The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


And finally… #3

Posted on January 26, 2013 by

There wouldn’t be many people left in the No campaign if these were the rules.

So remember, folks – calling someone a Nazi isn’t political debate. Nazis weren’t comical figures of fun. That sort of poison is “sick abuse and gutter politics”, and must be stamped on if we’re ever to raise the level of debate.

(Another nugget from the Scottish Political Archive.)

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

38 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Seasick Dave

I think that we should contemporise the good Lord Robertson and call him Lord Naw Naw.

To be fair to Labour, anyone who uses the Nazi jibe should be stamped on forthwith.

OT, and it may have been mentioned elsewhere, but Kevin McKenna is continuing in a fine vein of form.

DJ

I no longer get upset by the MSM. The “Dear Leader” pish peddled by Alan Cochrane (and Anas Sarwar’s elected dictatorship) is an insult to democracy, but embarrasses him more than anyone else.

Their bullets will run dry. Let them fire them and do the rebuttal in the final 6 months. To use the football analogy – you don’t win the league in September!  

Jim Watson

I remember the Monklands by-election. Jim Murphy was standing with a megaphone and saw me getting off an SNP truck. We had previously been colleagues (cannot bring myself to use the term Comrade in relation to him!) in the Labour Party but I had finally left it during the poll tax campaign. Through the megaohone he shouts “When did you join the Nazis?”. He was lucky that there were two others there that led me away having just been hospitalised by the BNP the previous month…

But what amuses me is how they can refer to the Secretary General of NATO as humane…  

Dracul

Really we have to have the Godwins Law discussion… in 2013… The Only Good Scotland is a Independent Scotland. Dont forget how not so Great Britan became that way. No were not friends, the English are tyrants and thives of land, history, and culture. 

ianbrotherhood

I’ve already posted enough for one night, so, apologies to anyone who sees my name cropping up yet again and is thinking ‘oh FFS, what is this guy’s problem..?.’

My problem is George Robertson. He represents everything I most hate about ‘politics’. I was politically dormant, neutered, whatever-you-want-to-call-it, until George Robertson became the Sec-Gen of NATO. I remember seeing him in a press conference when Belgrade was being bombed. Harold Pinter had managed to secure a BBC position, allowing him to legitimately question Robertson, Jamie Shea, or whatever other mouthpieces.
Pinter asked a question. Robertson, after digesting who he was talking to, gathered himself together and said ‘Ah, Mister Pinter, I didn’t realise you’d changed occupations.’ That’s not a verbatim quote, but pretty close, and the tone he used was just appalling.
Pinter was always, to me, someone to look up to, admire. His work was on the curriculum when I was in Secondary school, and that was in the mid-70’s. To hear him being patronised by that c-c-c-character was one of the most infuriating things I’ve ever witnessed.
Robertson is a living-fossil – he has many questions to answer over his involvement in NATO, and other matters closer to home. If he shows the slightest inclination to become involved in this referendum debate, he should be made aware, in no uncertain terms, cross-party, that he is not welcome. 

Robert Kerr

A couple of years ago I came across Robertson on Islay, specifically in the “Holy Cow” bistro in Bowmore. He didn’t know me from Adam but I new him. Our gazes touched and he new I knew him for what he was. 

He looked away knowing my contempt.
 

Cuphook

@Dracul
 
I think, like most people, that you misunderstand what Godwin’s law actually is.
 
I also think that you need to stop been a racist cock.
 

Tris

Ah Mr Robertson, that dedicated man of the people; their representative in the House of Commons, until he got the chance to take a seat in the House of Lords and get himself a top job in Brussels, that is.

At which point he jumped at the chance of becoming an aristocrat and ditched his constituents like they were white hot and smelly.

he’s a bit of a joke really. But, it’s Labour in general that makes me laugh. I mean, how many times are they going to scream at the SNP for doing things they have done themselves. Before they come out with something like the poster you feature, would it not be an idea to look round the office and ask: “Any of our guys ever made any connection between the SNP and dictators or Nazis?”

It really is quite frightening how inept they are.

 

dadsarmy

I don’t remember it but then though I was interested in the Devolution referendum, politics left me cold. Much more interested in bringing up my kids and earning a crust. Party Politics still leave me cold really, I just want to see them open again in Scotland, not closed doors in Westminster. Looking it up, apparently that slur was in retaliation for someone from Labour calling Alex Salmond “Alex in Wonderland”.

