“In the fall of 2009, I found myself in Korea with a collection of suit–and-tie-wearing hotshots. On a panel sat Takatoshi Kato, then the deputy managing director of a powerful institution. Before the panel discussion, he gave us a rapid PowerPoint presentation showing his and his department’s economic projections for 2010, 201, 2012, 2013, and 2014.
“… Listening to Kato’s presentation, I could not control myself and flew into a rage in front of two thousand Koreans – I was so angry that I almost started shouting in French, forgetting that I was in Korea. I ran to the podium and told the audience that the next time someone in a suit and tie gave them projections for some dates in the future, they should ask him to show what he had projected in the past – in this case, what he had been forecasting for 2008 and 2009 (the crisis years) two to five years earlier, in 2004, 2005, 2006, and 2007. They would then verify that Highly Venerable Kato-san and his colleagues are, to put it mildly, not very good at this predictionizing business. And it is not just Mr. Kato: our track record in figuring out significant rare events in politics and economics is not close to zero: it is zero.”
Nassim Nicholas Taleb, Antifragile, p. 134, emphasis added.
why does the Treasury have an Office for Budgie Responsibility? If it keels over do we know the UK’s fucked?
It’s a bit like the ravens at the Tower of London (if they fly away, the crown falls and Britain with it). If the budgie flies up the leg of Aunty Mary’s drawers, Scotland will become independent. So they keep a close eye on it.
O/T I have only just seen this, which begs the question, ‘why do these things not circulate effectively?’
if you have not seen it, the 900 or so comments really lift the spirit.
Change
Not sure their methodology is as sophisticated as a crystal ball.
More like wetting the finger and holding up. When I was a researcher for the Central Research Unit of the old Scottish Office, the Treasury generally deemed a project’s budget to have been acceptable if it was within plus or minus 50% of forecast. I’m not sure if this is still the standard.
P.S. Can the BoE tell us what the exchange rate for sterling will be, against a basket of currencies, at the end of the month?
A good friend of mine works at the Bank of Finland. He’s got a Master’s degree in economics, he’s a smart guy, and great fun, but he will not understand (or admit) the fact that economic predictions are mostly informed guesses. They can theorisize a lot after the fact but their predictions have a fatal flaw: they assume people behave in a rational manner.
People do not behave in a rational manner (as amply demonstrated by the NO Better Together campaign).
Ask almost any flat/house buyer. The home they bought was the one (within their price range) they fell in love with. They’re not giving much thought to resale value etc. They just want that particular home, and often pay a bit more than they thought they could afford.
People buy all kinds of unnecessary junk just because it’s “nice to have them”, or even because “it’s nice to buy”. That’s not very rational, is it?
About 15 years ago my brother was thinking of setting up an online grocery shop in Lissabon (he lived there at the time) and I told him, it’s no go. Nobody would buy tomatoes without seeing and feeling them first. He and his business partner went on regardless, and the venture didn’t last long. They’d thought it maked perfect rational sense but forgot the irrational human behaviour.
So I take any economic predictions with a pinch of salt, and politically motivated predictions, like the OBR’s, with the whole salt cellar. OBR has been so wrong about oil&gas, I’d rather take the projections of the people who actually work in the industry. Their projections are wildly different from OBR’s. They just don’t get headlined or even reported in the Scottish MSM. McCrone, anyone?
Comment - please read this page for comment rules. HTML tags like <i> and <b> are permitted. Use paragraph breaks in long comments. DO NOT SIGN YOUR COMMENTS, either with a name or a slogan. If your comment does not appear immediately, DO NOT REPOST IT. Ignore these rules and I WILL KILL YOU WITH HAMMERS.
