The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Matters of life and death 53

Posted on December 02, 2014 by

Of all the powers that Labour were reportedly responsible for keeping reserved to Westminster, abortion law is perhaps the most revealing about Labour’s true attitude towards Scotland and devolution during the Smith Commission’s deliberations.

It’s one of a handful of issues, including embryology, xenotransplantation (that’s transplanting a cell or organ from one species to another) and surrogacy, which would otherwise fall to the Cabinet Secretary for Health had Labour not specifically reserved them when creating the Scottish Parliament in 1997.

abortionloonies

(In fact, it was Tony Blair who personally insisted that abortion law remain reserved to Westminster. Donald Dewar was apparently in favour of devolving it, but we all know who wins in a battle between Scottish Labour and London Labour.)

If the Smith Commission was nothing else, it was an opportunity for unionists – Labour in particular – to prove their commitment to devolution by relinquishing their hold on powers previously considered too important to fall within the Scottish Parliament’s remit. Unsurprisingly, they declined it.

Read the rest of this entry →

Tags:
Category analysis, comment, scottish politics

The lesser of evils 115

Posted on November 18, 2014 by

Ever since Nicola Sturgeon announced on Saturday that the SNP would never put the Tories in government, various mainstream political pundits have shown an alarming level of inability to grasp the concept of someone who cannot possibly become Prime Minister declaring their preference out of those who can.

borgen

Perhaps we’re being a bit unkind, as this isn’t a regular feature of British politics – usually we only hear the leaders of the two main parties telling us why they’re the best for the job, with the Liberal Democrat candidate comically trying to pretend that they stand a chance of being Prime Minister – but it does highlight the extraordinarily parochial nature of political debate in the UK media.

Because anyone who cares to cast a glance across the continent will see that such scenarios are not just common, but often an integral part of politics across Europe.

Read the rest of this entry →

Tags:
Category analysis, europe, media, scottish politics

  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,868 Posts, 1,234,541 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

    and finally and firstly arithmetic fail braveheart klaxon britnats captain darling cartoons Chris Cairns confused cringe crybabies dateline debates Devo Nano Douglas Daniel Federalists Unionists and Devolutionists flat-out lies foreigner watch from the archives fundraisers galleries hamish hypocrisy liars light-hearted banter lizards memogate misinformation one nation perspectives poll project fear project feart qft Scott Minto smears snp accused soapbox the positive case for the union The Vow ticktock toldyouso too wee too poor too stupid unionist of the day vote no get nothing

