The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


The slowest reader in Scotland?

Posted on July 25, 2013 by
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

75 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Jiggsbro

He’s not a dimwit. He just hopes that voters are. He’s a liar.

Tinyzeitgeist

Better together? More like Dependency for Numpties!

AnneDon

Someone has retweeted him to my timeline, so I have already pointed out to him that he would know the figure if he read the newspapers.
 
And asked if he was conceding the post-indy 2016 election to the SNP already.
 
Probably get blocked for my cheek. 😉

beachthistle

He is just out of depth. A former less-than-stellar SpAd, New ‘Labour’ apparatchik and coordinator of the losing Milliband brother’s leadership campaign, we should be glad he’s there.
While his secondary school activist meets The Thick Of It tweets are annoying, we should just be relieved that the No campaign didn’t get a competent big-hitter. Let’s hope he lasts the distance…

Doug Daniel

I dunno Jiggsbro, I reckon the reason he’s so good at lying is because he’s thick enough to believe what comes out of his mouth.
 
Well, I say “good”, but I really mean “persistent”. His lies are terrible. 

Anon Sailor

Sorry but Faslane is a crass choice as a main base for Scotlands Main Head Quarters.

bunter

I think the BT lot think they can say anything and wont be challenged. They dont need to try as the MSM cover their back.

DanTDog

Sooner or later, the truth will out…let’s hope sooner, but as long as it peaks just before Indy Polling day, that’ ll do me… 😉
 
Vote YES for Scotland!

CameronB

This is either negligence, incompetence or dishonesty, verging on the criminal. Which is it Mr. McDougall?

benarmine

I’ll tell you what I’m worried about – that any of these thickos are invited to be part of post-victory cross party negotiating teams. They don’t deserve it and they are trouble with a big T.

Jamie Arriere

Attention to all those in the Twittersphere! If you want to keep informed in the Indy debate, don’t follow this sorry individual – he’s supposed to be a participant, but I’m afraid he’s just a spectator, and a blind one at that! (My God, that was a struggle not to be sweary and abusive!)

Morag

It’s the absence of mature civilised debate that bothers me.  And it’s all on the Bitter Together side.

Read what Salmond and Swinney said in Lerwick the other day.  Joined-up sentences making sense.  Talking to the people petitioning them, responding rationally and thoughtfully.  Read the Scottish government draft paper they’re all on about.  More joined-up sentences and sense.

And all we get in response is nasty snide yah-boo insults. And lies. I don’t think they’d know the truth if it hit them in the face with a wet haddock.  And that’s the only part of the “debate” the media reports.  These people are an absolute scunner.

cynicalHighlander

Since a lack of honesty is the theme the program about Falkirk on R4 should fit the bill.
 
link to bbc.co.uk

Doug Daniel

Morag – aye, but slowly the public are getting scunnered of the scunners!

IainB

Director of better together, one Blair McDougall, asking a question that’s been answered over & over obviously not getting answer he wants to put across to his gullible flock so keeps asking, trying to put forward an idea that people in SNP are clueless & have nae clue …. I wonder who really has nae clue?

Somebody

Can someone tell me how we don’t know that McDougal didn’t just type up that ‘private’ Swinney text in Microsoft word?

Macart

Blair McDougall…………
 
Nope I’d better not. Mother Macart always said if you don’t have anything good to say about someone, don’t say anything at all.
 
I’ll settle for CameronB’s query above, its probably about as civil as I could manage in Mr McDougall’s case.

Andy-B

Dont you get the feeling that BT, dont really care what guff they tell Joe public, the more outlandish the better,it strikes me as sensationalism, pick a figure multiply by the amount of fingers in a packet of Cadburys chocolate fingers, times this by, the amount of Lords in the House of Lords, add the amount of windfarms, Oban, and their you have it, now use a stern and concerned voice to relay the message, via the MSM, and flatly deny any other conflicting evidence.

