The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Lamont offers Scots [BLANK] tomorrow

Posted on January 31, 2012 by

We're supposed to live in an age where politicians are trained to within an inch of their lives by media advisers, in order that they can spout bland pre-programmed soundbites about any given subject at a second's notice. (With the infamous nadir of the phenomenon being represented by Ed Miliband's toe-curling broken-robot impression at the time of the public-sector strikes.) So perhaps we should be happy on the rare occasions when we discover a couple of elected representatives still willing to appear like clueless idiots in front of the public.

First came a few comments in the Scotsman from the leader of the SNP group on Glasgow City Council, Alison Hunter. With the SNP hoping to take control of the Labour stronghold this May – or at least deprive Labour of its majority – she was asked which policies she would seek to implement if her party pulled off such a titanic feat. Hunter's scarcely-believable and less-than-inspiring response was "I haven’t thought about that yet. Actually, I’m not an out-there leader. I’m a team leader. So we haven’t actually thought about that yet."

Before you ask, we have no idea what the difference between an "out-there leader" and a "team leader" is either, and we imagine Ms Hunter will soon be leaving SNP HQ with a well-skelped erse and a disinclination to say anything quite so stupid out loud ever again. In her defence, however, we suppose we could offer up the fact that she's highly unlikely to ever have to consider such a scenario – with Labour currently holding 45 seats (out of 79) to the SNP's 22, even denying Labour a majority in Glasgow this time round would be a huge and significant achievement for the Nats. Winning outright or even plurality control this year is surely beyond its reach.

We're not sure what Johann Lamont's excuse is, though.

Lamont is the leader of the opposition in the Scottish Parliament, with ambitions to be the First Minister of Scotland (go on, picture it). She leads a party which has formed the government as recently as five years ago. She's the figurehead (in Scotland, certainly, albeit largely by default) of the No campaign for the independence referendum – the side which is starting out well in the lead. In that latter battle at least, you'd have to say that she had a plausible chance of victory.

Her much-asserted position is that she and her party oppose both the status quo and independence. Lamont insists that Scotland needs greater devolution, but that (for some reason) the middle option cannot be part of the referendum. Devolution, says Labour's leader, is a "separate path" (does that make her a separatist?) rather than a point on a line, and the people of Scotland must first reject independence before they can be allowed greater powers within the UK.

So what ARE these powers with which Lamont hopes to tempt the electorate? They must be pretty attractive, you'd think, if they're going to persuade Scots to vote for the deeply unpopular status quo in autumn 2014 and trust Labour to create a better alternative at a later date. So when Lamont stood beside Ed Miliband in Glasgow yesterday and was asked to outline her vision for the future of Scotland, her reply – as reported by the Guardian – was all the more startling:

"Given that Labour lost the election last year, it would be presumptuous to have a firm answer to that now. [We want] to consult on this, particularly with business."

Sorry? Lamont's already-opaque position has been derided in the press previously as offering "jam tomorrow", but it appears that now she isn't even committing to anything that specific. Is it in fact jam that Labour's offering us tomorrow? Is it marmalade? Peanut butter? Economy lemon curd? Low-fat vegetable-oil spread? Week-old cat-vomit? In fact, are we getting any toast at all? (And when, actually, is tomorrow?)

Labour recently spent 14 months in the Calman Commission, formulating (alongside the Lib Dems and Tories) its official views on how to move forward with Scottish devolution. The outcome of these lengthy deliberations was the toothless, vague and increasingly doomed-looking Scotland Bill. So what are we to believe? That Labour was holding back on its true thoughts about constitutional developments all that time, but has now forgotten what they were and has to start again?

Lamont's response is an absolutely extraordinary display of both intellectual bankruptcy and arrogance. What does losing the election have to do with Labour's position on the constitution? Isn't that supposed to be a matter of principle? Why do you need to "consult", and who with, to know what you believe in? Why is it business, rather than Labour members or voters, who get to have the biggest influence on where Labour stands? How do you know that independence is the wrong choice if you don't even know what your alternative is?

We were distinctly unimpressed with Alison Hunter last week, but Johann Lamont occupies a position of far greater responsibility and has fumbled that responsibility much more dismally.  She might not have noticed, but the referendum campaign has started. If she still doesn't even know what she's arguing for, we're not sure how she hopes to persuade the people of Scotland.

1 Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. 01 08 14 10:24

    The Eternal Promise of Jam Tomorrow | We'll never be fooled again!

4 to “Lamont offers Scots [BLANK] tomorrow”

  1. Rolf says:

    "Vote Labour, go nowhere."
    They can have that slogan for free. Any more and I'll invoice them.

    Reply
  2. Subrosa says:

    Don't encourage Ms Lamont and her colleagues to form a strategy please. The independence cause is profiting well from her current stance.

    Reply
  3. An Duine Gruamach says:

    How do you know that independence is the wrong choice if you don't even know what your alternative is?
    Brilliant.

    Reply
  4. Shodan says:

    "If they want it then that's enoug for us to be against it!"
     
    In that mindset you don't need alternatives. I just wish Sottish Labour and other voters would wake up to this farce.

