The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Quoted for truth #9

Posted on February 24, 2013 by

A powerful reality check from Iain Macwhirter in the Sunday Herald:

“Scotland bailed out the UK economy in the 1980s with Scottish oil revenues, and received precious little in return except factory closures and the highest mortality rates in Europe. And it doesn’t take a genius to see that any improvement in the UK economy is going to happen in London and the southeast, rather than in Scotland. Like the high-speed rail link, it might eventually extend to Manchester but no further. Scotland is on its own whether it likes it or not.”

31 to “Quoted for truth #9”

  1. MajorBloodnok says:

    A great article from Macwhirter.  I was just reading it through about the real state of the UK economy and how we’ve not had anything like this since the late nineteenth century and then the last two paragraphs just bring it all into focus and say yes there is a way out of this if we chose to take it.

    Reply
  2. And this is the guy who was saying only the other week that he could think of a dozen positive reasons for keeping the union together???

    Reply
  3. CameronB says:

    Is this more than the Herald or Macwhirter sticking a finger in the air?

    Reply
  4. Marcia says:

    His blog has a good article about energy and LGO (Light go out) scare story etc etc
     
    link to iainmacwhirter2.blogspot.co.uk

    Reply
  5. CameronB says:

    @ Marcia
    Close thing, but you get the prize for first posting.

    Reply
  6. ianbrotherhood says:

    Shades of Max Keiser in the language Macwhirter’s using – has someone rattled his cage?

    Reply
  7. Baheid says:

    I remember something about Macwhirter not as appearing as much,(seems not at all now), on Newsnicht Scotland because of his leaning towards independence.
    I don’t think it was rumours, think it was official discussions within bbc scot.

    Reply
  8. DanTDog says:

    I’ve regularly thought Iain McWhirter one of the more thoughtful commentators on the Scottish spectrum, although not always aligned to my own viewpoint… if he’s beginning to see things from a more positive “Yes” perspective, that can only be welcomed…!

    Reply
  9. Baheid says:

    ianbrotherhood says:
    Shades of Max Keiser in the language Macwhirter’s using – has someone rattled his cage? 

    Max Keiser, will we get the likes of Keiser, Hartmann etc. on the Scottish broadcaster’s channel.
    Really annoys me when l watch these people knowing we have nothing like them, in general, to inform/debate. 

    Reply
  10. Morag says:

    Keiser?  I’d rather have someone credible who isn’t promoting a scam.

    Reply
  11. CameronB says:

    Scam?

    Reply
  12. Baheid says:

    Scam?, have no idea where that one comes from

    Reply
  13. Morag says:

    He is promoting a questionable economic theory which furthers his own economic self-interest.  Specifically GoldMoney.

    Reply
  14. Dcanmore says:

    Independence is a decision that’s going to hit a lot of Scottish people not because they support it, because for them it’s the only option. Iain McWhirter is coming to this conclusion, he now knows that further devolution or a federal UK set up is a pipe dream. It is hitting home now that the UK is sinking and the more that people realise that Westminster is only interested in protecting London, with its perpetual multi-billion £ projects and protection for the City bankers, then Independence for Scotland is the only choice. The consequences of a NO vote is becoming clearer in each passing month and is looking more horrific. There is a global battle going on with governments, treasuries and banks, but true to form Westminster will use Scotland as cannon fodder, stripping away every ounce of resources to prop up a failing State while the Scottish people will be left on the scrap heap for another couple of generations once again, being told to accept it because you’re British and it’s your moral duty.

    Reply
  15. CameronB says:

    I am no supporter of Keiser, but he is not a lone voice in the financial community. He is also quite open about his interests. Could I stick my neck out and suggest he has a better understanding of the issues than any of us?

    Has neo-liberalism worked?

    Reply
  16. Morag says:

    This is beginning to remind me of the early months of 2011.  I had planned to go out campaigning for the SNP because that’s what I do.  By the time April arrived, I realised it was more than that.  I was literally terrified of what would happen if Labour got back in and Iain Gray was First Minister.  Give me more leaflets, when as we campaigning in the town centre, is there anything else I can do….
     
    I’ve wanted independence since I was a child.  Now it’s more than that.  I am literally terrified of having to go on living in the UK as it has become.  I never, never thought I would say that.