Davy

Between Alistair Darling and Blair McDougall its going to be a hard fight for the “Numpty of the Week Award” they are such good candidates, still the week is not finished yet, so their is still plenty of time for one of the other BT supporters to put both feet in the mouth.
 
 
Vote YES, Vote Scotland.
  

craig m

The more I see of these Labour lies and misinformation, the more convinced I become that we are seeing the work of a collective of sociopaths. The lack of a positive case for the union just highlights the endless lies as a symptom of poisoned thinking, truly the work of broken and twisted logic. If nothing else, at least we now understand the true nature of the unionist political mindset. It is pure poison!

Tris

Morag @ 8.42
 
That sums the situation up brilliantly.
 
There must be a few clever people on the No side. Why don’t we hear from them proper arguments for being in the UK. Ukok won’t convince anyone with this uneducated drivel.

Tom Hogg

If you are going to tell lies, make sure they are whoppers. But it doesn’t matter because the media will not expose your lies.

annie

Tris – I was thinking the same  it must be their blind hatred of the SNP and Alex Salmond that turns their brains to mush just as they put their finger on the tweet button.

HandandShrimp

O/T but I see Rev and Wings get a mention on BBC Scotlandshire….probably already noted somewhere.

M4rkyboy

The Better together Facebook page banned me last week.What they do is make a flyer asking a question and when you answer it they delete your post,ban you and then hold there hands up and say the Seps have no answers.

ianbrotherhood

He’s rumoured to be paid £100,000 a year.’
 
Seriously?
 
Good god – you could get (almost) 10 hours’ worth of after-dinner pish from Darling for that kind of money.
 
What did BMcD do before this?

Murray McCallum

Bitter Together are locked in endless question mode.  Deflector shields repel all answers.

beachthistle

@ianbrotherhood
“Former Purnell SpAd and David Miliband campaign organiser Blair McDougall has been approached to run the pro-Union “No” campaign against Scottish independence. Blair’s current job as director of David Miliband’s shadow activist base the “Movement for Change” was advertised in yesterday’s Guardian. A Number 10 spokesman did not deny that McDougall has been approached.
Guido understands that Jim Murphy and Alistair Darling recommended the ultra-Blairite to Downing Street through the cross-party “No” umbrella group. As one Labour insider put it: “Well, they certainly cleared the ‘get a bloke with a Scottish name’ hurdle”. An SNP insider told Guido “never heard of him…””link to order-order.com
For a year or so he was also an adviser to the Government of Rwanda, via the UK tax-payer funded (Tony Blair) Africa Governance Initiative, just before DFID and others cut their aid to Rwanda because of, er, dodgy governance.

ianbrotherhood

There’s something surreal and slightly disturbing about the utter joylessness of these BT gatherings. They look like the local Women’s Guild and Masonic Club have gotten together to form a posse, and are debating who to hunt.
 
And Blair McD? Every time I see him I get this image flashing into my heid:
link to xtimeline.com
No idea why…surreal right enough.

ianbrotherhood

@beachthistle-
 
Cheers for that.
 
Lucky old Rwanda, eh? I’m sure he’s remembered across the nation with great fondness and will have his coupon embossed on their coinage in due course.

Anon Sailor

So SNP’s Defence plans are crass?

HandandShrimp

Anon Sailor
 
What crasser than aircraft carriers with no planes? I don’t think so. Are you saying it was crass to shut Rosyth? Perhaps it was but we are where we are and it is why FOSNI was placed at Faslane. As far as I see the SNP plans are practical and cost effective. 

Yesitis

Rev Stu
Oddly, clicking the link to the tweet no longer appears to show the numerous replies that were there 15 minutes ago.
 
Yeah, the Better Together and Blair MacDougall`s on the No side fair manage to lose a few tweets along the way. Their whole campaign is bogus and corrupt.

Anon Sailor

FOSNI !

Murray McCallum

Crass, crasser, crassest.
If SNP plans are crass, where on the scale are the UK’s?

