The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland



Weekend: The state of our union 9

Posted on May 19, 2012 by

As part of our continuing look at the people who haven’t yet their minds up about independence, we’re delighted to present this piece by Sue Lyons. If you’re a “Don’t know” too, we’d love to hear from you – why not drop us a line?

I am a mum and a wife. In point of fact, I’m an English wife married to a Scottish husband, with three English children from my first marriage and two Scottish children from my current marriage. Why would I even bother to mention that at all, you might wonder – surely it doesn’t matter where my children were born, surely I love them just the same? And you would be right.

What makes it worth mentioning is that my husband is a Scottish nationalist. In fact, he’s such a Scottish nationalist that were the UK government to say tomorrow “You can have independence for Scotland but you have to pay for it yourself”, he would say, “Where do I sign?”

He describes himself as “rabid” and he’s absolutely right – if you cut off his leg he would have a saltire running through it like a stick of rock (but not Blackpool rock, because that’s in England). Not for him the sitting on the fence that others might do, not for him the idea that you can vote for the SNP and yet still be undecided on independence. John is for an independent Scotland completely and absolutely. That sometimes causes fun and games in our own personal Union – our home.

Read the rest of this entry →

Weekend guest: View from the fence 57

Posted on May 06, 2012 by

Ray McRobbie has his own blog, but dropped us a line to ask whether we’d be interested in hearing from someone who used to be anti-independence but now resides in the “undecided” camp. We said we’d be delighted. Take it away, Ray.

I’ve written a wee bit on the issue of Scottish independence in the past, without explicitly outlining my own view. A couple of years ago I was quick to criticise the Scottish National Party, and I’m not exactly a fan of Alex Salmond. Since then I’ve seen a lot, heard a lot and read a lot. I’ve studied the issue in some depth for my dissertation at university, and I figure I’ll be reading and writing a bit more in the lead up to the 2014 referendum. So I decided at some point I should actually outline where I stand. At least for the moment.

As it happens, I’m not really a decisive person. I usually like to have all the facts on something before I make a choice. A yes/no question is not often easy for me as I might pick the “wrong” option. This is a strategy I cannot depend on when it comes to Scottish independence. The referendum will most likely boil down to a yes or a no, but in reality it’s much more than that.

Read the rest of this entry →

  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a (mainly) Scottish political media digest and monitor, which also offers its own commentary. (More)

    Stats: 6,753 Posts, 1,217,499 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh on A Poor Example: “Just came across an old paperback in a box of books in the loft. Following is an extract from ‘OUR…May 11, 01:39
    • sam on A Poor Example: “https://www.legalfeminist.org.uk/May 10, 21:17
    • Hatey McHateface on A Poor Example: “Sure. The white English come in for a lot of stick on here, some of it well deserved too. Defo…May 10, 21:07
    • Scot Finlayson on A Poor Example: “The biggest immigrant population in Scotland is white English, nearly 500,000,mostly in Edinburgh,East Lothian and Fife coast, it`s like Spain`s…May 10, 20:36
    • Alastair on A Poor Example: “Sorry but I have to challenge you. This is not a poor example… it an exact example of the absolute…May 10, 20:29
    • Hatey McHateface on A Poor Example: “I see that nice poot boy has insisted he leads his country in providing an “indestructible barrier against Nazism, Russo…May 10, 20:28
    • Hatey McHateface on A Poor Example: “It all starts to make sense if you imagine Mrs Humza is trans. That gets her a bye on all…May 10, 20:14
    • Dan on A Poor Example: “Immigration you say? C’mon YS, thought you said you’d been keeping an eye on us lot. Just because you’ve rocked…May 10, 18:15
    • Yoon Scum on A Poor Example: “That’s a very English attitude you are showing towards the glory of islam there If you’re a TRUE SCOT then…May 10, 17:00
    • twathater on A Poor Example: “If you try to force me to adhere to the laws and regulations LAID DOWN and enforced????? in Scotland and…May 10, 14:58
    • Yoon Scum on A Poor Example: “Should Scotland leave the union so we can have completely unlimited immigration? As the biggest driver behind the Reform vote…May 10, 14:12
    • Yoon Scum on The Last Thing They’ll Expect: “I’m glad to hear that you think we have brilliant apprentices Why aren’t as many interested WELL They can study…May 10, 13:02
    • Captain Caveman on A Poor Example: “O/T @RevStu Just read your post over at BEEX, almost choked on my Bran Flakes! Bravo. Haven’t laughed like that…May 10, 12:47
    • Dan on The Last Thing They’ll Expect: “yoon scum says: at 5:40 am “your post pisses me off and annoys me” Well that’s a result! But most…May 10, 12:35
    • Confused on A Poor Example: “relationship advice? this is un-islamic nonsense; I have 30 clerics opinions which tells me Humza can do what he likes,…May 10, 12:34
    • Andrea on A Poor Example: “This is what I would have thought. As to discrimination to other men, I can discriminate, say, according to educational…May 10, 12:26
    • Cuilean on A Poor Example: “Back to the Humzas original video pitch. The three responses are toe-curlingly sexist, as is the whole scenario depicted. To…May 10, 12:11
    • Dave G on A Poor Example: “Many people with skin in the trans game don’t want to understand the ruling and think if they ignore it…May 10, 11:58
    • Bilbo on A Poor Example: “It does feel that the only concrete outcome of the ruling has been safeguarding free speech and high profile activities…May 10, 11:55
    • agent x on A Poor Example: “https://www.heraldscotland.com/news/25146182.humza-yousaf-writes-india-pakistan-leaders-urge-restraint/ 7th May Former first minister Humza Yousaf and former Irish Taoiseach Leo Varadkar have written to the leaders of…May 10, 11:46
    • Owen Mullions on A Poor Example: “Can a concerned neighbour please check on James Kelly on SGP as he seems to have suffered a complete mental…May 10, 11:04
    • James Cheyne on A Poor Example: “And I wonder what would happen if 98-% of Scotland refused to vote at local and main elections. And the…May 10, 10:36
    • Neil McKenzie on A Poor Example: “Kin hell, 3 answers to st Yer bawsMay 10, 10:30
    • Vivian O’Blivion on A Poor Example: “Five, Westminster voting intention polls conducted with field work exclusively in May. Average results as follows: RefUK 29.8%, Lab 22%…May 10, 10:21
    • A2 on A Poor Example: “nah, you just need to make sure it is.May 10, 10:15
    • SilentMajority on A Poor Example: “There will no doubt be blatant attempts to ignore or circumvent the law. Hopefully those who have previously been pressured…May 10, 10:15
    • aLurker on The Last Thing They’ll Expect: “Hi Stuart MacKay. This seems like an opportunity to ask you how does that ranking actually work? i.e. how do…May 10, 10:11
    • James Cheyne on A Poor Example: “Turning the page by broadening the topic, not changing it. The trans topic of corse was not invented in Scotland,…May 10, 09:02
    • Rev. Stuart Campbell on The Last Thing They’ll Expect: “Pardon?May 10, 08:24
    • Bilbo on A Poor Example: “Of course there has been action with highly visible things like women’s sport but it’s becoming plain to see that…May 10, 08:17
  • A tall tale



↑ Top