Bob on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “I love the 12 mugshots: but what would Jon Snow say? (or, for that matter, Humza Yousef?)” Jun 13, 20:11
agent x on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “Sarah – have you read this response to the petition? https://www.parliament.scot/-/media/files/committees/citizen-participation-and-public-petitions-committee/correspondence/2024/pe2135/pe2135_c.pdf PE2135/C: Implement the International Covenant on Civil and Political…” Jun 13, 20:03
agent x on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: ““On the 17th June, a conference at the Assembly Rooms in Edinburgh will ponder the challenges and issues that will…” Jun 13, 19:52
sarah on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: ““What can ordinary independentistas do?” Talk to friends and family about Liberate Scotland so their candidates will receive votes in…” Jun 13, 19:42
James on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “Lol….good post, Breastplate. The yoons ate ramping it up on here, new ‘names’ by the day amongst the same old…” Jun 13, 19:23
James on The Grand Tour: “Agreed, aLurker. Northcode’s excellent points were proven almost immediately by five posts from the usual Yoon suspects. The arrogance of…” Jun 13, 18:55
Ian McCubbin on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “Deals for the favoured in SNP, the top grifters. It’s a disgrace. But what can ordinary independendistas do? Voting is…” Jun 13, 18:38
wullie on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “An occupying foreign power could not do a better job of destroying the country and looting its resources. In my…” Jun 13, 18:19
Effijy on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “Rebrand as the New SNP. Your independence party gearing up for the next millennium. The Westminster parties, Tory, Labour and…” Jun 13, 18:17
ScottieDog on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “They’re on course for a win next year, why would they change anything. More gravy. Some of them might even…” Jun 13, 17:52
twathater on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “I notice at any mention of SALVO or Liberate Scotland the FRANCHISE fanny and his fellow YOONS,Aiden,private clansman aka corporal…” Jun 13, 17:47
sarah on The Grand Tour: “I agree, Mary – the whole independence movement should get behind the two prongs of Liberate Scotland for the 2026…” Jun 13, 17:17
aLurker on Off-topic: “Hi folks. I am mostly a lurker, hence the moniker. But I was prompted to respond by Northcodes post today:…” Jun 13, 17:11
robertkknight on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “To all those SNP faithful/sheep out there, a quote from Johnny Rotten… “Ha ha ha… Ever get the feeling you’ve…” Jun 13, 16:59
Hatey McHateface on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “Wearing a baseball cap is a clear sign you’re adopting the colonialist mindset of the oppressor. Fits wrang wi a…” Jun 13, 16:55
Hatey McHateface on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “Could it be the UN have other things on their mind? Serious things? Important things? Matters of life and death…” Jun 13, 16:50
Hatey McHateface on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “Bad day for you is it BP? I’ve noticed you’ve resorted to playing solitary buzzword bingo. Or as our host…” Jun 13, 16:48
factchecker on The Grand Tour: “James says ‘There are some very interesting figures within Scotland’s ‘deficit’, for example: the figure of £9.1bn under the name…” Jun 13, 16:44
Onlooker on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “What the fuck does the weirdo Cherie Blair have to do with anything? is she going to have a rebirthing…” Jun 13, 16:40
Young Lochinvar on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “Dull as dishwater. At least Broontosaurus isn’t attending- perhaps they are having difficulty with his defrost setting in time for…” Jun 13, 16:38
Captain Caveman on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “So basically you couldn’t answer a single one of his points and resorted to weak insults. Standard. I suppose it…” Jun 13, 16:33
Andy Ellis on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “Isn’t a more likely explanation simply that Salvo isn’t in fact making much impact either in the popular consciousness of…” Jun 13, 16:32
Andy Ellis on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “If that was true – and I’m not at all sure there is a scintilla of evidence for it -…” Jun 13, 16:28
PhilM on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “Well I don’t have two brass farthings to rub together but if I did, I would be salivating at the…” Jun 13, 16:25
Peter McAvoy on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “They can start by keeping Alexander’s open and working.” Jun 13, 16:09
Breastplate on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “Shouda woulda, coulda. I’m sorry if this is confusing for you, it’s completely irrelevant to the point I made, then…” Jun 13, 15:53
MaryB on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “There certainly seems some desperation to avoid giving Salvo’s work any kind of publicity anywhere, especially as they are now…” Jun 13, 15:51
That and oil futures.
“Real Pea Souper in there.”
Have any of their forecasts been anywhere close to reality? Serious question as I have only ever seen their corrections Maybe I’ve missed something
Not sure their methodology is as sophisticated as a crystal ball.
