The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


The Crushing

Posted on April 16, 2025 by

We’ve all got a lot of extremely heavy reading and pondering to do now. But the short version of the outcome of For Women Scotland vs The Scottish Ministers is this:

On the face of the judgment just handed down live in the courtroom, a more absolute, comprehensive and legally momentous defeat for the Scottish Government – and the forces of gender ideology in general – seems difficult to imagine.

But we’ll get back to you on that after all the reading. Today, we’re just going to stand and salute FWS and their richly-deserved triumph. See you later.

0 to “The Crushing”

  1. willie says:

    A sensible judgement based upon biology.

    But is it appalling that it has taken a English court to reach this decision and reverse the woke nonsense of the woke Scottish Parliament.

    Exposed on the world stage as a joke government whilst simultaneously undermining Scotland as a state.

    But otherwise, a sensible result.

    Reply
    • Dr John says:

      It’s our court two. Currently the president and deputy president are Scottish judges. Both sat in this case.

      Reply
    • Nemisis Benn says:

      But until someone screws the lid down on the coffin of Trans it will not go away. Does anyone expect the NHS (Fife in particular?) and so many other bloated organisations throughout the UK to really, really, pay attention?
      Of course not!

      Reply
    • Dave says:

      A terrific result for common sense! (As though that counts for anything anymore in SNP-Green Scotland). However, on a point of fact: ‘But is it appalling that it has taken a *English court …’, it’s not an English court, it’s ‘The Supreme Court of the United Kingdom’.

      Reply
    • David Taylor says:

      It’s not an English court.

      Reply
  2. Jim Thomson says:

    Watched it on YouTube with some trepidation. Also annoyed by the time difference between the speech and video, but hey ho.

    The mood lightened as he continued reading.

    Great result.

    Reply
  3. Cynicus says:

    Calling Shirley-Anne Shambles:

    Transwomen are MEN.

    Your retraction of your earlier, contrary imbecility is eagerly awaited

    Reply
  4. Effijy says:

    Time for the government to acknowledge that the vast majority of women and men do not accept a person with a penis is a women and people with that sex organ should not access women’s toilets or changing rooms.

    They were happy to destroy their share of the vote on this matter but thankfully they now need to break the law if they are to go against it.

    If officials behind any law breaking are convicted they will be leaving the gravy train at the very next stop.

    This is likely their only motivation to comply.

    I make it clear that I am not against those transitioning but while they have male organs they use the facilities for those with male organs.

    Reply
  5. Davie says:

    Great news. Well done.

    The next battlefield is race grifting. It’s similar ground but much harder to overcome, because on the surface it isn’t so batshit crazy. It’s time to realise that ‘positive action’ is simply discrimination, and almost exclusively against the host population. Problem being that positive action is resulting in positions of authority being stuffed with direct beneficiaries, and turkeys don’t vote for Christmas. There are only so many TRAs to go round.

    Reply
  6. Skip_NC says:

    So if I understand the video correctly, For Women Scotland won against F@ck Women Scotland. I believe that Scotland will be better off running its own affairs but the fact that they had to go to the supreme court of another country tells us that there is much work to be done post-independence to bring people together for the common good.

    The cheering is to be expected but last few frames of the clip are incredibly powerful. That lady’s (I cay that without fear of contradiction) response tells us how important this fight was and is.

    Reply
  7. diabloandco says:

    Ashamed and annoyed it had to go this far but delighted with the final ruling.
    ( never thought the English were more sensible than Scots until now!)

    Reply
    • Yoon Scum says:

      As an English worshipping piece of shit who will be first up against the wall after the UN rules Scotland is an oppressed colony
      .
      I’ll step in to defend
      .
      .
      .
      .
      .

      The Scots

      I don’t believe for a nano-second that the majority of those foolish enough to vote for the SNP actually believe that men can get pregnant or that women have willies

      They just vote for the SNP as they hate people like me

      be that due to football or watching a shit film with an Australian in it

      Reply
      • Geri says:

        So you’re back to self identifying as English today are you?

        Okay – but just to correct you, yet again,

        SNP voters didn’t vote for this. The SNP had no mandate to approve Self-ID through Holyrood either. It also wasn’t in the SNP manifesto.

        If we didn’t have branch office rules – they’d have been removed from Holyrood – with Sturgeon & Harvie permanently removed from the building for blatantly disregarding public opinion.

        But wait …there’s more…. The Lib dumbs, Labour & the Tories voted this through too..so they must hate you too – right?

