The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


The problem with lying

Posted on January 13, 2010 by

As the writer of the Definitive series of games histories for Retro Gamer, the bane of my life is websites repeating stuff they found somewhere else and didn’t bother to check. Because if the original “fact” isn’t actually true, the weight of repetition quickly causes it to become accepted as the truth anyway, and you end up with a load of cobblers becoming the official historical record, at least until I have to come along and fix it, usually by playing the game(s) all the way to the bloody end myself.

(I suppose I shouldn’t complain, as if it didn’t happen so much Retro Gamer’s first feature on R-Type wouldn’t have been SO full of glaring errors that I couldn’t stop myself writing them an angry letter about it, and thereby managing to secure the Definitive gig in the first place, which has been quite a nice little earner.)

And printing rubbish about games can still be dangerous even if you think you’re really obviously joking, as this picture I recently found lurking on my hard drive proves:

It’s a picture of my telly, displaying one of the info screens from Sky TV’s set-top-box version of Space Invaders. Officially licenced from Taito and designed to be played with the Sky remote, it’s a rather nice version, complete with authentic bezel surround, which makes it slightly alarming that it features a piece of text lifted straight out of James Leach’s review of the Spectrum version of Super Space Invaders in Your Sinclair.

(Which incidentally also features one of my favourite Speccy loading screens ever, pictured below.)

Now, from reading even the first couple of paragraphs of that YS piece, it should be fairly obvious that it’s not exactly a serious piece of valid documentary data. But the story was repeated on a few websites that obviously didn’t quite “get” YS’s sense of humour (and can still be found on some today, for example here and here), and evidently someone coding the Sky version came across it, thought it was a fun trivia fact and bingo bongo, next thing you know it’s in an official release.

Do they even have figgy pudding in Japan?

0 to “The problem with lying”

  1. Irish Al says:

    Games writing is full of these. For example “Wolfenstein 3D” or “Doom” are routinely trotted out as being the first FPS when I distinctly remember playing LAN multiplayer Maze War on a Mac network in college in the late 80s, and *that* was around since 1974.

  2. gnome says:

    Well, I can’t say that the creation of this false kind of history isn’t amusing… And so very dada too…

  3. Andy Krouwel says:

    See also every April Fool’s joke on the Internet that then hangs around APPROXIMATELY FOREVER.




  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,945 Posts, 1,246,355 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Alf Baird on Search And Replace: ““Fabulous win” Aye, Norway were excellent against Brasil, unlike the confused and uncertain Scots; the contrast between a confident independent…Jul 6, 11:20
    • Kevin Cargill on Search And Replace: “I really can’t see any way forward towards Independence now until or unless Nicola Sturgeon is charged, tried, convicted and…Jul 6, 11:13
    • Southernbystander on Search And Replace: “Ignorance is always the norm with committed racists, made all the worse by a clear intelligence, but one that has…Jul 6, 11:10
    • Willie on Search And Replace: “How much public m9ney was secretly used to support anti independence dark arts organisations to undermine the independence campaign. And…Jul 6, 10:19
    • Marie on Search And Replace: “Yeah right. That’ll be why over 90 per cent of all indigenous Native American people alive today live South of…Jul 6, 10:17
    • Oneliner on Search And Replace: “Sure, we can vote them out. Removal of London’s Civil Service, with all the attendant subversive paraphernalia, is not so…Jul 6, 09:51
    • Lorncal on Search And Replace: “HMcH: I tend to agree. I have not read or heard anything that would indicate deliberate and prior intent to…Jul 6, 09:30
    • Hatey McHateface on Search And Replace: “According to Cesaire (I think – somebody will correct me if needed), the moon IS made of green cheese.Jul 6, 09:28
    • Hatey McHateface on Search And Replace: “Wow, TURABDIN. You’ve reached the age of “maturity” without ever learning that the Irish, Germans, Italians and Scots also reached…Jul 6, 09:26
    • Lorncal on Search And Replace: “james: then tell us which law pertains to ‘ring-fenced’ party donations being used elsewhere?Jul 6, 09:19
    • Lorncal on Search And Replace: “AdamH: so, Greens donated to another party for a referendum? Why? Why would anyone do that? If a referendum were…Jul 6, 09:16
    • sam on Search And Replace: “Blair Jenkins?Jul 6, 08:59
    • Hatey McHateface on Search And Replace: ““With this level of nonsense I hardly go online any more apart from a few sites like this one” That’s…Jul 6, 08:57
    • Hatey McHateface on Search And Replace: “So we Scots can’t conclude the SNP are corrupt incompetents and vote them out while we are still in the…Jul 6, 08:54
    • Hatey McHateface on Search And Replace: “A couple of thoughts about AI. We all see free AI-generated results when we use the internet, yet we are…Jul 6, 08:48
    • TURABDIN on Search And Replace: “i think the ENGLISH & AMERICANS are just «lucky» history, events have been notably kind to them how do they…Jul 6, 08:47
    • sarah on Search And Replace: “George, we will never improve our system UNTIL we leave the Union. From there it is a clean slate whereas…Jul 6, 08:38
    • Spartan 117 on Search And Replace: “We think alike, Dan. Truth bombs in every paragraph, especially regarding AI.Jul 6, 08:28
    • Hatey McHateface on Search And Replace: “Surely anybody holding serious, cast-iron doubts about the system and anything presented in court has a moral duty to attend…Jul 6, 08:20
    • DaveL on Search And Replace: “You’ve answered your question in the last sentence of your post. Having no confidence in the system you cannot be…Jul 6, 07:58
    • Hatey McHateface on Search And Replace: “Actually, Lorncal, I regard the fact that I appear to have more bank accounts than the SNP as sufficient evidence…Jul 6, 07:48
    • Slim Jim on Search And Replace: “Maybe they just don’t want to investigate this crime and are determined not to because then it all gets a…Jul 6, 07:45
    • Captain Caveman on Search And Replace: “Get in! 🙂 Reaching the QF was the “minimum acceptable” for me, so anything else is a bonus. Harland looking…Jul 6, 07:04
    • agentx on Search And Replace: “What a game! Fabulous win 🙂Jul 6, 04:13
    • james on Search And Replace: “Lorncal-Should those monies then be placed into an interest-bearing principal or can it be used for other purposes? Should the…Jul 6, 03:43
    • DavidT on Search And Replace: “If the first version is embezzlement, is the second not fraud?Jul 6, 02:33
    • crazycat on Search And Replace: “Yes, exactly. The website for the 2017 fund-raiser had the URL ref.scot, not snp.org, though that appeared on receipts for…Jul 6, 00:41
    • crazycat on Search And Replace: “John Logue explains that in another part of his interview: And so when the police carry out a complex investigation…Jul 6, 00:37
    • George Ferguson on Search And Replace: “I no longer believe in an Independent Scotland and Ross Greer has just told you why. We live in a…Jul 5, 23:55
    • Angus on Search And Replace: “The fobbing off by the utterly politically corrupt Police Scotland and the Crown Office will continue for ever. How much…Jul 5, 23:17
  • A tall tale



↑ Top