The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Some sort of charity

Posted on September 27, 2012 by

Scottish Labour mouthpiece the Daily Record is currently running a long series of horror stories about Atos “Healthcare” and their appalling persecution of the sick and disabled. We heartily and sincerely commend the Record for doing so, even if it usually fails to note that Atos were unleashed on the poor and vulnerable by a Labour government, and occasionally just outright lies about it.

You might expect, then, that the valid concerns of the Record and its readers would be earnestly reflected by the nation’s Labour MSPs when the Scottish Parliament debated the issue of Atos’ conduct of Work Capability Assessments yesterday.

You’d be wrong, of course.

The SNP desks in the chamber were fairly well populated for a member’s-business session, with MSPs attending in double figures and numerous speakers.

Over on the Tory/Lib Dem benches, Conservative MSP Alex Johnstone was perhaps understandably alone, with nobody else from the Scottish branches of the UK’s ruling parties wishing to be associated with defending the indefensible.

And for Labour? One.

We don’t just mean Jackie Baillie was the only Labour MSP to speak in the debate. Although not present at the beginning, she was the only one who bothered to show up at all, and she stood surrounded by empty seats as her party colleagues instead ran around defending Johann Lamont’s plans to subject Scotland’s poor and disabled and elderly to means-testing in order to keep receiving personal care and prescriptions.

We were about to be shocked and disgusted, until we remembered the words of Scottish Labour MP Tom Harris a little under a year ago, as approvingly quoted by the Telegraph’s arch-Tory columnist Alan Cochrane:

“We weren’t set up as some sort of charity to help the poorest in society – the long-term unemployed, the benefit dependent, the drug addicted, the homeless.”

We’re feeling a little bit sick ourselves now, readers, but please don’t tell anyone about it. Because we don’t want Atos “Healthcare” coming after us next.

20 to “Some sort of charity”

  1. Wullie B says:

    goews to show , the SNP and pro independence parties are the only ones to care aboput the Disabled in Scotland ,more now than never do we need independence

    Reply
  2. Holebender says:

    Gobsmacked! (You’d think I’d have learned by now, but Labour’s callous disregard of their core electorate continues to amaze me.)

    Reply
  3. panda paws says:

    Of course Labour were running about trying to defuse the Lamont bomb. It’s really really important to ensure a No vote in the referendum and to ensure the C listers keep their places at the Holyhood trough. After all, if it’s Yes, then some of the “A” listers might not get parachuted into rUK seats and be forced into Holyhood and were would that leave the C listers.
    Anyone would think Labour was set up for the working classes and the defenceless and to help those who need help. Oh right.
     
     

    Reply
  4. Vermin.

    Reply
  5. Erchie says:

    Elsewhere yesterday, Westminster Labour are promising a review on the WCA. We’ll see.
     
    Though Labour’s attitude to date has been a wonderful comparison to make on the benefits of deciding these things for ourselves

    Reply
  6. Macart says:

    There are not enough sweary words in the dictionary to describe Labour leadership’s actions of the past few days.

    They soooooo deserve what comes next at the ballot. 

    Reply
  7. Really I have no words to describe how I feel about Lamont and her cronies.I only am certain of this without independence all that was fought for by previous generations will be lost.
     

    Reply
  8. EdinScot says:

    Be aa breath of fresh air come independence to concentrate on tackling the many ills that  afflict our society instead of wasting all our energies on the laughingly called Labour party.  When you have the tory loving hootsman singing a so called Labour leaders praises, the writing is well and truly on the wall.  I hope its a quick 2 years til we vote YES.

    Reply
  9. Macart says:

    Its maybe worth noting they chose this particular week and the absence of the FM to drop these bombshells. Maybe they thought Nicola would be easier to handle at FMQs.

    Some hope. 😉 

    Reply
  10. MajorBloodnok says:

    Nicola is FM material, that’s for sure.

    Reply
  11. JBS says:

    Dear Undecided Voter –
     
    Vote Yes in 2014 to protect Scotland from the ravages of the neoliberal consensus.

    Reply
  12. Davy says:

    I would like to say nothing labour does surprises me anymore, but after tuesday’s speech, I can’t.

    I also watched FM’s question time today and watched Nicola skin the arse off both Lamont and Davidson with the greatest of ease, though I would have like to have seen the camera’s pointing at the labour seats when Ruth Davidson thanked labour for their support for their policys, (resulting in fast toilet break). We have a worthy Deputy Leader for Scotland.  

    Reply
  13. Arbroath 1320 says:

    Nice to see the Tories, of either colour, were in FULL support of the Health debate.
    Boy I bet their supporters were WELL impressed with their attendance…..NOT!
     
