The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Nope, still nothing

Posted on November 15, 2011 by

Scottish Left Review's "independence issue", in keeping with the publication's core philosophy, gives equal opportunity to both sides of the debate this month. Both a nationalist and a Unionist were asked to provide a "positive case" for their respective positions, from a left-wing perspective, and two substantial figures took up the challenge. For independence we heard from Stephen Maxwell (the Treasurer of the Scottish Independence Convention and the director of the SNP’s campaign for a yes vote in the 1979 referendum), whereas the Union's champion was current Lothians MSP Neil Findlay. The contrast is interesting.

Maxwell's piece, it must be said, is in fact largely negative. It focuses on the damage done to Scotland by various Tory governments, and that yet to come from the current one, while also making the legitimate but far-from-positive point that UK Labour now offers little more than a diluted version of Tory policies (for example on welfare reform). It does, however, also make a decent case for an independent Scotland being better able to afford social-democratic policies (thanks in part to increased oil income and significantly reduced defence expenditure), as well as having the demonstrated political will to carry them out. Maxwell reaches a cautious but optimistic conclusion about a greater sense of national self-confidence and the ability to challenge the prevailing neo-conservative view of UK politics.

Findlay's "positive case for the Union", however, (also run on LabourHame) presents only a dismaying blend of scaremongering, negativity and hopeless defeatism – indeed, it explicitly asserts that the SNP's optimism is a "mistaken analysis". It warns of the dangers of nationalism (spectacularly missing the point of civic as opposed to ethnic nationalism), then accuses the SNP of being pro-business and complains about the SNP's intention to remain in the EU, as if either of these were policies on which the Unionist parties offered an alternative standpoint.

Findlay then looks wistfully back at the working-class (small-L) labour movements of the 50s, 60s and 70s, characterising them as something that could somehow only have happened within the context of the UK without offering any explanation as to why. This is a viewpoint that neglects, for example, to consider the way even partial independence has enabled the Scottish NHS to resist many of the worst market-based "reforms" in the sector that have befallen England and Wales, or the education sector to retain free tuition while English and Welsh students are cast into debt.

He then ponders whether devo-max within the UK could offer social-democratic solutions for Scotland, before being forced to admit that there is no party in Scotland offering it, rendering the question something of a moot point. He concludes that "the role of the Labour and Trade Union movement has to be in evaluating and recommending just what arrangement is most appropriate for ordinary people", which ranks high on the scale of "the bleeding obvious" but perhaps more importantly has nothing whatsoever to do with the question he was asked, namely to provide a positive case for achieving such things under the Union as opposed to independence. "We need to think about it" isn't much of an answer.

It is strikingly and empirically self-evident that in the world as it currently exists, Scotland is better placed to pursue social-democratic policies on its own than within the UK. This is not a supposition or an opinion but a bare black-and-white fact: the UK, after all, just elected a neo-conservative government, while Scotland overwhelmingly returned a social-democratic one, and those respective governments will rule for the best part of the next half-decade (and probably longer). Findlay's piece contains not a single sentence of practical positivity, just vague socialist nostalgia combined with a fantasy about a UK political environment that doesn't currently exist and shows no signs of doing so. Is it really so hard to think of a single positive advantage of the Union? For now, the wait goes on.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest


2 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Peter Carter

Just thought I'd point out that Stewart Maxwell is an MSP and you are almost certainly thinking of Stephen Maxwell.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a (mainly) Scottish political media digest and monitor, which also offers its own commentary. (More)

