The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


2012: Question Of The Year

Posted on December 23, 2012 by

While we’re not planning to shut Wings Over Scotland down during the festive break, obviously political stories are likely to be a bit thin on the ground with Parliament on recess and everyone plonked in front of Doctor Who full of turkey and booze. So to fill the gaps we’ll be resorting to some traditional methods – scattered in among new articles will be some end-of-year awards, best-ofs and perhaps the odd reprint of stories from earlier in the year when we had only a fraction of the readership we do now, and which most people therefore won’t have seen.

So let’s start with our favourite piece of terrier-like interrogation from the nation’s broadcast journalists, reporters and presenters. These are the people ultimately charged with holding our politicians to account on our behalf – literally so in the case of the BBC – so it’s vital they keep on top of their game with a firm grasp of the issues and an ability to cut through the waffle and obfuscation of their interview subjects and get to the heart of the matter.

So for a gem that dates way back to almost the first political programme of the year but which nobody managed to better for the entire 11-and-a-bit months that followed it, our first-ever “Wingy” goes to… Raymond Buchanan of BBC Scotland!

The January 11th edition of Newsnight Scotland featured duelling lawyers, with conflicting views on the legality of the Scottish Government’s proposed referendum. Professor Adam Tomkins from the University of Glasgow put forward the opinion that Holyrood basically had no power to do anything at all and should be grateful for Westminster’s “very generous” offer to help out, while Professor Stephen Tierney (batting for the University of Edinburgh) posited the alternative interpretation that an advisory referendum was perfectly fine as it didn’t in itself trigger any legislation and therefore exceed the Parliament’s competence.

Presenter Buchanan tried to navigate the tricky constitutional minefield between the two, and after Prof. Tierney had given his explanation of why the referendum bill might be lawful, Buchanan stabbed right at the heart of the dilemma when he asked the question thousands of viewers across the nation were shouting at their screens:

“Just to clarify that: so, so, if there was a Yes vote, which said “Go and negotiate with Westminster” and then, uh… then Westminster… or the… what you’re saying whether the voters rejected that then, what would happen or… Westminster rejected it, what impact would you, were you saying?”

Such was the searing power of this unanswerable inquisition that just a few short months later, the Westminster and Holyrood governments had banged their heads together and come up with the historic Edinburgh Agreement, rendering the legality of the referendum beyond doubt. Come 2014, Wings Over Scotland will not forget the man who made it all possible. Raymond B, we salute you.

8 to “2012: Question Of The Year”

  1. Turnip_Ghost says:

    *wipes a tear*

    what a hero! 

    Reply
  2. heraldnomore says:

    to be fair he’s managed to keep up that standard all year; the very epitome of impartiality throughout…..

    Reply
  3. Doug Daniel says:

    Ha ha! Poor Raymond, I thought you were actually being nice until I got to the quoted bit!

    Reply
  4. Vronsky says:

    How about a PPP Wingy  – for Political Product Placement – inserting a political message into an apparently non-political programme.  I propose  Neil Oliver of the BBC’s ‘Coast’ series.  Marching along like the wee lassie in The Exorcist with his head rotated 180 degrees so that he can talk to a camera held, inexplicably, directly behind him, he told us how the coast united Scotland, England and Wales into one unit and, he said very warmly, ‘I like that’.  Can’t remember the exact date of the broadcast, but I’m sure there was an election coming up at the time.

    Reply
  5. Yesitis says:

    I wonder if Raymond (and the rest of his BBC Reporting Scotland unionist friends) know that at the very least, one third of his viewers know he wears union jack underpants?
    I have a feeling he does; in fact, I have a feeling he quite enjoys the thrill of his obvious scripted nat-baiting.
    I think I meant nat-baiting? Anyway, I hope he can find work in England; I can`t imagine he`d be employable up here after 2014.
     

    Reply
  6. Ron says:

    I’m never quite sure whether his projecting hairstyle reminds me more of a thatched roof or a geisha’s parasol – very silly either way!

    Reply
  7. Oldnat says:

    Ron

    Talking of hairsyles, I’ve bought a bottle of Glenfiddich for the Xmas Day do, for all those who dislike Donald Trump.

    Don’t expect it to last very long! 

    Reply
  8. ayemachrihanish says:

    In his acceptance speach he acknowladged that while George Washington had cationed that ‘a passionate attachment of one nation for another produces a variety of evils’, he was okay with that, beceause Tony Blair had told him that “evil was the new good” and that the BBC were past masters at evil… or was it good? 

