The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Spend, spend, spend

Posted on October 06, 2015 by

The media and Unionist politicians (we really need to come up with a word to describe that single entity), when not concocting hysterical frothing diatribes against Michelle Thomson or complaining about the Scottish Government giving money to T In The Park – a position we must confess we find ourselves in some sympathy with – have recently been loudly protesting about last year’s “underspend” in the Holyrood budget.

There’s an extremely good article here by Dr Craig Dalzell of the Scottish Greens dealing with the broader issue of why such complaints are idiotic, so rather than go over the ground again we thought we’d look at another angle.

heraldspend

Above is a Herald article from earlier this year, reporting an exaggerated version of the figure, which has now been accurately identified at £347m (almost £100m less than the Herald’s original one).

But what’s more puzzling is why the Herald thought £444m was a record anyway.

As Dr Dalzell notes in his article linked above, underspends of the budget are almost inevitable because of the way Holyrood’s finances are managed – without the ability to borrow to cover any shortfalls or emergencies, the Finance Secretary of the day HAS to err on the side of caution or risk unforeseen catastrophe.

Since the SNP took over the Scottish Government, underspends aren’t “lost” money – they carry over to the next year. Under previous Labour/Lib Dem adminstrations, the “spare” cash was returned to the coffers of the Treasury in London to gather dust.

(After the Nats’ first election victory in 2007 an arrangement was made to claw back the accumulated £1.5bn of underspends over four years – see image and link below.)

clawback1

Which makes it even more surprising that there was so much of it.

“The total sum, described as end of year flexibility (EYF), has been announced in June for the past three years. In 2000 the EYF was £435m, but this rose sharply to £718m the following year, before falling to £643m in 2002.”

In other words, in two separate years of the first Lab-Lib coalition, there was an underspend each year of almost TWICE what the Scottish Government underspent last year. And since the Herald knew perfectly well how big the previous underspends had been, it’s very odd that it would make such a clumsy mistake as suggesting that £444m was a “record” total.

We’re often cynical about the competence of mainstream-media hacks, but we’re reasonably confident even the likes of Magnus Gardham know that 643 and 718 are bigger numbers than 444.

There’s probably a logical explanation. Answers on a postcard please.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

138 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
ThemadMurph

Collective term, how about mudionists?

walter scott

A Beeb of unionists. A Murphy… … I’m bored now

Corm

Media and Unionist politicians > MUP > Muppet’s.

saor alba

Great article..

Collective term for Media and Unionist Politicians (MUP), supporters and groupies can be labelled as MUPPETS

manandboy

The media and Unionist politicians – HackUticians

thomaspotter2014

MUD-ONIONIST?

gordoz

Loonionists ?

Nei McAdam

meanunists

Robert Louis

You know, the media should hold all Governments to account, and highlight any failings, but here in Scotland, all we get are nonsense, ill-founded anti-SNP stories dressed up as political discourse.

I am honestly coming to the opinion, that political reporting in Scotland by a ten year old, would have more substance, be more incisive and contain more actual facts, than the utter propagandist tripe we are getting fed by supposed ‘professional’ ‘journalists’.

Seriously, those supposed ‘journalists’ get paid actual money for such tosh. Hard to believe.

yesindyref2

“The media and Unionist politicians (we really need to come up with a word to describe that single entity)”

The Blob?

Big white

Muppets
Media, unionists , politicians , perpetual excremental tabloid stories

K1

Collective term for the media and Unionist politicians: The Bastards.

Robert Louis

K1 at 625pm,

Or you could just drop the ‘the‘. 🙂

yesindyref2

Under previous Labour/Lib Dem adminstrations, the “spare” cash was returned to the coffers of the Treasury in London to gather dust.

(After the Nats’ first election victory in 2007 an arrangement was made to claw back the accumulated £1.5bn of underspends over four years – see image and link below.)

This isn’t right in its inference, and has led to one of the unchallenged myths from the Indy side, that the Lab / LibDems “gave back the money to Westminster”.

During previous admins ScotGov could automatically draw down returned sums the next year, SG effectively wasn’t allowed to have a savings acccount, so the arrangement was to leave it with the Treasury – for next year if needed.

In around 2006 / 7, the Treasury changed the rules so that in future it would be lost, and SG had to make its own arrangements to keep unspent funds. It happened that the SNP got into power, but Lab / LibDems would have been able to do exactly the same thing as the SNP – “clawback” those monies.

David

Magnus Gardham can count to potato.
No, wait…

Magnus Gardham can count to SNPBad.

Skip_NC

Could the $435m etc be equivalent to the Closing Balance in the graphic above the quote?

K1

Aye Robert, initially I did, but then “The Bastards’ as a ‘collective term”, distinguishes them from all other ‘ordinary’ Bastards…if you see whit a mean 🙂

jimnarlene

Media and unionist politicos, careerist chancers.

Good post, as usual.

Brian Powell

The answer is Gardham is a Unionist hack, and a lickspittle, of mediocre ability, but it took the referendum to highlight this.

YesMeansYes

Mediaocracy?

Also works as a gag (mediocracy)

yesindyref2

Incidentally that Herald article shows just how far the Herald has declined in its pursuit of a fair deal for Scotland, whether it believes in Home Rule as it stated a few days before the Ref, and that it had done for decades, or whether it supports the status quo or more powers makes no difference.

