaps they could get on with campaigning for a better future for Scotland’s people, which is only going to be possible with a YES vote, instead of pussy-footing around and swithering.

handclapping

There are four sides to any argument on a Yes/No question, pro-Yes, anti-No, pro-No and anti-Yes. At the moment we only have the first and the last which is why there is no real debate, it is all cardboard cutout stuff.

Only when we get the anti-No and pro-No arguments into the debate will we start to get any light on how to properly answer the question.

heedtracker

They do get a lot of air time. WoS billboards in bus, rail stations. They’re trying to close down WoS online, see how they like reading WoS waiting for their train to the office of a bettertogether morn.

balgayboy

Hackers will not stop us

Flower of Scotland

No thanks ! Wouldn’t give either of them any more airtime !
I’ve got a lot of time for Margo but not her sulky husband !!

Doug Daniel

Okay, so the CTRL+F5 thing doesn’t actually work, so like everyone else I am resorting to posting a message just for the sake of it.

balgayboy

Seems like the attack of this site is getting stepped up by whoever. It maybe to screw up your crowd funding event, so it maybe prudent to have a alternative process for the upcoming donation request.

Geoff Huijer

Agree with balbayboy at 10.55

And like Les Wilson I would not trust McLeish

Calgacus MacAndrews

It would be a muddle (not a fiddle) …

MekQuarrie

Tick, thumbs up, like, +1…

Paul

Both are yesterday’s men Any money could be used in a better way.

john king

“Hmmm, where’s my gravitar?”

Where did you leave it?
I’m seeing what looks like a nun in yellow is that it?

Tony Little

OT apologies. Not sure if people are keeping tabs n the recent threads, so I just wanted to post the reply I received from the EU Edinburgh about Barroso’s intervention. They did not common ton my remarks about his intervention being perceived as interference in a Member Satte (no surprise) and have obviously developed a standard line.

We acknowledge your concern in this matter. I am unable to comment on the interview but recognise it has provoked a strong response.

The European Commission’s general view has been given in replies to MEPs:

If a part of the territory of a Member State ceases to be a part of that state because that territory becomes a new independent state, the treaties will no longer apply to that territory. In other words, a new independent state would, by the fact of its independence, become a third country with respect to the Union and the treaties would, from the day of its independence, not apply anymore on its territory.

Under article 49 of the Treaty on European Union, any European State which respects the principles set out in Article 2 of the Treaty on European Union may apply to become a member of the Union. An application of this type requires, if the application is accepted by the Council acting unanimously, a negotiation on an agreement between the Applicant State and the Member States on the conditions of admission and the adjustments to the treaties which such admission entails. This agreement is subject to ratification by all Member States and the Applicant State.

probably not much point in pursuing further. But they are covering tracks like crazy.

john king

How long will the fundraiser run for Stu? I’m not going to have money to put in until the end of the month.

john king

Both are yesterday’s men Any money could be used in a better way.

I agree I wouldn’t want to pay to give Henry McLeish a platform.

balgayboy

John King @ 12.15:

“Money is no object” according to David Cameron!

john king

“Money is no object” according to David Cameron!

If only that were the case.

patronsaintofcats

@john king

I realised that I had a typo in my email addy on the first comment I made. Carry on, all is well 😉

Desimond

@Tont Little

Scarily Interetsing or EU vague…i cant quite decide.

Were we a state before the Union and before EU Union?..some lawyers could make a right few quid in the next few years!

muttley79

@Les Wilson

“I doubt he could stand up to Sillars, and would not want such a debate. Whether you agree with Sillars or not, I personally question his timing to be negative all the time with the SNP, there would be no referendum without them.”

I can’t agree that there would be no referendum without Sillars. He has a long track record of changing positions on major issues, and even political parties. The guy has no consistency or patience. The truth is that it is through the efforts of the present SNP leadership that the people of Scotland are getting a chance to have a vote on self determination. Salmond, Swinney, and Sturgeon never walked away in the huff after countless defeats, disappointments and setbacks. Sillars did.

patronsaintofcats

^

…which I see the Rev has now deleted. I’m not a crazy person, really I’m not!