    If we DON’T have a YES win in 20124 then, in my view, we could be looking at this happening a few years later.
    I know I DON’T want this!
     
    link to bbc.co.uk

    link to guardian.co.uk

    Reply
  14. Macart says:

    @MajorBloodnock

    I get the feeling it won’t be that far in the future either. 

    Reply
  15. Cuphook says:

    I’m sure that many of the sick and disabled are capable of some sort of work if supported properly. Many of them would probably appreciate the opportunity to participate more fully in society. But this is not the way to go about it.  

    I’ve a friend who has excellent IT skills and is logical, intelligent and imaginative – for six months of the year. The other six – not so much (I actually did lol there). I always find it a shame that no one has found a way to use his talents when he is capable. He’d like to work and have colleagues and office parties with kissing in the copy room.  

    No doubt ATOS will find him fit for work and he will then be presented with ludicrous opportunities.          

    Reply
  16. james morton says:

    @cuphook what kind of work could they do? The real issue is not what work it prevents them from doing, thats usually self evident. It’s finding that *opportunity” werr their disability would not be an issue. But it doesn’t begin and end there. There is the how he gets to work…is transport a problem, will access be a problem. Is the actual workspace safe for this person. Adequate facilities present on site? Will the employer even want to hire said disabled person – bearing insurance costs and liabilities. Are they able to do a full day or half a day, can they be left on their own or will they need assistance or a minder to keep an eye on them.
    The problem is that ATOS doesn’t support disabled people into work – it simply kicks them off the support system and throws them into the unknown. They don’t give a shit at this point. If its your friend they will find him capable and when he fails to find employment and reapplies for assistance, ATOS get to do it to him again – kaching! – another cash bonus for them.
    I am relativley lucky – I have crohns disease which is in remission so I can work. But when it was doing its absolute worst to end me, I was effectively unemployable for about a year. I am employed by the government and so had generous sick leave, without which i would have found myself out of work while still desperately ill. I count my lucky stars that I fell ill when I did. When the tories were not in government, and New labour were not the vile sh*ts that that they are today.
    If you can genuinely help a disabled person into some sort of work – thats fine and dandy but you have to be honest and compassionate enough to accept that perhaps, you simply can’t help this person. What you don’t do is harass them, hound them, attack them in the press, and generally behave like a vile tory shit towards them.
    If ATOS had appeared when the tories took over, I would not have been surprised, but it was labour who enabled these nasty vile ratfucks to prey upon the most vulnerable in our society. The tories must have been sick from laughing at the opportunity this contract gave them to do what they do best…be complete and utter bastards

    Reply
  17. Appleby says:

    It’s got to the point where part of me feels that if Scotland and the Scottish people aren’t sensible enough to vote YES on 2014 that they frankly deserve the likely dystopian nightmare that will follow from it. It’s just a shame that me and mine will also be dragged into that nightmare, so I can’t simply give into fate or despair. The effort’s still on to avoid that possibility!

    Reply
  18. Holebender says:

    If Scotland’s voters vote NO in 2014 they deserve everything that’s coming to them, and I won’t be sticking around to witness it. I’ll find a proper independent democracy to live in.

    Reply
  19. Erchie says:

    Cuphook

    I believe you have said similar things before and been corrected

    The current system takes someone who is weak from Chemo to combat their cancer, tells them they are fit to work and tells them if they do not work shelf stacking for a rich company in exchange for that benefit they will lose it,

    Unlike earlier schemes there is no help towards transport costs or a top up to the benefit.

    It is not a mere matter of presentation, about a fair system unfairly vilified, it really is a fucking horror with the “Health Professionals”, e.g. a physio nurse, being pressured to find folk fit to work who should be inpatients at hospitals

    Reply
  20. Appleby says:

    Atos and its kind represent the kind of world we used to look down upon in the world or back on in dark histories from sadder times. I’ve yet to meet anyone who things these things are good, so how have they been getting away with pushing it all so far?

