The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


One-way traffic

Posted on November 15, 2011 by

We've just caught up with an interesting piece over at Bella Caledonia from a few days ago, in which Robin McAlpine, editor of the non-aligned Scottish Left Review, heralds that publication's "independence issue" with an overview of the Scottish political left wing's position on the subject. We'll let you read it for yourself, but the takeaway soundbite is this one:

"roughly no-one seems to have been persuaded out of a pre-existing pro-independence position but more and more people are moving in the other direction"

The true nature of the modern Labour Party seems to have taken a while to fully dawn on the left, in the UK but particularly in Scotland, and it's intriguing to see a slow but perceptible shift begin to take place, especially with regard to trade unions. The fight between Unionists and the independence movement for the heart and soul of socialism seems to be very much on.

Comment - please read this page for comment rules. HTML tags like <i> and <b> are permitted. Use paragraph breaks in long comments. DO NOT SIGN YOUR COMMENTS, either with a name or a slogan. If your comment does not appear immediately, DO NOT REPOST IT. Ignore these rules and I WILL KILL YOU WITH HAMMERS.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,779 Posts, 1,220,506 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Andy Ellis on A different school: “The Danes tried to suppress the Faroese language for centuries. Given current circumstances I reckon most Scots would take a…Jun 23, 19:49
    • Hatey McHateface on A different school: ““world gone mad” Ah ken fit ye mean. I really struggle when Cooper, a politician I have detested since the…Jun 23, 19:48
    • Xaracen on A different school: “It’s a constitution, Aidan, not a system of modern democracy, and it has sod all to do with running an…Jun 23, 19:43
    • Sven on A different school: “James @ 19.16. Indeed they did not, James, and I share what I’m guessing is your entirely justified and righteous…Jun 23, 19:40
    • Hatey McHateface on A different school: “This is powerful stuff, NC. Who knew that the Scots for “internalised oppression” is “internalised oppression”? Or that the Scots…Jun 23, 19:30
    • James on A different school: “But Sven….did the Faroese parents and/or teachers ever belt their weans for speaking in their ain language though?Jun 23, 19:16
    • Aidan on A different school: “@Twatselfhater – Can you find me a single example of a recent case where the outcome was determined based on…Jun 23, 19:15
    • Hatey McHateface on A different school: “@ Lorn says: 23 June, 2025 at 4:27 pm “So you anticipate a breakdown of civilization as occurred in the…Jun 23, 19:13
    • Sven on A different school: “Kanska skuldi eg stríöst fyri á mínum forfedramáli, føroyskum. No, it may be this Scots ancestral tongue,however I do believe…Jun 23, 18:49
    • wullie on A different school: “S. N P Scotland Not ProsperingJun 23, 18:45
    • sarah on A different school: “🙂 🙂 🙂Jun 23, 18:30
    • Sven on A different school: “My online friend, Northy. Thank goodness then for such as I, who happily post using my very own heritage tongue,…Jun 23, 18:10
    • Rev. Stuart Campbell on A different school: “It’s an idea proposed by Wings in 2020. https://wingsoverscotland.com/the-snp-manifesto-2021/ (Although it makes more sense to use the constituency vote.)Jun 23, 18:09
    • twathater on A different school: “So ayden “The obsession with trying to dig up ancient documents and relitigate 1707 has got to be in the…Jun 23, 18:09
    • faolie on A different school: “The manifesto for independence needs a pretty decent level of public support however. Sign the petition to tell the pro-independence…Jun 23, 18:00
    • MaryB on A different school: “Lorn @ 4.27pm Slovakia is exactly as you say. The Slovaks had no say in becoming independent. It was forced…Jun 23, 17:34
    • 100%Yes on A different school: “George Galloway has made a surprise call for a Scottish independence referendum. Question why? Cause he knows the SNP isn’t…Jun 23, 17:32
    • Alf Baird on A different school: “” Internalized oppression” or ‘Appropriated Racial Oppression’ is an important feature within colonized and hence oppressed societies. To a large…Jun 23, 17:20
    • David Holden on A different school: “Please do not feed the troll collective whatever he\she\it is called this week. Thank you. Message ends.Jun 23, 17:12
    • Daisy Walker (no more) on A different school: “Daisy Dog passed last week folks, (for those who knew her) 17 years young. She didn’t suffer. Re the above,…Jun 23, 16:48
    • Doug on A different school: “Swinney and the SNP hierarchy continue to give every impression that they just wish this pesky independence thing would go…Jun 23, 16:46
    • Northcode on A different school: “A’ve been readin aw aboot different kinds o’ oppressioun. An a hiv juist feenisht readin’ aboot thon internalised oppression. Noo,…Jun 23, 16:34
    • Moon on A different school: “The next holyrood parliament needs parties like reform. This means the parliament will be distributed by disagreements regularly. Voting SNP…Jun 23, 16:28
    • Lorn on A different school: “So you anticipate a breakdown of civilization as occurred in the Balkans or Eastern Europe? Why? A Bulgarian working in…Jun 23, 16:27
    • ScottieDog on A different school: “Mr Galloway – a rank outsider, or is he?Jun 23, 16:14
    • Hatey McHateface on A different school: “I’m guessing that internalised oppression and marginalised groups might be of interest to individuals who have yet to succumb to…Jun 23, 16:06
    • Aidan on A different school: “Whether the ToU was lawfully executed or whether England simply invaded is a very interesting historical subject, for a historian.…Jun 23, 16:03
    • Northcode on A different school: “What is internalised oppression? “Internalized oppression is when the oppression that permeates the environment is able to seep into oppressed…Jun 23, 15:49
    • factchecker on A different school: “Correct; they are still extant. Many people posting on this blog insist that the ToU is invalid because it was…Jun 23, 15:49
    • Aidan on A different school: “Read the article above: Tommy Sheridan’s view is that this is what will mobilise the current non-voters. As if “we…Jun 23, 15:44
  • A tall tale



↑ Top