        So off you pop & update yer bot…

      • Yoon Scum says:

        So the SNP are an English party

        I bet you hate everyone who voted for them

        WHICH

        Includes ME

        I voted for them when Salmond ran them as he realised Scotland needs to show that they are capable of grown-up government

        AND

        You voted for them

        YEP

        You voted for an English unionist party

  8. ian foulds says:

    hea, hear

    Reply
  9. sarah says:

    Fantastic result. Congratulations and thank you to For Women Scotland and all their supporters. And you, Rev.

    Reply
  10. John H. says:

    This is a sensible decision that should at least begin a return to normality. Sturgeon and her puppets will be furious, though she was happy to agree with the Supreme Court when it suited her.

    Reply
  11. Breathless Mahoney says:

    This just in – “Transwomen are men.” – OFFICIAL

    Reply
  12. BLMac says:

    A victory for common-sense and women.

    Meanwhile the elation of the gender-woo at their successful subversion of our cause has turned to ashes in their mouths.

    At least they have their bags of pronouns to comfort them.

    Reply
  13. Andrew scott says:

    Greatnews
    The nutter that is maggie chapperson is having a fit of the vapours obviously

    Reply
  14. SilentMajority says:

    Wonderful, wonderful news. I am so very happy for ‘For Women Scotland’ and their supporters, and equally for the continued strive to promote this sanity through WoS.

    Now waiting for the first signs from our government on how they will still try and wriggle out of it…

    Reply
  15. Callum says:

    The political class supporting so called Progressive politics should all hang their heads in shame today and profusely apologise to women who became victims of the Trans cult.

    Heads should roll in civic organisations like universities, councils, NHS, quangos who subjected women to harrassment, cancel culture and loss of jobs.

    As for Police Scotland and the prison service there should be a public investigation into the clear and evident misogny that these organisations undertook that put all women in danger.

    Today is not a day for celebration but represents a huge sigh of relief that biological facts trumped a flawed and dangerous ideology. ,

    Reply
    • Hatey McHateface says:

      “Today is not a day for celebration”

      I must respectfully disagree, Callum.

      Have you any idea how much the claims and counter-claims, the law suits and counter suits, the compensation payouts and the legal wranglings over the compensation payouts, are going to cost in the years to come?

      Naw. Me neither, but be assured that as so much of it will be funded from the public, Scottish tax-payer’s purse, it won’t be kept down to mere groats and bawbees.

      I’m certain there will be many in the legal profession taking an early weekend today, to get hammered senseless celebrating the turning on of a brand new high-pressure serious cash gusher, with them positioned right beneath it.

      A serious cash gusher they can confidently expect to shower them in dosh for years to come.

      Reply
    • Geri says:

      Well said..

      Reply
  16. Hatey McHateface says:

    Lions 1 – Unicorns 0

    I think that actually works on two levels 🙂

    Reply
  17. sarah says:

    Fully Repeal the Gender Recognition Act petition.parliament.uk/petitions/705403

    Now is a good time to sign this petition.

    Reply
    • Neil Mackenzie says:

      Indeed. This petition has stalled and needs 87,000 more signatures by August to put back on the agenda.

      The government’s response was a nonsense which doesn’t address the fundamental dishonesty and logic-failure of the Act.

      Reply
  18. Jim Bo says:

    Epic stuff! So chuffed at this result.

    Reply
  19. Adam says:

    Is Swinney that bothered about all this? Probably glad the decision was taken out of his hands.

    I certainly can’t imagine Forbes ever supported any of this stuff.

    Reply
  20. Patsy MIllar says:

    Yeah!

    Reply
  21. Edward McPhee says:

    This judgement called the Holyrood legislation “incoherent and impractical”. Who are responsible for framing an act that is now legally incoherent and impractical. How much has been the cost to Scotland with what can only be described as an abuse of power?

    Reply
  22. Yoon Scum says:

    Can we just reflect on the judges in this case

    Decades up decades of hard work and study

    Learning every law and judgement

    Reading countless obscure cases

    Studying the finer details and nuances of UK regulation

    Hours and hours late at night furiously scribbling notes

    Debating and testing laws

    and finally they reach the very pinnacle of their career and they get

    Get tested with the question of

    Do chicks have dicks

    Reply
  23. panda paws says:

    The correct decision. And for all the TRAs weeping and wailing, trans people are protected under the characteristic gender re-assignment as they always have been. They just don’t get to ride roughshod over other protected characteristics.

    As for those chuntering btl on about English Courts, it is of course the UK Supreme Court and of the 5 judges, 2 were English, one Welsh and 2 (posh) Scottish.

