The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Education, education, education

Posted on May 22, 2013 by

Johann Lamont used to be an English teacher. We presume she was a conscientious and caring educator. We imagine she’s as horrified and embarrassed by this press release from the train-drivers’ union ASLEF yesterday as we are.

dunce

JOHANN LAMONT WANTS ‘REAL POLITICS’

Johann Lamont, the leader of the Scottish Labour Party, said she didn’t – and no one should – underestimate the challenge of wining back the trust

“Winning” back, we hope. Unless she plans to try to make people vote for Labour by getting them drunk, which by the state of recent polls might actually be her only hope.

of the people of Scotland for Labour – and that includes many trade unionists.

‘I want trade unions to form the policies, not accept them. I want you to shape policies, not hear them from me. ‘

She said unions should inform the argument about what a fairer Scotland can be. ‘I want real politics,’ she declared. ‘I am tired of fantasy world

We’ll let the missing hyphen slide. There are bigger problems here.

debates about an independent Scotland that is either the land of milk and honey or a place of doom and depression. I want real problems to be discussed – unemployment, education,

Education is not a “problem”.

too many life chances defined by the age of , better transport …’

Wait, too many life chances defined by the age of what? The dinosaurs? The train? Speaking of which, “better transport” isn’t a “problem” either.

She declared, ‘Salmond wants to divide Scots and English.

“Divide Scots from English”. We’re reasonably sure Alex Salmond has no interest in creating divisions among the people of England. (Unless you mean he wants to stop Scots using the language, but frankly there’s only one person who’s divided from the English language here.)

Cameron wants to divide between rich and poor.

You don’t “divide between”. You can create a divide between, but you can’t use it as a verb followed by “between”.

Falange wants to divide between people and immigrants.

“Farage”. Also, immigrants are still people.

‘I want to unite and progress.’

You want to unite what with what? You can’t just “unite” by yourself. And progress from where to where?

Speaking about unions and industrial disputes, she declared herself in favour of ‘a level playing field’. Companies with lawyers to stop strikes by picking up legal details is not the answer.

It’s not a sentence, either. (And you mean “solution”, not “answer”, anyway. For there to be an answer you need a question.)

Labour in Scotland will consult on a mutual model for rail. ‘We are developing firm ideas for a mutual alternative. We will have to pour over the books

Pour what over the books? Condensed milk? Orange squash? Some of that wine you’ve got left over from the first paragraph? The word you’re after is “pore”.

when we eventually win back the trust of Scotland, but then we want a railway that does not have funding taken away to line investors pockets,

To line investors’ pockets, with an apostrophe. There’s more than one investor.

and is democratically accountable.’

There’s nothing wrong with that bit grammatically. But with Labour having recently been in power in the whole UK for 13 years without doing a thing to make railways “democratically accountable”, we’d deduct marks anyway for a failure of plausibility.

(Mind you, if we’re picking holes in the content as well as the style and execution, we’d be here all day. If Johann wants trade unions to tell her Labour’s policies, exactly what are they paying her for? If she’s tired of Scotland being painted as “a place of doom and depression”, maybe she should tell her colleagues. And so on and so forth.)

These are cheap shots, of course – this is our late-night light-hearted comedy and satire slot, after all. But it’s hard not to draw conclusions about the mental abilities of TLPiS from this sort of abysmal, sloppy, lazy drivel. (And even if some of the mistakes are the fault of some incompetent intern on the ASLEF website, others are clearly part of Lamont’s actual speech.)

This, supposedly, is Labour’s top brain in Scotland. What are the stupid ones like?

 

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

33 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Linda's Back

As Johann’s chief press officer, is Simon Pia not to blame?  He certainly has a lot to say when on TV as a pundit with his frequent interruptions of other speakers.

Lynn MacRae

And my mother wondered why I failed my Higher English? With JoLa as teacher it’s any wonder I can string a sentence. 

benarmine

Cheap shots maybe but hilarious. Keep showing up this pea-brained drivel, there’ll be plenty more no doubt.

Robert Bryce

Ohhhhhh sweet Jesus please make it stop!

Vronsky

Knew it reminded me of something.
 

Ronnie

Education is a problem when schools are built on PFI,  Thanks to her lot, councils are too busy paying many times over for school buildings instead of school education.
 

