The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland



Weekend: The state of our union 9

Posted on May 19, 2012 by

As part of our continuing look at the people who haven’t yet their minds up about independence, we’re delighted to present this piece by Sue Lyons. If you’re a “Don’t know” too, we’d love to hear from you – why not drop us a line?

I am a mum and a wife. In point of fact, I’m an English wife married to a Scottish husband, with three English children from my first marriage and two Scottish children from my current marriage. Why would I even bother to mention that at all, you might wonder – surely it doesn’t matter where my children were born, surely I love them just the same? And you would be right.

What makes it worth mentioning is that my husband is a Scottish nationalist. In fact, he’s such a Scottish nationalist that were the UK government to say tomorrow “You can have independence for Scotland but you have to pay for it yourself”, he would say, “Where do I sign?”

He describes himself as “rabid” and he’s absolutely right – if you cut off his leg he would have a saltire running through it like a stick of rock (but not Blackpool rock, because that’s in England). Not for him the sitting on the fence that others might do, not for him the idea that you can vote for the SNP and yet still be undecided on independence. John is for an independent Scotland completely and absolutely. That sometimes causes fun and games in our own personal Union – our home.

Read the rest of this entry →

Weekend guest: View from the fence 57

Posted on May 06, 2012 by

Ray McRobbie has his own blog, but dropped us a line to ask whether we’d be interested in hearing from someone who used to be anti-independence but now resides in the “undecided” camp. We said we’d be delighted. Take it away, Ray.

I’ve written a wee bit on the issue of Scottish independence in the past, without explicitly outlining my own view. A couple of years ago I was quick to criticise the Scottish National Party, and I’m not exactly a fan of Alex Salmond. Since then I’ve seen a lot, heard a lot and read a lot. I’ve studied the issue in some depth for my dissertation at university, and I figure I’ll be reading and writing a bit more in the lead up to the 2014 referendum. So I decided at some point I should actually outline where I stand. At least for the moment.

As it happens, I’m not really a decisive person. I usually like to have all the facts on something before I make a choice. A yes/no question is not often easy for me as I might pick the “wrong” option. This is a strategy I cannot depend on when it comes to Scottish independence. The referendum will most likely boil down to a yes or a no, but in reality it’s much more than that.

Read the rest of this entry →

  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a (mainly) Scottish political media digest and monitor, which also offers its own commentary. (More)

    Stats: 6,673 Posts, 1,203,322 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Hatey McHateface on A Personal Best For Kezia: “Insult your intelligence? Think about it. How could I make a start on doing that? If it’s all about control…Nov 26, 20:53
    • Mia on A Personal Best For Kezia: “I have come across this interesting article in internet:”The Pedantic Critic: New study looks at the motive behind nitpicking other…Nov 26, 20:47
    • Robert Matthews on A Personal Best For Kezia: “scotland(North Britain) is in the UK, so yes, calls go to a UK call centre.Nov 26, 20:38
    • Muscleguy on A Personal Best For Kezia: “John Hannah of ISP gained 8.75% of the vote coming 4th in the Tamworth by election a few months ago.…Nov 26, 20:34
    • Michael Laing on A Personal Best For Kezia: “Howsabout you explain to us how Scotland benefits from being in the UK instead of making pathetic comments about other…Nov 26, 19:59
    • Sven on A Personal Best For Kezia: “Police Scotland Call Service Centres are listed as being in Glasgow, Motherwell & Edinburgh.Nov 26, 19:53
    • Campbell Clansman on A Personal Best For Kezia: “There’s 4 more council by-elections in Scotland this year. Alba (the “true Indy Party” according to some here) can’t find…Nov 26, 19:48
    • Republicofscotland on A Personal Best For Kezia: “You would’ve thought that Scotland’s Police Force would have its own separate number. Of course Police Scotland was formed in…Nov 26, 19:47
    • Republicofscotland on A Personal Best For Kezia: “Mia – I think you might be replying to an AI Bot there in use now – and are quite…Nov 26, 19:38
    • Sven on A Personal Best For Kezia: “Any MSP of any Party who condones, far less advocates, allowing biological males within a mile of a womens’ refuge,…Nov 26, 19:38
    • Republicofscotland on A Personal Best For Kezia: “I see – that not just the Scottish government (SNP) – but many MSPs at Holyrood don’t know what a…Nov 26, 19:23
    • Hatey McHateface on A Personal Best For Kezia: “It’s perfectly reasonable for you to have that wish. I guess where the difficulties arise is that once you get…Nov 26, 19:12
    • Mia on A Personal Best For Kezia: ““We’re fighting people who blow dams and destroy millions of hectares of rich agricultural land” Who exactly is “we”? Scotland…Nov 26, 19:10
    • MaryB on A Personal Best For Kezia: “Maybe off topic, but, a 101 call to police Scotland now goes to a UK call centre. They asked which…Nov 26, 19:09
    • Zander Tait on A Personal Best For Kezia: “Farewell Campbell Clansman.Nov 26, 19:07
    • James on A Personal Best For Kezia: “Psychotic too….. These old HAL9000 units are showing their age.Nov 26, 19:06
    • Mia on A Personal Best For Kezia: ““the SNP are not nationalists” And they proved that beyond any reasonable doubt in 2015, 2017 and 2019 by rendering…Nov 26, 18:57
    • Tartanpigsy on A Personal Best For Kezia: “Any Plans for Saturday? Our Great Leader St Giles? I’m planning to be outside but not privy to any planned…Nov 26, 18:56
    • Mia on A Personal Best For Kezia: ““Labour hate the SNP more than the Tories” That might have been the case up to 2015. Since the political…Nov 26, 18:54
    • Captain Caveman on A Personal Best For Kezia: “We. Are. Not. The. Same. PERSON. What is it with internet-addled, scary-eyed saddos like you? Everyone disagreeing with what ever…Nov 26, 18:52
    • James on A Personal Best For Kezia: “Jeezo. Talking to himself now. Bad sign, that. Needs a reboot.Nov 26, 18:44
    • Sven on A Personal Best For Kezia: ““From the bottom up”. Why do these words strike fear into my heart when uttered by any MSP in the…Nov 26, 18:42
    • Zander Tait on A Personal Best For Kezia: “Ha ha ha. I reply to Captain Caveman but use his Campbell alias and, hey presto, the Captain replies. This…Nov 26, 18:41
    • Alf Baird on A Personal Best For Kezia: “Demonstrably Labour are neo-imperialist in ideological terms, as demonstrably are the SNP. Imperialism and nationalism are incompatible but this is…Nov 26, 18:34
    • Hatey McHateface on A Personal Best For Kezia: “It’s Regan, Ros. It’s not a good look if you can’t even spell the name of the only Scottish Indy…Nov 26, 18:29
    • Mia on A Personal Best For Kezia: ““English ‘breakaway republics’ ” And there we go. The raw colonial self-entitlement, the raw colonial self awarded commanding power and…Nov 26, 18:10
    • Frank anderson on A Personal Best For Kezia: “Labour hate the SNP more than the Tories. Labour are unionists, through and through, a nd will join any unionist…Nov 26, 17:53
    • Hatey McHateface on A Personal Best For Kezia: ““good authority”? No way!Nov 26, 17:52
    • Young Lochinvar on A Personal Best For Kezia: “Hear hear! Well said Mia.Nov 26, 17:45
    • Hatey McHateface on A Personal Best For Kezia: “Great news, Ros. We’re fighting people who blow dams and destroy millions of hectares of rich agricultural land. They’re people…Nov 26, 17:41
  • A tall tale



↑ Top