The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Scotland’s guilty Euro-secret

Posted on November 11, 2011 by

The current narrative of the opposition parties and media is focusing heavily on an independent Scotland's status in the European Union, and whether it would have to adopt the Euro or not. The Unionist camp is getting extremely agitated about the issue, which is slightly mystifying as it's not one which has ever featured highly on lists of Scottish voters' priorities whenever anyone's asked them.

There's probably a very simple reason for that: nobody really cares. UKIP gets next to no votes in Scotland, and the average Scot in the street, we suspect, doesn't actually give a monkey's about Scotland's Euro-status. That's not because they're insular or stupid, but because they realise it doesn't make a great deal of difference to anything.

Why? To see the answer to that, the most obvious thing to do is to look at some of the nations most easily comparable to Scotland, and that means a glance over the North Sea to our Scandinavian neighbours. Conveniently, between them the Scandinavians encompass all possible permutations of EU and Euro membership, and three of them are almost identical in size to Scotland (pop 5.2m), meaning we should be able to draw a few broad but useful parallels. So let's take a wee peek.

This is a quick and dirty comparison, so we're only going to look at a couple of basic indicators to keep things simple. The Gini coefficient is a measure of how equal or unequal a country's population is, ie how evenly its wealth is distributed (and therefore how happy the people tend to be). A low Gini score is a good thing, and the latest full world rankings can be found (in reverse order) here, so we'll put them the right way up and see who's top of the smile table.

Secondly, we'll compare GDP, by the Purchasing Power Parity method. This, very crudely speaking, is a means of adjusting raw GDP to take account of the cost of living in various countries so that the comparison is meaningful. So if a Belgian had a GDP of $50,000 a year compared to a Latvian's $25,000 but housing and bills and food and so on only cost half as much in Latvia, then both countries would have the same GDP when adjusted under PPP. (In our two-country example, $37,500.)

Still with me? Then let's check out some of an independent Scotland's peer states.

DENMARK: pop. 5.6m, in the EU, not in the Euro. Gini 3rd, GDP $36,000

NORWAY: pop. 5m, not in the EU, not in the Euro. Gini 4th, GDP $52,000

FINLAND: pop. 5.4m, in the EU, in the Euro. Gini 18th, GDP $35,000

And just for fun, the United Kingdom, of which Scotland is currently a component:

UK: pop. 65m, in the EU, not in the Euro. Gini 43rd GDP $35,000

Summary: Denmark, Norway and Finland are all far more equal countries than the UK, and have equal or higher GDP per capita. All three are plainly doing absolutely fine, whether they're in or out of the EU, and whether they're in or out of the Euro.

Conclusion: being in or out of the EU, and in or out of the Euro, makes very little detectable difference to anything at the end of the day. Whichever situation Scotland eventually ends up with, the sky isn't going to fall in.

Analysis: if the Unionist parties are counting on Europe as being the issue that will swing the referendum for them, they're probably in for an unpleasant surprise.

