The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland



What does it mean to be Scottish? 196

Posted on August 03, 2014 by

The above is a deceptively simple question and one to which the answer, of course, is as varied as the people you might ask it of as we approach September’s vote.

The debate so far would suggest that at one end of the scale, we’re a nation of poor wee souls, much safer shackled to a United Kingdom that gifts us stability and security in the face of choppy global waters and saves us from the hassle of making crucial political decisions for ourselves. At the other end, we’re a proud nation of untold prosperity, a nirvana of wealth and social justice primed to emerge after our divorce from our oppressors in Westminster.

For anyone in between and still grappling with their identity, the Economist helpfully informed us recently that being Scottish means painting a Saltire on your face, wearing a Jimmy hat and shouting at nothing in particular. Glad that’s sorted then.

The truth is that very few of us will see ourselves in these broad-brushed caricatures of Scottish identity. I certainly don’t. In fact, the more I force myself to think about it, the clearer it becomes that I don’t have a bloody clue what it means to be Scottish.

Or at least I didn’t until last month.

Read the rest of this entry →

  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a (mainly) Scottish political media digest and monitor, which also offers its own commentary. (More)

    Stats: 6,754 Posts, 1,217,601 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Xaracen on The Blindness Of Hatred: ““To make the union fair, should Scotland have as many MPs as England?” No, it just needs a Dual Majority…May 12, 09:10
    • Tenruh on The Blindness Of Hatred: “Great idea, every household a week before the postal vote goes out must get a leaflet explaining the whole process.May 12, 09:07
    • GM on The Blindness Of Hatred: “THE PAID TROLLS ARE ON YOUR EVERY POST GERI. YOUR INDEPENDENT CAST OF MIND DISTURBS THEM. THINK LIKE ENGLAND GOD…May 12, 08:31
    • Hatey McHateface on A Poor Example: “Thank you for your clarification. The reality remains though, that for some high tech jobs, such as IT, UK employers…May 12, 08:18
    • Hatey McHateface on The Blindness Of Hatred: “Where is it written, “Dave”, that only the rabid, dyed-in-the-wool, blue-ersed Indy supporters are permitted multiple identities? Is it adjacent…May 12, 07:57
    • Hatey McHateface on The Blindness Of Hatred: “Well, Marie, I’m stumped. It’s more-or-less an article of faith on here that after Indy, we’ll all be rolling in…May 12, 07:49
    • Hatey McHateface on The Blindness Of Hatred: “That’s quite a post, Barbie, from somebody who only a few weeks back was enthusiastically volunteering to “man” the Scottish…May 12, 07:38
    • Dickie Tea on A Poor Example: “Has anyone reported this as a Hate Crime yet?May 12, 07:35
    • Dickie Tea on A Poor Example: “It’s concerning to see such a misleading claim going around. The latest trade deal with India doesn’t mean all Indian…May 12, 07:34
    • Hatey McHateface on The Blindness Of Hatred: “Aw, Barbie, that’s so sweet. All the time you’ve been “away”, you’ve been thinking of me.May 12, 07:27
    • Dickie Tea on The Blindness Of Hatred: “The real issue is that most Scots who vote SNP don’t actually understand how the List system works. They’ve been…May 12, 07:23
    • Skip_NC on The Blindness Of Hatred: “Alba has to work with the resources it has. Yes, it would be great to stand in all 73 constituencies…May 12, 02:15
    • Geri on The Blindness Of Hatred: ““You would happily see scotland as a 3rd world poverty stricken hellhole if you get to say up yours to…May 12, 01:21
    • Geri on The Blindness Of Hatred: “If I was in charge I’d make all who voted on this to volunteer a family member first. Same with…May 12, 00:39
    • BLMac on The Blindness Of Hatred: ““You would happily see scotland as a 3rd world poverty stricken hellhole if you get to say up yours to…May 12, 00:10
    • Geoff Bush on The Blindness Of Hatred: “look – its simple – James is now a member of the SNP – if he didn’t say stuff supportive…May 11, 23:02
    • Marie on The Blindness Of Hatred: “Oh absolutely. The nation state can’t possibly be burdened with the mentally ill as well as the physically ill. THAT…May 11, 22:21
    • Scot Finlayson on The Blindness Of Hatred: “Voting at Holyrood on the assisted killing bill on Tuesday, the bill is being forced through by LibDem MSP Liam…May 11, 22:04
    • Michael Laing on The Blindness Of Hatred: “@ David Holden: Yoon’s Cum seems pretty appropriate to me. Doing a LOL!May 11, 21:37
    • sarah on The Blindness Of Hatred: “It is very worrying that so many people don’t understand the Holyrood voting system. Even more worrying, that the SNP…May 11, 21:05
    • Scot Finlayson on The Blindness Of Hatred: “Lord Palmerston once said: “Only three people have ever really understood the D’Hondt method list vote system – the Prince…May 11, 20:59
    • Rev. Stuart Campbell on The Blindness Of Hatred: “Oh for fuck’s SAKE. Yes, they’ll get no seats if nobody votes for them. The point is that if you…May 11, 20:57
    • Craig on Some People Try To Fuck With You: “Get the Civil Restraint Order fired in now mate, never mind the lunacy of the guy, he is clearly a…May 11, 20:43
    • 100%Yes on The Blindness Of Hatred: “It would appear James Kelly is a frequent visitor here.May 11, 20:10
    • Aidan on The Blindness Of Hatred: “Yup Yoonscum this is getting silly nowMay 11, 20:03
    • diabloandco on The Blindness Of Hatred: “Tar would be pretty good.May 11, 19:56
    • David Holden on The Blindness Of Hatred: “As Yoon’s cum seems to be going for a period on the naughty step I wonder what cunning new name…May 11, 19:54
    • Rev. Stuart Campbell on The Blindness Of Hatred: “Okay, enough. You were warned.May 11, 19:35
    • Rev. Stuart Campbell on The Blindness Of Hatred: “A 10-to-1 numerical outnumbering might conceivably help.May 11, 19:35
    • Yoon Scum on The Blindness Of Hatred: “If us English are so pathetic, useless and snivelling cowardly pieces of subhuman shit How do we have our boot…May 11, 19:20
  • A tall tale



↑ Top