    Reply
  17. Craig P says:

    MacWhirter has always been a unionist, but a soft unionist, and he thinks about the future more than most journalists in Scotland. For example he was warning about house prices beingunsustainable and a financial crash for two or three years before it actually happened. Got a lot of time for MacWhirter, I suspect he will eventually go the way of Ruth Wishart and declare for yes, anybody who thinks long enough about the issue tends to find that being the conclusion. He also ha a great phrase about the relationship between England and Scotland, still connected, he said, but being pulled apart like pieces of pizza connected by strings ofcheese alone…

    Reply
  18. cath says:

    Morag: “I’ve wanted independence since I was a child. Now it’s more than that.”

    I’ve gone the same way, Morag though to and from different places. I’ve always vaguely thought Scotland should be independent, and not quite understood why we weren’t. But I always accepted that was just the way it was, and I never cared enough for it to be any part of my politial or emotional life.

    But then after growing up with Thatcher, we finally got New Labour and they were dire – Iraq, house price bubble, debt, PFI, banking crisis. And the same preference for putting the rich over the poor as the Tories.

    Now, it wouldn’t matter where in the UK I was based, I’d be despairing about the direction of the UK and Westminster’s ability or will to change anything, or shift direction.

    In Scotland though, we have a chance for real change, to break away from that AND to do it by becoming the sovereign nation we always should have been. I could easily  have been persuaded to federalism, purely to stop a divisise debate and not have to debate “independence” with friends and family in England who will be seeing it reported very negatively.

    But that’s not on the table, so I just can’t understand anyone not being pro-indy now. Who would seriously argue Westminster’s doing a great job and independence isn’t a good thing for a country? So as time goes by, I find I’m getting more and more depressed by the thought of what waking up after a no vote would feel like. I dread that utterly, similarly to you, in a way I wouldn’t have imagined last year.
     

    Reply
  19. Baheid says:

    Morag says:
    He is promoting a questionable economic theory which furthers his own economic self-interest.  Specifically GoldMoney.
     
    I know, that’s why China buys a couple of hundred tons of gold every few months, ( sell as little as 20% of what they mine),
    Germany won’t their gold delivered out of the US fed vaults, (that’s if it is still there!!?),  
    India and others are buying/selling commodities using gold etc etc.
    J P Morgan and their mates are being accused of manipulating the gold & silver prices; I wonder why they would be doing that!? (Self interest pertaining to the dollar, surely not)

    Reply
  20. Morag says:

    Oh, hitch your wagon to his star if you like.  Just don’t run away with the idea that he’s some respected guru.

    Reply
  21. Baheid says:

    I have no guru’s

    Mr broon sold half our gold reserves, that’s clever ?
    And he sold at an all time low in the market, really clever ?
    Why not sell the rest, awfy clever

    Aye right

    Reply
  22. Simon says:

    Yes I am also not a wild fan of Keiser, but given the choice between his analysis, or the instiutions of economic governance that we have in the central bank and government, I know which I would be more likely to label a “scam”.

    Reply
  23. ayemachrihanish says:

    Slightly O/T – The link below – is what Westminster do not wish the Scots to know. The fact that an Independent Scotland would immediately get access to the funding and support to create the rail infrastructure that would provide direct access – (not change at London access) to an  integrated Pan -EU railway network.
     
    The European Commission today announced a comprehensive package of measures to deliver better quality and more choice in railway services in Europe. 
     
    Brussels, 30 January 2013
     
    link to europa.eu
     
    Vice President Siim Kallas, European Commission Vice President responsible for Transport said: “Europe’s railways are approaching a very important junction. Faced with stagnation or decline in rail in many markets across Europe, we have a simple choice. We can take the tough decisions now that are needed to restructure Europe’s railway market to encourage innovation and the provision of better services. Rail will be able to grow again to the benefit of citizens, business and the environment”.
     

    Reply
  24. scotchman says:

    Any chance of posting this article on your site? Can’t access it on Herald page.

    Reply
  25. Luigi says:

    It is rumoured that Broon had no choice to sell the gold. The UK were in a bit of a fix because they had been looking after German gold and the Germans decided they wanted it back. Surprise surprise, it wasn’t there any more! Not sure about the exact detail, but the end result was a massive sell-off of British gold. Of course it was spun by Broon as a great move – all those valuable bonds and paper derivatives, worth much more than gold! 

    Reply
  26. ayemachrihanish says:

    The EU aim (and has been for years) is that all member capitals are linked by a high speed rail network. Currently London provide that tick in a box. But an independent Scotland would require Edinburgh to be directly part of that network.  Seperately, an independent Scotland provides the means (via a new link) for Dublin to do likewise.

