The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


From the archives #2

Posted on December 11, 2017 by

There was a time, readers, when Murdo Fraser was a bright young radical thinker who backed Full Fiscal Autonomy and even supported the idea of Universal Basic Income.

We think “committed Unionist” in this case is a euphemism.

516 to “From the archives #2”

  1. wull2 says:

    Could somebody post a link to this weeks AS show, so I can get some real news.
    Thanks to anyone who does.
    ——————————————–
    Scottish Government is totally limited in what they can do to raise money as they only have control of 20% of economic levers (poisoned chalice) and 15% control over piecemeal welfare powers. Up until 2016 it was 7% overall.

    Reply
  2. ronnie anderson says:

    Richard Leonard’s ( stop the press revelations ) in Holyrood today . Phillp Hammond intends to sell off RBS . Laughter Curve will be aplenty for this afternoon’s session of Holyrood .

    Reply
  3. ronnie anderson says:

    The baubles falling of the christmas tree outside 10 downing st Blatant advertizing Hendy Hoover used to clean them up lol.

    Reply
  4. Jack Murphy says:

    OT. Scottish Parliament TV.

    2pm today:

    Ministerial Statement:
    Scottish Government’s Draft Spending and Tax Plans for 2018-2019

    link to scottishparliament.tv

    Reply
  5. Nana says:

    @wull2

    link to rt.com

    Reply
  6. orri says:

    Unpicking devolution isn’t quite as simple as some on the unionist side might delude themselves.

    Their first problem is that rather obviously unless they remove powers from Holyrood any law they pass can be cancelled as simply as Holyrood passing an annulling motion. So the “not normally” part is a simple consequence of the futility of getting in to that kind of tennis match.

    Their second problem is that where laws concern devolved matters they have to get the Queen to sign off on them. Which then gives the First minister an effective veto as she advises her on the use of the Royal Prerogative. Obviously that advice could be ignored but in either case you’ve entered Constitutional Crisis territory.

    Trying to bypass Legislative Consent by unilaterally amending the Scotland Act is nowhere as easy as the press would like us to imagine.

    Nor would/should amending Scots to add the, till now, absent concept of (Westminster) Parliamentary Supremacy and thus allow them to dictate to Scotland be allowed to stand.

    Reply
  7. CameronB Brodie says:

    On the subject of English cultural nationalist and ‘British’ exceptionalism (e.g. Brexit). Scotland’s emancipation threatens the self-conception of such individuals. Lots of English self-identities will take a knock when they ‘loose’ Scotland. A fair few cringing Scots will also be bit scunnered.

    Pluralistic Conditioning: Social Tolerance and Effective Democracy

    Abstract: One of the main principals upon which liberal-democratic and non-democratic regimes differ is the incorporation of diverse viewpoints into public life. Exposure to such variety highlights any existing heterogeneity in society, and, for most individuals, exposure to this heterogeneity promotes tolerance of difference (pluralistic conditioning). However, those who are exposed to diversity under aversive conditions are instead pushed toward intolerance of difference (aversive pluralistic conditioning). We thus predict that increased democracy will increase tolerance of outgroups in general while decreasing tolerance among authoritarians, who are defined by their inherent distaste of diversity, relative to the general population.

    We test these predictions with multilevel models and survey data across several countries and find strong support for our expectations: under non-aversive conditions, exposure to the diversity inherent to effective democracy corresponds with higher levels of tolerance of outgroups; exposure under aversive conditions corresponds with relatively lower levels of tolerance toward outgroups.

    link to eprints.whiterose.ac.uk

    @Dave
    You really are a bit of an ignorant bigot. Crack on though son as your a laugh a minute.

    Reply
  8. Jack Murphy says:

    OT. Scottish Parliament TV. LIVE.

    2pm TODAY:

    Ministerial Statement:
    Scottish Government’s Draft Spending and Tax Plans for 2018-2019

    link to scottishparliament.tv

    Reply
  9. Capella says:

    R Scotland media review today engaging and informative. Ken MacDonald presenting and what a breath of fresh air he is. No wonder the BBC took him off air during 2014 in the run up to the referendum. Too intelligent an well informed to be given regular air time.

    Reply
  10. Greannach says:

    Does Labour have more people at Holyrood who have been leader than haven’t?

    Reply
  11. Proud Cybernat says:

    BREAKING from Pravda Quay
    with Jackie Kim Ono

    link to imgur.com

    Reply
  12. ronnie anderson says:

    Dun n Dusted Scottish Budget being supported by Patrick Harvey

    Reply
  13. Fred says:

    @ Cybernat, brilliant stuff but Jackie’s coupon portrayed must have been taken about 20 years ago!

    Anent, the Scots skeletons in Durham, they should be brought back to Scotland for burial, the guys fought for Scotland & should be returned forthwith!

    Reply
  14. CameronB Brodie says:

    Why do you think Farage (as in garage) has been given so much media coverage? The New Right shall not be defied, there is no alternative!