    Reply
  24. Confused says:

    the hungarians show us all how it is done; no messing
    link to archive.ph
    – the caribbeans and west africans also continue to impress

    none of this goes remotely far enough – there is a whole operation that needs to be wound up

    Reply
    • Geri says:

      Great news. I like the one for cash too.

      Reply
      • Yoon Scum says:

        After Scotland is freed

        And you are placed as supreme leader

        Will you ban English from being used in official Scottish government documents and force us all to use Gaelic instead?

        Also

        Will I still be allowed to say the Proclaimers are shit?

  25. Nae Need! says:

    This ruling lays an important foundation stone in the rebuilding of a saner and safer Scotland. But I can’t get overly chuffed.

    But whilst Rev. Stu still has grounds to write articles like ‘The Gender of Mountains’ and ‘The Groomer’s Shield’ none of us are entirely safe from the TRAs and this ideological madness. There is still far too much work to be done in restoring our society to a semblance of healthy functioning, and normality.

    Children are still being groomed in a wide variety of curricular and extra-curricular activities: safeguarding is next to non-existent, institutions are captured, secretive and confused, individuals (male and female) are still being persecuted out of their livelihoods & careers and being forced to fight David and Goliath legal battles, and the list goes on and on.

    Today’s ruling is a milestone, a battle won, in what is going to be a long drawn-out war. It does though give us hope that one day we might consign this repugnant and malign influence to the history bin. Where it belongs.

    Reply
  26. Grouser says:

    Does this now mean that Fife Health Board will stop their ridiculous persecution of Sandie Peggie and offer her an apology and compensation for all the distress they have caused her? And tell the good Doctor not to use the women’s single sex space?

    Reply
    • Willie says:

      The Sandra Peggie case is a appropriate one to raise.

      A contemporary case reflecting the nonsense of transwoman being allowed to encroach on biological women’s spaces.

      Maybe the tide will turn further and there could be some overdue sackings in the Fife health board.

      Reply
  27. Confused says:

    The irony of all this – good from evil – is that the Supreme Court is itself an abomination which clearly DESTROYS the basis of the union between Scotland and England; it is a clear breach and as soon as it was setup the ScotGov should have withdrawn from the treaty and gone to the UN to inform them that the UK no longer exists.

    Given the english are the most hated people on earth we would easily have won acceptance, likely 197 to nil.

    Reply
    • Hatey McHateface says:

      “Given the english are the most hated people on earth”

      Given that you can’t show your working or any evidence, sane, rational readers can safely discount your assertion.

      I’d blame the Covid vax if I was you.

      I’m sure you must have been fine before you got jabbed 🙂

      Admit it, Confused. You are SO CLOSE to wanting to support dicks in female spaces just because the Supreme Court says NO. I bet that even now, all over Scotland, hundreds are going that extra inch that you so far won’t and thundering:

      Support Our Scottish Trannies! Because They’re Scottish!

      Reply
      • Confused says:

        you should think before you post … but why stop now?

        my position on the trannies is clear, as is what I said

        do you deliberately miss the point all the time or are you just thick or so determined to push your stupid agenda you can’t even pick a good ground to attack from?

        The english have been booted out of 65 countries, no one ever wanted them back.

        The separation of the legal systems was baked into the treaty to begin with; it is quite important. For the scottish “nationalists” to miss this gold played opportunity is just another proof of them “jist na intae it”.

    • Dave says:

      You’re right about one thing: you really are confused. Are you a fan of urophagia, by any chance?

      Reply
      • Confused says:

        your mother is

        she said so last night

        but I made my excuses and left

        I made a donation of £10 so she could buy your dinner from iceland

      • Geri says:

        You should hear what the geopolitical channels say about the English… you’d need smelling salts. Their attempts at trying to re-establish their Empire & meddling in wars they’ve no chance of winning is the butt of many a brutal scathing attack from analysts online..

        English elite are delusional, devious, full of pedophiles, incest & secretive diabolical rituals that has riddled their brains through incest. Their specialty is intel gathering & blackmail through their networks which they use against others to keep an air of relevance & influence on European elites. Everyone knows about it. Their posh schools churn them out by the dozen & the House of Lords is hoaching with them. Passed down through generation to generation. They have no cure. Just laugh at then, they have nothing to offer. All they have is a small black book & a yappy mouth making demands their arse can’t cash. What do they have really? Rolls Royce? So what? Remove that & they’re 3rd world. It’s a degenerate country. They’re witless & not rational people but they are dangerous because they’re an obstacle. Like a small yapping dog getting under everyone’s feet demanding to be noticed”

        Ouch…

        That’s just one from tonight on the topic of the FBI throwing London under the bus for a lot of the shit they’ve been doing in U that they should be held accountable for… Oh deary. Is the special relationship over?

