The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Author Archive


What does it mean to be Scottish? 196

Posted on August 03, 2014 by

The above is a deceptively simple question and one to which the answer, of course, is as varied as the people you might ask it of as we approach September’s vote.

The debate so far would suggest that at one end of the scale, we’re a nation of poor wee souls, much safer shackled to a United Kingdom that gifts us stability and security in the face of choppy global waters and saves us from the hassle of making crucial political decisions for ourselves. At the other end, we’re a proud nation of untold prosperity, a nirvana of wealth and social justice primed to emerge after our divorce from our oppressors in Westminster.

For anyone in between and still grappling with their identity, the Economist helpfully informed us recently that being Scottish means painting a Saltire on your face, wearing a Jimmy hat and shouting at nothing in particular. Glad that’s sorted then.

The truth is that very few of us will see ourselves in these broad-brushed caricatures of Scottish identity. I certainly don’t. In fact, the more I force myself to think about it, the clearer it becomes that I don’t have a bloody clue what it means to be Scottish.

Or at least I didn’t until last month.

Read the rest of this entry →

  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,930 Posts, 1,244,564 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • sarah on Wider Than A Mile: “Thanks, Confused. I’m sure that the Convention wouldn’t truck GRR or men in women’s prisons, either. I’ve just heard back…Jun 11, 14:15
    • James Barr Gardner on Wider Than A Mile: “Double adapter….Jun 11, 13:57
    • Ian on Wider Than A Mile: “Scientific analysis indicates two main characteristics of SNP members. Old codgers and young chancers.Jun 11, 13:36
    • Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh on Wider Than A Mile: “Consulted a thesaurus: double-dealer? double-speak? double-faced? double-bind? double-agent?Jun 11, 13:14
    • Confused on Wider Than A Mile: “when someone is on the fiddle, gets caught at one thing, the sensible thing to say is not “you were…Jun 11, 12:59
    • Confused on Wider Than A Mile: “you’re right, the convention wasn’t called this guy has the details https://angrypict.substack.com/ NB the convention’s entire purpose was to stop…Jun 11, 12:57
    • Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh on Wider Than A Mile: “Cynicus @ 1.54 am “Is Honest John double-jobbing as a banana wholesaler?” —— Double-crossing, certainly…Jun 11, 12:40
    • Alf Baird on Wider Than A Mile: ““the pretendy Scottish parliament” Yes James, the “Manichaeism of colonial rule” (Fanon), where we see: – a people in ‘colonial…Jun 11, 12:26
    • sarah on Wider Than A Mile: “How many people know that Scotland had a two-tier system to approve legislation? England had, and has, the Commons and…Jun 11, 12:23
    • Alf Baird on The Ever-Changing Lie: ““a genuinely indigenous, Scottish line of reasoned logic” Here it is Hatey: https://cpb-us-w2.wpmucdn.com/wp.towson.edu/dist/b/55/files/2022/05/The-Socio-Political-Determinants-of-Scottish-Independence.pdfJun 11, 11:55
    • Aidan on Wider Than A Mile: “These issues have already been dealt with, at length, and in very great detail. Everyone understands Article 1 of the…Jun 11, 11:54
    • Cynicus on Wider Than A Mile: “Sean Duffy says: 10 June, 2026 at 4:38 pm “Scotland should demonstrate that it has not become some backward, banana…Jun 11, 11:54
    • James Che on Wider Than A Mile: “Stu, My full apologies for hijacking the money that was missing until your persistence journalism investigation was villified. But the…Jun 11, 11:28
    • James Che on Wider Than A Mile: “If union supports claim we are held together by a treaty, they need to evidence to prove their theoretical position.…Jun 11, 11:18
    • James Che on Wider Than A Mile: “There is a high % of people in Scotland that would appreciate this topic being aired from its origins to…Jun 11, 11:07
    • James Che on Wider Than A Mile: “The money is now not missing due to you being persistent in tracing the source of the deceit Stu with…Jun 11, 10:16
    • robertkknight on Wider Than A Mile: ““The definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over and expecting different results”. A bit like voting…Jun 11, 10:06
    • Hatey McHateface on The Ever-Changing Lie: “Alf, I guess the irony of your post dissing the coloniser’s values, hoaching with quotes, none of which are from…Jun 11, 09:07
    • Hatey McHateface on The Ever-Changing Lie: ““The Scottish Government is very mildly celebrating what is in effect the closure of Grangemouth” No shit Sherlock, er, Robin!…Jun 11, 08:08
    • Hatey McHateface on The Ever-Changing Lie: “You raise some good points, Bob, but how else are we to sweep the Arabic chanters and their tea-towel toting…Jun 11, 07:59
    • Hatey McHateface on The Ever-Changing Lie: “I’ve been thinking a lot about my own fossil fuel consumption, recycling, etc. Then I listen to the news to…Jun 11, 07:54
    • Hatey McHateface on The Ever-Changing Lie: “Exactly. In addition, as no second referendum has yet been held, a ring-fenced £660,000 carefully invested for several years might…Jun 11, 07:44
    • Hatey McHateface on The Ever-Changing Lie: “Our self-identifying, 1,000 year old, space traveling Pict accuses you of childishness, Mark. I hope you’re listening.Jun 11, 07:38
    • Ex President Xiden on Wider Than A Mile: “Credit where credit is due. With the SNP rejecting a call for a full public inquiry into this affair, they…Jun 11, 07:33
    • RobertG on Wider Than A Mile: “It was strange that Kate Forbes did not win the leadership election when Sturgeon had to quit. Forbes was the…Jun 11, 07:16
    • MarkD on Wider Than A Mile: “The bit I do not believe is when Swinney (aka Stewie) is sick. He would be high fives at that…Jun 11, 01:40
    • Cynicus on Wider Than A Mile: ““ Swinney rivals Trump for BS ” ========= So, the rumours are true! He really is Sturgeon’s ventriloquist’s dummy.Jun 11, 00:47
    • Dan on The Ever-Changing Lie: “Hmm, more on planet Armageddon. https://robinmcalpine.org/five-years-ago-progress-on-climate-change-ground-to-a-halt-in-scotland/ So is the perceived lack of further progress on climate action actually because it…Jun 10, 20:36
    • robertkknight on The Ever-Changing Lie: “I agreed with you Willie right up until your united Ireland assumption. I see it this way… A unified Ireland…Jun 10, 19:27
    • Dan on The Ever-Changing Lie: “Aye, I’m minded to agree with that Northcode. It seems to me that there are too many supposedly pro-returning Scotland…Jun 10, 18:55
  • A tall tale



↑ Top