Desimond

@Tony Little
Apols for typo…

Ananurhing

@Tony Little

So worst case scenario is, Scotland debt free 2016, Scottish Govt. unencumbered by EU contributions till it decides whether EU or EFTA membership suits the country’s interests best, and we all retain EU citizenship till someone figures out how they can expel us.

CHARTER OF FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS OF THE EUROPEAN UNION
Article 19.
Collective expulsions are prohibited.

balgayboy

@ John King: With you on this BTW, was only jesting.

john king

” I’m not a crazy person, really I’m not!”

I wasn’t thinking that before, no really

now? meh! 😉

Vincent McDee

You are going to love this:

link to twitter.com

Orkney and Shetland seceding from Indy Scotland. The Unravelling: starring Alex Salmond “I don’t give a damn about anything but 1314. #Naw

john king

” was only jesting.”

maybe we could ask Dave for a sub? 😉

The Rough Bounds

Sillars and McLeish. A couple of pub lawyers and nothing more.

Vincent McDee

I truly didn’t know Twitter could be more entertaining than the comedy channel:

link to twitter.com

Tim Shipman (Mail)

The value of PMQs is not to help people decide how to vote. It is a trial of strength by which backbenchers and the media judge leaders…

HandandShrimp

Alas Galloway seems happier to spout ill informed Daily Mail tropes than actually engage his brain. Is that what he has become? A Mr Shouty spouting angry Mail threats? It is very sad. He has talent as debater and orator but it is consumed in a fog of arcanely postured rhetoric that I no longer believe he believes.

Rod Mac

Yesterday’s men and irrelevant to the debate today ,would be better getting Stewart Hosie against any of the naysayers.
As SNP finance spokesperson in Westminster who better to slay eyebrow blinker the house flipper?

patronsaintofcats

I understand that he appeals to a certain group of people so Sillars may be changing some minds, but when I listen to him talk it’s like biting down on a piece of aluminium foil. Not a pleasant experience, and one I try to avoid. As for McLeish, meh.

balgayboy

@ John King: As long as it’s not nuclear, we have them already!

john king

“As long as it’s not nuclear, we have them already!”

dead from the neck up today, that took me about 30 seconds to figure out what you meant doh!

john king

Thanks rev, I’ll have funds in two weeks

Vincent McDee

Amazing article by Angus Roxburgh:

link to theguardian.com

“As a Scot leaning towards the yes side, but still agonising, I welcome every constructive argument, but nothing infuriates me more than the rising torrent of unsubstantiated “facts” being presented by opponents of independence, serving no purpose other than to intimidate.

Bugger (the Panda)

Henry McLeish would be a another unneeded obstacle in the clarity of the debate.

he is an out and out Devo man, like McWhirter, and is irrelevant to the Referendum which does not have Devo (whatever) as an option.

His position would only serve to sap the switherers from a Yes vote and if offered some “Pie-in-the Sky jam tomorrow you gullible peasants” they may be enough to give the edge to No.

remember he said that he was deceived over that sea grab. He knew all about it and was “deceived”

Naïve and a “useful idiot.”

Sillars on the other hand is a visceral hater of the SNP’s leadership and feels it should have been me.

The two of them together would be just NOT what the Yes campaign needs.

Why do you think that the BBC has started to use them on their broadcasts?

jake

couldn’t we just have staedler & waldorf?

Dick Gaughan

Sillars v McLeish?

I reckon the money could be put to something more constructive.

I mean, it’s not quite Foreman v Ali, is it?

john king

What BtP said
ditto

Dan Huil

O/T Anyone got a video of Digby Jones [a lord, apparently] going nuts about independence on last night’s BBC newspaper review 2230?

chicmac

OT Radio Scotland should be renamed Radio Furth.

Virtually all voices of `authority` now seem to come, usually by phone and frequently seemingly devoid of any real expertise, from outside Scotland.

Except for cooking and sport.

liz

I agree with the comment re funding as we want to make sure it doesn’t get ‘lost’ in the post.

I’m finding it harder to keep my temper with everything that’s going on but it was mentioned in your previous thread about ‘is it becoming more prevelant to insult Scotland and the Scots’ – or words to that effect.

I’m beginning to actively dislike people I used to like – what is it with ‘comedians’ who seem to think it’s open season to slag us off constantly on TV?