Paul

“Falange” is actually quite appropriate.

Jiggsbro

“We presume she was a conscientious and caring educator.”
 
Really? I’d always assumed she devoted herself to getting up the union greasy pole and out of the classroom as soon as possible.

pa_broon74

So we can expect to see some firm policies from labour courtesy of train drivers?
 
Well, its a start I suppose.

(I’ll start…)
 
Perhaps this’ll get TLPiS back on track.
 
Next?

SCED300

At the ASLEF conference, “Delegates welcomed United Nations recognition of Palestine statehood”, but ASLEF decides to campaign against recognising ours!
 

Derick Tulloch

o/t but your friend Smart has been making a pure tit of himself on twithingy again. 

Geoff Huijer

Truly shocking!
 

tartanfever

On the topic of Education, I see the BBC are in urgent need of geography lessons.

They are running a story about unhappy students at ‘UK’ universities. It’s available here:

link to bbc.co.uk

However, the report on which this ‘journalism’ is based is actually titled ‘ The Academic experience of students in English universities’
I’m getting really tired of this from the BBC.
 

velofello

Quote for the day, from a punter. “I’d vote Yes for independence but I’m terrified of Labour getting back in power after independence”.

Jock McDonnell

Clearly, she wrote it herself. E for effort.

kininvie

@velofellow
So am I! In fact, I’m terrified by the thought that Lament might have to be asked to be on our negotiating team post indie. Surely to God we can avoid that?

Marker Post

‘I want trade unions to form the policies, not accept them. I want you to shape policies, not hear them from me. ‘

Had to laugh at that one, I don’t think there’s much chance of hearing any policies from Lamont.

Seasick Dave

The thought of my future being shaped by Johann Lamont’s ‘vision’ is truly awful.
 
 

Desimond

In fairness, it may be Aslef that have made any spelling mistakes, going by yesterdays post ( Hollyrood) they do have history.
 As for Labour talking of plans regards “Unite”…didnt her boss upset that Union recently :
link to bbc.co.uk

Desimond

re Unite….what does The Prince say about that again:
“Upon this a question arises: whether it be better to be loved than feared or feared than loved?” writes Machiavelli. “It may be answered that one should wish to be both, but, because it is difficult to unite them in one person, it is much safer to be feared than loved, when, of the two, either must be dispensed with.”

Seasick Dave

Is that Johann in the picture at the top?

Desimond

Seasick Dave says:
23 May, 2013 at 9:08 am

Is that Johann in the picture at the top?
Cue a “I will not be silenced” Johann being comforted by Susan Calman after another week of “Cybernat Bullying Yet again!” headlines
 

Max

 
If she stopped using her husband’s teeth she would sound a lot more convincing. 

Training Day

Come on, Lamont’s making progress.  Not a single mention of cerr wurkursh or indeed shepratishticulsh. 

pa_broon74

Still, its good of Lamont to offer ASLEF members a platform from which to offer policies…
 
 

Sapheneia

Vronsky’s post – Peter Seller’s
Excellent speech by Peter. It really has stood the test of time as it still seems to be the de facto fall back position of many of our politicians.  It’s actually a bit like listening to one of Ms Lamont’s speeches at FMQs.

mealer

I think this thread is a bit P*shy really.But I’ve no doubt Rev Stu will come up with something meatier shortly !

Ananurhing

“Schizophrenia is a psychiatric illness in which disorders of thought content are a prominent feature. The disruption of normal flow of thought, or “Formal Thought Disorder” (FTD), has been traditionally assessed through the content and form of patients’ speech, and speech abnormalities in schizophrenia were considered as a by-product of the disruption in conceptual structures and associative processes related to psychosis. This view has been changed due to increasing evidence that language per se is impaired in schizophrenia, especially its semantic, discursive, and pragmatic aspects. Schizophrenia is currently considered by some authors as a “language related human specific disease” or “logopathy”, and the neuroanatomical and genetic correlates of the language impairment in these patients are under investigation. Such efforts may lead to a better understanding about the pathophysiology of this devastating mental disease. We present some current concepts related to FTD as opposed to primary neurolinguistic abnormalities in schizophrenia.
Key words: schizophrenia, thought disorder, language disorders, thinking, linguistic, psychotic disorders.”
 
