The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


A letter from Quebec 227

Posted on June 23, 2014 by

As a French Quebecer belonging to a generation that was deeply influenced by Harry Potter, it was with great interest and concern that I read JK Rowling’s recent letter on why she opposes Scotland’s independence.

quebec

Of herself and her fellow Scots, she justly writes that “whatever Scotland decides, we will probably find ourselves justifying our choice to our grandchildren.”

Well, I’m one of those grandchildren previous generations now find themselves having to justify their decisions to, and I can tell you how it went for us.

Read the rest of this entry →

Tags:
Category comment, history, scottish politics, world

  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a (mainly) Scottish political media digest and monitor, which also offers its own commentary. (More)

    Stats: 6,669 Posts, 1,202,457 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

    and finally and firstly arithmetic fail braveheart klaxon britnats captain darling cartoons Chris Cairns confused cringe crybabies dateline debates Devo Nano Douglas Daniel Federalists Unionists and Devolutionists flat-out lies foreigner watch from the archives fundraisers galleries hamish hypocrisy liars light-hearted banter lizards memogate misinformation one nation perspectives poll project fear project feart qft Scott Minto smears snp accused soapbox the positive case for the union The Vow ticktock toldyouso too wee too poor too stupid unionist of the day vote no get nothing

  • Recent Comments

    • Alf Baird on The Way Forward: “Aye Robert, this is all part and parcel of the ‘colonial condition’. Scots have endured for decades all our best…” Nov 18, 17:06
    • Neil Singleton on The Way Forward: “It’s walking dogs in the park and in the countryside that causes racism in Wales, don’tcha know.” Nov 18, 16:45
    • Neil Singleton on The Way Forward: “You need to have a word with the passengers of over 400+ private jets who winged their way to Baku,…” Nov 18, 16:43
    • Aidan on The Way Forward: “I agree, the wind issue is one where some parts of the Yes campaign have really tied themselves in knots.…” Nov 18, 16:41
    • TURABDIN on The Way Forward: “If US Democrats have their way, should really all be over by Christmas….cheers!” Nov 18, 16:41
    • Chas on The Way Forward: “You are getting your erse handed to you on a plate today. Fully deserved.” Nov 18, 14:41
    • Chas on The Way Forward: “The majority on here have no interest in economic or constitutional questions. Did you not know that these kinds of…” Nov 18, 14:31
    • Steve on The Way Forward: ““Learn from the country that, along with England, scuppered our independence vote, and smeared Alex Salmond,” The US smeared Alex…” Nov 18, 14:31
    • Stuart MacKay on The Way Forward: “The author is making the mistake of thinking that American politics are universally applicable. The issues discussed, inflation, etc. are…” Nov 18, 14:17
    • Lorna Campbell on The Way Forward: “Yes, but the first retrying we must do post independence is establish the banking sectors we need for investment and…” Nov 18, 14:02
    • Vivian O’Blivion on The Way Forward: “In science, we construct experiments to test theories. The environmental parameters to which the thesis is exposed are extreme in…” Nov 18, 13:59
    • Lorna Campbell on The Way Forward: “Correct again. Only independence can tease out the true wealth potential of Scotland. It won’t be easy for about five…” Nov 18, 13:45
    • Steve on The Way Forward: “I guess we will see if the administration will fall apart. Though it sounds more like wishful thinking on your…” Nov 18, 13:44
    • Lorna Campbell on The Way Forward: “That is the truth of it, but, if this regional and city autonomy/devolution get off the ground, we will be…” Nov 18, 13:44
    • Aidan on The Way Forward: “That’s just a flat out lie, for starters there’s been four New Caledonia referendums, all of which have been organised…” Nov 18, 12:56
    • James on The Way Forward: “Scots??” Nov 18, 12:14
    • James on The Way Forward: “Check out the recent New Caledonia referendum. Followed UN rules. Read it and weep.” Nov 18, 12:13
    • TURABDIN on The Way Forward: “WHEN DID WE ALL BECOME WOMEN? https://archive.ph/ACLfx A serious overview from 2006 before «woke» went worldwide…now it’s truly culturewide.  Small…” Nov 18, 11:49
    • Michael Laing on The Way Forward: “I agree. The argument that we should do nothing to reduce carbon emissions and prevent climate catastrophe just because the…” Nov 18, 11:01
    • McDuff on The Way Forward: “Unfortunately that is exactly the way things stand at the moment so I don’t quite understand why there are so…” Nov 18, 10:48
    • Hal Martin on The Way Forward: “Incredible stuff. Learn from the country that, along with England, scuppered our independence vote, and smeared Alex Salmond, so they…” Nov 18, 10:42
    • Robert Hughes on The Way Forward: “A better thing than having actual Scottish people , y’know those people born in Scotland to Scottish parents in those…” Nov 18, 10:34
    • Andrew Abel on The Way Forward: “I would have thought that having people all around the world who have spent time in Scotland and know about…” Nov 18, 10:22
    • Dan on The Way Forward: “Tenuously relevant. Catching up with some of the posts on Off-Topic Scotland. https://www.offtopicscotland.com/post/we-are-not-rats-and-our-time-is-now Article is a decent read but this…” Nov 18, 10:14
    • 100%Yes on The Way Forward: “The Funny for today is, Stephen Flynn claims ‘Holyrood needs me’ like a whole in the head. He’s only just…” Nov 18, 09:59
    • Andrew Abel on The Way Forward: “Ugh. There’s a lot to dislike there. It reads like a manifesto of someone who has spent too much time…” Nov 18, 09:53
    • Robert Hughes on The People You Most Suspected: “L.O.L. I was going to point out the , erm ….* slight * discrepancy here , but I try not…” Nov 18, 09:47
    • The Flying Iron of Doom on The Way Forward: “I think he meant a link to the source material from which the image was lifted?” Nov 18, 09:39
    • Blunt gaper on The Way Forward: “Edinburgh University” Nov 18, 09:25
    • Steve Ellwood on The Way Forward: “Having stewarded at many SNP events/conferences, there is absolutely no shortage of English voices in the SNP. I was one…” Nov 18, 08:58

  • A tall tale



↑ Top