        I can’t argue with any of his views. They’re spot on. From Spoon face & his love of pigs – tae Epstein Island. Fae the Masonic order – tae Jim’ll Fix it yer scarred for life..There’s been ex MPs expose Westminster’s little black book before & how they use it to remove ppl or cover up the dead bodies. What a nasty bunch. Maybe the English should abolish those toff schools completely. They’re a breeding ground for churning out mentally deranged fuckwits that go on to be PMs & lawmakers.. it’d be the only cure to break the cycle.

      • Hatey McHateface says:

        That’s right, Barbie, you tell it how it is.

        You’re gonna need a bigger gas chamber.

        Beats me how you never achieved Indy high office with a popular policy like this one. Maybe just biding your time, eh, Babs?

      • Aidan says:

        When you say “geo-political channels”, you mean specifically the channels of one particular country, the country that has continually been invading its neighbours for the last 20 years. The one that has caused nearly a million deaths and casualties over the last three years with a totally unprovoked crime of aggression.

      • Geri says:

        Nope.

        I mean the channels that have a whole host of guests from all over the world.

        Spare us the bullshit you lot are famous for. It only works in your wee inbred bubble.

        We all know exactly who started it, when & who was right there in the thick of it noising things up & like a dog round shite looking for scraps at the end of it. The exact same colonisers who are currently there, pouring in £billions to keep fighting & fck their own citizens at home & Us sovereigty – fighting over rare earth minerals & other resources like fcking savages they claim everyone else is. The vultures now think they’ll carve it up & power share LOLz! Awww, back with their Nazi brethren at last & a new union to force onto what’s left..

        The coup in 2014 was the invasion.

        Rejecting three peace proposals cost lives & still is.

        The message was simple. No NATO because everyone knows NATO is nukes on Rs border & a permanent, antagonist anti social neighbour permanently looking for a fight.

        It was all rejected. R knows the English are responsible for terrorist attacks inside of R too & assassinations/attempts so they can fck right off now. The game has changed & they’ll no longer be giving back the buffer zone.

        There goes England & it’s wee cowardly terrorist attacks again.

        UN has already received a dossier on the intel gathered of an imminent biological attack from one of USA/Us 46 bio labs they claimed not to own but were later forced to recant at Senate & admit they had them with absolutely no knowledge to the BWC of the shit they are conducting there. The USA had to hurry up & protect them incase *the Rs got their hands on them* cause gawd knows what *they’d* do with them. Like they’re any better! It’d kill most of Europe we discovered. Already admitting then that it was some serious shit they had going on, all unregulated & unknown to the BWC. These Muppets are as thick as shit cause now it’s on video evidence

        Perfidious Albion then assassinated the author/Investigator. Too late tho – dossier already compiled & submitted.

        But tell us, Einstein, what the actual fck is Perfidious Albion doing there since 2014 anyway? What business was it to you plebs? Oh, noising up a civil war & persecuting R speaking regions. I think we can safely rule out the bullshit they were trying to save us from invasion. The ‘I was just protecting myself by invading & occupying them’ bullshit has finally been exhausted to now being a standing joke. One that won’t work at the Hague when all this shit is over. R, having won, will demand the criminals are brought to justice on behalf of the innocent civilians they killed on a beach & at a music concert.

        Wear a uniform to fight – you cowardly fckwits. Instead of conducting terrorist attacks. You pulled the same bullshit in NI.

        That is why yer despised around the globe. Everyone’s had a taste of yer terrorist activities. It’s only in yer head that you think you are loved around the world, you’re really aren’t.

      • Aidan says:

        @Geri – could you refer me to one of these “channels” and advise which programme I should be watching?

        Again – intrigued on where I can find this dossier demonstrating an imminent biological attack was about to take place? Please provide a link for that.

    • Mark Beggan says:

      It’s pish like this that put pish like Sturgeon in n power.

      Reply
    • Yoon Scum says:

      Don’t forget that the English state believes the earth is round

      here you go

      link to theflatearthsociety.org

      Reply
      • Confused says:

        the english believe in a lot of mad things, including that they still rule the earth

        youtu.be/kpgZy67yjFI?t=65

        you know, I have been opposed to “assisted dying” from the beginning, but your posting stream of late is turning me around

        lieben unwertes lieben

        – come the day, we will send round the mobile gas van for you YS

        I will be the guy driving it, wearing the armband.