That crystal ball should be replaced with a shite laden tombola.
Roll up! Roll up! Come & have a go on Gideon’s amazing shite filled tory tombola!!
“In the fall of 2009, I found myself in Korea with a collection of suit–and-tie-wearing hotshots. On a panel sat Takatoshi Kato, then the deputy managing director of a powerful institution. Before the panel discussion, he gave us a rapid PowerPoint presentation showing his and his department’s economic projections for 2010, 201, 2012, 2013, and 2014.
“… Listening to Kato’s presentation, I could not control myself and flew into a rage in front of two thousand Koreans – I was so angry that I almost started shouting in French, forgetting that I was in Korea. I ran to the podium and told the audience that the next time someone in a suit and tie gave them projections for some dates in the future, they should ask him to show what he had projected in the past – in this case, what he had been forecasting for 2008 and 2009 (the crisis years) two to five years earlier, in 2004, 2005, 2006, and 2007. They would then verify that Highly Venerable Kato-san and his colleagues are, to put it mildly, not very good at this predictionizing business. And it is not just Mr. Kato: our track record in figuring out significant rare events in politics and economics is not close to zero: it is zero.”
Nassim Nicholas Taleb, Antifragile, p. 134, emphasis added.
This fortune teller clearly doesn’t have the foresight of such esteemed members of society as Terry Kelly.
I know about canaries in coal mines but why does the Treasury have an Office for Budgie Responsibility? If it keels over do we know the UK’s fucked?
OBR
Old Bollocks Regurgitated.
why does the Treasury have an Office for Budgie Responsibility? If it keels over do we know the UK’s fucked?
It’s a bit like the ravens at the Tower of London (if they fly away, the crown falls and Britain with it). If the budgie flies up the leg of Aunty Mary’s drawers, Scotland will become independent. So they keep a close eye on it.
..O/T…..Mel Smith (Not the Nine Oclock News ), has just died of a heart attack
I think wee Geordie Osborne is underneath the table (standing up) kicking the wummin’s shins shouting “Wrong answer! That ball never fails for me!!”
O/T I have only just seen this, which begs the question, ‘why do these things not circulate effectively?’
if you have not seen it, the 900 or so comments really lift the spirit.
Change
Looking to the future, I wonder what slant the two Wallace TV shows planned for next year will take?
link to guardian.co.uk
@ HandandShrimp
Not sure their methodology is as sophisticated as a crystal ball.
More like wetting the finger and holding up. When I was a researcher for the Central Research Unit of the old Scottish Office, the Treasury generally deemed a project’s budget to have been acceptable if it was within plus or minus 50% of forecast. I’m not sure if this is still the standard.
P.S. Can the BoE tell us what the exchange rate for sterling will be, against a basket of currencies, at the end of the month?
A good friend of mine works at the Bank of Finland. He’s got a Master’s degree in economics, he’s a smart guy, and great fun, but he will not understand (or admit) the fact that economic predictions are mostly informed guesses. They can theorisize a lot after the fact but their predictions have a fatal flaw: they assume people behave in a rational manner.
People do not behave in a rational manner (as amply demonstrated by the NO Better Together campaign).
Ask almost any flat/house buyer. The home they bought was the one (within their price range) they fell in love with. They’re not giving much thought to resale value etc. They just want that particular home, and often pay a bit more than they thought they could afford.
People buy all kinds of unnecessary junk just because it’s “nice to have them”, or even because “it’s nice to buy”. That’s not very rational, is it?
About 15 years ago my brother was thinking of setting up an online grocery shop in Lissabon (he lived there at the time) and I told him, it’s no go. Nobody would buy tomatoes without seeing and feeling them first. He and his business partner went on regardless, and the venture didn’t last long. They’d thought it maked perfect rational sense but forgot the irrational human behaviour.
So I take any economic predictions with a pinch of salt, and politically motivated predictions, like the OBR’s, with the whole salt cellar. OBR has been so wrong about oil&gas, I’d rather take the projections of the people who actually work in the industry. Their projections are wildly different from OBR’s. They just don’t get headlined or even reported in the Scottish MSM. McCrone, anyone?