The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Double takes and double standards

Posted on April 17, 2012 by

As we browsed the papers this morning, naturally our attention was captured by the implausible-sounding headline "Rennie Hails Breakthrough At Launch Of Poll Campaign". Coming the day after a YouGov poll suggested the Liberal Democrats had suffered the indignity of falling behind UKIP in nationwide voting intentions, we were intrigued at the notion of a positive turnaround in their fortunes.

The story wasn't quite as exciting as it sounded, referring as it did to a local-council by-election in Inverness that the Lib Dems had captured from Labour in November 2011 (quite why the Herald feels it to suddenly be front-page news in April 2012 we're not sure), beating the SNP by seven votes. But as we casually skimmed the piece we were startled into alertness by the revelation that the election had been brought about by the conviction of the previous Labour councillor for benefit fraud.

Attentive readers can't have failed to notice that the Unionist parties and media have been on something of a witch-hunt against the SNP recently, particularly the party's councillors and prospective councillors as – quite coincidentally, we're sure – crucial local-government elections loom.

The best-known example is of course that of MSP Bill Walker, which we've documented at some length before, and who has been the recipient of far more media and political opprobrium for violent crimes he's alleged to have committed 20 years ago as a private individual (but strenuously denies and has not been charged with, let alone found guilty) than Scottish Labour MP Eric Joyce, who pleaded guilty to a number of violent drunken assaults committed while a serving MP (indeed, committed in the House Of Commons) yet remains the elected representative of the people of Falkirk.

But we've also had the bizarre case of Lyall Duff, a man hounded out of the party under concerted and suspiciously-timed media pressure – most notably from the Telegraph, the Scotsman and the Herald – for some frank but fairly innocuous comments made weeks ago on a private Facebook page which appears to have been hacked in order to view them, leading to the curious situation where none of the newspapers involved have actually printed any images of Duff's alleged comments, citing possible legal issues.

(It's curious because if the information was obtained lawfully, there can be no possible grounds to fear publishing it. If Mr Duff expressed his views in public, they're fair game to reproduce. If he didn't, the newspapers concerned are guilty of intercepting someone's private communications, which is a criminal offence.)

Yesterday the Scotsman whipped up another smear about an SNP councillor, this time a non-story about a non-existent conflict of interest with a company in administration, and today the lead story – that's the lead story – in its Politics section is an absurd and hysterical piece based around an article openly written by an SNP MSP in a newsletter and illustrated with a picture of her, but which (in addition to spelling her name wrongly) attributes her academic history to the wrong university. This error leads the Scotsman to bewilderingly describe the entire newsletter as a "fake leaflet".

Earlier this month the same paper prominently reported some rather feeble allegations of "ballot-rigging" by SNP members (in an internal candidate-selection process), and also ran with a story of another SNP councillor who'd apologised for making a tasteless joke. Attentive readers will note that the media rarely fails to include the word "SNP" in the headlines of articles like the ones we've listed in this piece.

But oddly, even though it only happened a few months ago, we couldn't remember reading of any Labour councillor being convicted of benefit fraud, which seemed strange as you'd imagine it was a bigger story than a badly-subbed newsletter or some sour grapes from an unselected council candidate. So we got our Googling hats on.

The councillor turned out to be John Holden, who was found guilty of embezzling a hefty £43,000 from the taxpayer and sentenced to a year in prison, although he was released after just three months. The story was extremely widely reported in the media, with some notable exceptions.

The Herald ran two separate stories on Lyall Duff, while the Telegraph incredibly felt that the obscure prospective councillor's private opinions merited FOUR lengthy pieces in a UK national broadsheet. Yet amazingly, neither paper – so far as we've been able to establish – covered the conviction and imprisonment of John Holden at all. We were unable to find a single story about this serious crime, not even a passing paragraph, in either the Herald or the Telegraph, despite the fact that it had been covered in scores of other media, both Scottish and UK-wide.

(The Telegraph's silence is of course particularly mystifying, as it's not known for willingly overlooking a good opportunity to attack either Labour or benefit cheats.)

The Scotsman did manage to feature it, twice, though curiously both of its headlines omitted to mention which party Mr Holden represented, an oversight the paper – as we've seen – is always careful to guard against whenever the SNP are involved. Indeed, the first Scotsman story neglects to note Mr Holden's party affiliation anywhere, while the second mentions it just once, five paragraphs in, in the context of the fact that Labour had promptly suspended him when the allegations came to light.

We're sure there's a good reason for these unfortunate inconsistencies. We'll get back to you as soon as we've figured out what it might possibly be.

1 to “Double takes and double standards”

  1. Christian Wright says:

    A well constructed piece.
    They have no shame. The cosmically dumb contrivences employed to turn the most inocuous events into an attack story on the SNP, beggar belief. The sore loser councillor ballot rigging narative is my favorite, and this most recent one about the faked flyer runs a close second for carnival barking nonsense.
    I think the motivation behind many of them though has its roots in the dancing monkey theory of hack journalism. There have been an number issues of moment that have been trumped by these daft confections. Cruddas revealing Tory party duplicity WRT their commitment to the referendum campaign, never was given the status and exposure it deserved.
    The photos you published of the Tory Troon trombola I thought put the electoral significance of the Tories in stark perspective, evinced their isolation, and revealed them to be a decrepit and moribund cohort. They are led by an ingenue who garnered a derisory1800 constituency votes, coming in 4th or 5th in the only election she has ever participated in as a candidate. Yet this electoral loser gets serious face time on TV and lots of ink in the colonial press. I thought that a great story begging to be brought to a wider audience.
    End rant.
     