      • Hatey McHateface says:

        “I have been opposed to “assisted dying” from the beginning, but your posting stream of late is turning me around”

        Haha, good one Confused.

        And I’m Lord Lucan.

        But what makes you think you’ll be allowed to drive? You’ll have to wait your turn behind all the rest of the usual suspects.

        C’moan Confused, think outside the box. How else are you going to get your majority for Yes?

      • Geri says:

        LMAO!

        Aye..& I’ll be tour guide Barbie making sure no seat goes to waste…

      • Hatey McHateface says:

        Sure, Geri, but your mates will choose to call you Klaus.

        You’ll need to put a point on your batten 🙂

      • Yoon Scum says:

        After you lot get your ideal independent scotland

        I’ll happily get in the van

        If only to escape the Scottish broadcasting corporation

        which will be Braveheart on an infinite loop

      • Geri says:

        A step up fae posh Kiddie chasers then..

        Superb…

    • Chas says:

      Congratulations on your very apt username. A suggestion-you could add another two words to it-‘and thick’ would be appropriate.

      Maybe the Poileas will be at your door soon. Nearly everything you post is a Hate Crime!

      Reply
      • Confused says:

        the union is a hate crime – the greatest of all time, leviathan on an ocean of blood

        everything you post is a boredom-crime

  28. Ian McCubbin says:

    Let’s hope this is the end for Swinney and Co with their gender woo woo.
    I sincerely hope Fife council also apologise to the nurse in her tribunal case and compensate her.

    Reply
  29. Peter McAvoy says:

    Well done to everybody who campaigned for this.

    I am no fan of the UK supreme court but they made the right decision on this issue.

    How much will it cost the taxpayer to amend all government literature and websites.

    Reply
  30. Callum says:

    So ends Sturgeonism and I think the most relieved person will be Swinney who quickly accepted the ruling. He had no choice but Swinney may start to put distance between the SNP and the Trans cult.

    Reply
  31. Confused says:

    classic copypasta : print t-shirts, flyers …

    YOU WILL NEVER BE A REAL WOMAN. You have no womb, you have no ovaries, you have no eggs. You are a homosexual man twisted by drugs and surgery into a crude mockery of nature’s perfection.

    All the “validation” you get is two-faced and half-hearted. Behind your back people mock you. Your parents are disgusted and ashamed of you, your “friends” laugh at your ghoulish appearance behind closed doors.

    Men are utterly repulsed by you. Thousands of years of evolution have allowed men to sniff out frauds with incredible efficiency. Even trannies who “pass” look uncanny and unnatural to a man. Your bone structure is a dead giveaway. And even if you manage to get a drunk guy home with you, he’ll turn tail and bolt the second he gets a whiff of your diseased, infected axe wound.

    You will never be happy. You wrench out a fake smile every single morning and tell yourself it’s going to be ok, but deep inside you feel the depression creeping up like a weed, ready to crush you under the unbearable weight.

    Eventually it’ll be too much to bear – you’ll buy a rope, tie a noose, put it around your neck, and plunge into the cold abyss. Your parents will find you, heartbroken but relieved that they no longer have to live with the unbearable shame and disappointment. They’ll bury you with a headstone marked with your birth name, and every passerby for the rest of eternity will know a man is buried there. Your body will decay and go back to the dust, and all that will remain of your legacy is a skeleton that is unmistakably male.

    This is your fate. This is what you chose. There is no turning back.

    Reply
  32. Terry says:

    Take a bow Stu. You have been incredible on this. As an active womens campaigner I can’t thank you enough xxx

    Reply
  33. Confused says:

    The fallback position of the middle class brigade (when they are not making violent threats) – “just be kind” – does not come without cost.

    Last night on the news, shitty wee story about a wee boy who has this horrible muscle wasting disease; there is a drug for it, but the NHS don’t provide it. Now it could be – the drug is shit, the pharma corp are profiteering like fuck, or there are “better things to spend the money on” – but it made me think : how much real money is spent on this totally unnecessary “gender medicine”?

    – tranny surgery and drugs on the SNHS is a bit like weapons with ukgov – there is always money available for nukes, warplanes, stupid countries who did stupid things, foreign conflicts which shouldn’t concern us (reeves even raised the debt ceiling, her own rules, to do this) … infinity money for our hobby horses, but fuckall for you plebs.