The stories it prints these days are increasingly hysterical anti-SNP bile, with no thought or care for Scotland whether YES or NO.

Kenny

I would call them the Fifth Estate. As in fifth column….

Mind you, the likes of the Sun and Daily Mail should really be called the Filth Estate.

Jimbo

Didn’t the newspapers used employ people called editors who supposedly checked what the so-called journalists passed off as news?

Seems that nowadays dishonest hacks have a free hand to lie to their hearts content without having to answer to their employers. A few defamation cases against the employers would maybe make them up their game.

michael diamond

Corrupt. Unionist. Numpties. Trashing. Scotland.

call me dave

Well you swatted that story flat. Excellent stuff… Next!

Proud Cybernat

Scottish Politicians And Media’ (SPAM or SPAMMERS).

Lesley-Anne

Collective term for the media and Unionist politicians:

Well how about The Frozen (as in time, ideas, understanding etc)

gillie

MUNTS seems to fit perfectly.

Dandy Dons 1903

The Herald has turned into a slightly more up market version of The Daily Rectum, with its ever increasing SNP bad stories and downright pro unionist drivel. Its no friend of Scotland or the indy movement thats for sure. Another enemy within.

liz

I’m feeling overwhelmed by all the crap reporting.

I hate the Scottish corporate media but I can’t think of a name terrible enough for them.

We will never get a fair deal until we are independent

manandboy

I’d be happy to call them either, Jack Shit, Black & Blue, Snotterz, Arseholes, Bluenoses, Oranges and Lemons,
or Piss n’Boots, or the Panzers, or The Empire Brigade.

neil bruce

A far as I am concerned, septic tanks covers both
politicians and media.

For both content and rhyming slang.

Brian Adams

Corrupticians

bugger (the Panda)

cannae counters, failed the qualiy.

Like Johanne, Iain and Kezia.

heedtracker

Loads of names for this lot but howsabout a UKOK bullshit scale monitor thing, out of 10, with this pretty routine fraud from Herald chumps say 6/10 UKOK?

Economic genius that is toryboy austerity teamGB, now running £170.8 billion deficit last year, still the same £170+ billion. UKOK national debt first quarter 2015, £1.56 trillion, heading for £2 trillion, interest alone approx £50 billion.

Why is UKOK austerity for the poor, socialism for the rich making no debt difference, why is Gideon celebrated by BBC etc, does it matter? Not if you’re a 10/10 unionist chancer.

Graham Bradbury

In conversation, I tend to be diplomatic and refer to them as ‘Club UK’!

ross

Heres an idea. Crowd fund the hiring of an private investigator and have them dig the dirt on the worst offending unionist journos (we know who they are).
Then publish the info on blogs like this. Fight fire with fire. Everyone has done things theyd prefer no one else knew about. Find out theirs. I reckon theyd think twice about what they wrote if they thought there was a chance something could be dug up about them.

peter

How about clusterf*****s

Croompenstein

The Zoomerati, not quite the illuminati but bastards just the same

ross

You could call them The Keek

Heidstaethefire

There is a logical explanstion, but it won’t fit on a postcard

gillie

Jackie Baillie may find herself being charged by the police for interfering in a criminal investigation.

caz-m

Is it safe to come out from behind the couch yet?

I am avoiding listening to any Scottish news bulletins today.

I am maxed-out on mortgages.

STV need to pay some kind of price for this attack on the democratically elected Government of Scotland.

Companies who advertise on this channel need to be made aware of the bias reporting that is coming out of the STV newsroom.

Tell these companies that you will refuse to watch STV while this Bias, anti-SNP reporting is going on.

As a protest, I have not watched STV all day.

STV Bad!

Lesley-Anne

I’m sorry but just read this. 😉

Labour’s leader in Scotland Kezia Dugdale has faced fresh questions on her position on Trident today – after admitting to a policy which is “deliberately unclear” and mired in “confusion”.

link to snp.org

If I have not suggested this recently then I apologise but … seriously … wee Kezia really REALLY should be on the stage! 😀

Stand by for Eeyore. 😉

link to youtube.com

handclapping

You do pose the difficult ones. 🙂 My best shot is, as we are dealing with two groups both suffering from projection, is … the 2stupid, from their common refrain that they are too wee, too poor and too stupid.

Lesley-Anne

gillie says:
6 October, 2015 at 7:24 pm

Jackie Baillie may find herself being charged by the police for interfering in a criminal investigation.

Oh PLEASE! 😀

Kenco

Munions.

Rock

Buy The National to keep The Herald alive.

McBoxheid

Cattle
because they go
MUH
Media and Unionist Hacks

and they are suffering from BBC naw, BSE, aye ah knew it was some TLA

Bob Mack

Therè already is a word——-Establishment. They are all part and parcel of the same thing.

Finlay

“The Establishment” I’d have thought?

“The British Establishment” in this case?

link to en.wikipedia.org

Wuffing Dug

Croomp @ 7.15

I like the illuminati comparisons.

I could imagine firing up to one of them in the street and pointing / shouting -ZOOMERATUS!

Or how about;
The fuckwitati
The cuntwitati
The ifanninati

Scraping the barrel now.

McBoxheid

If forgot to mention

male cattle keep producing bullshit is great quantity

The majority of male cattle have been castrated. (They can no longer do what they were meant to)

galamcennalath

Name? Tories. Simple.