     

    Reply


Comment - please read this page for comment rules. HTML tags like <i> and <b> are permitted. Use paragraph breaks in long comments. DO NOT SIGN YOUR COMMENTS, either with a name or a slogan. If your comment does not appear immediately, DO NOT REPOST IT. Ignore these rules and I WILL KILL YOU WITH HAMMERS.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,778 Posts, 1,220,160 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • GM on Holiday Relief: “I PDF’ed most of his articles in the period after Iain died. I go back to them from time to…Jun 17, 23:46
    • crazycat on Holiday Relief: “The legislation only applies to England and Wales. It always used to be SNP policy not to vote in cases…Jun 17, 23:12
    • Insider on Holiday Relief: “agent x…… Well, we must all wait with bated breath to see what “post colonialism” tells us ! It will…Jun 17, 22:45
    • Towbar Sullivan on Holiday Relief: “This vote on Abortion – did the SNP go AWOL? There’s no record of them voting at all. WTF? https://votes.parliament.uk/votes/commons/division/2058Jun 17, 22:35
    • George Ferguson on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “@James 9:56pm Welcome to the World of lost deposits. I was a member of the SNP and Alba. I thought…Jun 17, 22:35
    • Scot Finlayson on Holiday Relief: “What is wrong with this British Labour government, Starving kids, freezing pensioners, allowing the mass rape of young girls, assisted…Jun 17, 22:23
    • James on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “Voting for me? Dunno what planet you’re on, George. I ditched my membership in 2018 when the missing money/Salmond stitch…Jun 17, 21:56
    • George Ferguson on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “@James An SNP thug. Nuf said. When you come up with intelligent policies I will start voting for you again.…Jun 17, 21:20
    • James on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “Ah. Freeport Forbes supporter eh? ‘nuf said.Jun 17, 20:58
    • George Ferguson on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “@James 8:26pm According to Grok I am an Architect from Bristol. Of course I think freeports is an opportunity just…Jun 17, 20:51
    • sarah on Holiday Relief: “Reading some of Iain Lawson’s blog articles today showed what quality of thinking and personality is missing from the SNP.…Jun 17, 20:32
    • James on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “Are you the same George Ferguson who bigs up Freeports?Jun 17, 20:26
    • agent x on Holiday Relief: “How much has the Scotland 2050 thing cost and who is paying for it?Jun 17, 20:17
    • George Ferguson on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “@Hatey McHateface 7:25pm And the tradegy is my wife was friendly with the Murkle cluster. Not long married I represented…Jun 17, 19:59
    • agent x on Holiday Relief: ““Orkney Islands Council has accepted it must remain part of the UK – after spending two years exploring opportunities for…Jun 17, 19:52
    • Hatey McHateface on Holiday Relief: ““preferred the presenter to be a bit more serious” Hmmm. Not with a name like Randy Credico. That handle will…Jun 17, 19:46
    • Chas on Holiday Relief: “783 times. I confess, I may have missed a few as I am not on here every day. Most people…Jun 17, 19:37
    • Hatey McHateface on Holiday Relief: “Wouldn’t a truly representative Scottish Citizen’s Convention reflect Scottish society at large – 52% opposed to Indy? That being the…Jun 17, 19:30
    • Hatey McHateface on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “James will still be able to grasp his chipolata in the dark. That’s all that matters to him.Jun 17, 19:25
    • Hatey McHateface on Holiday Relief: “Nah. It’s them that’s supposed to laugh at you. You’ll never reach Step 3 if you’re doing Step 2 all…Jun 17, 19:20
    • sarah on Holiday Relief: “Gordon MacIntyre-Kemp talking a lot of sense in an email this evening. He says that SNP need to refocus on…Jun 17, 19:11
    • agent x on Holiday Relief: “I don’t think that Swinney’s I have a dream speech will knock Rev. Martin Luther King Jr’s speech off top…Jun 17, 18:36
    • Young Lochinvar on Holiday Relief: “Indeed, or that of sneaky Pete and the 600 grand?Jun 17, 18:25
    • twathater on Holiday Relief: “And yet the cult will gorge on this cold wattery porridge as if they were attending a banquet of the…Jun 17, 18:12
    • Onlooker on Holiday Relief: “How’s the Salmond case coming along?Jun 17, 17:56
    • George Ferguson on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “@James 5:07pm Easy if you understand how the National Grid works. You want to live in the dark and that…Jun 17, 17:22
    • Alf Baird on Holiday Relief: “Yes 100%, I see Indyscotnews now offers the audio in program entitled: ‘WBAI New York: ‘Live On The Fly’ with…Jun 17, 17:14
    • James on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “But don’t we export 8Gw of leccy 24/7 as it is? Why on earth would we want a nuclear power…Jun 17, 17:07
    • 100%Yes on Holiday Relief: “Hi Alf, was listening to Craig Murray, Sara Salyers and yourself on Randy Credico radio talk show, well done all…Jun 17, 16:58
    • George Ferguson on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “@Mary B 11:26pm You should been at the EDRP Inquiry in Caithness. The cluster theory was well and truly debunked…Jun 17, 16:45
  • A tall tale



↑ Top