The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Author Archive


Soapbox: In the hawk’s nest 238

Posted on July 26, 2020 by

This week saw publication of the long-awaited Intelligence and Security Committee (ISC) report on alleged Russian interference in British affairs. Despite media hysteria, the report contained no new revelations, just all-too-familiar catastrophising about Moscow’s ill-defined “disinformation” efforts and warnings of the undue influence rich Russians (most of whom are actually Kremlin opponents) have bought themselves.

The most salient point for supporters of Scottish independence to consider was the allegation that Moscow’s interference efforts extended to the 2014 indyref. As Wings pointed out earlier this week, however, the “evidence” to support this sensational claim amounted to nothing more than a heavily-redacted single paragraph, citing “credible open source commentary” as its sole source.

A look at the paragraph’s accompanying footnote reveals the “credible open source” commentator was Ben Nimmo of the Atlantic Council. For those in the fortunate position of being unfamiliar with his work, Nimmo is known for, among other things, falsely identifying a Syrian-Australian blogger and a British pensioner as Russian bots – so clearly someone whose expertise should be relied upon to determine the extent of Russian infiltration into Scottish politics.

I mention this not simply to reveal the transparently amateurish nature of the ISC’s report but rather to offer a commentary on the SNP’s (predictably) disappointing response to its allegations.

Read the rest of this entry →

  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a (mainly) Scottish political media digest and monitor, which also offers its own commentary. (More)

    Stats: 6,697 Posts, 1,210,440 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Mia on Saying sooths: “Absolutely!Jan 28, 22:47
    • Mia on Saying sooths: ““and which would deprive MP’s from Wales and Northern Ireland of a say over UK constitutional matters?” And when exactly…Jan 28, 22:45
    • gregor on Saying sooths: “Gerry Rafferty: Get It Right Next Time: “Out on the street, I was talking to a man He said, there’s…Jan 28, 22:44
    • Mia on Saying sooths: “In case anybody is interested in reading Mr Martin’s article, it can be found by following the link below: https://www.bsg.ox.ac.uk/sites/default/files/2021-04/Scotland_Referendum_final.pdfJan 28, 22:39
    • Mia on Saying sooths: “Well, I got a positive vote. That means at least one person invested their precious time in reading it. That…Jan 28, 22:38
    • Xaracen on Saying sooths: “Why would an upside to the Scottish half of the Union be a downside to the UK government, Aidan? And…Jan 28, 22:32
    • Mia on Saying sooths: ““Nicola Sturgeon: vote for SNP is not vote for second independence referendum” And here is my question: What right did…Jan 28, 22:29
    • Hatey McHateface on Saying sooths: ““The Picts were maistly written oot o oor history for some reason” It’s hardly a mystery, Alf. The Declaration of…Jan 28, 22:25
    • Mia on Saying sooths: ““are likely to appeal to 20/25% of the Scottish electorate” Labour has the majority of Scotland’s MPs after getting support…Jan 28, 22:23
    • Hatey McHateface on Saying sooths: ““Politics is what has been used to force Scotland out of the EU despite the people of Scotland categorically voting…Jan 28, 22:16
    • Mia on Saying sooths: ““it’s not lawful and won’t be recognised” “lawful” according to whose laws? Those of the entity that has been for…Jan 28, 22:13
    • Xaracen on Saying sooths: “Wales and N. Ireland do have their say as they are both territories of the Kingdom of England as you…Jan 28, 22:12
    • Hatey McHateface on Saying sooths: ““Politics as a route of independence is dead” Oh well then, we’re doomed. Unless … Can we post stuff online…Jan 28, 21:58
    • ross on Saying sooths: “Stewart M16donald got cosy. Scottish independence should be a threat to the UK, no ifs no buts. Got cosy.Jan 28, 21:55
    • James Macnicoll on Saying sooths: “They have done absolutely nothing for independence since Salmond left,in fact Sturgeon and now Swinney are actively discouraging people from…Jan 28, 21:50
    • moixx on Saying sooths: “There might be a lot of people who’d vote for your ‘interim alternative’. At the very least, it’d be interesting…Jan 28, 21:46
    • gregor on Saying sooths: “M.I.A.: BORN FREE: “…I don’t wanna to be that fake Cause you can do it And imitators yeah stick it!..…Jan 28, 21:30
    • Alf Baird on Saying sooths: “Yes, the historical and archaeological record tells us a great deal aboot the Picts as descendants of the Neolithic people…Jan 28, 21:29
    • Insider on Saying sooths: “FFS ! Stop spamming Mia ! No-one is going to waste their time reading this verbal diarrhoea !Jan 28, 21:20
    • gregor on Saying sooths: “Mia is thriving with her independence and doesn’t require any parliamentary carrots to convince her that she doesn’t hold any…Jan 28, 21:15
    • Stevie on Saying sooths: “The SNP’s Scotland Fornever Campaign – I now hate the SNP ; I used to loathe them but now it’s…Jan 28, 21:07
    • agent X on Saying sooths: ““We ALREADY won that independence at the ballot box on the 8th May 2015” Sturgeon General election 2015 Nicola Sturgeon:…Jan 28, 21:03
    • factfinder on Saying sooths: “I’m sure you’re right. I imagine they felt the same way about the invasions from Ireland by the Scots.Jan 28, 21:03
    • jock mctavish on Saying sooths: “It’s simple, you attend their parliament, you swear the oath and you condone their parliamentary sovereignty and f##k the Scottish…Jan 28, 20:59
    • factfinder on Saying sooths: “Thanks, but if you’ve signed it, it presumably was after 1928? I asked for something earlier.Jan 28, 20:57
    • Alf Baird on Saying sooths: “Aye, its quite a phenomenon, a people celebrating their invader/oppressor. Happens elsewhere in Scotland too. Tho it seems the Picts…Jan 28, 20:54
    • jock mctavish on Saying sooths: “hear! hear!Jan 28, 20:48
    • jock mctavish on Saying sooths: “SNP’s death by a thousand cuts, all self inflicted. They truly are unelectable now. Assimilated by the union collective, incapable…Jan 28, 20:45
    • Andy Ellis on Saying sooths: “The rest of the UK wouldn’t of course: it would only grant devo-max or some other sheme for more devolution…Jan 28, 20:39
    • stonefree on Saying sooths: “SNP have been flirting with Labourand vice versa since Jan 2022 Don’t know which was the main pursuerJan 28, 20:39
  • A tall tale



↑ Top