It’s insulting, it’s pathetic and it’s disgraceful, whichever side does it.

Sorry if that doesn’t follow any party line.

Macart

Dracul

Here’s me thinkin’ we’re looking forward. We’re trying to create an inclusive society.

“The enemies of Scottish Nationalism are not the English, for they were ever a great and generous folk, quick to respond when justice calls. Our real enemies are among us, born without imagination.” 

RBC Graham 

douglas clark

It seems odd that our correpondent didn’t add, or simply missed the ‘a’ at the end of their name. Is this an attempt to get us all tarred as mad bigots? Y’know, being quoted as the genuine view of a typical ‘Yes’ voter?

Just asking.

Macart

Does seem a bit ‘out there’ DC. I don’t think I’ve ever come across anyone in the campaign personally who hates anything other than social inequality and jaffa cake theft from the canteen.

Anyone who steals the jaffa cakes should be hunted down and thrashed wi nettles. 🙂

Seasick Dave

OT, but here is a story to stir things up…

link to heraldscotland.com

No comments allowed.

douglas clark

Also OT, but this story doesn’t really stack up for me. Can anyone more familiar with cross border energy subsidies confirm any of this?
 
link to heraldscotland.com

scottish_skier

@Seasick Dave

Trying your link again:

link to heraldscotland.com

Aye, seems the knives are oot for Matheson. 

The Rough Bounds.

@dracul
 
What is a ‘thive’?
 
That posting looks, judging by the poor spelling and poor syntax, to be the work of someone with an age of around 16.

Marcia

Yes campaign have issued this in response to a poll in the Sunday Times:

link to yesscotland.net

Yes 34 No 47 Und 19 

Erchie

Godwin’sLaw merely states states “As an online discussion grows longer, the probability of a comparison involving Nazis or Hitler approaches 1

There is nothing in that about the discussion being over. 

This is particularly true in threads discussing the causes and conduct of WW2 

scottish_skier

@Marcia

Further evidence that the No has peaked and is slipping down again after briefly pushing above 50% in the autumn of last year (following the Yes climbing ahead of the No post SNP win). The trend is back to don’t know, which is to be expected. A good sign; those who panicked and thought ‘no’ are now deciding to give it more thought…

A majority of Scots are not prepared to vote for the union with 7 in 10 wanting independence or all but (Devo Max). That’s all we need to know right now. 

Laura

Tris
At which point he jumped at the chance of becoming an aristocrat


The thought of George Robertson being discribed as an aristocrat has to be the funniest thing I’ve heard all week. Thanks for the laugh.
 

MajorBloodnok

@Laura
 
Not so far fetched – m’Lord Robertson has the look of a Habsburg about him, I’ve always thought.  Particularly that of Carlos II (euphemistically referred to as the ‘bewitched’ or ‘spellbound’, rather than ‘congenital idiot’).

link to en.wikipedia.org

Marcia

SS

The voting intention for Holyrood in that poll is

SNP 45 Lab 33 Con 13 LD 5 Others 5. Why are LD so high? 🙂    

Holebender

Erchie, you’re right that Godwin’s Law itself does not say anything about the discussion being over, but there is a well known and well understood corollary to the law which says exactly that. As wikipedia notes: “there is a tradition in many newsgroups and other Internet discussion forums that once such a comparison is made, the thread is finished and whoever mentioned the Nazis has automatically lost whatever debate was in progress. The coupling of this corollary with the initial statement of the law proves every threaded discussion to be finite in length.[6] This principle is itself frequently referred to as Godwin’s law.

Marcia

As I can’t edit the post re voting intention, it relates to the Constituency vote.

scottish_skier

@Marcia

Very nice poll. SNP still on what they got in May 2011.

‘Attack Salmond / the SNP’ is a useless tactic. Would only work if the SNP actually were really crap and not the decent government the are.

The negative unionist campaign is working, slowly, just not in the way they intended. 

dadsarmy

Poll good news, though not surprising. I do wish the YES website would put the actual results as Marcia has, rather than just “Poll: Swing of just 7% would put Yes ahead”.

Give the figures, give the facts, give the flaming figures. They speak for themselves, they don’t need spin, even if it isn’t spin, it just looks like it. So annoying.

I can see now why ken900 kept just posting the figures in Guardian articles.