  • Recent Comments

    • Cynicus on The Secondhand Amendment: “Vivian O’Blivion, 19 January, 2026 at 9:09 am “In the seventies, and eighties, the composition of Westminster could be lazily…” Jan 19, 10:46
    • 100%Yes on The Secondhand Amendment: “Nigel Farage will ‘try to scrap Holyrood’ as PM, says John Swinney, sign me up. The SNP has used Holyrood…” Jan 19, 10:38
    • Alf Baird on Learning Insanity: ““there would be no Union” More astute observers now realise that the so-called UK ‘Union’ is of course a charade,…” Jan 19, 10:30
    • Patsy Millar on The Secondhand Amendment: “Absolutely!” Jan 19, 10:14
    • 100%Yes on The Secondhand Amendment: “Long tails and short skirts will sooner or later will have to end in favor of biological women and men.…” Jan 19, 10:05
    • James Cheyne on The Secondhand Amendment: “Lorna, I have replied to you’re comment you made yesterday on Stu’s previous post, so not to interrupt this one…” Jan 19, 09:58
    • James Cheyne on Learning Insanity: “Lorna, The need to research the accumulated information under one roof would not go amiss, which is something that not…” Jan 19, 09:54
    • James Cheyne on Learning Insanity: “Lorna. It did not simply expand Great Britain parliament. It dissolved the parliament of Great Britain in 1800, You will…” Jan 19, 09:43
    • Sven on The Secondhand Amendment: “One can only applaud Mr Kennedy, and, of course, our esteemed host.” Jan 19, 09:15
    • Rogueslr on The Secondhand Amendment: “When West Midlands Police ‘made up’ evidence to ban fans, and referenced events that never occured, the result was the…” Jan 19, 09:14
    • John on Learning Insanity: “FYI, The ‘Metagender’ status is specifically fluidity within identity. The technical term is ‘Schrodinger’s Twat’.” Jan 19, 09:13
    • Vivian O’Blivion on The Secondhand Amendment: “The balance between independence, and oversight of the judiciary is the perennial problem. In the seventies, and eighties, the composition…” Jan 19, 09:09
    • Effijy on The Secondhand Amendment: “Absolutely unacceptable whitewash and a very large nail in the coffin of justice. Why don’t they just tear up the…” Jan 19, 08:31
    • WeeChid on Learning Insanity: “I’m so glad I’m retired ’cause if I was still in the workplace and had to go on one of…” Jan 19, 08:26
    • Adam Hibbert on The Secondhand Amendment: “As I understand it, “Judicial colleague” is a standard phrase only used to refer to fellow judges. So the error…” Jan 19, 08:10
    • Willie on The Secondhand Amendment: “If it was AI as you suggest Iain then this would mark Judge Kemp as a liar since Sandra Muir…” Jan 19, 04:09
    • Tim on The Secondhand Amendment: “Are the judges and lawyers (reputed to have been) involved in “Fettesgate” in the early 90s still in place? That…” Jan 19, 03:50
    • Northern Lad on The Secondhand Amendment: “*complaint not compliant!” Jan 19, 03:28
    • Iain mhor on The Secondhand Amendment: “Everybody and their dug knows it was AI. Every Civil Service letter I get is patently AI generated. Nobody in…” Jan 19, 03:18
    • Willie on The Secondhand Amendment: “Surely not another cover up? Surely yes I’m afraid Northern Lad. Duvet government, duvet law, might be euphemisms to describe…” Jan 19, 03:18
    • Campbell Clansman on The Secondhand Amendment: “The Muir reply was pure Sir Humphrey Appleby.” Jan 19, 01:55
    • Northern Lad on The Secondhand Amendment: “A long time reader and admirer of the site but rarely a commentator. What I would say is that the…” Jan 19, 01:21
    • Willie on The Secondhand Amendment: “A most excellent informative article Rev Stu. And a thanks too to solicitor Ewen G Kennedy for his excellent complaint…” Jan 19, 01:20
    • Cynicus on The Secondhand Amendment: ““Whether it was Judge Kemp or our mysterious John or Jane Doe who made them up, they were still made…” Jan 19, 00:44
    • Young Lochinvar on Learning Insanity: “H McH Another your “bad” to add to your count. Wrong again. FACT!” Jan 18, 22:13
    • Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh on Learning Insanity: “For an overtly Christian articulation of the case for Scottish independence I would direct attention to the seminal 2009 book…” Jan 18, 20:19
    • Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh on Learning Insanity: “Professor ALF BAIRD’s commendable letter to the MODERATOR of the Church of Scotland is on BarrheadBoy’s site here: SCOTLAND’S COLONIAL…” Jan 18, 19:34
    • Alf Baird on Learning Insanity: ““Indy should be such an easy sell, a unifying idea, that we really shouldn’t be bringing religion into it. Not…” Jan 18, 19:23
    • BigJay on Learning Insanity: “…and I’ve found the letter in reply from the Moderator to the Professor: “Dear Alfie, TL;DR. Lots of love, Rosie.”” Jan 18, 18:45
    • DaveL on Learning Insanity: “I can’t remember this particular halfwits name but I do recall that he was known for constantly ‘flouncing’ off twitter.…” Jan 18, 18:42

  • A tall tale



↑ Top