    The wee lad with the Duchesnes Muscular Dystrophy – I bet there would be money available if he wanted to cut his dick off … but if there was money for this, supposed he changed his mind and said : actually, why not spend the dosh on the drugs for my muscles.

    Sometimes you need to think laterally.

    Reply
  34. 100%Yes says:

    Well done supreme court haven’t those who tried to state otherwise now have egg on there faces.

    Maybe the SNP can now focus on the bread and butter of politics and deliver on the mandates the party has been given over the last ten years and delivery the referendum promised.

    Reply
  35. Mark Beggan says:

    Does this mean all those middle aged English women with pink hair will return to their own country now.

    Reply
  36. robertkknight says:

    So many employers and organisations are sh!t scared of litigation by mentally ill individuals taking them to court for ridiculous sums in compensation, because their feels got hurt when someone didn’t entertain their outlandish claims to be a blue-haired and thoroughly confused whatever.

    As with illegal immigrants, it’s the playing-the-system lawyers who need reigned in IMHO.

    What did Shakespeare say about them in Henry VI Part 2? Little has changed since 1591!

    Reply
  37. James Barr Gardner says:

    The Day of the Trans has passed, ach weel whits next ? Age of consent reduced to 10 years old……….

    Reply
  38. Young Lochinvar says:

    An Admiral Byng moment for SHE whose name shall not be mentioned and her coven of hangers-on..

    Reply
  39. Vivian O’Blivion says:

    I congratulate For Women Scotland on securing a victory for common sense. It would be my understanding that one of their concerns was that spaces mandated for females on Scottish Government funded bodies would be usurped by mentally ill men in dresses. That seems like a reasonable anxiety.

    From the Scottish Government website: “The Gender Representation on Public Boards (Scotland) Act continues to set the objective for 50% of non-executive public board members to be women, helping ensure greater equality at the highest levels of public life.”

    How does this work in practice (in some instances)?
    Well, former SNP MP Angela Crawley recently joined the Board of Who Cares? (Scotland), a charity funded by Local Authorities (who are in receipt of the Scottish Government, block grant).
    Who Cares? (Scotland) has 14 Board members of whom 5 have XY chromosomes.

    I demand gender parity on Scottish Government funded bodies! Oh yeah, I forgot, that train only runs in one direction.

    Reply
  40. Colin Alexander says:

    Well done FWS. Great news.

    Reply
  41. Andy Wiltshire says:

    Further legal opinion required here – would Scottish independence mean that this decision could be overturned?

    Reply
    • Geri says:

      An independent Scotland would have her own EA & laws.

      We’d no longer be in the UK so not under UK legislation.

      The branch office wouldn’t be either, where this crap passed in the first place.

      *Not a lawyer*

      Reply
    • Hatey McHateface says:

      Of course. Who else will be in power post-Indy, if not the SNP?

      It’s their baby.

      As I pointed out earlier, the very fact that it’s an “English court” will be hardening attitudes all across Scotland as I write.

      In blind, unthinking opposition to everything English, and so in favour of every thing the “English courts” oppose.

      Who wants to fanny aboot judging the merits of the case when there’s some tribalist loyalties to celebrate?

      Can we expect some variant of “Oor trannies were dragged oot o the lassies changing rooms agin oor will” to show itself?

      My gut says yes we can.

      Reply
      • panda paws says:

        A judgement made by two English women, a Welsh man and two Scottish men is not an “English court”. It’s literally called the United Kingdom Supreme Court. The Equality Act is a reserved piece of legislation passed by the Westminster parliament.

        Is it a matter of great shame that so many, in all parties, in the Scottish parliament passed the GRRB – yes. Is it appalling that the Scottish government have allowed, indeed promoted, effective self id in some many areas of Scottish life. You bet! However whilst Scotland remains in the UK, your preferred position after all, Scottish people can take cases to the UK Supreme Court where necessary and your trolling about it being English can be taken with the huge grain of salt it deserves.

      • Hatey McHateface says:

        Sorry, panda paws, but I thought me putting “English court” in double quotes would clearly signal I was being ironic.

        Obviously not.

        As for my preferred position being that Scotland should remain in the UK, you are making the same mistake the knuckle-draggers on here make. They assume that No True Scot would ever criticise our elected SNP numpties at HR, nor diss the kind of lowlifes on here that call for gas chambers to eliminate those who disagree with them.

        I believe that No True Scot would give these people a waft of the steam off their pish. They’re a stain on the honour of my country and No True Scot could thole for even one minute the idea of them ever getting control over the rest of us.