Tory Press, Tory Media if necessary.

The concept of Red and Blue Tories is well established. It means any Unionist.

It’s a ‘dirty word’ to most Scots, therefore appropriate.

There is a precedent. During the American struggle of independence, any colonist who favoured continued British rule was termed a Tory.

One online definition says “A supporter of traditional political and social institutions against the forces of democratisation or reform”. Sounds right.

[…] Spend, spend, spend […]

Big Jock

They are not even trying to appear unbiased now. Straight in with the lies and a daily assault on the Scottish government. By default they are assaulting the Scottish electorate.

Here’s how this works! The SNP managed 51% of the vote at the last election. The opposition managed 49% collectively. 97% of the MSM is on the side of the 49%. Maybe I am just a cybernat,but to me the majority of Scots are being slandered,pilloried, sleazed on a daily basis.

But here’s the good thing. The majority and counting of Scots know what’s going on, and more and more are getting genuinely angry.

The media are actually falling to pieces. Remember the outrage of the Unionists in George square. They weren’t the majority but acted like it. Scotland will judge the media at the ballot box. They are finished.

The really scary thing is that Cameron’s narrative about taking the shine off the SNP. Is being mirrored by the press. This is the millionaire Tory paper owners calling the shots. No doubt more peerages have been promised. There are no Scots writing the headlines for the Herald or Scotsman. This is fleet street dictat.

heedtracker

This is nice and say, around strength 6/10 on the Cardham Bullshit scale. Rancid Graun reportage on Daily Telegraph liars going after JC, for shame!

link to theguardian.com

But same creepshow totally ignored/not reporting anything at all over Daily Telegraph liars, IPSO ruling and their great UKOK Carmichael memogate fraud on Scotland.

link to wingsoverscotland.com

“Press regulator Ipso orders paper to run prominent correction after it ‘distorted’ comments made by a prominent Labour MP in a front-page story”

Good luck with that IPSO, run by charming toryboy at the Telegraph.

link to wingsoverscotland.com

Sandy Miller

collective name I would us “The Vichy Scots”

Bill Dale

How about Media Imperialists ‘n’ Corporate Establishment, MINCE for short. (Steak mince of course, no pork here please)!

Wuffing Dug

STV Shitehoose Tele Vision

BBC British Bluster Calamity

ITV Insidious Trash Vanity

liz

They don’t pretend any more because we can always call them out on social media and they know it.

They are relying on those who don’t use social media.

There will be some out there who believe every word about MT, and they might be right, but there is no case yet.

However there might be enough who realise this is completely OTT,

Fireproofjim

Rock
Your anti-National obsession is getting boring. We did that yesterday.
Buying the National does NOT subsidise the Herald.
They are two separate papers and profit centres in a stable of over two hundred papers owned by an American group.
If the Herald makes money it survives. If the National makes money it survives.
If everybody followed your advice the National would fold. There would be no Independence supporting paper, but it seems that is what you want. God knows why!

Lesley-Anne

Completely off topic and about 1,000 miles from where we are at present. 😉

Here is a wee video of a certain Vladimir Putin, no I have no idea who is either 😉 , giving a BBC “correspondent” a right royal smackdown. 😀

link to youtube.com

link to youtube.com

Luigi

neil bruce says:
6 October, 2015 at 7:02 pm

A far as I am concerned, septic tanks covers both
politicians and media.

For both content and rhyming slang.

The septics are tanking. 🙂

frogesque

If my dear old mum were still with us she would use the collective term ‘ Penny Dreadfuls ‘ to describe the Rag, Tag and Bobtail of the comentartie.

yesindyref2

Anyway, I quickly had a look to get back in the swing of it, though lat time I spent hours instead of minutes. Some interesting links to do with DEL and EYF are:

link to theyworkforyou.com

link to gov.scot

link to publications.parliament.uk

Stu Magoo

BritCunts?

Tinto Chiel

“They are not even trying to appear unbiased now. Straight in with the lies and a daily assault on the Scottish government. By default they are assaulting the Scottish electorate.”

Yes, Big Jock, but this is a marathon, not a sprint, and the law of diminishing returns will also take its toll on The Establishment.

The general hysteria of the Press/BBC/STV causes more and more people to switch off and this level of monstering is unsustainable over a seven month period, without further alienating Scottish voters.

I think your optimism is justified and I wouldn’t be too worried about Call Me Dave. He has a limited shelf-life, like pulled pork. Boris and Gideon are waiting in the wings.

David McDowell

Big Jock at 7:44pm
“By default they are assaulting the Scottish electorate.”

This is the real problem Jock. These media ("Tractor" - Ed)s are subverting the democratic will of the Scottish people.
The Scottish Government are sitting back allowing this to happen. They have a duty to defend our democracy from those who subvert and undermine it.

Dr Jim

I don’t know why we bother voting a Government in to work and run the country for us when the Media seems to want the job so much more

Maybe the First Minister should just relinquish all power to the BBC the Herald and the Guardian and take herself off for a nice wee holiday Scotland will be in safe hands I’m sure

I’m heartily sick and tired of all this unremitting Unionist lying constant stream of shit, I did hope that maybe STV would stay only mildly biased but no, it seems the game is up they’ve pulled their mask off and joined in

Well hell mend them it just means they go on the list and that’s unfortunate once the bodies start piling up when they lose and lose they will, so far I have not heard one adverse comment about Ms Thomson everybody seems more determined than ever to increase the SNP vote because they know this is all Bullshit

The Media’s greatest success in Scotland will be, to have elected, by the biggest majority in living history an SNP Government which will lead us to Independence in record time

So for that,….. Media I thank you

yesindyref2

It’s all coming back to me now. There is one unfairess for Scotland in this. If Scotland has an EYF of £1 billion at the Treasury, it earns not one single penny interest on this to give extra spending.