Anon Sailor

No wait guys before Im accused again of being a unionist troll: SNP plans for Faslane to be the main base for the Scottish Defence Force is madness, thats all Im saying.

The Man in the Jar

@Tris
@Morag
There are no proper arguments for the union so even the cleverest unionist can do nothing but exaggerate the negative.

annie

What is it with these Labour guys and foreign fields Blair Mc Dougal Rawanda Iain Gray the killing fields of Cambodia?

HandandShrimp

Anon Sailor
 
FOSNI
 
the bear in the Muppets?
 
There are three bases left in the UK two on the south coast of England one in Scotland. If Faslane is madness for an independent Scotland it is madness as it stand now.
 
 

Robert Bryce

Anon Sailor says:
No wait guys before Im accused again of being a unionist troll: SNP plans for Faslane to be the main base for the Scottish Defence Force is madness, thats all Im saying.
 
OK elaborate & give us your alternative.

ronald alexander mcdonald

Did he listen to a tactics talk from Pat feckin Fenlon?

David McCann

Meanwhile over at BBC Scotland news, no mention of Salmond speech. The did however manage to squeeze in a knocking piece about minimum pricing and the effect it is having on Portugese and French wine producers- they even sent a reporter. Then we had the ‘controversial’ Beauly to Denny pylons re-hash story. But pride of place must go to the wonderful investigative piece about a dating agency scam, which was simply a puff for a programme which followed the news.
I give up.

Murray McCallum

Maybe believes Faslane will be part of rUK?

I’m no military expert but wouldn’t having our army largely based in Scotland naturally improve our defence?

Marker Post

@Annie

Iain Gray says he visited Rwanda through his work as campaigns director for Scottish branxh of Oxfam. Wasn’t aware that Blair McDougal had worked there too.

As if the Rwandan people didn’t have enough problems.

Domac

Someone has already mentioned it…their comments are designed for the average joe public who struggles with understanding politics and are easily scared by rumours. In the hope that out of fear thy will vote no. 

James Morton

Is anyone remotely surprised that they are recycling their old scares?

Jamie Arriere

I had a look for FOSNI – it seems to be the Flag Officer Scotland & N. Ireland, used to be at Pitreavie now moved Faslane. Seems to be responsible for coastal protection, both RAF and navy? Could be wrong but after Rosyth closed, made sense to move it to the other naval base.
 
What’s your problem with ‘crass’ Faslane? Is there so much leaking radiation there that it glows in the dark? What?

Robert Bryce

OT but does anyone know what the latest Yes declaration tally is standing at?

CameronB

I can’t think of anything crasser than Trident.

Jimbo

Although clearly out of his depth, McDougall thinks he knows exactly what he is doing.

Part of his brief is obviously to intrigue against the Yes Camp and SNP – to be disruptive and to create confusion, scandal, and false rumour. If played right it can work well on the uninformed.

McDougall has a long, long way to go – Machiavelli he is not. It’s probably getting near to the stage where his employers (and probably he himself) become very disillusioned in his ability to play tig with foxes.

We on the outside of the BT bubble can see he is overrated. The No Camp leaders are just that bit slower on the uptake, but I have no doubt that some-one there will eventually pick up on his ineptness and the puerility of his actions. Time for a move sideways.

Sneddon

Maybe Sailor Anon is concerned the land based part of the SDF will be based at Faslane and all of the 15,000 personnel will be based there.  Not thinking through the difference between HQ and bases.  mibbe.

Jimbo

Cameron B:
“I can’t think of anything crasser than Trident.”
 
Yes, indeed. I always wondered at the sick minded inhabitants of Westminster who signed up to the ban on cluster bombs as being dangerous to any civilian who might pick one up, yet want to keep that abominable weapon of mass destruction capable of wiping out civilisation.

Guy McV

For a second there, I was trying to picture Blair MacDougall “reading the news” like a bad version of John Beattie. Took me a minute to get it. Must be late.