    Reply


Comment - please read this page for comment rules. HTML tags like <i> and <b> are permitted. Use paragraph breaks in long comments. DO NOT SIGN YOUR COMMENTS, either with a name or a slogan. If your comment does not appear immediately, DO NOT REPOST IT. Ignore these rules and I WILL KILL YOU WITH HAMMERS.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,995 Posts, 1,254,124 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • James Che on Mind Your Business: “Early discussions with Alex Salmond, after he had been in Westminsters library regarding the Treaty of union caused a change…” Nov 22, 12:56
    • Captain Caveman on Mind Your Business: ““Confused is correct” Ha. Really? Apart from the laughable inconsistencies that I’ve pointed out between the very things even he…” Nov 22, 12:41
    • James Che on Mind Your Business: “Only when the people of England, Wales and Ireland recognise there is no actual parliament of Scotland in the Westminster…” Nov 22, 12:18
    • sarah on Mind Your Business: “Rev, I hope that your network of supporters is gathering a body of donors to provide statements of authority for…” Nov 22, 12:13
    • James Che on Mind Your Business: “Police Scotland are actually police England under the Crown of Englands Westminster laws, legislation and Statues ” Scotland Act “…” Nov 22, 12:01
    • Geri on Mind Your Business: “AI- Dan “Yes – if in doubt blame the “Anglo” Boo boo! Perfidious Albion wasn’t coined for nuffink. You really…” Nov 22, 11:58
    • James Che on Mind Your Business: “The way out for all of the nations of these Isles is some genuine fact finding to the original hoax,…” Nov 22, 11:42
    • James Che on Mind Your Business: “What happens when England, Wales and Ireland realise that there is No treaty of Union with Scotland other than a…” Nov 22, 11:23
    • James Barr Gardner on Mind Your Business: “Police Scotland refused to issue an incident number for the report of crime of reset, their answer it was covered…” Nov 22, 11:04
    • Hatey McHateface on Mind Your Business: “@Geri 9:08 Biolabs. You forgot the biolabs. Also the Nazis. And the baby eating. Take your time, Geri, as otherwise…” Nov 22, 08:57
    • Minceheid on Mind Your Business: “Hatey McHateface says: 21 November, 2026 at 4:47 pm It’s not something you can do all by yourself, MH. You’ll…” Nov 22, 08:22
    • twathater on Mind Your Business: “Andee has stated that 3/4 of uk citizens either want back into the EU or want to work closer with…” Nov 22, 03:09
    • twathater on Mind Your Business: “THAT is a great idea ,as one who has repeatedly proposed and promoted that DONORS get together and instigate a…” Nov 22, 02:43
    • Aidan on Mind Your Business: “Yes – if in doubt blame the “Anglo”” Nov 22, 01:40
    • Anthem on Mind Your Business: “Because their fat controller is a member of the cabinet.” Nov 22, 00:25
    • Geri on Mind Your Business: “Confused is correct. The EU was colonised by the yanks & the wankers in Blighty, the kiss ass errand boy,…” Nov 21, 21:08
    • Hamish M on Mind Your Business: “Breaking news: SNP cancels £60,000 loan repayment owed to Peter Murrell https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c9p83kyryp7zo” Nov 21, 18:20
    • Captain Caveman on Mind Your Business: “To be fair, Spartan, I’m surprised you give Confused’s inane arse-drippings the time of day. Funny how the “english” [sic]…” Nov 21, 17:29
    • Hatey McHateface on Mind Your Business: “It’s not something you can do all by yourself, MH. You’ll need somebody to shovel your shite on a daily…” Nov 21, 16:47
    • Hatey McHateface on The Shots You Don’t Take: “You don’t really want to know the answer, Confused. Very probably far more than you.” Nov 21, 16:34
    • Hatey McHateface on Mind Your Business: “Seriously? So you’re another antisemite blaming the Jews for everything? Or is what Confused’s angling at going over the top…” Nov 21, 16:31
    • Hatey McHateface on Mind Your Business: “Always helps to hear the view from The Kremlin. Cheers, Geri.” Nov 21, 16:27
    • Spartan 117 on Mind Your Business: “For once, a sensible post from Confused that sums up the state of the European Disunion and the “thinking”, if…” Nov 21, 16:02
    • A2 on How To Change People’s Minds: “That Moawri link takes you off this page (which I was trying to read)on to your x link for the…” Nov 21, 14:57
    • Andy Wiltshire on Mind Your Business: “Was it anonymous again?” Nov 21, 14:46
    • James on Mind Your Business: “Excellent. Keep ’em coming. The squealers will appear ony meenit.” Nov 21, 13:32
    • Confused on The Shots You Don’t Take: “questions that need answered (a selection) “So, Nikki – how much fanny have you had?” SNP gov is full of…” Nov 21, 13:25
    • Confused on Mind Your Business: “the EU was a good idea to begin with – a west european trading bloc and a counterbalance to overweening…” Nov 21, 13:17
    • Minceheid on Mind Your Business: “Hatey McHateface says: 21 November, 2026 at 9:42 am I don’t understand it myself, but it seems there is no…” Nov 21, 11:49
    • Geri on Mind Your Business: ““They’re not gonna be wanting to hear any of your puerile shite.” You better STFU then. The EU won’t exist.…” Nov 21, 10:53
  • A tall tale



↑ Top