If on the other hand it had its own bank account rather than not drawing down the case from the Treasury and thre was on interest on that, the amoung available to dwar down would drpo by the same amount. In other words, it would have by prudent savings and timings, not one single penny for extra spending.

Just another note before I bore myself to sleep. In 2007 the SNP accused the Labour / LibDem of having an “election fund of £1 billion”, in other words they could make promises to the electorate of spending £1 billion on goodies. Of course, the same EYF was available to the SNP.

In 2016 the Labour will be accusing the SNP of having an “election fund of £347 million”, in other words they can make promises to the electorate backed by that £347 million. Of course, the same EYF is available to the Labour party.

Ain’t politics fun!

Xaracen

Feral Banshees!

Because all of them are wild harbingers of doom and misery.

cynicalHighlander

Gutter dredgers.

yesindyref2

Good grief, that’ll teach me to trypo in near darkness.

Jimbo

“Incidentally that Herald article shows just how far the Herald has declined in its pursuit of a fair deal for Scotland”

The Herald has been lying on behalf of the Westminster establishment for two hundred years, ever since the days of those earlier Scots who sought independence – the Radicals

David McDowell

Dr Jim at 8:21pm

“everybody seems more determined than ever to increase the SNP vote because they know this is all Bullshit”

I think at last someone has put their finger on it.

The only thing that will ever stop these media attack dogs is the public showing them at the ballot box their lies are well and truly rumbled.

That is the only thing that can take this propaganda “big stick” away from them.

There are signs many more people are starting to see this.
The general election in Scotland is the best local example but people in Greece and Catalonia have also recently shown they will not be cowed by scare stories and propaganda.

NiallD

Another excellent piece of debunkment( if that’s a word) by the Rev. MSM mouth frothing shown for what it really is….complete SNP bad twaddle.
However an excellent piece by Dr Dalzell showing the Scottish Government to be fiscally responsible and the reason so many people vote SNP/support independence. Competence!

Big Jock

Remember in the Matrix when they said, we will show you how deep this wormhole goes! McWhirter,McKenna,Hassan…that’s how deep it goes.

Tinto Chiel

Yes, Jimbo, since the time of Thomas Muir.

Same old, same old, as you say.

But the referendum was the triumph of experience over hope: by their fruits shall they know them, etc. No-one’s fooled by The Herald any more, I think.

Robert Peffers

Robert Peffers says:

6 October, 2015 at 8:41 pm

Don’t ask me how but this ended on the wrong topic. Here it is again

We have been using the correct collective term for the whole boorach o thaim, “The Establishment”, for a long time. They have been ever present even before the printing press was invented.

It encompasses the royals, Aristocracy, government, the media, armed & security services, the established church, the legal system, the police, the civil service and the Education System.

paul gerard mccormack

The penny has just dropped for me as to why I can never ever understand what Kezia Dugdale is saying. This happened when I saw a transcript of her talking.

How she talks is that she says the same thing 5 times, except in different ways and in different word order. I used to be listening out for the development of an idea, but no, she doesn’t lead on and develop from her first sentence, all she does is go round and round as fast as she can.

pure nightmare.

galamcennalath

@paul gerard mccormack

It’s not an uncommon fault. Nothing much to say, but feels obliged to make a noise. Not a good trait in a politician, though!

scotspine

@ Robert, As an employee in one of those “Boorach” of Establishment organisations and someone who voted YES, how do you square that circle?

David McDowell

You’ve got to believe the day will come when most people rumble the media’s big scary “Wizard of Oz” face for what it is – a load of sad old gits hiding behind a curtain typing on laptops.

More and more people are realising they are being duped.

Nana Smith

off topic for a moment

The Uk’s sorry excuse for a prime minister being interviewed by Jon Snow.

link to twitter.com

Robert Peffers

@Bob Mack says: 6 October, 2015 at 7:37 pm:

“Therè already is a word——-Establishment. They are all part and parcel of the same thing.”

Got it in one, Bob Mack. I’ve been calling them that for decades. Ever since I realise they were all in it together throughout British history.

Want the perfect example? On the run up to the Treaty of Union the Establishment’s undercover man in Scotland was none other than Daniel Defoe. He had been recruited by the Establishment long before and had published loads of political pamphlets for the English Parliament parties.

link to en.wikipedia.org

Tackety Beets

Angus Anderson @ 3.20pm

I suspect that the record of SALES being only 2

1) Wrights purchase from council @ £21K

2) MFPS arrange a sale to 3rd party @ £75K ( this may or probably was a Co already known to Frank or Michelle and the worst case senario would be if MT was actually connected in any way with said 3rd party purchasing Co.)

The 2nd Sale is recorded as the same day the Wrights got their money . MFPS get a kick-back of £75-51K = £24K from either the Wrights ? or more probable the 3rd party.