Holebender

Can someone tell me how we don’t know that McDougal didn’t just type up that ‘private’ Swinney text in Microsoft word?
 
It’s too well written to be McDougal’s handywork. Besides, I don’t think the government has denied authorship, have they?

CameronB

@ Jimbo
The decision to keep Trident has been made at a time that the UK can least afford it.  Wait…..that doesn’t make sense. Why would you want to afford the capability of bring about Armageddon? A small one at that.

G H Graham

McDougal & Darling should move in and live with each other. They’d make a great couple. Their pathological lying is what makes them a partnership of equals.
They could always choose to cohabit in one the houses Darling flipped for a tidy little profit.

john king

jiggsboro says
“He’s not a dimwit. He just hopes that voters are. He’s a liar.”
 
exactly 

john king

doug daniel says
“Morag – aye, but slowly the public are getting scunnered of the scunners!”
 
aye, an if they keep it up we’ll set supergran on them 🙂

john king

“What did BMcD do before this?”
 
winning his knot tying badge I reckon

john king

Ian Brotherhood says
“And Blair McD? Every time I see him I get this image flashing into my heid:”
link to xtimeline.com
 
hmm scary
the thought I have is a little less surreal
its the Scottish bluebell matches advert 
the English army are advancing and the we snivvely scots soldier says 
“a cannie get the matches tae light”
and the big highlander says 
“ach ya dunderhied
ye should have used Scottish Bluebell”
at which the wee highlanders cannon roars and the English colonel says 
“Beck leds! Thar using Scottish Bluebail!”
 

john king

andy b says
 ”
pick a figure multiply by the amount of fingers in a packet of Cadburys chocolate fingers”
which flavour? 
this is important
otherwise we’ll be accused of obfuscation 🙁 

john king

anon sailor says 

“No wait guys before Im accused again of being a unionist troll: SNP plans for Faslane to be the main base for the Scottish Defence Force is madness, thats all Im saying.”
excuse the automatic assumptions I think sometimes (we’re all) subject to a hair trigger reaction, I did’nt think your point with a question mark ? was trolling
whats your thoughts on that, anon, why isn’t it a good idea?

  

john king

gh graham says
“McDougal & Darling should move in and live with each other. They’d make a great couple. Their pathological lying is what makes them a partnership of equals.”
 
hmm
can just see the scene at the breakfast table 
porige McDougal?
yes Darling! 🙂

Dal Riata

100K? Bloody hell! Um, what for, exactly? Scaremonger-in-Chief, Liar-Liar-Pants-on-Fire Departmental Head, Number-One-FUD-U-LIKE…?
 
And, who pays him, by the way?

Red squirrel

Brilliant – stellar example of showing himself up as a complete numpty. You should pay more attention in class Mr McDougall and stop all that idle gossiping or you’ll never amount to anything. Oops, too late.

Anon Sailor

Sorry John I jumped into the jacuzi last night and didnt see your post, need a waterproof ipad.

Anon Sailor

Even if Faslane is available to use I think its a bad choice due to its isolation.
 
Being a Naval base full of matlots I dont think they would take kindly to pongos crawling all over them. 

john king

I only posted my comment at half seven this morning 
now I know Im going to be sorry I asked this but whats a pongo?
besides why would its (relative ) isolation be a bad thing, its only an hour at worst from Glasgow

Albalha

@dalriata
Their largest donor is Ian Taylor, oil trader and the one that puts cash into Harris Tweed, friend of B Wilson, and this from a Guardian article on some of the others ….. of course, fwiw, the YES campaign people will no doubt be on comparable salaries.
Those include former Inverness Caledonian Thistle FC chairman Alan Savage (£100,000); Gordon Baxter, of the eponymous soup makers and foods firm Baxter and Sons, (£10,000); Douglas Flint, former chairman of HSBC Holdings (£25,000); Sir Gerald Elliot, chairman of the shipping firm Christian Salvesen (£10,000) and two co-founders of the Edinburgh-based investment firm Artemis Fund Managers, John Dodd and Mark Tyndall (£10,000 each). (Dodd has just sold his Angus grouse shooting estate at Glenogil, a property at the centre of alleged bird of prey persecution cases).
link to guardian.co.uk

