The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Unionists ponder suicide pact

Posted on November 08, 2011 by

David Maddox in the Scotsman livens up a previously-slow news day with a report that Labour are preparing to team up with the Conservatives in the UK Parliament to force a Westminster-led referendum on Scottish independence. The article is short on solid quotes to contradict David Cameron's repeatedly-stated position that the referendum is a matter for the Scottish Parliament, relying instead on unnamed "sources", but if true it would be an astonishing development. None of the UK parties stood on a platform of holding a referendum – indeed, all three explicitly opposed the idea – so where they'd be conjuring a mandate to do such a thing from would be anyone's guess, whereas the SNP have an extremely clear one from the Scottish people to conduct the vote in the second half of the Holyrood parliamentary term.

Most observers on both sides of the debate agree that a Westminster-imposed referendum would be an enormously risky gamble for the Unionists, as Scottish voters are unlikely to take kindly to such a democratic trampling. But it may be that the three London-based parties sense a growing trend of support for a Yes vote – reflected in recent polls – and consider it less of a risk than waiting for three more years of brutal cuts to take effect and persuade Scots that they're better off away from Tory-led UK governments. Labour especially, though, would be dicing with death were they to collude in such a scheme. We shall see.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a (mainly) Scottish political media digest and monitor, which also offers its own commentary. (More)

    Stats: 6,683 Posts, 1,207,102 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • gregor on Once more around: “Labour (2024): Keir Starmer’s time as Director of Public Prosecutions (CPS): “Keir Starmer was appointed Chief Prosecutor and head of…Jan 2, 20:19
    • Mia on Once more around: “What this means is that, in practice, Scotland does not care if that bottle of whisky is sold to England…Jan 2, 20:07
    • Mia on Once more around: ““How is the value of the money the same?” If the price Scotland sets for a particular bottle of whisky…Jan 2, 20:03
    • Dan on Once more around: “Port wise, dinnae forget the massive warmongering bastard tourism boost to Scotland’s economy of aw the weapons of mass destruction…Jan 2, 20:00
    • Iain More on Once more around: “He missed the touchline as Indy is also going to get well hoofed into touch by the Creepy Stalker Wokes…Jan 2, 19:41
    • gregor on Once more around: “Keir Starmer (2014): How can we prevent another Rotherham? “It’s not about individuals. Abuse scandals on the same scale will…Jan 2, 19:39
    • Iain More on And Then What?: “And there is the problem right there. Scots should back Indy regardless of who the fuckin English vote for. Indy…Jan 2, 19:38
    • factchecker on Once more around: “As I said in my comment above, the value of the money of every country is the exact same as…Jan 2, 19:28
    • Campbell Clansman on Once more around: “I give facts and statistics. You respond with something illiterate about the “next First Minster.” [sic] I’m pleased with the…Jan 2, 19:26
    • Mia on Once more around: ““Where exactly would you like to locate all the extra ports round our coastline?” I am not an expert, but…Jan 2, 19:17
    • factchecker on Once more around: “I agree – they should have had a vote. Re those unfortunates in engerland: I’m glad you can make yourself…Jan 2, 19:04
    • Dan on Once more around: “A new year and here we are on 2nd January 2025, which is 116,029 days since the union, and still we…Jan 2, 19:02
    • willie on Once more around: “Dear oh dear what absolute twaddle Campbell. You certainly get belters here below the line. Mumbo jumbo and numbers rumbled…Jan 2, 19:02
    • Mia on Once more around: ““If Scotland exports a higher %age of its exports to rUK than vice versa, it ‘needs’ rUK more than rUK…Jan 2, 18:58
    • factchecker on Once more around: “I agree with a lot of what you say. However, it’s equally true that many countries with all of Scotland’s…Jan 2, 18:49
    • Dan on Once more around: “I don’t live in a bubble so there’s no bubble burstage occurring, but do like to see honest discussion. So…Jan 2, 18:47
    • Alf Baird on Once more around: “The so-called Scottish ‘Government’ is a UK Government spending department whose allegiance/oath and that of its MSPs, Ministers and civil…Jan 2, 18:46
    • Campbell Clansman on Once more around: “In the Dec. 31st poll I cited, 22.9% of Labour supporters said they’d vote for Indy. Sorry to burst your…Jan 2, 18:40
    • twathater on Once more around: “Funny how FARTCHECKER has drawn out the big guns franchise fanny to explainerise how the rest of the wurld thinks…Jan 2, 18:39
    • factchecker on Once more around: ““England has never been part of the EU” That is factually incorrect. England’s territory was part of the EU until…Jan 2, 18:32
    • twathater on Once more around: “What happened to ALL those EU citizens who lived , worked and paid taxes in the uk but were then…Jan 2, 18:32
    • Dan on Once more around: “Hey CC, I see you’re still posting highly selective bollox. “The Ipsos poll shows that almost 40% of Scottish Labour’s…Jan 2, 18:31
    • gregor on Once more around: “NOTHING TO DECLARE: Louder Than Words: Savior: “We’re not the same Yet we still pretend we are Living in this…Jan 2, 18:30
    • Mia on Once more around: ““You’re assuming (without any evidence I can see) that the poll was just some online poll in The National” You…Jan 2, 18:27
    • twathater on Once more around: “All good words but when you invite the foxes into the henhouse and give them votes on the future of…Jan 2, 18:14
    • Dan on Once more around: “https://wingsoverscotland.com/the-case-of-the-missing-billions/ https://www.taxresearch.org.uk/Blog/2019/08/21/the-gers-data-is-ludicrous-scotland-does-not-generate-60-of-the-uks-net-fiscal-deficit/Jan 2, 18:09
    • sarah on Once more around: “It is very interesting that Winnie Ewing talked in terms of the transfer being a breach of the Treaty of…Jan 2, 18:09
    • sarah on Once more around: “Sorry! Lloyd Quinan not Neale Hanvey. It was on a TASP that Lloyd said it.Jan 2, 17:59
    • gregor on Once more around: “Wow, 2 nasty anti-social-human fu**s are lurking in the shadows (like a glowing nuclear powered Neon Red sign – stuck…Jan 2, 17:56
    • Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh on Once more around: “Link to PDF of original Westminster legislation: 1999 No. 1126 CONSTITUTIONAL LAW DEVOLUTION, SCOTLAND The Scottish Adjacent Waters Boundaries Order…Jan 2, 17:56
  • A tall tale



↑ Top
266
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x