The other possibility is that as MFPS arranged the deal for the Wrights(after all Mrs Wright admits to contacting MFPS with the view of concluding a quickish sale) MFPS handled the transaction and MFPS cut of £24K is taken Off the £71K as costs ,before the Wrights get their £51K less the 30K that also legally has to be paid to clear Wrights Mortgage.

Anyway as per my previous posts & my limited dealings on property ,in a certain way, I have done MUCH WORSE

I wonder Rev , did it take a lot of effort to uncover the FACTS ?

Strikes me the MSM are a total waste of space and cant be ar$ed investigating or reporting the truth , too much effort required perhaps ?

Douglas gourlay

Collective term! Wankers? Far too easy 🙂 what’s my prize?

Sadly the fun of calling the msm and establishment politicians wankers as a collective term is only a short little giggle. The reality is that the journalists (?) that write this stuff need to be challenged and held to account for what they write. They put their names to the words. Is there no journalistic overseer or ombudsman to raise a complaint to? No right of reply that demands a justification in what they write? Or is their right to freedom of speech untouchable?

handclapping

Of course the likes of Gardham are desperate to bring the SNP down. They got their reputation because they knew where the SLAB plumbing leaked, but in 2007 that, and SLAB, became irrelevant. SLAB wasn’t the Government anymore and they had no contacts in the SNP. If you were getting the lowdown from Labour you weren’t allowed to talk to the Nose Pickers.

Now they are loosing their reputation because they’ve nothing to say and Stu is picking apart the pish they are spouting their jackets are on the shoogly peg unless Labour get in again or are the leaders in a coalition. I doubt any of them have managed to make contacts with the Torys so when it comes to their editors comparing the progress at the National with their declines, guess who is sitting on the trap-door with mortgages / alimony / schools to pay for.

macnakamura

“media and Unionist politicians
(we really need to come up with a word to describe that single entity)”
=========
MUPpets ?
MUPpests ?

De Valera

Please don’t think of this as incompetent journalism. Just as we are detrrmined to see independence, they are are equally determined to thwart it.

In our medias’ eyes, they are fighting for their survival and they will fight as dirty as they see fit.

The establishment thought our movement would die after September 2014, the opposite has happened. What we are seeing is the tip of the iceberg.

Tinto Chiel

“Want the perfect example? On the run up to the Treaty of Union the Establishment’s undercover man in Scotland was none other than Daniel Defoe. He had been recruited by the Establishment long before and had published loads of political pamphlets for the English Parliament parties.”

Just so, Robert Peffers. And if anyone wants a reliable account of the Darien Project, see “The Darien Disaster” by Francis Russell Hart.

Not quite the Ian Hyslop pack of lies that he trots out on HIGNFY and PE.

“He who controls the past, controls the future” and all that.

Grouse Beater

Peffers: “On the run up to the Treaty of Union the Establishment’s undercover man in Scotland was none other than Daniel Defoe.”

His “History of the Union” published 1786 is about to come up at auction. I’ll be bidding. 🙂

Tackety Beets

Sorry folks , last post @ 9.14pm is on wrong thread should have been previous one.

Doh !

Robert Peffers

@Luigi says: 6 October, 2015 at 8:03 pm:

“A far as I am concerned, septic tanks covers both
politicians and media.

For both content and rhyming slang.

The septics are tanking. “

Nah! While they may often be full of pish shite and slops the Septic Tank, serves a very necessary and useful function.

Not only that but it actually neutralises the disgusting contents into something much more acceptable. Whatever would country dwellers do without them?

The Establishment works in a similar manner – but in reverse. It takes the more acceptable stuff and makes it disgusting.

scribblerdubious

the term for “that single entity”:

the boorach

Lesley-Anne

Just a wee heads up to who are on the panel for Question Time on Thursday night.

Pritti Patel
Lisa Nandy
Tim Farron
Melanie Phillips

Oh and someone called Stewart Hosie.

No I haven’t a clue who he is but he may be able to keep the five Tory party members in check though. 😀

Early Ball

Lisa Nandy is Labour and she made a great speech in the Trident debate a few months ago.

EphemeralDeception

I like the term MUPpets but I think Demersal (bottom feeders) is a more accurate term.

Grouse Beater

Lesley-Anne: I haven’t a clue who he is but he may be able to keep the five Tory party members in check.

And the obvious planted question?

“Does the panel think it ethical a politician should own a property company that exploits values?” or some such construct.

Robert Peffers

@David McDowell says: 6 October, 2015 at 8:19 pm:

” … The Scottish Government are sitting back allowing this to happen. They have a duty to defend our democracy from those who subvert and undermine it.”

So, David, that’ll be why support for the SNP has been creeping up inexorably over the last few years and that of the Unionist Establishment has declined exponentially, will it?

Why on earth do you think the SG should lower themselves and, with an aim of beating them, join them in the conduct that is slowly pushing more and more of the people of Scotland towards independence?

Never change a winning formula, as long as it is working, and never interrupt your opponent when they are making errors.

Kenny

Looking at the picture of the Herald front page at the start of this article and the list of most popular stories, I cannot help thinking that it would be much easier (and much cheaper!) for the Herald to just print SNP BAD in large block capitals, filling the entire page.

Then, having understood the whole content, people would be able to get on with the rest of their daily lives much quicker.