Marcia

the List vote in the same poll with the changes from 2011

Regional vote:
SNP 44% (nc)
Labour 31% (+5)
Con 12% (nc)
Greens 6% (+2)
Lib Dem 5% (nc)
Others 3%
  

AndrewFraeGovan

Seems BT/MSM lies are having an effect though:

“It found 60% of voters agree an independent Scotland would not automatically become a member of the European Union.
Almost half (49%) agree independence would cost Scotland many defence jobs.
Alex Salmond has suggested a healthy outlook for North Sea oil revenues, which would help balance the books of an independent Scotland, but more Scots than not agree with claims the oil is running out (46%).
The poll found that 40% agree with the No camp that the SNP plan would leave Scotland with “little say over interest rates and spending levels” while 26% disagreed and 34% were unsure.
With Scots indicating they would have to expect to be £500 a year better off to back independence in the 2014 referendum, there is further bad news for the nationalists.
Asked whether an independent Scotland would be financially worse off than the rest of the Britain, 40% said it would be while 37% said it would not and 23% are unsure.”

link to realradio-scotland.co.uk

Dcanmore

Ah, that’ll be the former Gen Sec of NATO George ‘Bomber’ Robertson the killer of thousands of Serb and Iraqi civilians, or how he called it “soft bombing” as non-military buildings and infrastructure were targeted. Another New Labour blood-thirsty maniac who loves the idea of projecting power. Now a Lordy and dirctor of several large companies including Cable and Wireless, as a reward for all the ‘good work’. What a price to pay for ambition, power and entitlement, and can anyone tell me what legacy our comrade left behind for the good people of Hamilton South constituency? … no? Thought not.    

dadsarmy

@AndrewFraeGovan

So with the question about better off, directly linked to a vote for Independence, there’s just a 3% gap between YES and NO – and the realradio thinks that’s BAD news for the YES campaign?

muttley79

I remember Jim Murphy’s “sewer rats” jibe at the SNP, and thinking to myself that the guy was an unpleasant, smear merchant.  Nothing that has happened since has changed my mind on that….Alex Neil’s “Lord Haw-Haw” jibe at Robertson was stupid as well (even if Robertson is a horrible character).

dadsarmy

MacWhirter on Sunday Politics, the Irish response reported.

AndrewFraeGovan

@Dadsarmy
It seems so obviously to me that we would be hugely better off in virtually every respect with independence. It puzzles me that so many of us still can’t see it. Scales will fall eventually I hope. 

Jeannie

Just watched Sunday Politics.  I was amazed to see Alastair Darling unwittingly destroy his own argument that we are better together by (almost hysterically) painting a picture of a future UK as an economic basket case.  It obviously didn’t occur to him that some of us would then wonder why on earth he was advocating that Scotland remain a part of it.
It would be great if someone more IT-competent than myself could reproduce it as a clip as it’s a bit of a gift.

Laura

Thank you Major – remarkable resemblance!

Macart

@dads

Considering Pacific Quay’s penchant for running stories/reports directly from Sunday Politics, tonight’s Reporting Scotland should be interesting. 🙂 

Angus McLellan

@Marcia: Panelbase poll is good news for Greens. Plenty of fuss about UKIP maybe sneaking the 6th MEP’s job, but the Lib Dems would lose their seat to the Greens on that basis. And the SGP does better at Euro elections than at Holyrood.

Erchie

Hole bender, yes, but they never cite the extrapolations, which are custom rather than a ‘Law’

And sometimes tcomps parisons are apt, like Disabled Rights protesters contrasting rhetoric in the press with Nazi posters quantifying the disabled as burdens on the state  

Sometimes those comparisons are apt 


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a (mainly) Scottish political media digest and monitor, which also offers its own commentary. (More)