        I don’t see you as being in the knuckle dragging lowlife camp, PP, so perhaps you should pay more attention to what I post.

      • panda paws says:

        Hatey

        I’m a rare poster or indeed reader btl on WOS these days so I’m not familiar with all the usernames, far less all their posts. I’ve criticised the nuSNP loads of times as they deserve it! For me it’s independence and women’s rights and they fail on both!

    • Yoon Scum says:

      As we have left the UK then that ruling vanishes in a puff of logic

      Along with all other UK laws

      NOW

      Seeing the UN is going to phone up Westminster anyday now and free Scotland

      then we’ll still have the SNP loonies in charge

      So they can pass any law they wish

      If they decide that it is illegal to suck a lesbians cock

      then they can

      and they probably would

      On your knees

      Derek the 6foot tall hairy lesbian wants some fun

      I do hope for your sake “she” has had a shower after a hard day emptying bins as “her” balls get really sweaty

      Reply
  42. Nae Need! says:

    I believe that Stu might also be enjoying a more personal celebration this evening . . . something I didn’t know about.
    Congratulations, Stu 🙂

    “In good news for free speech, a claimant today has failed in a judicial review of Greater Manchester Police’s decision to take no further action against Stuart Campbell (AKA @WingsScotland).

    The claimant, a trans woman, complained to Greater Manchester Police after Stuart made a series of tweets in 2023 criticising what he characterised as the weaponisation of Brianna Ghey’s murder by trans activists and referring to biological sex. The claimant alleged that Stuart had committed offences contrary to the Malicious Communications Act 1988 and the Communications Act 2003.

    The High Court today determined that Greater Manchester Police were entitled to take no further action. First, Stuart was expressing a valid opinion on what he perceived as the politicisation of Ghey’s death; and second, Stuart’s views on biological sex were recognised as being worthy of tolerance in a democratic society, as per Forstater v CGD Europe and Higgs v Farmor’s School.

    Mrs Justice Hill said that:

    “The Defendant’s conclusion properly reflected society’s fundamental values of free speech, including the need for tolerance of statements and opinions that some might find offensive or upsetting.”

    “FSU is proud to have assisted Stuart in this case and expresses thanks to Roddy Dunlop KC for representing Stuart.

    The judgment is available to read here:
    link to assets.caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk

    Reply
    • Rev. Stuart Campbell says:

      Obviously we’ll have more on this, but today is FWS’s day 🙂

      Reply
  43. Well Done FOR WOMEN SCOTLAND!

    FOR WOMEN SCOTLAND 10 vs Nicola Sturgeon 0 !!

    Well done for all those women – Marion Calder, Susan Smith, Joanna Cherry, JK Rowling and many more – in The Supreme Court today – against the Scottish Government and for common sense.

    Now the battle begins for implementation!

    Reply
  44. Geoff Anderson says:

    Best line on Twitter
    “The Supreme Court Ruling is a real kick in the balls for TransWomen everywhere

    Reply
  45. Muscleguy says:

    Reality has ways of reasserting itself when fantasy nees to be punctured. This time it used the medium of Supreme Court Judges.

    BTW this court breaks the Treaty and Acts of Union. Will Scotgov now go all Salvo on them and repudiate the court?

    Reply
  46. Casper1066 says:

    Its now even cold yet.

    link to dailymail.co.uk

    Labour trying to stop it they are not happy with Supreme Court decision. Fight is still on

    Reply


Comment - please read this page for comment rules. HTML tags like <i> and <b> are permitted. Use paragraph breaks in long comments. DO NOT SIGN YOUR COMMENTS, either with a name or a slogan. If your comment does not appear immediately, DO NOT REPOST IT. Ignore these rules and I WILL KILL YOU WITH HAMMERS.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a (mainly) Scottish political media digest and monitor, which also offers its own commentary. (More)