    Stats: 6,707 Posts, 1,212,980 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • twathater on The thickness of blood: “Geoff if these arsewipes continue with their disciplinary procedure on Friday and SP’s lawyers are forced to go to court…Feb 17, 17:15
    • Hatey McHateface on The thickness of blood: “I’ve tried everything FIoD. £50 says the problem lies in Bath. Karma for the leccy thieves 🙂Feb 17, 14:55
    • The Flying Iron of Doom on The thickness of blood: “Any update on the server problem? Anyone?Feb 17, 14:04
    • Hatey McHateface on The thickness of blood: ““Apparently we have free speech and live in a democracy” I’m free to call you an eejit and vote out…Feb 17, 12:07
    • James Gardner on The thickness of blood: “https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_CrusadesFeb 17, 11:48
    • James Gardner on The thickness of blood: “Looks like Sandie can take them to the cleaners for harassment………..Feb 17, 11:43
    • Marie on The thickness of blood: “She’s possibly been shadow banned by some entity intent on destroying free speech. Apparently we have free speech and live…Feb 17, 11:11
    • Dave on Nicola’s Non-Truths: “Hot air All of itFeb 17, 10:49
    • Andrew scott on The thickness of blood: “Dr whatever is a BLOKE no gender certificate why was a bloke in a frock allowed-to go into the ladies…Feb 17, 09:35
    • diabloandco on The thickness of blood: “Biology is no longer a hard and fast science in Scotland even in medical circles – utterly beyond belief and…Feb 17, 09:30
    • The Flying Iron of Doom on Seeding the briar patch: “Is the site still useable on smartphones and tablets?Feb 17, 08:51
    • Hatey McHateface on The thickness of blood: “MSM reporting that a gentleman reputed to be the world’s first openly gay imam, has been shot dead in South…Feb 17, 08:47
    • Caledonia on The thickness of blood: “Why has the community notes disappeared from steve north tweetFeb 17, 08:47
    • Hatey McHateface on The thickness of blood: “Thanks for posting that link, Geoff. It’s a disgraceful tale of madness, petty venom and open mis-use of taxpayer’s resources…Feb 17, 08:35
    • Hatey McHateface on The thickness of blood: “Please clarify for us, gregor. Is it Him who’s been speaking to you, or just you that’s been speaking to…Feb 17, 08:11
    • Hatey McHateface on The thickness of blood: “Is Rev Stu trying to tell us something? The state of this site mirrors the state of Scotland under the…Feb 17, 08:00
    • Young Lochinvar on The thickness of blood: “The 2 types used to be generalised/ known as the flashers and the peeping Toms/ knicker nickers I.e. no outdoor…Feb 17, 00:27
    • Geoff Anderson on The thickness of blood: “Now they are going to sack Sandie for “misgendering” https://archive.ph/XmNMjFeb 16, 20:42
    • Southernbystander on The thickness of blood: “Same here as of Sunday evening. Click on anything much on the site and it tries to download this app.…Feb 16, 20:19
    • gregor on The thickness of blood: ““For the wrath of God is revealed from heaven against all ungodliness and unrighteousness of men, who by their unrighteousness…Feb 16, 19:18
    • Dan on Off-topic: “Test Site is still fucked and auto-downloading exe. file when trying to navigate the site. Multiple people commenting on the…Feb 16, 18:11
    • twathater on The thickness of blood: “Rev I made 4 or 5 comments yesterday on my tablet and laptop which haven’t appeared , I also just…Feb 16, 17:51
    • George Ferguson on The thickness of blood: “Stu we have serious issue with this executable attachment. I have very expensive anti-malware software. I can’t do anything to…Feb 16, 17:51
    • Hatey McHateface on For Mridul And Sandy: ““Jist say naw tae nonsense” Looks like somebody was listening. And acted 🙂 Geri first victim tae. Awww.Feb 16, 17:50
    • Del G on The thickness of blood: “My cache/history are purged, yet that pesky client still shoves its tootsies into my download folder. I think you may…Feb 16, 16:40
    • George Ferguson on The thickness of blood: “This executable file attachment is very persistent. I keep clearing everything but it pops up on each attempt to post.…Feb 16, 16:35
    • Caledonia on The thickness of blood: “How did steve north get the community notes removed under his post of trans woman are womanFeb 16, 16:08
    • Hatey McHateface on The thickness of blood: “Site is well and truly f**cked ATM. Usual form is to say a big boy did it, then ran away.…Feb 16, 15:28
    • doddsotheglen on The thickness of blood: “yes this happened to me I did nothing , is it a virus?Feb 16, 15:16
    • Confused on The thickness of blood: “sort out this website FFS you click a link if tried to download an exe supportclient but if you click…Feb 16, 15:15
  • A tall tale



↑ Top
164
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x