Albalha

@johnking
Anyone from the Army

Neil MacGillivray

The repetition of lies works only so long as the BBC and MSM are onside. Of course the Project Fear team know this full well and will continue to pour out their disinformation to be lapped up by their minions at the BBC. That way Labour sinecures in the House of Commons and House of Lords are maintained and the Labour supporters in BBC Scotland hope to be richly rewarded.
BUT – what happens to them when Scotland votes YES and their lies come back to haunt them? rUK will not welcome them, Scotland will shun them  – I think after 1945 the term was displaced persons. Who will take them? Any ideas?

JLT

benarmine says:
 

I’ll tell you what I’m worried about – that any of these thickos are invited to be part of post-victory cross party negotiating teams. They don’t deserve it and they are trouble with a big T.
——————–
No chance! Absolutely none! It is truly safe to say that the likes of Darling, Lamont, McDougall, and whoever else is part of the BT mob, will be shut out of the room, should it be a ‘Yes’ victory.
When Salmond, Sturgeon and the rest of the ‘Yes’ group sit down with Cameron, Osborne and Co, there is no chance that the BT mob will be in the room. They had their chance – they blew it!
And being the clowns and liars that they are, Cameron will not want half-wits sitting on his side of the table. The last thing he needs is Lamont or Darling belching and farting absolute nonsense at the ‘Yes’ team. Cameron needs Scotland, whether it is independent or not. He will not want negotiations ruined by Independence-haters …who could be handing Salmond gold-minted bullets. Pee the ‘Yes’ group off, and it could be something like, ‘Well if Alistair Darling feels like that, well, I’ll tell you what, David, I think we’ll just create our own currency. Hopefully …that shouldn’t affect the rest of the UK economy …hmmm…what do you say?’
The losers will be locked out the room …just as Labour were, when Salmond and Cameron drew up the Edinburgh agreement. We’ll hear a lot of wailing and screaming, but it will be drowned out by the laughter….
 

Anon Sailor

Percy Pongo, where Percy goes the pong goes! Sodgers!
I guess an Hr from Glasgow is fine too, just thought top brass prefer to be equidistant to bases and infrastructure. Besides Im not sure Faslane has capacity for extra staff etc, its such a bespoke place for Trident, and other boats. I served 10 yrs and we matlots wouldnt want our base turned into a squaddies playground, Marines and Gurkhas were bad enough!
Im also not sure we will have full control ober Faslane till Trident has gone and at risk of upsetting the good rev again on that issue, Id stick by my view that Trident will remain until its replacement date around 2016 unless its extended by 5 yrs as the yanks have done.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a (mainly) Scottish political media digest and monitor, which also offers its own commentary. (More)