    Reply
  27. scotchman says:

    Thanks Rev – cookies devoured.
    Macwhirter is increasingly a voice of reason, shedding light on the debate. rUK heading down the pan – do we follow on the grounds of moral support, or save ourselves?
    No brainer…..

    Reply
  28. Chic McGregor says:

    My comment on his blog:
     
    Iain,
    While the Scottish government energy policy is by no means perfect, it is infinitely saner than the UK. You ask where price hikes are comming from, I will give you one of the biggest examples.

    Please study the following map carefully. It comes from the EEA, the European Environmental Agency. I know the data are somewhat dated, but in the context of comparison and conclusions one might draw from it, that is not important. It depicts the expected cost per unit (kWh) of elctricity production from windpower which are largely a function of terrain type and average wind speed – in that order in NW Europe. It does not include grid support costs as that varies enormously due to how remote from centres of use the wind farms are.

    link to i51.photobucket.com

    What I want you to note is:

    1) The British Isles, including England, is slap bang in the lowest cost band for ON shore wind production along with Denmark, Far North of Germany and Southern Sweden.

    2) The cost of OFF shore wind power compared to ON shore British Isles is TWICE AS MUCH.

    3) The Highlands of Scotland are not as commercially attractive even discounting extra griding costs.

    OK, got that?

    Next,I want you to look at the following chart. This is also based on EEA data but which are kept up to date so only about a year or two old. It shows the actual installed ON shore wind capacity of various countries in the Europe. To take account of the varying size of country, it has been normalized to population by calculating installed capacity per million people.

    link to i51.photobucket.com

    Note the extraordinary extent to which English NIMBYISM has been indulged.

    It has been described by a European wind power expert as “Being like a Saudi Arabia which refuses to drill for oil”.

    Now take on board the fact that England already has more OFF shore wind generation than the rest of the world put together and is planning up to 35 GW in total.

    Think what that means for electricity prices in the UK.

    That is why no other country, even Green Party lobbied environmentally mad Germany has considered serious OFF shore development until they had filled the place up with ON shore.

    Note, I am not at all saying that it is not right that we should have OFF shore, but it is commercially insane to do so until you need to.

    UK leccy bill payers (or tax payers if they disguise things by “subsidy”, “tariffs” or whatever ) will have a very high price to pay in order to indulge English NIMBYISM.

    Nuclear, again is even more costly but we’ll leave the above to sink in for now.

    Reply
  29. Chic McGregor says:

    @Luigi
    It is the Federal Reserve in the USA which is suspected by some of no longer having the gold they were holding for Germany and other countries.
     
    Brown, allegedly sold the gold at a 20 year low to depress gold prices so the main American traders who were exposed, could buy at reduced price.
     
     

    Reply
  30. Jeannie says:

    @ayemacrihanish
    Thanks for the link re the rail networks.  That’s an incredibly important piece of information and invaluable in persuading the business communities of the benefits of independence.  I’ve re-posted it on Facebook.   We should all do that.  It’s just one of those things Westminster can’t argue with as the money won’t come from them.  Git postin!

