The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland



What does it mean to be Scottish? 196

Posted on August 03, 2014 by

The above is a deceptively simple question and one to which the answer, of course, is as varied as the people you might ask it of as we approach September’s vote.

The debate so far would suggest that at one end of the scale, we’re a nation of poor wee souls, much safer shackled to a United Kingdom that gifts us stability and security in the face of choppy global waters and saves us from the hassle of making crucial political decisions for ourselves. At the other end, we’re a proud nation of untold prosperity, a nirvana of wealth and social justice primed to emerge after our divorce from our oppressors in Westminster.

For anyone in between and still grappling with their identity, the Economist helpfully informed us recently that being Scottish means painting a Saltire on your face, wearing a Jimmy hat and shouting at nothing in particular. Glad that’s sorted then.

The truth is that very few of us will see ourselves in these broad-brushed caricatures of Scottish identity. I certainly don’t. In fact, the more I force myself to think about it, the clearer it becomes that I don’t have a bloody clue what it means to be Scottish.

Or at least I didn’t until last month.

Read the rest of this entry →

  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,980 Posts, 1,251,497 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • James Barr Gardner on His Majesty’s Loyal Sabre: “She would have been quite good as she has been skating on thin ice for years !Sep 21, 18:34
    • twathater on A Thousand Islands In The Sea: “I was once a staunch trade unionist until I found out what unions and Liebour thought of workers rights I…Sep 21, 18:20
    • Bilbo on His Majesty’s Loyal Sabre: “The State asset says that the TV show she got a fee to appear in exposes ‘our’ threadbare defences. What…Sep 21, 18:20
    • Red on His Majesty’s Loyal Sabre: ““The SNP has always had a hawkish faction,” That’s a polite way of saying “MI5 bumboys”Sep 21, 18:17
    • Bilbo on His Majesty’s Loyal Sabre: “The UK in the worldwide top ten of defence budgets but as a state, it can’t even maintain it’s borders.…Sep 21, 18:10
    • Bilbo on His Majesty’s Loyal Sabre: “I see the State asset said she had turned down an offer to go onto Dancing on Ice TV show.…Sep 21, 18:07
    • Red on His Majesty’s Loyal Sabre: “Sounds like MMT, the Sovereign Citizen theory of economics. There’s a finite amount of resources they can seize. An infinite…Sep 21, 17:54
    • Spartan 117 on His Majesty’s Loyal Sabre: “Not according to the Fabians who are rife across the major political parties, including those that are purportedly “Conservative”. The…Sep 21, 17:43
    • Minceheid on His Majesty’s Loyal Sabre: “Not everything is about Thatcher, unless you’re the early ’90s Ben Elton whose repertoire largely consisted of his shouting “Fatcher!”…Sep 21, 17:14
    • TURABDIN on His Majesty’s Loyal Sabre: “Having moved to London she will be concerned about the possibility of her new home being nuked. All this lends…Sep 21, 16:17
    • Adrian on His Majesty’s Loyal Sabre: “Government funds are not finiteSep 21, 16:04
    • Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh on A Thousand Islands In The Sea: “TRADE UNIONS ‘PUT WOMEN’S RIGHTS IN JEOPARDY’ BY SUPPORTING GENDER ID The Trades Union Congress (TUC) has committed its 5.3…Sep 21, 15:49
    • Rob on His Majesty’s Loyal Sabre: “The first responsibility of any government is defence of the realm. This is whether it is Scotland, the UK or…Sep 21, 15:31
    • Nancy Somerville on His Majesty’s Loyal Sabre: “I note that she says she hopes that the show “..sparks a debate about whether the country is properly prepared.”…Sep 21, 14:42
    • sam on A Thousand Islands In The Sea: “Thanks Northcode, A constitution is a set of principles and rules that outlines how a country is organised and governed,…Sep 21, 14:40
    • Jacqueline on His Majesty’s Loyal Sabre: “Thatcher doesn’t get a look in. What an evil piece. I sincerely hope that Paul gets to the truth and…Sep 21, 14:32
    • Spartan 117 on His Majesty’s Loyal Sabre: “More brilliant journalism from Stu, cutting through the keech in the MSM and delivering the hard facts on multiple fronts.…Sep 21, 14:27
    • Hatey McHateface on His Majesty’s Loyal Sabre: ““the USSR eventually won that battle” Helped by enormous gifts of material and money from the Yanks. Plus a second…Sep 21, 14:17
    • robertkknight on His Majesty’s Loyal Sabre: “Agent Sturgeon would certainly be best placed to defend mother England from the Orcs. Wouldn’t take much to perfect the…Sep 21, 14:05
    • sam on A Thousand Islands In The Sea: “Thanks Northcode, A constitution is a set of principles and rules that outlines how a country is organised and governed,…Sep 21, 14:01
    • Hatey McHateface on A Thousand Islands In The Sea: ““You’ve taken that one too far” The hunt for a migrant on an Orkney island and how the searchers will…Sep 21, 13:48
    • Mark Beggan on A Thousand Islands In The Sea: “That’s just a reflective response from the horses nervous system. It’s dead.Sep 21, 13:18
    • Hatey McHateface on A Thousand Islands In The Sea: “Something to remember the next time somebody starts to tell you that an Independent Scotland could be a lot like…Sep 21, 13:03
    • Hatey McHateface on A Thousand Islands In The Sea: “Of course, using Confused’s own logic, allowing “the Anglos” to cash in big on The Falkland’s mucho largesse would wean…Sep 21, 12:18
    • Hatey McHateface on A Thousand Islands In The Sea: ““well established and understood” Ha! I’d wager £100 that hardly any Scot knows of your post colonial boys, Alf. 20%…Sep 21, 12:07
    • Confused on A Thousand Islands In The Sea: “ANGLO PHILANTHROPY is jawdropping in its chutzpah : down the bottom – https://archive.ph/efFiS AT THE MOMENT, the deal is that…Sep 21, 11:32
    • Alf Baird on A Thousand Islands In The Sea: “Nice try, Northcode, but it is well established and understood that “colonialism only ends with the removal of the colonizer”…Sep 21, 11:30
    • Northcode on A Thousand Islands In The Sea: “BTL looked clinically dead a couple of hours ago. Now it’s twitching again. Interesting shift.Sep 21, 10:17
    • Hatey McHateface on A Thousand Islands In The Sea: “A fascinating article describing life in the place that has given us so much of what constitutes the modern world,…Sep 21, 09:34
    • Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh on A Thousand Islands In The Sea: “Can I just clarify that the above Vimeo link and YouTube link are to two different discussions.Sep 21, 09:33
  • A tall tale



↑ Top