I cannot understand why a paper would want to engage on a permanent 24/7 SNP-Bad-Fest. Everyone who wanted to has already voted No. The 45 are not going back in the box and it is months and months, I believe, since the polls showed support for independence as low as 45 anyway. The No press are rather like King Canute.

Gary45%

Collective term, Plamphers.
Look up the meaning Plamph.I think it works well

Wired of Hermiston

“Meanionists”, surely?

Cadogan Enright

I was on the point of wondering if Greens in Scotland were worth supporting again until after independence given some of the daft nonsense we saw in Westmonster. I had campaigned for them going back to 2007, and helped a green-led campaign in the Highlands in the referendum. But last time for WM I went SNP.

Craig Dalzell gives me hope link to thecommongreen.wordpress.com

Lesley-Anne

Well who saw this coming down the track? 😉

S******* 2015 STILL going with the Michelle Thompson thingy.

It looks like Bob Sinclair over on Twitter has had enough and is looking to reverse the tide.

@BBCScot2015 @0604Arb1320 do you REALLY want us to start looking at the property deals of Tories, Labour & Lib Dem MP’s?

Methinks we may be in for some interesting times ahead, and not just from Bob’s search for anyone who is unhappy with their house sale to a Tory,Labour or Lib Dem politician. 😀

Robert Peffers

@scotspine says: 6 October, 2015 at 9:03 pm

” … @ Robert, As an employee in one of those “Boorach” of Establishment organisations and someone who voted YES, how do you square that circle?”

first of all a, “boorach”, is defined as, A group, a heap or a pile. It is a collective so not, “one of those”.

In the second place It was a chance to receive the very best training there was and often the best way to fight a boorach is indeed from the inside.

Wasn’t the guy who originated the BOE, William Paterson, a London Scot and who afterwards was in Scotland beginning the Darien Expedition and thus fighting against Scotland from the inside?

Lesley-Anne

I think that goes without saying GB. Yet another excellent example of BBC bias!

heedtracker

The No press are rather like King Canute.

King Canute actually sat in front of the rising to show ye olde royalists that he wasn’t able to hold it back.

UK is owned by the super rich and they own all UK media including the BBC. So socio economic change in their Scotland region may have shock waves across the borders. And that’s why they are savaging the living shit out of Scottish democracy.

” Saudi prince al-Waleed bin Talal has refitted his Savoy, to the dismay of old-school visitors; and this summer the Barclay brothers sold their stake in Claridge’s, the Berkeley and the Connaught to a business controlled by Qatari sovereign funds, after the Abu Dhabi Investment Authority had reportedly offered £1.6bn.”

Lord Foulkes of Cumnock Labour
My Lords, what action are the Government taking to stop the use of tax havens such as the Channel Islands and Monaco for tax-dodging, which results in the rest of us having to pay higher taxes? Would he care to speculate on why a loyal newspaper such as the Daily Telegraph fails to publicise unpatriotic tax-dodgers such as the Barclay brothers?

The Queen is worth near $100 billion, Sir Ian Wood’s made enough money from not Scots oil, he can probably take it with him etc etc.

Liggers like Cardham or Torygraph comical Cockers. are merely protecting their bosses and their offshore stash.

There is some trickle down though,

link to cityam.com

Its a long non HS2 way from Cambuslang.

Nana Smith

@Lesley-Anne seems the constant barrage of crap is having an effect on folk right enough

link to xbasslichtie.blogspot.co.uk

Lesley-Anne

Don’t you just love it Nana when yet ANOTHER unionist ploy … erm … FAILS! 😀

Nana Smith

@Lesley-Anne

Yep! Give em enough rope and all that hahahaha….

Big Jock

I think Baillie is already in hot water. She is making accusations as an Msp during a live investigation. I hope the lawyers are still up.

Robert Peffers

@Grouse Beater says: 6 October, 2015 at 9:37 pm:

“Peffers: “On the run up to the Treaty of Union the Establishment’s undercover man in Scotland was none other than Daniel Defoe.”

His “History of the Union” published 1786 is about to come up at auction. I’ll be bidding.

I would imagine it will cost a great deal more than a Pretty Penny, but I may be putting too much importance upon it.

As the real history of his part in the affair is mostly air brushed out of the history most people are taught, it may not seem as important to non-history buffs.

neil bruce

Robert Peffers @ 9.42pm

Actually the first two paragraphs were from me, and the
riposte was from Luigi. Thanks for that Luigi, good one.

I agree Robert, I never thought through the usefulness
of a septic tank, and I should have as I have worked on
them.

However I

Robert Peffers

@Lesley-Anne says: 6 October, 2015 at 9:47 pm:

“Oh and someone called Stewart Hosie.

No I haven’t a clue who he is but he may be able to keep the five Tory party members in check though.

Ah! Lesley-Anne, I heard the rest of the panel were complaining to the BEEB that the though the BBC had stacked against them.

Lesley-Anne

I’m really seriously concerned that we do not have enough rope held in stock in S******* to do the job in one go Nana. We may have to let them hang themselves over a series of days. 😀

Oh PLEASE BJ.

So far I’ve read today that the Labour deputy of the branch office has his coat hanging on an extremely shoogly peg concerning a possible law suit!

Now we have rentahonk putting herself up for a possible lawsuit.

I wonder who is next, oh that’s right probably BBC,STV and meejia! 😀

Lesley-Anne

Aye well I’d expect nothing less rom that bunch of LOSERS Robert.

