The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Author Archive


What’s wrong with foreigners? 86

Posted on October 21, 2012 by

Do Ed Miliband, Tony Benn and George Galloway and now Sir Menzies Campbell (who appeared on today’s edition of The Sunday Politics Scotland) have some sort of problem with foreigners? It sounds like they do. For instance, read these words from Tony Benn, the great elder statesman of the Labour Party, this summer:

If Scotland wants to be independent they have the absolute right to do so. But I think nationalism is a mistake. And I am half Scots and feel it would divide me in half with a knife. The thought that my mother would suddenly be a foreigner would upset me very much.”

When asked about Benn’s views in a recent Holyrood magazine interview, Labour leader Ed Miliband had this to say:

I am not the only person with family ties abroad and family is family, whatever the accent or postcode. But the Scottish people with family in England, or vice versa, will be living in a foreign country if Alex Salmond gets his way, that’s just a fact. We live in an increasingly interconnected world; we shouldn’t be building artificial barriers, we should be working out how to work more closely together.

And on an episode of Scotland Tonight a few months ago, where Galloway discussed the issue of Scottish independence with YesScotland chair Dennis Canavan, the Respect MP talked passionately of solidarity between working-class people, which Scottish independence would, he claimed, damage. He felt just the same solidarity, he suggested, with bus drivers in Glasgow, Bradford and Belfast.

To which the most obvious immediate response is “What about bus drivers in Dublin, Oslo, Marseilles, Toronto or Lagos?” Does George Galloway not have the same sense of solidarity with them? Clearly not, if he feels that Scottish independence is somehow contrary to his solidarity with bus drivers either side of the border. If Scottish bus drivers somehow becoming citizens of a different country to bus drivers in his own Bradford constituency has any relevance to his ability to be in solidarity with them, you have to wonder about the nature of his socialism and his solidarity.

Read the rest of this entry →

  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a (mainly) Scottish political media digest and monitor, which also offers its own commentary. (More)

    Stats: 6,754 Posts, 1,217,700 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Scot Finlayson on The Blindness Of Hatred: “How can anyone welcome giving the state the right to kill you, the corrupt incompetent self serving state, 75,000 killed…May 14, 08:50
    • Dan on The Blindness Of Hatred: “Out of interest, John Hatey, have you ever had to look after someone 24/7 with a horrible terminal ailment? Maybe…May 14, 08:30
    • George Ferguson on The Blindness Of Hatred: “My main concern on assisted dying is the leglisative competence of the Scottish Parliament. Stage 1 general principles is one…May 14, 08:15
    • Hatey McHateface on The Blindness Of Hatred: “So the people we vote into power to keep us safe and help us out are now scheming to kill…May 14, 07:43
    • Aidan on The Blindness Of Hatred: “@Xaracen – Sovereignty is defined by the Oxford English Dictionary as “ the power of a country to control its…May 14, 06:19
    • Rev. Stuart Campbell on The Rorschach Test: “Um, that’s what a sex offender is.May 13, 23:13
    • Hatey McHateface on The Blindness Of Hatred: “Oh shit. If Sturgeon opposed it, that means that assisted dying will have to become the official policy of Wings…May 13, 22:34
    • diabloandco on The Blindness Of Hatred: “I have never understood those who think it’s fine to watch someone going through agony begging for death to release…May 13, 22:27
    • Hatey McHateface on The Blindness Of Hatred: “The runaway monkey takes time out from scratching beneath his pelt to tell the world that if I’m against assisted…May 13, 22:24
    • Xaracen on The Blindness Of Hatred: “@Aidan; you said, “the problem with your argument is that it isn’t supported … by the treaty of union” My…May 13, 22:00
    • twathater on The Blindness Of Hatred: “@ The bastard tax MOAN 13th May 7.15am I will gladly step forward as a guinea pig johnny boy right…May 13, 21:18
    • Owen Mullions on The Blindness Of Hatred: “I don’t know about religious fanatics but Sturgeon opposed it and the only religion she seems to believe in is…May 13, 21:18
    • Dan on The Blindness Of Hatred: “FFS John Hatey Main, if death means folk won’t have to endure reading your endless hypocritical dross, then that’s quite…May 13, 21:17
    • Confused on The Blindness Of Hatred: “Harold Shipman visionary maybe time for a pardon and that lass Letby which is just coincidence terrible times for all…May 13, 20:53
    • Captain Caveman on All Or Nothing: “Not merely obnoxious, but utterly repugnant and supremely incompetent. Seriously, no fair-minded arbiter could deny this assessment: the SNP make…May 13, 20:51
    • Aidan on The Blindness Of Hatred: “@Xaracen – it was me, and the problem with your argument is that it isn’t supported either by the treaty…May 13, 20:20
    • Hatey McHateface on The Blindness Of Hatred: “Only ever on Wings BTL, folks. Read how death changes your life for the better. To be scrupulously fair, I…May 13, 20:15
    • Glenn Boyd on The Blindness Of Hatred: “At Last!Legislation that will change lives for the better, assuming that it is not butchered on route by some of…May 13, 19:57
    • Dougie4 on All Or Nothing: “As an Englishman, I’ve always assumed the SNP’s underlying strategy was to be so obnoxious that the English voted for…May 13, 19:55
    • Hatey McHateface on The Blindness Of Hatred: ““abusively undemocratic, egregiously unconstitutional, and must constitutes a fatal breach of the Treaty” That’s great news, Xaracen. Why don’t you…May 13, 19:43
    • Former President Xiden on The Blindness Of Hatred: “Assisted dying bill past first stage today you say, blimey some on here are still debating laws from the 17…May 13, 19:35
    • Hatey McHateface on The Blindness Of Hatred: ““That should get rid of a lot of old NO voters” Let me correct that for you, x: “That should…May 13, 19:33
    • agent x on The Blindness Of Hatred: “Assisted dying Bill passed at first stage. That should get rid of a lot of old NO voters!May 13, 19:12
    • David Holden on The Blindness Of Hatred: “Green shoots of recovery. Things may be starting to change in the Indy movement. Here on a pile of rocks…May 13, 18:57
    • Stevie Fake on The Blindness Of Hatred: “On possible miscalls in the opening constituency map I feel like if the Dumfries and Galloway seats have stayed SNP…May 13, 18:29
    • Xaracen on The Blindness Of Hatred: “@James Cheyne; I don’t ‘square’ the voting system at Westminster at all, James; it is illegitimate and inappropriate because it…May 13, 18:11
    • ross on The Blindness Of Hatred: “on a vote share of circa 30% there are plenty seats more up for grabs than you are making out…May 13, 17:09
    • Owen Mullions on The Blindness Of Hatred: “Day 5 of James ‘I’m not obsessed’ Kelly posting about Rev Stu rather than independence. Thankfully, Eurovision should take his…May 13, 16:28
    • agent x on The Blindness Of Hatred: ““some of my posts are being delayed or not appearing at all,” ——————————————————– As you seem determined to take over…May 13, 16:19
    • Ben on The Blindness Of Hatred: “I cannot imagine ever voting in a general election again, I am sick of being lied to, a person can…May 13, 15:44
  • A tall tale



↑ Top