Comment - please read this page for comment rules. HTML tags like <i> and <b> are permitted. Use paragraph breaks in long comments. DO NOT SIGN YOUR COMMENTS, either with a name or a slogan. If your comment does not appear immediately, DO NOT REPOST IT. Ignore these rules and I WILL KILL YOU WITH HAMMERS.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,785 Posts, 1,221,653 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Northcode on Too Tight To Mention: “Something inspired me to write a wee poem. A hiv nae idea whit. Back door, front door, throu an open…Jul 8, 23:07
    • MaryB on Too Tight To Mention: “Re Craig Murray at the UN C24: If nothing else, it’s important for the rest of the world to know…Jul 8, 22:58
    • Aidan on Too Tight To Mention: ““Appear to have issued a D notice” ???? You really are off the reservation today aren’t you. Do you think…Jul 8, 22:10
    • James on Too Tight To Mention: ““This whole thing is going to be an absolute gift to the unionists” Says the unionist….Jul 8, 22:05
    • Northcode on Too Tight To Mention: “Craig says this… again just for good measure: “Be very very happy at the extent of international support for Scottish…Jul 8, 22:05
    • Alf Baird on Too Tight To Mention: ““This whole thing is going to be an absolute gift to the unionists” Actually our colonial rulers understandably don’t want…Jul 8, 21:49
    • Aidan on Too Tight To Mention: “Right, because whilst Scotland’s capital is more productive than Norway’s or Singapore, Scotland also has pockets of severe deprivation left…Jul 8, 21:39
    • Stuart on Too Tight To Mention: “Well Northcode that’s 52 minutes of my life I’m not going to get back… The upshot of it being no…Jul 8, 21:06
    • Chas on Too Tight To Mention: “Great stuff. At least I am not a twat.Jul 8, 20:52
    • Chas on Too Tight To Mention: “If Stu has any sense he won’t respond to your drivel. I suspect he has more sense than you. In…Jul 8, 20:47
    • Alf Baird on Too Tight To Mention: ““does Edinburgh not have one of the highest rates of GDP per capita anywhere in the world, higher than Tokyo…Jul 8, 20:41
    • Aidan on Too Tight To Mention: “@Xaracen – no, its thrown it out. Secondly, again you miss the point. The UN recognises the U.K. as a…Jul 8, 20:13
    • Young Lochinvar on Too Tight To Mention: “Easy Penisbreath. Stick your finger on the Atlantic side of the Panama Canal and you’re 9/10ths there.Jul 8, 19:52
    • Northcode on Too Tight To Mention: “On Craig Murray’s return from his ambassadorial mission to the United Nations in New York where he presented the case…Jul 8, 19:32
    • Xaracen on Too Tight To Mention: ““Right” Thank you, so, the C-24 hasn’t actually thrown out the Salvo Petition, it’s just shelved it until it becomes…Jul 8, 19:29
    • twathater on Too Tight To Mention: “Stuart you CLAIM to be an independence supporter yet you EAGERLY join with the yoonionists to try to demean and…Jul 8, 18:29
    • twathater on Too Tight To Mention: “YL try not to take much notice of Chas his comments usually consist of his sexual fixation with Prof Baird,…Jul 8, 18:14
    • Hatey McHateface on Too Tight To Mention: ““has ever presented anything positive” Ah, c’moan noo Alf. Why not ask one of the many perennial gurners about oor…Jul 8, 17:58
    • Hatey McHateface on Too Tight To Mention: “Your post above is a masterpiece, Chas. Or should that be “masturb piece”? 🙂 As for the TWAT, he’s fearfully…Jul 8, 17:48
    • Hatey McHateface on Too Tight To Mention: “Sure, x, but it’s kinda lost its ability to hit home. Put it another way. Nae steaming schemie at an…Jul 8, 17:42
    • Hatey McHateface on Too Tight To Mention: “I don’t understand hardly a word of Gaelic, Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh, but I always enjoy your contributions (in as far as…Jul 8, 17:32
    • Hatey McHateface on Too Tight To Mention: “Something else you’ve said before, NC, is that your ancestral language is Brittonic (apologies if I spelled that incorrectly). It’s…Jul 8, 17:18
    • Hatey McHateface on Too Tight To Mention: ““much bigger, fluffy and a white rear” A white sizzler bee. There’s more and more of them every year, surging…Jul 8, 17:08
    • Hatey McHateface on Too Tight To Mention: “I will happily admit to being unable to point out the location of “Darien” on a large scale map of…Jul 8, 17:04
    • Aidan on Too Tight To Mention: “As per usual Dan, your post doesn’t make any overarching discernible point or appear to raise any argument relevant to…Jul 8, 16:59
    • Hatey McHateface on Too Tight To Mention: “It’s worse than that, x. “I am a gormless, gumption-free Scot that wants others to gift us freedom from colonial…Jul 8, 16:57
    • sarah on Too Tight To Mention: “Thanks for the giggle, Dan. Bumble bee pelts indeed! I didn’t think bumble bees stung either but this one was…Jul 8, 16:56
    • Hatey McHateface on Too Tight To Mention: “Good wank was it? That’s so nice to know.Jul 8, 16:46
    • Hatey McHateface on Too Tight To Mention: “Sure Dan. We could do like the Bolsheviks did in Siberia. Force people into the cattle cars at gunpoint. Stop…Jul 8, 16:44
    • Pete on The separation of goals: “Jesus wept. This was written in 2016 and seeing where we (and the rest of the world) are in 2025…Jul 8, 16:37
  • A tall tale



↑ Top