    Emotion and Cognition
    link to youtube.com

    Social Psychology: Cognitive Misers, Schemas, and Social Cognition
    link to youtube.com

    The Psychology of Influence: Mere Exposure Effect
    link to youtube.com

    Reply
  15. One_Scot says:

    Sky News telling lies about the SNP budget,

    link to twitter.com

    You could not make it up, well obviously you can if you are Sky or any other unionist media news outlet.

    Reply
  16. Derek Henry says:

    We’ve been saying (MMT’rs) this for a long long time now and just before the first FED rate hike we said the following.

    That inflation would increase, the dollar would fall, gold and commodities would rise and Treasuries would be lower.

    The FED have had 4 rate hikes so far since December 2015 and yesterday was the fifth.

    Let’s have a look.

    December 2015, Dollar Index, 98.
    Today, Dollar Index, 94.

    December 2015, Dollar/yen, 121.00
    Today, dollar/yen, 113.00

    December 2015, Gold, $1050
    Today, Gold, $1240

    December 2015, Oil, $38
    Today, Oil, $57

    December 2015, 10-Yr Treas futures, 127.00
    Today, 10-year Treas futures, 124.00

    December 2015, CPI, 0.7% y-o-y.
    Today, CPI, 2.1% y-o-y.

    Don’t forget about the £ and the Euro against the $.

    Euro has gone from 1.08 to 1.19

    £ has gone from 1.2 to 1.36

    Since the FED started hiking and the $ weakened.

    None of this is supposed to happen right ? No matter what TV channel you watch or newspaper you read they go to extreme lengths to point out the opposit is true.

    MMT got everything right again. It’s all right there. The gold standard mainstream still can’t see it never mind why it has all happened.

    They’ll still tell you in every 15 mins soundbites that interest rate hikes fight inflation and make a currency stronger.

    We say interest rate hikes are simply price hikes right across the economy as the price hike get spassed on. We also say the mainstream completely ignore the interest income channels. We say interest rate hikes increase deposits.

    All else equal.

    They are price adjustments, pure and simple. Higher rates equate to higher prices and higher prices mean higher inflation. Inflation is not good for currency. Higher inflation is good for inflation-sensitive stuff like gold and commodities as well as some stocks.

    Currencies are a bit like bonds, the only difference being they have zero maturity. Everyone seems to understand that when rates go up bond prices go down. It’s an inverse relationship. The discount to par reflects the implied yield and that discount increases as rates go up.

    Same with currencies. The spot price of a currency can be considered par. In a rising-rate environment the forward prices of a currency are lower. The market is literally pricing in a lower exchange rate. The degree of discount to par reflects the implied yield. Buy a forward and hold it over time until it converges to spot and you will earn the implied yield.

    Gold and commodities exhibit the opposite behavior. They don’t earn. They cost you to hold. There are interest payments and storage costs so the natural “curve” of gold and commodity markets has a positive slope. (Deferred contracts are priced higher than spot.)

    In a rising-rate environment, forward contracts for gold are priced higher. That reflects the “cost” of holding, which equals the interest rate plus storage, etc. Prices rise in a rising-rate environment and they fall in a falling rate environment.

    Of course this does not reflect short-term portfolio shifts based on traders’ beliefs. Many believe that lower rates are bullish for gold or bearish for a currency and vice-versa. As a result, they act on those beliefs and buy and sell accordingly. However, that’s not the true fundamental effect. That’s why so many people lost money buying gold when they believed rate cuts would be inflationary. Similarly, they wrongly sold the dollar. These mistakes are being repeated now, only in reverse.

    The Fed thinks it is fighting inflation when actually it is feeding it via these rate hikes. Any commodity curve will show this in reaction to a rising-rate environment. The curve will instantly reflect higher future costs.

    In addition, their policy and statements seem to reflect a lack of understanding of the government being a net payer of interest. They talk about being on guard against further fiscal stimulus when it is the Fed itself that is doing the stimulating. It is paying. That is income added, not removed. While some may find it harder to borrow because of the higher cost of credit, that is offset by the additional income earned by creditors and savers. There is net income received by the economy and that is by no means a brake on economic activity.

    If you were a cynic You could possibly go further and say that central banks with their current policies show that the ONLY manifestation of inflation that they are interested in will actively try to stamp out is a rise in your wages.

    They tell everyone they are increasing interest rates to fight inflation but the reality of the situation is they are increasing inflation albeit slowly as the data suggests but destroy your income at the same time. Because your income can’t keep up with the growth in inflation they are causing.

    So are they stupid and they dont know what they are doing ?

    Or

    Do they know what they are doing all along ?

    It’s as if Mankwi was tasked by the corporate sector to write an economic textbook that is taught to economic students the world over that says black is white and white is black but ultimately no matter what colour it is everything will serve the corporate sector whilst we send the herd the other way. He got paid a lot of money for doing so.