    Stats: 6,750 Posts, 1,217,213 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Hatey McHateface on Let’s Make Jen Safe Again: “The MSM is reporting that President Trump has announced that the Hotties have hoisted the white flag. There does seem…May 6, 20:52
    • Hatey McHateface on Let’s Make Jen Safe Again: “Something else just occurred to me. Why didn’t the people of Clydebank just shout in unison “Bairns Not Bombs” at…May 6, 20:26
    • Hatey McHateface on Let’s Make Jen Safe Again: ““in various hot places not so near to here, the establishment, of which Sturgeon is a fully paid up member,…May 6, 20:22
    • Hatey McHateface on Let’s Make Jen Safe Again: “Your post has been up for several hours now, yet none of the usual suspects have jumped in with the…May 6, 19:52
    • Hatey McHateface on Let’s Make Jen Safe Again: ““a fetish for rectoral positions” Gigity!May 6, 19:41
    • Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh on Let’s Make Jen Safe Again: “Thank you for your interesting comment, Michael. I tried replying earlier today with footage of the Clydebank Blitz which certainly…May 6, 19:31
    • Bilbo on Let’s Make Jen Safe Again: “Stop talking rubbish you twat.May 6, 18:49
    • Yoon Scum on Let’s Make Jen Safe Again: “I know that this will be dismissed as FAR RIGHT ANTI-SCOTTISH HATE SPEECH FROM THE ENGLISH SCUM WHO SHALL BE…May 6, 18:37
    • Bilbo on Let’s Make Jen Safe Again: “FFS, calm down everybody. Twat has numerous meanings and Twathater is using it int the context of a foolish or…May 6, 18:34
    • Mia on Let’s Make Jen Safe Again: “Yes, now that I have calmed down a bit and I have had a bit more time to think, suddenly…May 6, 17:54
    • Yoon Scum on Let’s Make Jen Safe Again: “The more I look at the plans for the economy , the currency and the people we have in Holyrood…May 6, 17:18
    • Mia on Let’s Make Jen Safe Again: “The political fraud Sturgeon is quoted in the Herald as saying: “The question for me and I think for a…May 6, 17:14
    • SilentMajority on Let’s Make Jen Safe Again: “The Sturgeon revisionist bio will certainly be a hoot…hopefully straight into the recycle waste via the ‘bargain bin’.May 6, 14:39
    • Andrew scott on Let’s Make Jen Safe Again: “She/it/they is/are a HORRIBLE HARRIDANMay 6, 14:30
    • Michael Laing on Let’s Make Jen Safe Again: “An interesting account, albeit the Germans didn’t have four-engined bombers. Unless I’m mistaken, all their bombers were twin-engined.May 6, 14:10
    • Marie on Let’s Make Jen Safe Again: “And no apology to women and girls. Sturgeon is arrogant deluded and dangerous.May 6, 13:07
    • Michael Laing on Let’s Make Jen Safe Again: “The lives of unemployed and ill and disabled people are ‘almost unliveable’. Indeed, many have been forced to live on…May 6, 13:01
    • Stuart MacKay on Let’s Make Jen Safe Again: “Meanwhile in various hot places not so near to here, the establishment, of which Sturgeon is a fully paid up…May 6, 12:59
    • Dave Hansell on The Takeover: “Well, Hatey. I would debate the issue with you – and have tried to on several occasions over the past…May 6, 12:43
    • Vivian O’Blivion on Let’s Make Jen Safe Again: “Speaking to reporters in the Scottish Parliament Sturgeon told reporters : “… in my mind that we are at risk…May 6, 12:17
    • Jay on Let’s Make Jen Safe Again: “In a few years reading Wings, i have not seen such an ignorant attempt at criticising Rev Campbell as that…May 6, 12:16
    • Hatey McHateface on Let’s Make Jen Safe Again: “@William G Walker He sometimes asks people on here if they are heterosexual or homosexual. Read into that what you…May 6, 12:14
    • Hatey McHateface on Let’s Make Jen Safe Again: “Hands up everyone who absolutely loves, LOVES! I tell you, the proud, patriotic, nationalist, blue-arsed Scots, who don’t know the…May 6, 12:08
    • Jay on Let’s Make Jen Safe Again: “Agree with WG Walker, hating that female anatomy suggests some of the worst aspects of the trans movement, therefore a…May 6, 12:06
    • Oneliner on Let’s Make Jen Safe Again: “AGREED. But I doubt your viewpoint will gain much traction with the people of Grangemouth. Whilst the Rev is right…May 6, 10:54
    • William G Walker on Let’s Make Jen Safe Again: “How I AGREE with twathater’s comments on how much the SNP has changed over the last ten years or so…May 6, 10:44
    • diabloandco on Let’s Make Jen Safe Again: “Twathater ,round of applause from me!May 6, 09:08
    • Chas on Let’s Make Jen Safe Again: “That rant is a hate crime. I am unsure why Stu gives you a platform for your bigoted racist posts…May 6, 08:21
    • Anthem on Let’s Make Jen Safe Again: “Well said! ?May 6, 08:21
    • twathater on Let’s Make Jen Safe Again: “@ Andy Storrie YOU sound like a snp diehard and apologist can you then tell me what has the snp…May 6, 02:30
  • A tall tale



↑ Top