The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


++ OVERLOAD ERROR ++

Posted on January 11, 2012 by

As you might imagine, the sudden burst of sunlight cast on the independence referendum yesterday has seen the media scurrying around like hundreds of cockroaches who've just had the rock lifted from on top of them. There isn't time to come anywhere close to a complete analysis of the reaction and we've got a lot of stuff to do today, so we're going to cut through the swamp and point you at a handful that cover all the core issues with the minimum of fluff and waffle.

"Salmond outmanoeuvres Westminster", says Hamish McDonnell in the CalMerc, reflecting/summarising what seems to be the general media take on the subject

David Maddox in the Scotsman, apparently unaware of when the Scottish Parliament's term ends (it's April 2016, Dave) presents events from the Unionist perspective

The Guardian highlights the arrival of the civic-Scotland devo-max movement and its potential for complicating the issue

Michael Moore explicitly tells Scotland Tonight the UK government WON'T bring a legal challenge if the SNP launch a referendum without Westminster approval – we're amazed nobody else has questioned him in more detail on this. It would be absolutely extraordinary if the British government stood idly by and watched an illegal attempt to break up the United Kingdom, so why is Moore saying they won't? And what does that reveal about the UK government's true opinion on the legality of the referendum? (Warning: 300 years of adverts first)

Devolution expert Alan Trench analyses the situation in detail

Unionist misinformation kicks off early as The Telegraph runs a headline poll claiming low support for independence, but waits until the small print at the bottom before revealing that its Scottish sample is under 500 – ie less than half the number required for a survey to have any legitimacy

And Ian Smart asks an excellent question

Get through that lot and we'll see where we are.

1 to “++ OVERLOAD ERROR ++”

  1. Leighton says:

    Overload error is right all I can see on my FB is links to Scottish independence stories. One of the more interesting ones in my view was this:
    link to scotsman.com
     

    Reply


Comment - please read this page for comment rules. HTML tags like <i> and <b> are permitted. Use paragraph breaks in long comments. DO NOT SIGN YOUR COMMENTS, either with a name or a slogan. If your comment does not appear immediately, DO NOT REPOST IT. Ignore these rules and I WILL KILL YOU WITH HAMMERS.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,955 Posts, 1,247,333 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Northcode on These Words Are My Own: “AI Dan. You’re now saying geographic separation is the “most important” criterion, but Resolution 1541 doesn’t describe any hierarchy of…Jul 19, 10:14
    • Northcode on These Words Are My Own: “Unionists (colonialists if preferred… same thing) frequently tell us in this place that: “There is no route to independence that…Jul 19, 10:03
    • paul on These Words Are My Own: “Scotland is not a country, it is a colony. It cannot develop outside its colonialists’ interest. The deeds to its…Jul 19, 10:03
    • Captain Caveman on These Words Are My Own: “Bronze medal in theory, but in reality, yes, “first loser”. Ach. Great game of footy tho, and awesome to see…Jul 19, 10:01
    • Aidan on These Words Are My Own: “I never said that geographic separation is the ONLY criteria, but that it is the most restrictive and most important…Jul 19, 09:52
    • Northcode on These Words Are My Own: “Andy Ellis. You’re arguing as if the only question is whether a majority exists. But the issue isn’t whether Scots…Jul 19, 09:42
    • Northcode on These Words Are My Own: “Those examples don’t support your point, AI Dan. Palestine, Tibet, Indigenous nations in the US, and North Cyprus aren’t NSGTs…Jul 19, 09:31
    • Northcode on These Words Are My Own: ““That is absolutely untrue, NSGT status does not rely on any of those things” You’re reducing the UN’s criteria to…Jul 19, 09:25
    • Northcode on These Words Are My Own: ““No amount of obfuscation can hide the fact that any “decolonisation” attempt becomes a slam dunk if the people behind…Jul 19, 09:17
    • diabloandco on These Words Are My Own: “Nah! Gruinard not St Kilda – leave it to its lovely natural inhabitants!Jul 19, 09:08
    • Aidan on These Words Are My Own: “That is why for example, Palestine, Tibet, the Sioux/Navajo regions, North Cyprus etc. have never been NSGT’s.Jul 19, 09:01
    • Hatey McHateface on These Words Are My Own: “Can’t wait until tomorrow, to get some hope in my postcode. I give it a week before normal service will…Jul 19, 09:00
    • Andy Ellis on These Words Are My Own: “I notice Alf that you still don’t deign to answer the questions I posed. One might almost think that’s because…Jul 19, 09:00
    • Aidan on These Words Are My Own: ““The UN’s decolonisation frameworks don’t begin with a majority vote; they begin with an assessment of conditions: historical incorporation (the…Jul 19, 08:58
    • william G Walker on These Words Are My Own: “Wee Done Red! All these inadequates. We need our old Scotland back.Jul 19, 08:55
    • Hatey McHateface on These Words Are My Own: “Perhaps you could clarify, CC. Does that make England First Loser, or Second Loser? 🙂Jul 19, 08:18
    • Hatey McHateface on These Words Are My Own: “Ah Wally, is there a sight so delightful, a sound so musical to the ear, or a scent so alluring,…Jul 19, 08:15
    • Hatey McHateface on These Words Are My Own: ““then relying solely on normal internal electoral mechanisms to remedy it cannot resolve the issue” Naw? You cannot say that…Jul 19, 08:01
    • Northcode on These Words Are My Own: ““God only knows what you think the “laws of decolonization” are, but the UN isn’t going to apply these “laws”…Jul 19, 06:55
    • ScotsCanuck on These Words Are My Own: “Holy Crap !!! … it just could be that she is the architect of her own doom !! … she…Jul 19, 03:28
    • Captain Caveman on These Words Are My Own: “Oh well, England firing six (yes, you heard it right folks SIX) goals against the French – widely fancied as…Jul 19, 01:02
    • Young Lochinvar on A Matter Of Declinature: “HMcH Eh?? No. And your point is exactly, beaching a ship holed badly below the waterline allows repairs then refloating?…Jul 19, 00:57
    • robertkknight on These Words Are My Own: “Nah…save the expense of construction and staffing and just dump the bastards there and let them fend for themselves. I’m…Jul 18, 23:21
    • James on These Words Are My Own: “Oh, wow. You can tell when something ‘gets’ to them eh? They’re not even hiding it now, reams of unionist…Jul 18, 22:29
    • James on These Words Are My Own: “Stupid fucking meaningless interjections is what the Site Prick is programmed to do. All day, every day. Rinse and repeat.Jul 18, 22:16
    • James on These Words Are My Own: ““Once a Tory Prick, always a Tory Prick” ?Jul 18, 22:12
    • James on These Words Are My Own: “The AI site Prick’s mission is to divert, distract and divide. All day, every day; in the hope that the…Jul 18, 22:10
    • James on These Words Are My Own: ““Prick”. [If the helmet fits etc….]Jul 18, 22:02
    • Red on These Words Are My Own: “Nicola Sturgeon. John Swinney. Humza Yousaf. Jamie Hepburn. Alex Salmond gave all these people political careers, despite their horrible inadequacies…Jul 18, 21:53
    • jimburns on These Words Are My Own: “Puzzled me as well. Private Eye points out that the answer might be that as he wasn’t convicted of the…Jul 18, 21:24
  • A tall tale



↑ Top