    Reply


Comment - please read this page for comment rules. HTML tags like <i> and <b> are permitted. Use paragraph breaks in long comments. DO NOT SIGN YOUR COMMENTS, either with a name or a slogan. If your comment does not appear immediately, DO NOT REPOST IT. Ignore these rules and I WILL KILL YOU WITH HAMMERS.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,993 Posts, 1,253,916 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Hatey McHateface on How To Succeed In Scotland: “@Alf Perhaps I’m aware of when Scotland and the Scots were pre-eminent in many areas, and people from third-world shitholes…” Nov 16, 17:10
    • Alf Baird on How To Succeed In Scotland: ““who could hate Scots and Scotland more” ‘Self-hatred’ is an essential part of the colonial condition (Fanon), and colonialism itself…” Nov 16, 16:49
    • Hatey McHateface on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Well done, Dave, big word – “rhetorical”. Did you get help? Here’s a big phrase: “logical fallacy”. Naw, Dave, nowt…” Nov 16, 16:40
    • DaveL on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Rhetorical question, is there anyone alive who could hate Scots and Scotland more than wee Adolf McHateface?” Nov 16, 15:45
    • Captain Caveman on How To Succeed In Scotland: ““It really is incumbent on all of us, CC, to continue to expose what clings to the Scottish Indy movement,…” Nov 16, 14:46
    • Captain Caveman on How To Succeed In Scotland: ““They’ve lived under illegal sanctions for decades” “Illegal” sanctions you say – how precisely are they supposedly illegal? On the…” Nov 16, 14:41
    • Lorncal on How To Succeed In Scotland: “I know, 100%, that the SNP leadership and so many of those that fawn around it, are irredeemable and should…” Nov 16, 14:11
    • Lorncal on How To Succeed In Scotland: “The ‘gender’ thingy was never a distraction, Geri. It was the vanguard of a huge ‘woke’ – post modernist/cultural Marxist…” Nov 16, 13:57
    • Hatey McHateface on How To Succeed In Scotland: ““I’m terrified and despairing” Naw, sarah, you’re not. Genuine question. If anybody knows of a more self-pitying, hysterically over exaggerating…” Nov 16, 13:39
    • Hatey McHateface on How To Succeed In Scotland: “I guess, Alf, we have to learn to separate Memmi’s “objective of the coloniser” from the common sense “objective of…” Nov 16, 13:32
    • sarah on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Yes indeed. We are all completely at the mercy of international profit-makers who have no concern for our welfare. Does…” Nov 16, 13:08
    • Alf Baird on How To Succeed In Scotland: ““make it even harder for us to break away and become independent” Some here appear to be doing a good…” Nov 16, 13:01
    • Hatey McHateface on How To Succeed In Scotland: “I’m certainly smart enough to understand that if it’s the will of the Scottish people (it’s certainly the will of…” Nov 16, 12:37
    • Hatey McHateface on How To Succeed In Scotland: ““They’re considerably better off than you are” There you go, CC, that’s you been told. Told by somebody who would…” Nov 16, 12:22
    • Hatey McHateface on How To Succeed In Scotland: ““she stuffed every seat in Holyrood with fuckwits” Inexplicable you don’t have one. Then again, maybe you do. Your inability…” Nov 16, 12:13
    • Hatey McHateface on How To Succeed In Scotland: ““The British Bulldog with no teeth, bad legs, failing eyesight living on ever more meagre rations is there for all…” Nov 16, 12:07
    • Geri on How To Succeed In Scotland: “They’ve lived under illegal sanctions for decades. Imposed on them by Colonisers unable to accept they’ll not bend the knee.…” Nov 16, 12:00
    • Hatey McHateface on How To Succeed In Scotland: ““Colonisers are on their way out” Oh dear, Geri. Poot’s nae gonna like ye saying that.” Nov 16, 11:59
    • Geri on How To Succeed In Scotland: “The English are colonised by America. The dumbos on the street just haven’t cottoned on yet. They sold the family…” Nov 16, 11:40
    • Captain Caveman on How To Succeed In Scotland: “@Geri Your blaming the domestic atrocities and suffocating lack of freedoms in modern “I” – fully half a century after…” Nov 16, 11:32
    • Geri on How To Succeed In Scotland: “SNP have deliberately styled themselves as new labour. Sturgeons intake was to quash any notion of independence. She made sure…” Nov 16, 11:19
    • willie on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Couldn’t help but reflect on the nuclear submarine that’s just come back after being at sea for six months. When…” Nov 16, 11:18
    • Geri on How To Succeed In Scotland: “All in hand, shit face. Events, dear boy, events. Colonisers are on their way out. Dumb placemen are too. Tho,…” Nov 16, 10:03
    • Hatey McHateface on How To Succeed In Scotland: ““In any other walk of life they’d be run tae fuck out of town” It would be highly popular, Geri.…” Nov 16, 09:27
    • Hatey McHateface on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Organ harvesting, Geri. You forgot to rant and rave about organ harvesting. Oh, and industrialised baby farming for food. You…” Nov 16, 08:16
    • Geri on How To Succeed In Scotland: “Well, Shit face, we certainly wouldn’t have ended up with them as anti social neighbours! A blight on this island…” Nov 16, 00:41
    • Hatey McHateface on How To Succeed In Scotland: ““decided to come down & mate with the womenfolk instead” Crivens, Geri, if only you had been on hand, how…” Nov 15, 22:04
    • Lorncal on How To Succeed In Scotland: “You may be right, H McH. I also acknowledge that you are right about the SNP voters, but, while all…” Nov 15, 21:47
    • Hatey McHateface on How To Succeed In Scotland: ““Who am I to burst yer wee delusional bubble” Now you’re getting metaphysical, Geri. Can one delusional bubble burst another?…” Nov 15, 21:39
    • Geri on How To Succeed In Scotland: “I’ve been watching some of those documentaries about the Book of Enoch. Fascinating stuff. So apparently, the watchers were sent…” Nov 15, 21:22
  • A tall tale



↑ Top