When did this become acceptable – it’s like they have always ‘put up with us’ but now they see it as OK to do a hatchet job – or am I just losing my sense of humour?

muttley79

Well said Bugger.

Steve B

I don’t think the issue is about liking or trusting either of them. The question is whether the debate will serve a purpose or not – ultimately will it help gain more Yes voters or not?

There are obviously dangers in that both participants are somewhat loose cannons but I think on past form, most of the shots from both of them will be heading towards Better Together – although nothing is certain 🙂

fitheach

Your chance to hear Jim Sillars this Thursday and Friday unfiltered by the media (I don’t think Henry will be there however).

yeshighland.net/nofear

muttley79

Anyone that sends a contribution to Rev Stu via post should e-mail him. That is what I did the first time, and I will do again for this fundraiser. I simply do not trust the British state.

msean

YES

muttley79

@liz

They put up with us as long as we do not support Scottish independence. If we bend the knee to the British establishment, then we are only tolerated at best. As soon as we show more ambition for Scotland than merely knowing our place, then the attacks and the personal abuse start.

velofello

Reference Sillars and McLeish;

Why do you think the BBC have started to use them on their broadcasts? Exactly Bugger the Panda. And Barroso, and Galloway.

heedtracker

Put more money into publicising WoS is what I say! Look at hard core tory boys like Frazer Nelson or Crichton Torquil/Torquil Crichton. They’re never off the box or the radio and Reverend you are the only YES vote journalist around so you should be able to have the same opportunity to do as these guys do, talk about why Scotland is voting YES. That’s if you’re up for say STV, Mr Ponsonby and co. I seriously doubt the corrupt nutcases that think they own the BBC in Scotland would allow you air time but now is the time.

Vincent McDee

More fun from Severin:

Gordon Brown warned his fellow Scots today that a vote for independence would mean them losing their British state pension.

The former Prime Minister said the payments could only be made by pooling risk and resources on a UK-wide level and warned Scotland’s more rapidly ageing population would lead to a higher pension bill after separation.

In your friendly neighbour the Torygraph, o’course.

link to telegraph.co.uk

MMcCourt

Heading to the Jim Sillars talk in Inverness on Thursday myself. Regardless of his feelings towards and opinion of the SNP he should be a welcome voice in the referendum debate. The more that the referendum is seen as everyones chance and other visions of a better future for us all the less anti-SNP > Anti-Yes linking there can be. Even Henry, should he have a vision of a post independent Scotland he wishes to share, should be welcome to a platform to show it should he have the urge to do so.

cirsium

No thanks, RevStu. I agree with BtP and Les Wilson.

heedtracker

How do Scots age faster than the English then? The UKIPer that said England’s floods were the Lord’s punishment for same sex marriage has more cred than Crash Gordon. “I ended boom and bust” and “I saved the world” etc

Grant_M

@ Dan Huil

(The Papers is on BBC iPlayer…)

link to bbc.co.uk

MMcCourt

simply making the point that theres too much linking of the SNP and the Referendum and any opportunity to bust that little myth of Bitter Together’s shouldnt be ignored. nothing flip floppy about it. Are you suggesting you’d block say… Johann Lamont from sharing a vision of an independent Scotland (not bloody likely lol but anyways…) if she actually had one and wanted to make it heard just because you didnt like or disagree’d with her prior actions / her?

One of the things I find of most interest in the debates and talks being held around the country (thank you youtube etc.!) is all the differing reasoning for voting Yes and visions of our possible futures. Its fascinating stuff regardless of personal feelings or grudges towards the speaker.

liz

Gordon Brown is a f**king liar and he knows it – the man is demented, the Britshers hated him – why does he keep supporting them?

Please explain why folk who live in Spain etc can still continue to draw a UK pension.

He is telling lies to scare older folk that they might lose their pension – that is beneath contempt from the ‘son of the manse’

Clootie

O/T

I keep reading about denied access and posts not appearing?
I have never had a single problem (I use a PC and an Archos tablet)

The only change I’ve observed is that the autofill for comment box is disabled.

Annibale

Brown is a liar with form. People in Scotland currently die younger than those in fUK on average, making pensions MORE affordable. Hopefully, this will change in an independent Scotland.

Dick Gaughan

I’ve always reckoned there was an outside bet on McLeish jumping ship to LFI. Any thoughts on that?