    Reply


Comment - please read this page for comment rules. HTML tags like <i> and <b> are permitted. Use paragraph breaks in long comments. DO NOT SIGN YOUR COMMENTS, either with a name or a slogan. If your comment does not appear immediately, DO NOT REPOST IT. Ignore these rules and I WILL KILL YOU WITH HAMMERS.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a (mainly) Scottish political media digest and monitor, which also offers its own commentary. (More)

    Stats: 6,747 Posts, 1,216,853 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Hatey McHateface on The Takeover: “Careful, Southernbystander, Barbie has been spotted heading for the mobile gas chamber, jump leads in hand. Alert readers will spot…Apr 30, 10:39
    • David on The Takeover: “Whose side are the government and media on as well… not the pro life side. Killing your children is the…Apr 30, 10:19
    • factfinder on The Takeover: “But surely the Sovereign people of Scotland asked for the devolved parliament to be created. And that wish is sovereign…Apr 30, 10:04
    • Geri on The Takeover: “Aidan That’s funny. What are the UN & the courts doing at the moment via Palestine? Or the Chagos Islands?…Apr 30, 10:03
    • James Cheyne on The Takeover: “Personal attacks when yo cannot deal with facts. Oh dear. History does not change to suit those whom are mentally…Apr 30, 09:37
    • Geri on The Takeover: “Southerwanker You know what to then eh? Go for English independence & stop being a leeching parasite to Scotland, the…Apr 30, 09:16
    • Chas on The Takeover: “Geri Is that drivel supposed to make any sense? All written in a style which befits someone of limited intelligence…Apr 30, 09:08
    • Aidan on The Takeover: “@Chas – completely, it’s a total dead end strategy. No court, or the UN, is going to decide that we…Apr 30, 08:19
    • Hatey McHateface on The Takeover: “Ouch, Southernbystander, that must sting! YL Sah! has just let you have a brace of his signature “double taps”. I…Apr 30, 08:13
    • Hatey McHateface on The Takeover: ““I’d bet a pound to a pile of shite” Nah, Barbie, ye widnae. You’ve a track record of being wrong…Apr 30, 08:02
    • Captain Caveman on The Takeover: “Honestly, Wings BTL is a must-read for me, daily. Particularly good and especially deliciously unhinged of late! Please, please… keep…Apr 30, 06:21
    • Yoon Scum on The Takeover: “Geri You need to address a MAJOR issue with leaving the union us English filth live in Scotland How are…Apr 30, 06:00
    • Young Lochinvar on The Takeover: “Wow! Something got shook loose there!! Fat? Seen many Anglos recently? Clearly not! Go to Benidorm and view the Engerlund…Apr 30, 01:15
    • Young Lochinvar on The Takeover: “Andrew Sorry, I disagree. Good points are being made and “BTL” post protocols aside it gets asinine with folk “wanging…Apr 30, 00:49
    • Geri on The Takeover: “I’d bet a pound to a pile of shite there is an Englishman there in the thick of it all.…Apr 30, 00:17
    • James on The Takeover: “AH! A “Carol”. Where did you appear from, poppet? Diversity! The 77th now have a laydee poster. Or is wee…Apr 30, 00:11
    • James on The Takeover: ““Chas” (lol) “How come so many nutters contribute to the ‘comments section’ on Wings?” Go on “Chas”, Look in a…Apr 30, 00:03
    • Geri on The Takeover: “GM They’re making a big deal of it because colonialism thrives on division & conflict & sectarianism is their favourite…Apr 29, 23:49
    • Geri on The Takeover: “James Cheyne I’m so sorry for your loss. I hope you are okay. Sending you hugs at this difficult time…Apr 29, 23:31
    • GM on The Takeover: “Hatey McHateface says: 29 April, 2025 at 9:16 pm You are being taken for a fool.. Could be! Political Islam…Apr 29, 22:51
    • Yoon Scum on The Takeover: “Chas Are you saying that we can’t cast a magic spell while wearing the holy tartan cap and holding up…Apr 29, 21:17
    • Hatey McHateface on The Takeover: ““The Muslims from Scotland that I know are Scottish. No question” Yet only a few posts above, we have Alf…Apr 29, 21:16
    • GM on The Takeover: “Aye, f all to do with being muslim. I am slightly puzzled why they are making a big deal out…Apr 29, 20:59
    • Chas on The Takeover: “Sadly Cheyne is not alone in posting repetitive pish. There are too many living in the past banging on about…Apr 29, 20:48
    • Bilbo on The Takeover: “Who controls the past, controls the future.Apr 29, 20:27
    • GM on The Takeover: “NO.Definitely not Bilbo. Hopefully copying the USA is at the start of being on its way ootApr 29, 20:27
    • GM on The Takeover: “The Muslims from Scotland that I know are Scottish. No question and the ones I know from abroad don’t exhibit…Apr 29, 20:11
    • Hatey McHateface on The Takeover: “You’re wasting your time on the right side of history, Marie. The left side of history is where all the…Apr 29, 19:59
    • carol Neill on The Takeover: “Much as I am sympathetic with James cheynes recent loss I am not missing their posts Same shit all day…Apr 29, 19:52
    • Bilbo on The Takeover: “Never heard of the band until recently. They sound like the Northern Irish version of the Bearsden and Milngavie scheme…Apr 29, 19:43
  • A tall tale



↑ Top