The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Author Archive


What does it mean to be Scottish? 196

Posted on August 03, 2014 by

The above is a deceptively simple question and one to which the answer, of course, is as varied as the people you might ask it of as we approach September’s vote.

The debate so far would suggest that at one end of the scale, we’re a nation of poor wee souls, much safer shackled to a United Kingdom that gifts us stability and security in the face of choppy global waters and saves us from the hassle of making crucial political decisions for ourselves. At the other end, we’re a proud nation of untold prosperity, a nirvana of wealth and social justice primed to emerge after our divorce from our oppressors in Westminster.

For anyone in between and still grappling with their identity, the Economist helpfully informed us recently that being Scottish means painting a Saltire on your face, wearing a Jimmy hat and shouting at nothing in particular. Glad that’s sorted then.

The truth is that very few of us will see ourselves in these broad-brushed caricatures of Scottish identity. I certainly don’t. In fact, the more I force myself to think about it, the clearer it becomes that I don’t have a bloody clue what it means to be Scottish.

Or at least I didn’t until last month.

Read the rest of this entry →

  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a (mainly) Scottish political media digest and monitor, which also offers its own commentary. (More)

    Stats: 6,747 Posts, 1,216,706 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • James on The Takeover: “YS; Should you not be locked in your ward by this time of day?Apr 28, 15:21
    • The Flying Iron of Doom on The Takeover: ““Do you think Trump and Biden will attend each others funeral..” How would a dead man manage to attend the…Apr 28, 15:08
    • Nae Need! on The Takeover: “Not at the same time, no 🙂Apr 28, 15:01
    • Alf Baird on But No Cigar: “Yes James, this is ‘Lord Lugard’s famed policy of indirect rule (Said) whereby co-opted native elites and colonialists (Gramsci’s ‘cultural…Apr 28, 14:55
    • Willie on The Takeover: “Sarwar, and indeed his chum Yousaf are I am sadly afraid racist. For them, as the piece illustrates, white white…Apr 28, 14:55
    • Effijy on The Takeover: “I’m watching a recorded TV show about the Muslim grooming gangs in the Rochdale Area of England. Silly young girls…Apr 28, 14:53
    • duncanio on The Takeover: “It’s a bit concerning that some mouthy politicians from a tiny minority in Scotland appear to be far more interested…Apr 28, 14:46
    • MaryB on The Takeover: “It’s just another divide and rule tactic to confuse, divide and distract from support for independence. Similarly to gender reform,…Apr 28, 14:43
    • Young Lochinvar on The Takeover: “Or, maybe they’ll just team up and kick lumps out of Bangladesh.. No idea why, who have the Banglis ever…Apr 28, 14:42
    • Young Lochinvar on The Takeover: “Nothing lasts forever. Just as an aside: Do you think Trump and Biden will attend each others funeral..Apr 28, 14:34
    • George Ferguson on The Takeover: “Odds on another Indo-Pak war. The fifth since Pakistan Independence in 1947. I wonder if Anas will return to his…Apr 28, 14:24
    • Morgatron on The Takeover: “Belter Stu, 100 % agree and we are standing by watching it and as you rightly point out unable to…Apr 28, 14:15
    • Rob on The Takeover: “Yoon Scum “I’m perfectly happy with the idea of keeping Scotland for the Scottish” I am perfectly happy with the…Apr 28, 14:15
    • Ryan on The Takeover: “Do the anti hate crime laws only apply against whites too? Perhaps that’s why people are afraid to speak up?Apr 28, 14:15
    • Rob on The Takeover: “Scotland is not less racist than than the south, its simply because the proportion of non white folk in most…Apr 28, 13:50
    • Rob on But No Cigar: “Not sure what “debate” you think I am making. I simply stated that there was a separate government in India…Apr 28, 13:38
    • Stevie on The Takeover: “I watched the Sarwar speech : it’s a spread Islam via subterfuge around the globe ideology (evidently he sees his…Apr 28, 13:34
    • Ian McCubbin on The Takeover: “Well done again Stu for pointing out the true facts about these two men. I conclude they just want special…Apr 28, 13:33
    • SuperTonkatsuFighter on The Takeover: “Wake up, white peopleApr 28, 13:26
    • Yoon Scum on The Takeover: “Mmmm this is going to need a lot of pop-corn NOW Tell me how you agree with the tone of…Apr 28, 13:18
    • Yoon Scum on But No Cigar: “if reform want to gain votes in Scotland and England then they should promise a UK wide vote on scottish…Apr 28, 12:47
    • James Cheyne on But No Cigar: “Ho Rob, That debate you put forward holds little water on two accounts. 1, I have researched my family history…Apr 28, 12:40
    • James Cheyne on But No Cigar: “Hi Rob, Merely as an observation I have been keeping an eye on reform too, there are a few controversial…Apr 28, 12:15
    • Rob on But No Cigar: “That is nonsensical. India had its own government and viceroy because it was so far away in time and space…Apr 28, 11:58
    • James on But No Cigar: “Don’t waste keystrokes on YS. He/she/it is a half wit.Apr 28, 11:49
    • Marie on But No Cigar: “Excellent analogyApr 28, 11:39
    • Rob on But No Cigar: “I’ll need to keep an eye out for what Reform want to do with the SP, I am not really…Apr 28, 11:18
    • Aidan on But No Cigar: “It’s not that Reform’s policies don’t have any support in Scotland, it’s that Reform don’t maintain any presence in Scotland…Apr 28, 11:14
    • James Cheyne on But No Cigar: “When Britain ruled over India, it needed two governments. The main One in London and a sub-government to control the…Apr 28, 10:53
    • Yoon Scum on But No Cigar: “Have you worked out the process to deal with people born in Scotland who are faithful to the English invaders?Apr 28, 09:51
  • A tall tale



↑ Top