MMcCourt

hmm, middle comment disappeared so that looks a little odd now… oh well.

RoughMan

@ liz, 12.50

Not losing yr sense of humour liz; I’ve noticed the same stuff happening more and more. Looks like the more they become aware of us, the more they want to shoot us down. Not really their fault, they’re brain-washed by centuries of misleading information. 🙂

Murray McCallum

“Gordon Brown warned his fellow Scots today that a vote for independence would mean them losing their British state pension.”

Gordon Brown needs to tell the DWP about this as they have thus far advised the exact opposite.

link to bbc.co.uk

Gordon Brown’s intervention is right up there with Barroso in terms of false allegation.

The man who ended tax credits for pension schemes, thereby removing £5 billion from poccupational schemes, should not be going around scaring elderly people. Gordon Brown’s ego has no limit. He has no shame.

link to thisismoney.co.uk

heedtracker

link to order-order.com This is what oap frightner/Labour’s world saviour really spends on himself and this is the UKOK BetterTogether vote no spin on his giving nature link to dailyrecord.co.uk

Calgacus MacAndrews

Hermless

X_Sticks

Dan Huil says:
“Anyone got a video of Digby Jones going nuts about independence on last night’s BBC newspaper review 2230?”

Nope, but did see it. I thought he might have let something out the bag when talking about the oil. He said something like just wait ’til we hit them with the decommissioning costs. I hope some of the high heid yins in Yes/SNP are aware of this. Forewarned and a’ that.

Onzebill

Liz @ 12.58 I am the same I am becoming more and more heated/bitter about what is going on and at times have to force myself to calm down and count to ten before I open my mouth in company, its sad and bad. I used to buy every paper printed and watch the EBC without a thought, but I no longer buy newspapers which I really miss and now never watch the ebc in Scotland and never will again. Unforgivable.

Thistle

Hi Stu

got Jim Sillars on the next free event and live stream on the 24th Feb at Shettleston Juniors, I could always ask?

Also on panel we have comedian Bruce Morton, Donald Reid and MD Michelle Thomson and Ivan McKee.

If you want to ask your own questions of panel tune into live stream or see you at event and ask them in person.

link to facebook.com
link to youtube.com
link to new.livestream.com

Appleby

Genius. That is all.

tartanarse

Liz and OnzeBill

I too share the same view. I havne’t bought a newspaper since 2007. No coincidence this date. It was then that the things that you describe started to happen and have steadily grown to the outright racism, for thats what it is, started.

I often ask the fools on other sites if they remember the good old days when you could tell golliwog and Irish jokes.

Now you can’t. In fact St Patricks day celebrations outnumber St Georges day in England.

I can appreciate ignorance from Scots. I mean If your subject to this media constantly and do not have many brain cells I can understand but to be Scottish and act like this is simply a disgrace.

I try to explain to unionists that when these people slate Scots, its all Scots. They don’t know by looking at you if you’re for i, they just don’t like you full stop.

Gordon Brown. Best example . They hated him and didn’t even attempt to hide it.

Somehow though, we’re better together and polls suggest they all want to keep us.

Like a pet.

Iain Henderson

Someone give Henry a YES lollipop and get Jim some nice tartan slippers and a pint. Prob2 solved.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a (mainly) Scottish political media digest and monitor, which also offers its own commentary. (More)