I can’t wait to see how far Stewart gets before the inevitable constant interruptions start up from the Tory Defence League Chairman!

Big Jock

Well Baillie’s exact words were: ” We know solicitors take advice from their client’s.” This is libelous. The solicitor is under legal investigation for sharp practices. However Jackie is advising she was acting on the say of her client Michelle Thomson.

The libel is in in the implication that Michelle authorised illegal practices through a solicitor. In other words they both knew it was illegal. But the facts are that Michelle is not under legal investigation but the solicitor is. Michelle has not done anything illegal as far as the police are concerned or she would be investigated right now.

Jackie has her as guilty by association. We don’t even know yet if the solicitor has been found guilty never mind Michelle.
Call it what you want defamation,libel slander its all there. I expect Jackie to be silenced shortly once she gets a call from SLABs lawyer.

Gavin

MUnions or just plain minions!

Robert Peffers

@neil bruce says: 6 October, 2015 at 11:02 pm:

“Actually the first two paragraphs were from me, and the
riposte was from Luigi. Thanks for that Luigi, good one.

I agree Robert, I never thought through the usefulness
of a septic tank, and I should have as I have worked on
them.

I think my mind works a wee bit different from most. Comes for years of diagnosing complex electro/mechanical systems.

We had two kinds of people who diagnosed such things. One would immediately start doing complex tests on intricate circuits and get out the complex test gear.

Only when they had everything rigged up and went to power up the gear did they discover the mains fuse had blown.

It often pays to look at things from the alternative viewpoint.

Valerie

Yup, agree with Big Jock.

Baillie behaviour abhorrent, despite James Dorman being clear, and trying to warn her.

I hope she gets her arse kicked for that performance.

I’m starting to get really angry now. Also stated a Tory has contacted the Standards Commission.

I think the only small consolation is that I’m sure they were all warned big time what to expect, in terms of muck raking, and fabrication.

Big Jock

A can of worms was duly opened tonight. Proverbial shit to hit fan.

There’s a reason why SlAB are now falling behind the Tories. They really are as stupid as everyone suspected.

Incidentally what happened to the new Kezia positive vision? Is this charade part of it.

Glass houses and all that.

Kevin Evans

My suggestion for a media/unionist sounds like hunt and starts with a C.

Alan

Meduksa or something that riffs on Medusa.

“a monster, a Gorgon, generally described as having the face of a hideous human female with living venomous snakes in place of hair. Gazing directly into her eyes would turn onlookers to stone.”

Maybe you should change your moniker from Rev to Perseus.

Michael McCabe

My Name for the press and the media is. The Plague.

Dorothy Devine

Perfect Michael! I can see the pustules every time I look at their articles.

OT I have just watched a wee documentary on RT about stateside whistleblowers – quite alarming.

Hamish Douglas

How about the Unionedia?

Grouse Beater

Peffers: As the real history of his part in the affair is mostly air brushed

From what I’ve manage to glean from books and pamphlets of the day, the arguments for Scotland to be the battered wee brother of England remain exactly the same, including that we would all become ‘foreigners’ if independent. Defoe’s warped version of history should confirm that ugly bias.

Davy

I’m a bit confused ? why was BBC Scotland last night saying the top legal guy for Scotland was going to enlarge the inquiry into that dirty lawyer and “other peoples” roles.

Yet on their teletext (Scotland section) they were saying the top legal guy has said their was no need for any further inquiry.

Did someone not get the memo ?

Tom Platt

The explanation that Rev Stu seeks is surely clear. The author name “Gardham” is a nom-de-plume derived from “guard them” or, as we often say in Staffordshire, “guard ’em”. It is adopted by all those who are determined to guard and otherwise be gatekeepers for the Westminster Establishment. These guarding duties involve rubbishing any threat to Westminster, like Scottish Government and involve frequent use of the chant “SNPbad, SNPbad, SNPbad!”

Cuilean

Excellent expose of Glasgow Herald’s ‘wilful blindness’ to facts.

It is for that simple reason that myself and thousands upon thousands of fellow intelligent newspaper readers are losing the newspaper habit.

I for one would never buy a lying (ie Unionist) newspaper ever again.

Jack Murphy

BBC Question Time.Lesley-Anne said at 9:47 pm. 6th October:-
“Just a wee heads up to who are on the panel for Question Time on Thursday night.
Pritti Patel
Lisa Nandy
Tim Farron
Melanie Phillips”

As a political novice I haven’t a clue who they are except for this person,Melanie Phillips,a journalist:-“The Scots really hate the English”,interviewed on American TV. 🙁

YouTube FILM:- link to tinyurl.com

[…] The media and Unionist politicians (we really need to come up with a word to describe that single entity), when not concocting hysterical frothing diatribes against Michelle Thomson or complaining about the Scottish Government giving money to T In The Park – a position we must confess we find ourselves in some sympathy with – have recently been loudly protesting about last year’s “underspend” in the Holyrood budget.  […]

Rock

Fireproofjim,

“Buying the National does NOT subsidise the Herald.”

Yes, it does. Fool yourself if you like. Some of us are less gullible.

Why does it not publish proper investigative articles like the Rev. Stuart does?

Why hasn’t he been invited to write a regular column?