Hmmm! “Formal thought disorder”, “Logopathy”? Also see “Dysytntaxia”. This might help to explain Lamont’s Logocide!

Caledonian Lass

Without her prepared speech, Johann Lamont rambles incoherently and is unable to answer questions properly.  It has to be said that, even with her prepared speech, she doesn’t make a lot of sense  – so much for being a former English Teacher!
As for Labour regaining Scotland’s trust, you just have to think of the McCrone Report suppression, Denis Healey’s recent admission that Labour lied about the extent of North Sea oil’s potential, plus the theft of 6,000 square miles of Scottish sea in 1999 (by Labour and Liberals) to realise why they shouldn’t be trusted.  During Labour’s 13 years in power Scotland didn’t prosper.   In their attempt to woo voters in the south east of England they abandoned their core principles and have resembled the Tories for a considerable time.
The only way forward is an independent Scotland.
 
 

The Rough Bounds

Regarding the privatisation of the railways, didn’t Dreary Donald Dewar, our very own walking question mark and ‘Faither o’ the Nation’ (Notion?) make a tidy pile out of that little bit of business?
 
”Pour over…”.    haw haw haw. Best one yet.
 
(Johann; This was very poor work and shows complete lack of preparation. See me after class.)

Juteman

On the subject of education, i’ve always thought successive uk governments policy would come back to bite them.
To keep the true level of unemployment down, various tricks have been used. Under 18’s not counted, folk on disability benefit not counted and students not counted, etc, etc……
An unintended (from the governments viewpoint)  side effect of trying to get +50% of young folk in further education (to lower the unemployment statistics), is that you produce a more educated unemployed person.
Chickens, roost, home, coming, to.

mike abbott

At least Johann Lamont recognizes the important part trade unions have to play in engineering industrial democracy, signalling  their political engagement in the democratic process and , unlike the sleepers from the 70’s who steam-rollered Labour policies through , and to be frank, got a bit above their station in adopting the party line, she is not above coaching younger acolytes to guard the precepts of Labour, keeping them on track to engineer a return to power, if she can un-couple a distinctly Scottish ticket from her London-centric colleagues. Her timetable for a resurgence of labour support is a  problem however, as repeated attempts to drive the party forward have met with delays, cancellations, re-routings and political fellow-travellers not sharing her ticket, in fact trying to shunt modern policies into the sidings. It will be a long slow haul for Scottish Labour to redeem any respect  from Scottish voters , even though they may still give Lamont a season ticket in Holyrood. She needs to make hay, market her policies as being central to a resurgence of traditional labour values and rail against the forces of narrow-gauge self-interest and individualism at such an important junction in the nations fortunes.

Chic McGregor

Someone has had a quiet word in her ear about the number of times she called for a debate.  Note she is now fed up of debates but instead calls for ‘argument’ and ‘discussion’ instead. 
 
Still the basic “don’t ask me nuffin” message though.
 
A Thesaurus makeover, nothing more.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a (mainly) Scottish political media digest and monitor, which also offers its own commentary. (More)