    Stats: 6,679 Posts, 1,205,126 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • gregor on Trump’s Card: “Donald Trump Jr. @DonaldJTrumpJr: “Apparently a large group of Democrat legislators plan to boycott my father’s inauguration, which is great…Dec 14, 22:10
    • Geri on Trump’s Card: “Aye cause we can be forgiven & that tosser can’t. I watched a video ad for this organisation a while…Dec 14, 22:07
    • gregor on Trump’s Card: “satan is the dumbest fuck of all time – The diabolical freak is terrified of humans: #HeavenlysatanDiapersDec 14, 21:51
    • Geri on Trump’s Card: “I wonder why they were colonised for centuries then? You’ve been at the Christmas crackers haven’t you? Fun fact but…Dec 14, 21:44
    • Geri on Trump’s Card: “The Swiss have gone full tonto. It’s the NATO membership doctrine. All laws must now be rewritten to accommodate one…Dec 14, 21:31
    • gregor on Trump’s Card: “Luke Garfield: Yes You Are: Yes You Are: “You spoke the stars Into existence You gave the laws of gravity…Dec 14, 21:21
    • Geri on Trump’s Card: “WEF Where Satan gathers his wealthy minions to discuss ways to fuck up the lives of the poor..Dec 14, 21:20
    • Mark Beggan on Trump’s Card: “The success of the AK. Is in its design. It can operate under the most extreme conditions. In an enclosed…Dec 14, 21:10
    • gregor on Trump’s Card: “World Economic Forum: 75 years of NATO: The North Atlantic Treaty Organization explained: ‘We stand with you in your courageous…Dec 14, 21:01
    • Hatey McHateface on Trump’s Card: “Maybe naebody kens fit a repocussion is, Geri. Could it be some kind of replica soft thing you sit on…Dec 14, 21:00
    • Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh on Trump’s Card: “Dr John Campbell’s broadcast today (‘The Banality of Evil’) highlights this powerful quote by CS Lewis: “The greatest evil is…Dec 14, 20:59
    • Geri on Trump’s Card: “I can’t for the life of me think who was responsible for that.. You must be delighted they’ve emptied all…Dec 14, 20:57
    • Captain Caveman on Trump’s Card: “Still waiting. /tumbleweedDec 14, 20:56
    • Hatey McHateface on Trump’s Card: “It’s certainly a great favourite of the chief Orc himself, poot. He said it’s: ”a symbol of the creative genius…Dec 14, 20:50
    • Geri on Trump’s Card: “Well isn’t that strange? The ICJ ruled that countries had to cease & desist supplying weapons to aid in gen-ocide.…Dec 14, 20:32
    • Hatey McHateface on The Wage Thief: “So you believe protesters “dress up” to protest? My, my, Geri, who could ever accuse you of being “boring”! Get…Dec 14, 20:30
    • Mark Beggan on Trump’s Card: “Down Among The Big Boys.Dec 14, 20:24
    • Mark Beggan on Trump’s Card: “The AK-47 is the African way of doing business.Dec 14, 20:23
    • Geri on Trump’s Card: “Aye, she says she’s not leaving. WTF do they find these mentalists?Dec 14, 20:16
    • gregor on The Wage Thief: “The Sherbs: The Skill: I Have The Skill: “I have the spirit, I’ll never be broken… W?ll maybe you think…Dec 14, 20:04
    • Hatey McHateface on Trump’s Card: “Syria is already a war torn failed state. Inexplicable you couldn’t have noticed, Ros, but maybe there’s no media in…Dec 14, 20:03
    • Republicofscotland on Trump’s Card: “The French – really are the persona non grata in the Sahel – already several countries including Niger, Burkina Faso,…Dec 14, 19:44
    • Hatey McHateface on Trump’s Card: “Still nae a gen0cide Ros. As for the humous boys, I call them craven, yellow, skulking defilers of helpless lassies,…Dec 14, 19:39
    • gregor on The Wage Thief: “77th Brigade: Adapting to warfare in the information age: “Warfare is rapidly evolving and the ability to compete in the…Dec 14, 19:37
    • Republicofscotland on Trump’s Card: “The ruling goes against the ICC’s issuing warrants for the arrest of the head of the snake.”A Dutch court has…Dec 14, 19:34
    • Hatey McHateface on Trump’s Card: “I guess this cartoon might be open to different interpretations. I assumed Mr Cairns was making the point that no…Dec 14, 19:25
    • Hatey McHateface on Trump’s Card: “It’s “Scotland” and it’s “NATO”, Ros. Congrats on spelling the boy’s name correctly though. Telling that you can do it…Dec 14, 19:12
    • Republicofscotland on Trump’s Card: “Switzerland will pass laws to ban any form of knattizz-i symbolism – yet the same country has proscribed hHam-mas and…Dec 14, 19:06
    • Republicofscotland on Trump’s Card: “Looks like the Nnatto/EU coup has failed “The Georgian parliament has voted to appoint former Manchester City player Mikhail Kavelashvili,…Dec 14, 18:55
    • Republicofscotland on Trump’s Card: “The Mayor of Scotland Swinney will comply with whatever Trump wants – as long as his London masters, okay it.Dec 14, 18:50
  • A tall tale



↑ Top
33
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x