Big Dave

Unionists will be Unionists but our mainstream media’s level of bias is unparalleled out with dictatorships. A collective term would be LUM (Liars Unionists Media) although did chuckle at the MUNTS suggestion.

iclare

The media and Unionist politicians (we really need to come up with a word to describe that single entity)

”BubbleBrits” ?


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a (mainly) Scottish political media digest and monitor, which also offers its own commentary. (More)

    Stats: 6,670 Posts, 1,202,767 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • James on The Long Unravelling: “And what? The English Parliament will serve us any better? Just asking, like.Nov 21, 13:21
    • James on The Long Unravelling: “Aye, willie, times are hard, everything’s going up in price and in wades the Scottish Government to help everyone out…Nov 21, 13:15
    • James on The Long Unravelling: “Ah, but the *Great Producer of Spittle’s Daily Heil says different. [*The smart-arsed half-educated sophistry merchant]Nov 21, 13:11
    • James on The Long Unravelling: ““12 UK Shadow Storm missiles launched by U into R. Each missile costs £767k. £9ml for one day of firing…Nov 21, 13:08
    • Mark Beggan on The Long Unravelling: “Wouldn’t it be nice to blame the Scottish for shiting in their own kennel once and awhile.Nov 21, 13:06
    • Campbell Clansman on The Long Unravelling: “Reminder: Swinney has been in SNP leadership roles the last 25 years, including the Salmond years. He LED the SNP…Nov 21, 13:02
    • James on The Long Unravelling: ““…Slava Johnny…” LOLNov 21, 12:41
    • TURABDIN on The Long Unravelling: “Roll up! Roll up! Choose your «nationalism»… https://archive.is/53H02 but make it one Nato can use…..mr Swinney & coNov 21, 12:40
    • Alan Austin on The Long Unravelling: “Unfortunately promoted well above his abilities. Even worse he is the best the SNP have. Not sure any of the…Nov 21, 12:28
    • Robert Hughes on The Long Unravelling: “You . What fckn difference will your preference for one side make ? Zero . What get’s me is people…Nov 21, 12:24
    • Dan on The Long Unravelling: ““…the genie is out the bottle, so yes, you need to pick a side. Or, do you have an alternative?”…Nov 21, 11:50
    • Shug on The Long Unravelling: “So is swinney a plant or promoted above his abilitiesNov 21, 11:46
    • robertkknight on The Long Unravelling: ““Is that what you think this is about , eg ” supporting ” XY or Z” That’s exactly what it’s…Nov 21, 11:09
    • Hatey McHateface on The Long Unravelling: ““where a country has its territorial integrity invaded by a foreign power, that has to be repelled… I support the…Nov 21, 11:07
    • Alan Austin on The Long Unravelling: “As a unionist and someone who voted against having a devolved parliament I am afraid all my fears have come…Nov 21, 11:02
    • Hatey McHateface on The Long Unravelling: “I think most readers will understand that anybody genuinely anticipating “Catastrophic Nuclear War” won’t be wasting precious time pontificating on…Nov 21, 10:56
    • Dick Wall on The Long Unravelling: “As humans we are little different from any others. What makes us different is our institutions. How we go about…Nov 21, 10:40
    • Aidan on The Long Unravelling: “The report does not use the word “conditional” anywhere and certainly does not describe the ability of the U.K. Parliament…Nov 21, 10:38
    • TURABDIN on The Long Unravelling: “Nobody is more dangerous than he who imagines himself pure in heart; for his purity, by definition, is unassailable. James…Nov 21, 10:11
    • boyce on The Long Unravelling: “Alex Salmond passed a powerful and successful organisation to Nicola, who then immediately drowned it in a cesspit. She’s now…Nov 21, 09:54
    • boyce on The Long Unravelling: “You’d think with John Swinney would be able to control the finances wouldn’t you?Nov 21, 09:50
    • gregor on The Long Unravelling: “Yup: #WEFButtPlugsRUs #ScotlandLastNov 21, 09:33
    • boyce on The Way Forward: “You omit the reasons though. The SNP lies about Alba, its demand for both votes and the national media’s exclusion…Nov 21, 09:20
    • boyce on The Way Forward: “I stopped voting SNP because the SNP promised the world and then, like Labour, settled into power in Holyrood and…Nov 21, 09:15
    • Colin Alexander on The Long Unravelling: ““MSP ‘disturbed’ over Milngavie schools participation in ‘LGBT project'” “AN MSP says she was “deeply disturbed” to find out two…Nov 21, 09:00
    • Robert Hughes on The Long Unravelling: “He’s just following orders from his superiors : like the rest of ” them “Nov 21, 08:49
    • Breeks on The Long Unravelling: ““… is difficult to sustain in the face of the evidence as to what Parliament has done without objection and…Nov 21, 08:30
    • Robert Hughes on The Long Unravelling: “And all the Reality-denying idiots are out still refusing to accept we stand on the very brink of absolute devastation…Nov 21, 08:17
    • gregor on The Long Unravelling: “re. “Swinney The Muppet” LBC: NEW: Scotland’s FM John Swinney backs US measures to allow U***ine to use long-range missiles…Nov 21, 08:15
    • gregor on The Long Unravelling: “The National: Exclusive: Fears for nuclear ‘target’ Trident amid escalation tension with Ru****: “Hosting nuclear submarines in the Clyde isn’t…Nov 21, 08:12
  • A tall tale



↑ Top
114
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x