    Stats: 6,684 Posts, 1,207,436 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Geri on Where We Stand Now: “The West is a minority. They have the biggest mouth, for now, due to coercion & illegal sanctions but that’s…Jan 5, 21:34
    • alan scott on Where We Stand Now: “As a twat and a piece of despicable scum who does not support breaking up the United Kingdom you tell…Jan 5, 21:30
    • Geri on Where We Stand Now: “Everyone except the G7.Jan 5, 21:27
    • James Gardner on Where We Stand Now: “The fact that there is a large number of non-voting electorate yet the SNP still trying to get so called…Jan 5, 21:16
    • gregor on Where We Stand Now: “Express it allJan 5, 21:14
    • gregor on Where We Stand Now: “Sorry to disappoint you, Evil_c #FreedomJan 5, 21:13
    • gregor on Where We Stand Now: “Mental As Anything: Live It Up: “How can you see looking through those tears? Don’t you know you’re worth your…Jan 5, 21:07
    • Aidan on Where We Stand Now: “Could you provide me with a list of countries who are highly regarded on the International stage?Jan 5, 21:04
    • Aidan on Where We Stand Now: “Don’t be so dismissive, those 186 votes could easily affect the outcome of a parish council election. Causes that enjoy…Jan 5, 21:00
    • Geri on Where We Stand Now: “The delusion is strong in you. The UK is a joke on the international stage & they know all too…Jan 5, 20:49
    • willie on Where We Stand Now: “Away with ye Peter McAvoy. Stripping the pensioners of the winter heating allowance is a wizard idea. If they are…Jan 5, 20:46
    • Geri on Where We Stand Now: “Suck it up , sunshine. That’s the Union for you… independence supporters voted to leave that set up & keep…Jan 5, 20:39
    • Aidan on Where We Stand Now: “Liberation is not going to get Scotland listed as a non-self governing territory though so all of the consequences that…Jan 5, 20:39
    • Republicofscotland on Where We Stand Now: “The Scottish taxpayer is bank rolling this known sex pest. “A shamed former SNP MP who sexually harassed a teenage…Jan 5, 20:37
    • gregor on Where We Stand Now: “Kid: “A child: He took the kids to the park while I was working.”: https://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/english/kidJan 5, 20:24
    • Confused on Once more around: “– that “rodent” is a civic animalist and is a “new squirrel”. Dan should be minister for offgrid, come the…Jan 5, 20:22
    • willie on Where We Stand Now: “No doubt Scotland’s International Development Alliance with a replacement “rocket” at the head of policy and communication he will soon…Jan 5, 20:22
    • Geri on Where We Stand Now: “Aye, like they weren’t remotely interested in a diddy wee province called Northern Ireland where they sent a whole team…Jan 5, 20:21
    • Mia on Where We Stand Now: “Oh for goodness sake. What part of “there is more than one way to skin a cat” or “to bring…Jan 5, 20:20
    • willie on Where We Stand Now: “Disgraced sex pest and ex SNP MP Patrick Grady who sexually harassed a teenage staffer has just been appointed head…Jan 5, 20:14
    • KT Lorimer on Where We Stand Now: “Interesting – I see the McEleny debacle is being picked up on and an interest in the NSP proposal.Jan 5, 20:13
    • gregor on Where We Stand Now: “Keep your children safe: https://tinyurl.com/3u69hjyz #PedoCharterExtravaganzaJan 5, 20:11
    • Campbell Clansman on Where We Stand Now: “The “New Scotland Party” wants to lead an Indy movement, but can’t even create a working website. BTW, even the…Jan 5, 20:11
    • Campbell Clansman on Where We Stand Now: “Reliable sources placed the AUOB crowd at 20,000, not 100,000-200,000, Sarah. I suppose a moonhowler movement needs to invent fantasy…Jan 5, 20:06
    • Confused on Where We Stand Now: “micro expressions tell allJan 5, 20:03
    • gregor on Once more around: “Libs of TikTok @libsoftiktok: “The “science guy” who Biden just awarded a Presidential Medal of Freedom doesn’t know basic biology…Jan 5, 20:02
    • Peter McAvoy on Where We Stand Now: “Holyrood should have a vote to gain more taxation powers to reinstate the winter fuel allowance and prevent the imposition…Jan 5, 20:02
    • Campbell Clansman on Where We Stand Now: “In short, in 2024, about 736,000 voted for the (nominally) Indy parties (SNP and Alba)–about 30% of those voting, and…Jan 5, 20:01
    • Tartanpigsy on Where We Stand Now: “Instead of more of the same, I’d prefer to see articles promoting how the non party Yes movement is getting…Jan 5, 19:55
    • Mia on Where We Stand Now: “Let’s see: Total electorate in Scotland: 4,078,398 Turnout: 2,414,810 (59%) Votes for labour: 851,897 Votes for SNP: 724,758 Votes for…Jan 5, 19:48
  • A tall tale



↑ Top
141
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x