The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


A new low

Posted on April 01, 2012 by

Normally we enjoy a little chuckle at Kevin McKenna’s weekly column in the Guardian, as befits one of the stalwarts of our Zany Comedy Relief link section. On taking an early peek at this week’s effort, it looked to be one of those rare occasions when Kevin takes a break from slagging off the SNP and talks about something else, but instead we were horrified to witness one of the most despicable things we’ve seen in the mainstream “quality” press for quite some time.

Most of Scotland united in saluting Jocky Wilson when he sadly passed away at the too-young age of 62 a week ago. Our Twitter feed quickly filled with tributes to the much-loved Kirkcaldy dartsman from all sides of the social, cultural and political spectrum (we particularly liked this one from Alex Massie), and the idea that anyone would seek to turn the tragedy to political advantage seemed beyond imagination. So we were happy to see that McKenna’s column was ostensibly another salute to one of Scotland’s favourite sons. That feeling lasted as far as the third paragraph.

“It’s just a shame that, among the garlands and tributes that greeted Jocky’s untimely death at the age of 62, there was nothing from the SNP, Scotland’s party of government.”

We’re not going to dignify the piece with a direct link, but McKenna goes on to draw a tortured contrast between Wilson’s love of a drink and a smoke and the SNP’s supposedly puritanical attitude towards such pursuits, with particular reference to the recent passage of the minimum-pricing bill.

(Oddly, for some reason he doesn’t feel compelled to also highlight the smoking ban introduced by the previous Labour/Lib Dem administration at Holyrood, or to mention that it was the booze and fags that actually led to both the demise of Wilson’s career and his untimely death from chronic pulmonary disease.)

He finally works himself up to a dismal and (ironically enough) pious attempt at satire, describing a hypothetical sanitised movie biopic of Wilson thus:

“The worst-case scenario would see Bobby Carlyle playing a slimmed-down version of Jocky as he sallied forth to smite English archers like John Lowe, Eric Bristow and Bobby George in a latter-day enactment of Braveheart. Jocky would be seen wearing one of those tartan blankets in which some SNP supporters dress at annual conferences. There would be facepaint.

In this positive outcome-driven version of Jocky’s life we would observe him being humiliated by crafty cockney Bristow as the effects of vodka and dartitis took hold. We would then see Jocky, in a Damascene moment, finally abjure the drink and sign up to Nicola Sturgeon’s new urban temperance league. He would enrol as a teacher in the newly created subject of Sobriety and preach self-denial.”

A commenter on the page is swift to point out that McKenna’s entire piece is based on a lie anyway – the First Minister was in fact one of the first to publicly express his sorrow at Wilson’s passing, while we’ve been unable to find any comments at all from Johann Lamont, Ruth Davidson, Willie Rennie or their parties – but we hope the Guardian will have the decency to wipe the entire shameful stain from its pages. We’ve seen Unionists sink to all manner of depths to attack the SNP, but this disgusting effort must surely be rock bottom. We daren’t imagine that there might be even worse to come in the next two years.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

1 Comment
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
steven luby

I will not pretend to understand what may or may not drive a journalist,nor will I succumb to the belief that the trade is rotten to the core,yet. I would have it on a parallel with a desire in becoming an M.P, when one is young and full of drive for better things as long ago as 35-40 years where there 'was' a desire to help aid/change things for the better perhaps? As I have said, I claim no knowledge of understanding in such things.
But the article involving Jocky Wilson and the S.N.P is something beyond comprehension.It is written in such a derogatory manner towards both 'parties' that I have reached the conclusion that it's 'author' is quite clearly unwell and his perspective on recent events have come off a wave of hatred and denial for anything Scottish.
The mantra that he clearly supports belongs in the lower-ground floor of a medical school where the lonely doctor encourages fictitious conversation with body parts.Then when his days work is complete,he scurries back home,with beads of perspiration and anxiety,oblivious to why no one else understands him!
Whatever 'rules' their may or may not be in journalism,I have the feeling we are dealing with the type of guy who would dearly love to set fire to somewhere, just to have the power to have someone who would not let him play center forward at school break be blamed,arrested and jailed.
This guy is really not a well bunny!