    Reply


Comment - please read this page for comment rules. HTML tags like <i> and <b> are permitted. Use paragraph breaks in long comments. DO NOT SIGN YOUR COMMENTS, either with a name or a slogan. If your comment does not appear immediately, DO NOT REPOST IT. Ignore these rules and I WILL KILL YOU WITH HAMMERS.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,776 Posts, 1,219,727 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Iain More on The Grand Tour: ““Anyone voting SNP on both ballots, then, for any reason, is unequivocally a moron.” They are worse than morons. Anybody…Jun 11, 02:16
    • Wullie B on The Grand Tour: “I think you might have a pleasant surprise from Banff and Buchan, believe it or not, between the fishing and…Jun 11, 00:25
    • Heaver on The Grand Tour: “Slag off some minorities. That’ll get you noticed. Works for Farage.Jun 10, 23:55
    • Willie on The Grand Tour: “Interesting day tomorrow in parliament. Will the vote on the decision released late tonight by the Scottish Government be enough…Jun 10, 23:49
    • Eddie Munster on The Grand Tour: “Alba are list only so to not split the indy vote, they’ve been saying that for a long time now.…Jun 10, 23:41
    • Bill Cowan on The Grand Tour: “ALBA a complete no-show? And what of the combination of all the other Indy parties, groups, and individuals, Liberate Scotland?Jun 10, 23:12
    • Jim Anderson on The Grand Tour: “S Gethins is earmarked to replace the useless Shona in Dundee East.Jun 10, 22:40
    • George Ferguson on The Grand Tour: “Excellent analysis Stu as usual. I can’t disagree with any of it. Slightly disconcerting to me trying to stand as…Jun 10, 22:22
    • sarah on The Grand Tour: “Rev, I take it that you don’t think that ANY SNP candidate can lose Edinburgh Eastern, given that Ash Denham/Regan…Jun 10, 21:57
    • KEITH HYND on The Grand Tour: “Even if the SNP were the only option on the ballot paper I still wouldn’t vote for them. They need…Jun 10, 21:50
    • Aidan on Two Of A Kind: “That’s not what you’ve been saying over the past few weeks and months though is itJun 10, 21:39
    • Rev. Stuart Campbell on The Grand Tour: “Edited, ta.Jun 10, 21:23
    • Viscount Ennui on The Grand Tour: “Just wondering if anyone has put in an FOI about how the Scottish bond initiative is going. I am so…Jun 10, 21:21
    • Hatey McHateface on Two Of A Kind: ““when did the north and south of Scotland become reconciled, and see themselves as one nation?” Yet to happen, IMO.…Jun 10, 20:54
    • @nairnkev on The Grand Tour: “You need to get the slacker cartoonist to produce a visual of a stinking festering corpse blocking the door to…Jun 10, 20:52
    • Hatey McHateface on Two Of A Kind: ““the management of North Sea resources” Aha! That’s what’s really getting their goat. It’s Scotland’s oil. They missed a trick…Jun 10, 20:42
    • Rev. Stuart Campbell on The Grand Tour: “Eh? I did.Jun 10, 20:32
    • sarah on The Grand Tour: “Constituencies SNP 56, Labour 9, LibDem 3, Conservatives 5.Jun 10, 20:31
    • Gary on The Grand Tour: “Would it be possible to finish the job, and add up the seats?Jun 10, 20:13
    • John McTaggart on The Grand Tour: “Annabelle Ewing is standing down in Cowdenbeath. I’m not sure if the selection has been made yet but I’d think…Jun 10, 19:37
    • Dan on Two Of A Kind: “Oh aye, here’s another splitter unable to get behind the original ISP formation. Fucked off to the US because he…Jun 10, 18:02
    • sarah on Two Of A Kind: “To clarify the UN procedure for being recognised as a Non-Self-Governing State, an existing member state of the UN can…Jun 10, 17:29
    • factfinder on Two Of A Kind: “James says: 10 June, 2025 at 4:13 pm “Factfinder” [lol] – read it and weep, sunshine No need for tears,…Jun 10, 17:00
    • AndrewR on Two Of A Kind: “factfinder The Schools Bill is really interesting. This is a general question to the forum: when did the north and…Jun 10, 16:51
    • Aidan on Two Of A Kind: “Taken from JPTI’s website today: “The C-24 has very strict rules. Only regions already on the UN’s official list of…Jun 10, 16:23
    • Willie on Two Of A Kind: “Just read this as I sit on a train on the West coast line travelling to Glasgow Partick. Only going…Jun 10, 16:17
    • James on Two Of A Kind: ““Factfinder” [lol] – read it and weep, sunshine. “…Most importantly, Scotland lacks international legal personality, is not permitted to conduct…Jun 10, 16:13
    • factfinder on Two Of A Kind: “The deliberate campaign to eradicate Gaelic language and culture was, of course, started long before 1707. The Establishment of Schools…Jun 10, 15:23
    • Northcode on Two Of A Kind: “Thanks for the link, Alf. Very helpful. This from the Justice pour Tous Internationale (JPTi) website : Building on two…Jun 10, 13:54
    • Alf Baird on Two Of A Kind: “Instead of playing British politics, here is what the SNP leadership should have been doing long ago, taking Scotland’s case…Jun 10, 13:14
  • A tall tale



↑ Top