    Stats: 6,668 Posts, 1,201,992 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Dan on The People You Most Suspected: “Three letters in my name is a close to god as I get. We* could stop it by working to…Nov 13, 08:47
    • Alf Baird on The People You Most Suspected: “The oppressor always seeks to sow division, which makes it easier to manipulate the people (Freire). Religion, language and identity…Nov 13, 08:36
    • Chas on The People You Most Suspected: “Where did I say that ordinary people can’t organise again and we are all in thrall to the media? Things…Nov 13, 08:28
    • Tinto Chiel on The People You Most Suspected: “And we shouldn’t forget the most revealing words which followed that statement, if I remember correctly: “How better can you…Nov 13, 08:24
    • Alf Baird on The People You Most Suspected: ““England has legitimate security concerns” “we’ll deserve to be destroyed as a nation” Scotland also has rather obvious security concerns,…Nov 13, 08:19
    • Oneliner on The People You Most Suspected: “We need a Tartan Brigade to match the Green Brigade. In Scottish football we have teams espousing Ireland (tricolour) and…Nov 13, 07:38
    • Hatey McHateface on The People You Most Suspected: ““Scotland gave greatly of its sons” Indeed willie, but dinna fash, we’ve few sons to give this time around. Or…Nov 13, 07:27
    • Hatey McHateface on The People You Most Suspected: “Why do we need the Western media to report the casualties, or anything else, when we have you? How can…Nov 13, 07:12
    • Robert Hughes on The People You Most Suspected: “This , ie the subject of this WOS post , is how the Unionists will take control of Holyrood .…Nov 13, 06:54
    • Hatey McHateface on The People You Most Suspected: “Aye, Bob, not enough casualties in U, and not enough casualties in Amsterdam either. Not for you, anyway. And as…Nov 13, 06:50
    • Jay on The Show Goes On: “’greed and will to power’ must be at the core of it, that brought to mind the alleged Cecil Rhodes…Nov 13, 06:13
    • Robert Hughes on The People You Most Suspected: “” I don’t wish to demean the casualties in any way, but for me, one of the most grotesque and…Nov 13, 06:12
    • The Flying Iron of Doom on The People You Most Suspected: “I know that the left’s hatred of private education is de rigueur but with the way the schools are at…Nov 13, 06:03
    • SteepBrae on The People You Most Suspected: “Which would help explain why we’ve lost so many good politicians in recent years, from all parties: they were grounded…Nov 13, 04:21
    • Campbell Clansman on The People You Most Suspected: “Uh, big historical miscues by commenter Fearghas. Wolfe wasn’t even in Canada in 1751, let alone a major general in…Nov 13, 04:11
    • Young Lochinvar on The People You Most Suspected: “I wonder what school Biology lessons are like now? No, strike that, I don’t.. Anyone else watch Starmer quoting unachievable…Nov 13, 01:49
    • Breeks on The People You Most Suspected: “I wonder how the current war in Eastern Europe compares, with regards to casualties. The wanton nature of the propaganda…Nov 13, 01:28
    • Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh on The People You Most Suspected: “Postmodernism, as we all well know by now, typically rejects any “Big Story” (meta-narrative). In its view of reality as…Nov 13, 01:15
    • Young Lochinvar on The Show Goes On: “COE’s head replacement; 1. Male 2. Female 3. Qwerty mouthpiece.. Odds on considering the crime perpetrated historically? You couldn’t make…Nov 13, 01:10
    • V Hartley on The People You Most Suspected: “Basic, but real – sad in a way. Where did the grown-ups go?Nov 13, 00:41
    • Kevin Cargill on The People You Most Suspected: “For the umpteenth time on here and everywhere else. The unionists are not pouncing on this issue for the same…Nov 13, 00:11
    • Jay on The People You Most Suspected: “”What are they getting out of it?” The reasons which you set out seem eminently reasonable but someone, somewhere, pointed…Nov 12, 23:09
    • Jay on The Show Goes On: “Bright man like you should be able to work out that Trump would not pull the plug on the promised…Nov 12, 22:36
    • Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh on The People You Most Suspected: ““I should imagine that two or three independent highland companies might be of use; they are hardy, intrepid, accustomed to…Nov 12, 22:17
    • Alf Baird on The People You Most Suspected: “In colonial societies the elite is made up of two main groups (Memmi): 1. the colonizer/se***er, and; 2. the more…Nov 12, 22:13
    • BLMac on The People You Most Suspected: “It’s obvious that schools would be targeted. After all, who benefits from all this? Not the kids, they’re victims. The…Nov 12, 22:12
    • Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh on The People You Most Suspected: “From Tom Devine’s book The Scottish Nation 1700-2000: “Of the 157 battalions which comprised the British Expeditionary Force, 22 were…Nov 12, 22:10
    • Alf Baird on The People You Most Suspected: “Domination and hence ‘sadism’ lies at the heart of colonial oppression (Freire), for which liberation is the only remedy (Memmi).…Nov 12, 22:02
    • Rev. Stuart Campbell on The People You Most Suspected: ““And meanwhile in the big world the ex prime minister is declaring that if president elect Trump decides to cut…Nov 12, 21:59
    • Lee on The People You Most Suspected: “I’m retired. An ex headteacher. How in the name of common sense (and more pertinently, safeguarding) this school.is still open,…Nov 12, 21:53
  • A tall tale



↑ Top
180
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x