The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Small is beautiful 88

Posted on May 04, 2013 by

Are we doomed to decline if Scotland separates? I can think of lots of good reasons why Scotland might want to vote to remain part of the United Kingdom. But the Commons’ Foreign Affairs Select Committee report this week is not one of them.

smallcountry

According to the report, if Scotland votes for independence, it would mean the UK was “a world power in irreversible decline”. Setting aside the question of whether we should expect folk to vote in the interests of geopolitical greatness, does being small mean you’re doomed to be weak? Not at all. The assumption that in geopolitics strength comes from scale is simply not true.

Read the rest of this entry →

Tags:
Category analysis, comment, scottish politics, uk politics

  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,776 Posts, 1,219,847 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

    and finally and firstly arithmetic fail braveheart klaxon britnats captain darling cartoons Chris Cairns confused cringe crybabies dateline debates Devo Nano Federalists Unionists and Devolutionists flat-out lies foreigner watch from the archives fundraisers galleries Greg Moodie hamish hypocrisy liars light-hearted banter lizards memogate misinformation one nation perspectives poll project fear project feart qft Scott Minto smears snp accused soapbox the positive case for the union The Vow ticktock toldyouso too wee too poor too stupid unionist of the day vote no get nothing

  • Recent Comments

    • George Ferguson on The Grand Tour: “I have to comment after that exchange I have just had. Decades ago when I join the SNP and a…” Jun 13, 00:01
    • Confused on The Grand Tour: “main spends all day trying to save old blighty, but it’s done https://archive.ph/gPbIQ and it won’t be 2100, more like…” Jun 12, 23:39
    • Scot Finlayson on The Grand Tour: “Ireland is one of the most indebted countries in the world, `The national debt of Ireland was estimated at approximately…” Jun 12, 23:29
    • George Ferguson on The Grand Tour: “@Insider Of course I know there is more than one George Ferguson. The point I was making which you missed…” Jun 12, 23:04
    • James on The Grand Tour: “Careful there, MaryB -you’ll set off the Yoonhowlers and Franchise fannies!” Jun 12, 22:44
    • Insider on The Grand Tour: “George Ferguson …. FFS ! Grow up ! Have you never realised there may be more than one person in…” Jun 12, 22:37
    • Insider on The Grand Tour: “Findlay… “Governments don’t need to borrow money, they could issue their own currency…..” Aye right ! I’ve still got some…” Jun 12, 22:32
    • MaryB on The Grand Tour: “Scot goes Pop so pathetic. Asks a question about who should have a vote in an Indy ref. But won’t…” Jun 12, 22:24
    • George Ferguson on The Grand Tour: “@Dan Hi Dan a good example of AI on X. I wrote a post and Grok3 said I was George…” Jun 12, 21:52
    • Findlay on The Grand Tour: “Scott, I thought that every country that uses a central banking system has a ;national debt’. You say that it’s…” Jun 12, 21:47
    • Scot Finlayson on The Grand Tour: “Even Norway has a national debt, it borrows money to pay for infrastructure like every other nation, it is cheaper…” Jun 12, 20:59
    • Hatey McHateface on The Grand Tour: ““It was just under a billion quid the taxpayer paid out in curtailment charges last year to big often foreign…” Jun 12, 19:47
    • James on The Grand Tour: “Dan – was the bot a “John Main” model? ;-D” Jun 12, 19:38
    • Dan on The Grand Tour: “@ Hatey Oh do fuck off. Show me where you have ever seen me state leccy would be free? If…” Jun 12, 18:59
    • agent x on The Grand Tour: “FIRST Minister John Swinney has said he does not think a challenge to his leadership would be a “good idea”.…” Jun 12, 18:37
    • Dan on The Grand Tour: “Has anybody tried switching the internet aff, and jist leaving it aff… Was trying to find the Wings article on…” Jun 12, 18:37
    • Hatey McHateface on The Grand Tour: ““The 6 farms that make up the Seagreen area off the Angus coast regularly are sitting in curtailment mode during…” Jun 12, 18:31
    • Hatey McHateface on The Grand Tour: ““provide its people with cheap renewable energy before exporting to England or anywhere else” Sigh. It is undeniable that the…” Jun 12, 18:23
    • Dan on The Grand Tour: “Aye James, most of the top 5 “concerns” that sit above Scotland returning to self-governing status can’t and won’t be…” Jun 12, 18:14
    • Dan on The Grand Tour: “@ JBG Scotland’s leccy demand could / should be significantly higher than it is if we had more industries requiring…” Jun 12, 18:05
    • Alf Baird on The Grand Tour: ““it’s the establishment in our neighbour’s capital that benefits tremendously by having Scotland shackled to it.” Yes, colonialism (aka ‘the…” Jun 12, 18:02
    • Northcode on The Grand Tour: “This extract from an article by Sara Salyers posted on the Salvo website. Political ‘Kryptonite’ and UK Exceptionalism: …Management of…” Jun 12, 17:53
    • PhilM on The Grand Tour: “Wait til Vivian O’Blivian takes a keek at that line-up for the Project 2050 conference…” Jun 12, 17:47
    • Breastplate on The Grand Tour: “That’s right, we’ve all had enough of this democracy nonsense. Democracy isn’t even in the top 10 of things people…” Jun 12, 17:46
    • James on The Grand Tour: “Scotland’s Imaginary Debt; In 2022-23 Scotland raised £87.5bn in tax which goes directly to Westminster. However, the Scottish Government only…” Jun 12, 17:32
    • James on The Grand Tour: ““…Independence isn’t even in the top 5 important issues that the general public are even interested in…” Maybe they don’t…” Jun 12, 17:28
    • Dunx on The Grand Tour: “The Barrhead Boy article just reads as a wish list. He treats UDI as an end in itself. There’s nothing…” Jun 12, 17:10
    • James Barr Gardner on The Grand Tour: “Scotland’s power requirement is under 5GW…… There must be a dale/tarn or two in Ye Merry Olde Engalunt that would…” Jun 12, 17:07
    • agent x on The Grand Tour: “Hatey McHateface says: Rev Stu won’t live forever. ————————————— Is that what the polls say?” Jun 12, 16:45
    • Insider on The Grand Tour: “Stuart… Give up son ! Hatey can swat away a dozen wannabe wee trolls like you in the blink of…” Jun 12, 16:44

  • A tall tale



↑ Top