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a (mainly) Scottish political media digest and monitor, which also offers its own commentary. (More)

    Stats: 6,688 Posts, 1,208,263 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Shug on In Ruins: “Well it doesn’t sound like Swinney is planning to turn away from the car crash. I am surprised that Forbes…Jan 11, 16:46
    • Andy Anderson on In Ruins: “Spot on Mia. My thoughts exactly.Jan 11, 16:43
    • Andy Ellis on In Ruins: “The polling I’ve seen does suggest Reform in Scotland is basically cannibalising the Scottish Tory vote, so more power to…Jan 11, 16:43
    • Andy Anderson on In Ruins: “The sad truth is that many SNP members still hold a strong belief that independence will happen via the SNP.…Jan 11, 16:42
    • Mia on In Ruins: ““the route to independence is about outlining that alternative that can inspire” No, it isn’t, Ms Forbes. The route to…Jan 11, 16:41
    • Mia on In Ruins: ““wee plucky countries can do a great job if they believe in themselves” Wee plucky countries cannot do anything for…Jan 11, 16:30
    • sam on In Ruins: “” Of over 13,000 islands examined, approximately 12% experienced significant shifts in shoreline positions. The total shoreline length of these islands…Jan 11, 16:30
    • gregor on Eyes Full Of Beams: “MrSuicideSheep: Tribe Society: Kings: “Runnin’ with all of my brothers I always wondered how far we could go If we…Jan 11, 16:29
    • Mia on In Ruins: ““Forbes says that the SNP’s primary responsibility is to ‘inspire hope’ ” inspire hope means to fool voters into believing the…Jan 11, 16:22
    • Andy Anderson on In Ruins: “The answer is not to use political parties at all as they are all, with the exception of the ISP…Jan 11, 16:20
    • Dan on In Ruins: ““And your realistic alternative to Alba is what exactly? I know there are plenty on here who like to disparage…Jan 11, 16:20
    • Andy Ellis on In Ruins: “And your realistic alternative to Alba is what exactly? I know there are plenty on here who like to disparage…Jan 11, 16:07
    • twathater on In Ruins: “I can’t believe that indy supporters are falling for snp version2 Alba, and Ash Regan”s faux outrage at the despicable…Jan 11, 15:48
    • Andy Ellis on In Ruins: “The condition precedent for the Secretary of State to hold a border poll in NI is if it: “..appears likely…Jan 11, 15:47
    • aLurker on In Ruins: “Thanks for the pointer sarah. https://grousebeater.wordpress.com/2025/01/11/the-aberdein-enigmaJan 11, 15:38
    • sam on In Ruins: “I think there is room for doubt. There are scientists, quite a few, who do not accept the narrative pushed…Jan 11, 15:37
    • twathater on Safeguarding Is Not Right-Wing: ““But the idea that the traditional Left (who died along with John Smith) are actually responsible for this is a…Jan 11, 15:30
    • gregor on In Ruins: “Are you prepared for ‘The Great Scotland Revival’ #PrepareJan 11, 15:17
    • Young Lochinvar on In Ruins: “I see anglofication continues apace under the SNPs watch; this time with proposals removing Burns from the “English”(sic) curriculum. That’s…Jan 11, 15:16
    • gregor on In Ruins: “The Jouker (2025) Andy Murray calls out Elon Musk for Twitter meddling: “”Murray said: “The top 17 posts on my…Jan 11, 15:13
    • Dan on In Ruins: “Just release a few more beavers, everything will be fine… lolz And seeing as so many humans can’t even be…Jan 11, 15:06
    • Vivian O’Blivion on In Ruins: “You are indeed correct. It’s the Carbon monoxide in Town gas that drove the jaikies pure mad mental. ?Stuff up…Jan 11, 15:05
    • Muscleguy on In Ruins: “If the human race do nothing about climate change at the very least we will have to move the line…Jan 11, 14:48
    • Muscleguy on In Ruins: “Net Zero is a scientific, environmental and societal necessity. Unless you want to abandon all the homes, businesses and infrastructure…Jan 11, 14:44
    • sarah on In Ruins: “Grouse Beater has an interesting post about Geoff Aberdein today. It fits with my thinking at the time that GA…Jan 11, 14:37
    • CapnAndy on In Ruins: “Being Pedantic, but electric soup was made by bubbling ‘coal gas’ through milk, not natural gas.Jan 11, 14:22
    • Rev. Stuart Campbell on Eyes Full Of Beams: ““Hope that is not me as the only filter I was evading is not even a banned word it seems,…Jan 11, 14:20
    • Mark Beggan on In Ruins: “Electric Soup was later bottled and rebranded as ‘Who you looking at.’Jan 11, 14:11
    • Ian on In Ruins: ““In a democracy, Westminster cannot stand in the way of the people of Scotland determining their own future”. Am I…Jan 11, 14:09
    • Chris Downie on In Ruins: “I read an article yesterday that they were (belatedly) floating a Northern Ireland style argument for a referendum, which immediately…Jan 11, 14:08
  • A tall tale



↑ Top
212
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x