    Reply


Comment - please read this page for comment rules. HTML tags like <i> and <b> are permitted. Use paragraph breaks in long comments. DO NOT SIGN YOUR COMMENTS, either with a name or a slogan. If your comment does not appear immediately, DO NOT REPOST IT. Ignore these rules and I WILL KILL YOU WITH HAMMERS.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a (mainly) Scottish political media digest and monitor, which also offers its own commentary. (More)

    Stats: 6,761 Posts, 1,218,144 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • James Cheyne on The shifting sands of memory: “Thank you stu for taking this discussion up, it is sorely needing clarification, It is without doubt that England presumed…May 21, 16:47
    • Ian McCubbin on The shifting sands of memory: “Northcode has it clearly. The book legitimacy….self determination clearly sets out the legal routes for colonies like Scotland. The Independence…May 21, 16:28
    • Dek on The shifting sands of memory: “Well said.May 21, 16:08
    • GM on The shifting sands of memory: “Aye, it is a wonder Peter. I recall at the time being extremely frustrated at Swinney accepting what was on…May 21, 15:55
    • Northcode on The shifting sands of memory: “My understanding of Professor Black’s view is that Scotland was illegally annexed as a territory of England and that the…May 21, 15:48
    • Peter McAvoy on The shifting sands of memory: “As I have mentioned on previous comments to articles on Wings Why do the SNP and other independence supporting parties…May 21, 14:47
    • Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh on The shifting sands of memory: “Scottish Sovereignty Research Group Conference (17 May 2025) KEYNOTE SPEECH BY PROFESSOR ROBERT BLACK KC Starts at 1.46.35 into youtube…May 21, 14:30
    • Skip_NC on The shifting sands of memory: “Can you extrapolate a Scottish sub-sample of Westminster voting intentions to Holyrood with any accuracy? Voters (well some at any…May 21, 14:30
    • Peter McAvoy on Just a couple more shots: “While watching the tv baftas,I wondered if someone would make a drama about For Women Scotland and their long and…May 21, 14:24
    • Effijy on The shifting sands of memory: “House Boy Kerr sits happily on the gravy train and no second class colony is going to take it away.…May 21, 14:13
    • PhilM on The shifting sands of memory: “Re: the inevitable comments of people unqualified to discuss the history of international law or the constitutional history of the…May 21, 13:59
    • Vivian O’Blivion on The shifting sands of memory: “Extremely rare for the SNP to hit 2%, four times in a row on UK wide, Westminster voting intention polls.…May 21, 13:53
    • Mark Beggan on The shifting sands of memory: “Better Together ?May 21, 13:45
    • aLurker on The shifting sands of memory: “CJ that link is broken. 🙁 So use this one instead: “The UK – A Voluntary Union or Capture by…May 21, 13:20
    • Ian McCubbin on The shifting sands of memory: “Well it just clarifies to us all that Scotland is a colony . Thus seeking independence has clearer reasons to…May 21, 13:19
    • 100%Yes on The shifting sands of memory: “What ever happened to the new site layout, I preferred it.May 21, 13:17
    • Young Lochinvar on The shifting sands of memory: ““We have catched Scotland and will hold her close” The Speaker at Westminster 1707 following the Treaty. Says it all…May 21, 13:17
    • 100%Yes on The shifting sands of memory: “I believe whats upset Mr Kerr is the fact he’s been running about like a tit all his life shouting…May 21, 13:12
    • Jennifer Livingston on The shifting sands of memory: “Robert the Bruce has made it clear by being accused of being a leper that he plans on being resurrected…May 21, 13:07
    • Aidan on The shifting sands of memory: “I’m not aware that anyone has ever said that ‘Scotland is a partner in the Union’ as a legal position,…May 21, 13:06
    • Robert Hughes on The shifting sands of memory: “One irony being the current SNP have studiously avoided referring to anything related to the * Union * , eg…May 21, 13:05
    • caltonjock on The shifting sands of memory: “https://caltonjock.wordpress.com/wp-admin/post.php?post=27761&action=editMay 21, 12:54
    • BLMac on The shifting sands of memory: “If Scotland has been “absorbed” into England, why isn’t it called England? Or how about “North Britain”? – They tried…May 21, 12:48
    • Tormod on The shifting sands of memory: “Well, tories (of whatever complaexion) are going to tory.May 21, 12:36
    • aLurker on The Ace Attorney: “Mia 20 May, 2025 at 9:41 pm >I do not know if they were nutters or not. What I do…May 21, 12:35
    • Mark Beggan on Just a couple more shots: “Exactly Lorn. How did we survive in the past, how did we ever manage to survive. I agree with whoever…May 21, 12:34
    • Hatey McHateface on Just a couple more shots: “I know what you mean, but if you take a look at the manboobs on some of those lardy trans…May 21, 12:31
    • aLurker on The Ace Attorney: “@Captain Caveman Every day is a learning opportunity eh? It is indeed a well known political saying. Often attributed to…May 21, 12:24
    • Hatey McHateface on The Ace Attorney: ““religious differences, none of which matter today” If only that was true. I’ve been slow to pick up on this,…May 21, 12:22
    • Northcode on Just a couple more shots: “James Cheyne I thank you, too, for the sentiment. Of course, you couldn’t have missed my comments if you weren’t…May 21, 11:37
  • A tall tale



↑ Top