The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Scotland’s secret constitution

Posted on December 12, 2011 by

We don’t intend to make a habit of punching holes in the Herald’s new paywall for people to have a free keek through, but an opinion column in today’s edition deserves a much wider audience, including those among us who live in places it’s not possible to buy the paper at all. It’s a piece by W. Elliot Bulmer, author and the research director of the Constitutional Commission, and it’s about the little-known draft document drawn up by the SNP for the written constitution of an independent Scotland. (Almost alone among democracies, the UK has no formal codified constitution.)

It’s an absolutely fascinating read, both in purely technical terms and political ones, and if you’ve already used up your free preview on the site you can see it below.

5 to “Scotland’s secret constitution”

  1. Bugger (the Panda) says:

    I am not so sure that this "Constitution" is so secret.
     
    It is only a draft.
     
    LPW has spoken of on more than one occasion and linked to it.

    Reply
  2. Rev. Stuart Campbell says:

    Well, I'd never even heard of it, and I'm really interested in Scottish politics, so I have to assume an awful lot of other people haven't either. (The headline was also partly in reference to it being behind the Herald's paywall.)

    Reply
  3. Rev. Stuart Campbell says:

    [Moved from another comment page]

    Iceland is currently drawing up a new constitution. Their method is interesting. A panel of 25 ordinary citizens is collating input from anyone who wishes to contribute. See link to participedia.net

    Could Scots do this?

    Reply
  4. G. Campbell says:

    You can view as many articles as you want on the Herald Mobile site if you disable javascript. Deleting the site coookie after every 5 page views also works. Some web bod will probably work it out it eventually, but at the moment you can still read stuff for free.

    link to heraldscotland.com
    link to heraldscotland.com

    Reply
  5. Rev. Stuart Campbell says:

    Hmm, they must have worked it out already, because those don't work for me even with Javascript off.

    Reply


Comment - please read this page for comment rules. HTML tags like <i> and <b> are permitted. Use paragraph breaks in long comments. DO NOT SIGN YOUR COMMENTS, either with a name or a slogan. If your comment does not appear immediately, DO NOT REPOST IT. Ignore these rules and I WILL KILL YOU WITH HAMMERS.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,988 Posts, 1,252,608 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Northcode on The fight about to come: ““Better to admit your faults than dress them in borrowed competence.” — attributed to Bea Lurt. Bea Lurt is often…” Oct 15, 11:54
    • Northcode on The fight about to come: “If we’re using fighting metaphors then the real, most obvious and most urgent, fight facing independence-seeking Scots is the one…” Oct 15, 11:01
    • Minceheid on The fight about to come: “I’m nae ower bothered about the beer because I have been abstinent for the past twenty years, but I’d be…” Oct 15, 09:34
    • Hatey McHateface on The fight about to come: “Too right. I read they have to even import welders these days.” Oct 15, 09:22
    • Hatey McHateface on The fight about to come: “Get a grip, Bob. Free beer would break their own alcohol Minimum Unit Pricing law. Ain’t never gonna happen.” Oct 15, 08:42
    • robertkknight on The fight about to come: “Aye, right… SNP announce new manifesto pledge… “Free Beer Tomorrow”. Fool me once, and all that.” Oct 15, 03:09
    • twathater on The fight about to come: “Sorted it for ye Rev” Oct 15, 02:18
    • Mark Beggan on The fight about to come: “Do you have growth in your postcode? See a Doctor.” Oct 15, 00:25
    • Rob on The fight about to come: “Who is looking for perfection? Just basic competence and the feeling that they represent the majority of the country instead…” Oct 14, 22:55
    • 100%Yes on The fight about to come: “The national will feed you any story that makes you buy the paper, so your being lied to and your…” Oct 14, 22:39
    • Hatey McHateface on The fight about to come: “Aldi 3 YO blended whisky on your breath.” Oct 14, 20:19
    • Hatey McHateface on The fight about to come: “Aye. Right. What is it with people constantly parroting this £600,000 shite? It’s as if they never heard of bank…” Oct 14, 20:00
    • Aidan on The fight about to come: “Exactly – a “perfect” government is impossible because people will evaluate a government against different sets of values, interests and…” Oct 14, 19:56
    • SilentMajority on The fight about to come: “‘Groundhog Day’ anyone? “Our money’s all been spent I don’t know if all that’s true ‘Cause you got me and…” Oct 14, 19:08
    • Mark Beggan on The fight about to come: “Walk on with hope in your heart and growth in your postcode.” Oct 14, 18:59
    • factchecker on The fight about to come: “There has never been a perfect government, anywhere. But it is reasonably to expect competence. And it is essential to…” Oct 14, 18:18
    • sarah on The fight about to come: “🙂 🙂” Oct 14, 18:15
    • factchecker on The fight about to come: “Sarah, That is defeatism. It is perfectly simple to remove these “morons” at any election. Vote for another party. Otherwise,…” Oct 14, 18:12
    • Ex President Xiden on The fight about to come: “The good news is the SNP has a £600000 referendum fighting fund put aside. I remember them asking for donations.” Oct 14, 18:02
    • Spartan 117 on The fight about to come: “No excuse in my opinion. Voting SNP and expecting independence is like voting Tory and expecting conservatism/tax cuts/small state. If…” Oct 14, 17:49
    • Spartan 117 on The fight about to come: “Just as a clarification, my comment about “laughable agitprop fanfic” refers to The National and not Stu’s excellent blog. Sorry…” Oct 14, 17:40
    • Spartan 117 on The fight about to come: “A very naive view. The career politician is an established industry across the West now and it won’t go away.…” Oct 14, 17:37
    • Spartan 117 on The fight about to come: “Looks like (yet another) recycle of made-up front-page “headlines” as seen on the montage to the right of this page…” Oct 14, 17:28
    • am firinn on The fight about to come: “Sarah is right again. Anyone who thinks that independence must wait for a perfect Scottish Government to be achieved does…” Oct 14, 17:20
    • BLMac on The fight about to come: “Looks like the SNP have dug out the Independence Carrot from under all those Stonewall Gender Manuals. Now they’re looking…” Oct 14, 16:52
    • Aidan on The fight about to come: “Oh yeah if Scotland achieved independence at the helm they’d definitely all just resign en-mass wouldn’t they, rather than say…” Oct 14, 16:38
    • sarah on The fight about to come: “It’s so obvious, isn’t it? Why don’t the members all see it? Perhaps they do but they see no alternative…” Oct 14, 16:25
    • sarah on The fight about to come: “@ Rob, these morons will probably stay in charge until we leave the Union. They will have no hold on…” Oct 14, 16:17
    • Lollysmum on The fight about to come: “Of course Indyref2 is looming or ahead according to Keith Brown & that’s where it will always remain “ahead” as…” Oct 14, 16:11
    • Dubh on The fight about to come: “Utterly frustrating and damning in equal measure. *sigh” Oct 14, 16:04
  • A tall tale



↑ Top