The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Author Archive


Independence for England 521

Posted on December 16, 2018 by

The great frustration of the current Brexit shambles is that we’re being told there are no viable options. But that isn’t true. This site has already put forward one perfectly workable proposal, and here’s another.

Before the 2014 referendum on Scottish independence, Scotland was told that if they left the UK, they would automatically leave the EU, leaving the rUK as the successor European state.

Scotland, it was said, would be cast out of Europe, immediately and automatically and without negotiation. Brussels agreed with Westminster on this interpretation.

This outcome of independence was said by Westminster sources to be a legal certainty, with no possibility of avoiding the consequences of being bounced out of the EU. The EU could not rescue Scotland and no treaties would exist to do so.

And that leads to a logical conclusion: if England (and perhaps Wales) decided to leave the UK instead of Scotland, leaving Scotland as the successor state in the EU, the same would be true.

Read the rest of this entry →

  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a (mainly) Scottish political media digest and monitor, which also offers its own commentary. (More)

    Stats: 6,751 Posts, 1,217,356 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • sarah on All Or Nothing: “He will need all our very best wishes. He is accusing COPFS.May 8, 13:00
    • Aidan on All Or Nothing: “@Dunx – exactly, that is the political problem. If the UNCRC agrees with Scotland’s claim, how then does it approach…May 8, 12:50
    • sarah on All Or Nothing: “NB Mark Hirst’s case for malicious prosecution is being heard today. He will need them.May 8, 12:43
    • Bilbo on All Or Nothing: “I came across a news article yesterday which mentioned the Gen Z are turning to religion more than other generations.…May 8, 12:23
    • James on All Or Nothing: “Sam; LOL – the correct answer!!May 8, 12:08
    • James Cheyne on All Or Nothing: “Colin, In what fundamental article of the treaty of union does it state that Scots can only hold a referendum…May 8, 11:50
    • Dunx on All Or Nothing: “One problem with the UN approach is that it relies on the support of member states with their own indy…May 8, 11:47
    • sarah on All Or Nothing: “Not today – it was yesterday, 7th May.May 8, 11:40
    • James Cheyne on All Or Nothing: “If we were adding a maths equation we would have to include all the figures together to reach an accurate…May 8, 11:37
    • sarah on All Or Nothing: “Today’s entertainment – an excellent, almost funny, piece by Robin McAlpine “It’s Karaoke Night in the Mediocracy Cafe” [over on…May 8, 11:19
    • Aidan on All Or Nothing: “Sure – I’m not asking whether you’ve ended the union yet, I just want to know whether you’ve received a…May 8, 11:19
    • Gordon on All Or Nothing: “More tripe about GERS. Scotland’s tax take was £88billion, that’s £40b that could have been spent in Scotland for Scotland,…May 8, 11:08
    • Alf Baird on All Or Nothing: “A wee bit patience please, we have to undo 300+ years of colonialism efter aw, its related pathology, a UK…May 8, 10:53
    • sam on All Or Nothing: ““We have identified and examined a number of individual themes across this body of work including, inter alia: ? The…May 8, 10:39
    • ross on All Or Nothing: “what utter guff. Most people in Scotland want a Parliament regardless of independence status. Totally false choice. This does not…May 8, 10:23
    • sam on All Or Nothing: “Farage is on record saying that he opposes Scotland’s independence. People in England most likely to support Reform are ambivalent…May 8, 09:41
    • Aidan on All Or Nothing: “@Alf – It’s nearly two months since your submission was sent to the UNCDC. What response have you received?May 8, 09:37
    • sam on All Or Nothing: “A brainMay 8, 09:34
    • Chas on All Or Nothing: “Have I got this right? After Independence Scotland will automatically have an honest, competent Government. The Government, who ever that…May 8, 09:21
    • Colin Alexander on All Or Nothing: “It is sheer folly to engage in a dead-end colonial-Scotland political system for the purpose of Scottish independence since The…May 8, 09:17
    • Alf Baird on All Or Nothing: “You make an excellent point Robert. The Rev’s view (and that of the daeless co-opted SNP leadership) that Scottish national…May 8, 09:03
    • MaryB on All Or Nothing: “I think Robert, above, is correct. The unionist are deliberately fostering despair and apathy and you, Stu, are playing their…May 8, 08:56
    • Chas on All Or Nothing: “The psychiatric nurses forgot to lock the door to the computer room again! You never disappoint Billy. Mince after mince…May 8, 08:41
    • Hatey McHateface on All Or Nothing: “I’m with you, Bob. Post the date and time of the March On Hollyrood on here and I’ll see you…May 8, 07:57
    • Hatey McHateface on All Or Nothing: “Why aren’t you wearing a bunnet, or a glengarry, or a tam o’ shanter? What are you, some kind of…May 8, 07:39
    • Robert Hughes on All Or Nothing: “” And the reason for that is that in their hearts everyone knows independence is dead as a genuine political…May 8, 07:39
    • Hatey McHateface on All Or Nothing: “That’s fit ah always say tae the boy wha comes tae read ma meter: “Giza power plant o ma very…May 8, 07:31
    • Aidan on All Or Nothing: “No, the view from the U.K. treasury and its economists, not from you misquoting William Waldegrave (who in any case…May 8, 06:24
    • yoon scum on All Or Nothing: “got any figures on how much we send to the English and what we get backMay 8, 04:22
    • Billy Carlin on All Or Nothing: “Actually you might want to watch the Electric Universe guys expose what caused canyon systems etc on Mars, the Earth…May 7, 23:42
  • A tall tale



↑ Top