    Stats: 6,677 Posts, 1,204,859 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Zander Tait on The Wage Thief: “Ha ha ha. You really have no idea, do you? Yes, you have a nice day too, Grendel.Dec 11, 13:46
    • Campbell Clansman on The Wage Thief: “Glad to see you admit that Scotland is NOT a “colony.”Dec 11, 13:41
    • Captain Caveman on The Wage Thief: ““I will be here tomorrow and the day after and the next and the next.” Oh, I don’t doubt it,…Dec 11, 13:27
    • Zander Tait on The Wage Thief: “Ooh you poor delicate little snowflake, Grendel. Never fear Grendel. I will be here tomorrow and the day after and…Dec 11, 13:22
    • Captain Caveman on The Wage Thief: “Yes, you’ve pissed me off. Well done you, troll. Mission accomplished as you say. I console myself, however, that I’m…Dec 11, 13:11
    • Zander Tait on The Wage Thief: “Charming. Unfortunately for you, Grendel, the only individual I have pissed off is you. Which is mission accomplished. Have a…Dec 11, 12:59
    • Captain Caveman on The Wage Thief: “lol, right on cue, another one of the dribbling grievance chimps turns up. Another fragile little twat with nowt to…Dec 11, 12:57
    • Michael Laing on The Wage Thief: “You’re the one who needs to piss off, you obnoxious troll. What makes you believe anyone gives a toss about…Dec 11, 12:47
    • Captain Caveman on The Wage Thief: “I’m not even the one you’ve been having the conversation with, you UTTER BELLEND – as I’ve already told you.…Dec 11, 12:28
    • Alf Baird on The Wage Thief: “Yes, colonialism, which ‘is based on psychology’ is ‘a disease of the mind’. Its just a pity the SNP has…Dec 11, 11:56
    • Republicofscotland on The Wage Thief: “Sorry to read that harrowing experience of your friend – sadly Sven I don’t see things improving any time soon.Dec 11, 11:32
    • Republicofscotland on The Wage Thief: “She failed to deliver indy – no actively worked against it – indy would’ve allowed more money to be pumped…Dec 11, 11:17
    • gregor on The Wage Thief: “Whereas some people (a cohort of stupid, hapless and weak forever-losers) prefer to be Ruled over – while they await…Dec 11, 10:45
    • Harry Dunlop on The Wage Thief: “If you take a moment to stand back and think about NS and her time as FM – and even…Dec 11, 10:39
    • TURABDIN on The Wage Thief: “You’re being rather literal in this matter. There is a cultural colonization, a colonization of the mind. The modern version…Dec 11, 09:31
    • Zander Tait on The Wage Thief: “Now now, Grendel mind your blood pressure. It’s a tough decision to figure out which alias I should reply to.…Dec 11, 09:29
    • gregor on The Wage Thief: “NFrealmusic: Hope: Hope: “Yeah, I’m on my way, I’m coming Don’t, don’t lose faith in me I know you’ve been…Dec 11, 09:24
    • Robert Hughes on The Wage Thief: “You are the moron who described the ” Indy ” cause as being on ” life support ” , despite…Dec 11, 09:00
    • gregor on The Wage Thief: “Your foresight and wisdom is King, Alf. #AriseScots #FreedomDec 11, 09:00
    • Robert Hughes on The Wage Thief: “I bet all the 1000s of OAPs ( aka – Geriatric Millionaires , according the warped perception of ” some…Dec 11, 08:35
    • Alf Baird on The Wage Thief: “Aye Gregor, President Trump does love Scotland and the Scots and will surely help liberate us fae oor doun-hauder. Thar’s…Dec 11, 08:18
    • gregor on The Wage Thief: “Kiss: Crush Collision: Age of Chance: “You don’t have to be Prince if you want to dance You just have…Dec 11, 07:55
    • robertkknight on The Wage Thief: “Completely off topic, but this popped up on my gadget this a.m. Just something unrelated to world events with which…Dec 11, 07:45
    • gregor on The Wage Thief: “BBC: Swinney has ‘positive’ phone talks with Trump: “The phone call was initiated by Trump’s team and lasted around 20…Dec 11, 07:41
    • Aidan on The Wage Thief: “It’s even more fun than that. An organisation which doesn’t even have a postal address and who’s height of democratic…Dec 11, 07:37
    • Young Lochinvar on The Wage Thief: “Well Gloriana; I’ve asked you similar before but you keep replaying the same broken record. If the SNP is done…Dec 11, 07:26
    • Hatey McHateface on The Wage Thief: “I understand where you’re coming from. Thing is, if I waste an evening watching TV, whether it’s news, entertainment or…Dec 11, 06:52
    • Robert Matthews on The Wage Thief: “Skrewdriver : I Don’t Like You. 1-2-3-4, I don’t like you! Get out on the job in the morning Time…Dec 11, 02:41
    • Campbell Clansman on The Wage Thief: “Alf, you are aware, aren’t you, that the UN maintains a list of “colonies” (they call them NSGTs) and Scotland…Dec 11, 02:31
    • Robert Matthews on The Wage Thief: “Of “days that will never come”.Dec 11, 01:15
  • A tall tale



↑ Top
149
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x