The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Sauce for the gander

Posted on December 19, 2011 by

The lawyer and Labour activist Ian Smart has had a few strong things to say in the last couple of weeks, not least a coruscating attack on the poor quality of the Scottish party’s leadership candidates. But the piece that caught our eye was one last Monday which was ostensibly about the EU and Eurozone crisis. Commenting relatedly on the internal machinations of the last Labour government, Smart said:

“Any time Blair did anything really unpopular Gordon’s people would let it be known that he would have done things differently. They were careful never to say what they would actually have done, just that it would have been something different. Thus, that ‘something different’ could be whatever you wanted it to be… if the leader of the Labour Party wants to become Prime Minister then he or she will require to win a General Election. And that requires an ability to answer the question ‘What would you do?’ with something more than ‘something different’.”

And yet, when we look at Smart’s party in Scotland, what clearly-specified, active policies do we find that it presently stands for (rather than just against)?

– on the constitution?Vote for the status quo and we’ll change things at some undetermined point in the future, in some unspecified way or ways (even though we’ve just finished spending several years on the Calman Commission supposedly coming up with a settled and lasting position on devolution).”

– on local taxation?We’ll get back to you on that.

– on higher education funding? We haven’t made a decision yet.

– on fighting sectarianism? We refuse to participate in the discussion.

– on minimum alcohol pricing?We’re for doing something, but not this.

– on gay marriage?The time is right to consult on options.

– on maintaining/upgrading nuclear weapons?No comment.

– on building a new generation of nuclear power stations? We haven’t ruled new nuclear power in, but neither have we ruled it out.

Help us out, readers (or Mr Smart, if you’re there) – is there anything Scottish Labour and its new leader actually DOES currently have a policy on?

2 to “Sauce for the gander”

  1. Dubbieside says:

    “is there anything Scottish Labour and its new leader actually DOES currently have a policy on?”

    Yes if the SNP propose it we are against it. Its worked great for us so far, so why should we change, we are Scotlands natural party of government after all.

    Reply
  2. DougtheDug says:

    I suspect that one of the main reasons that Labour are rudderless in Scotland is that although Gordon Brown was a prime example of a man who avoided decisions he did at least know where Scotland was and regarded it as his personal fiefdom. Ed Milliband might know but he's not that interested.
    As a regional branch Labour in Scotland are waiting for directions from their leader which never come. That's their actual leader, not the Scottish regional manager the media keeps claiming is their party leader.

    Reply


Comment - please read this page for comment rules. HTML tags like <i> and <b> are permitted. Use paragraph breaks in long comments. DO NOT SIGN YOUR COMMENTS, either with a name or a slogan. If your comment does not appear immediately, DO NOT REPOST IT. Ignore these rules and I WILL KILL YOU WITH HAMMERS.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,783 Posts, 1,220,809 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Hatey McHateface on The Art Of Noise: “Surely Swinney is doing a first-class job? It’s not his fault that nobody ever asked for the job description to…Jun 27, 21:24
    • sarah on The Art Of Noise: “They got rid of the Good Guys and they changed the party rules to permit self-identifying of disability in order…Jun 27, 21:13
    • Alf Baird on Holiday Relief: ““linguicide” (death of a language due to natural or political causes) is derived from the Latin ‘lingua’, meaning tongue.Jun 27, 21:11
    • Hatey McHateface on Holiday Relief: ““Linguicide” 🙂 Loving it, Alf. BTW, what’s the Scots for linguicide? That’s surely gonna be the first question every alert…Jun 27, 20:59
    • Hatey McHateface on And it’s goodnight from he/him: “That’s a thought provoking post, Andy, but tell us true. If we Scots all just shouted “Bairns Not Bombs” in…Jun 27, 20:51
    • socratesmacsporran on The Art Of Noise: “You might have hoped, given what a success Swinney was as SNP leader, first time round, a half-way sensible party…Jun 27, 20:43
    • Hatey McHateface on But Don’t Give Yourself Away: “James’s Mammie gone oot again. Hope she left James plenty of Kleenex!Jun 27, 20:42
    • Alf Baird on Holiday Relief: ““Scots displacing other native languages” ? Hardly. Lets looks at the facts: Gaelic came from Ireland. Norse from Scandinavia. English…Jun 27, 19:33
    • Andy Ellis on And it’s goodnight from he/him: “You clearly don’t know what you’re talking about. Many US defence systems actually depend on European (and sometimes Taiwanese, Japanese,…Jun 27, 18:39
    • James on But Don’t Give Yourself Away: ““…You’re coming across as obsessed, tending towards unhinged…” ROTFLMFAO – look in a mirror, Prick.Jun 27, 18:36
    • Andy Ellis on Holiday Relief: “@Fearghas I’m sure this has been pointed out to Alf before: the colonialism goose sauce serves equally well for the…Jun 27, 18:26
    • Confused on The Art Of Noise: “stop being so lazy and read the article; grandad was a yookie who did a lot of yehudis but then,…Jun 27, 18:04
    • Hatey McHateface on But Don’t Give Yourself Away: “Are you on a piece rate for every time you drop the ‘g’ word, Mia? You’re coming across as obsessed,…Jun 27, 17:35
    • Alf Baird on Holiday Relief: “If we consider Scots-speaking communities throughout Scotland it does appear that descendants of the Picts did help develop and speak…Jun 27, 17:33
    • twathater on The Art Of Noise: “What a condescending, patronising piece of excrement this tr@ itor to Scotland and Scots is, that he can sit there…Jun 27, 17:31
    • Hatey McHateface on The Art Of Noise: “Must try harder. Shoehorn DEW into your title somewhere.Jun 27, 17:30
    • Hatey McHateface on And it’s goodnight from he/him: “Whoops did you say crack?Jun 27, 17:27
    • Anthem on And it’s goodnight from he/him: “Oh please, stop the drivel. My point is clear. None of the manufacturing for American based products will be based…Jun 27, 16:49
    • Anthem on And it’s goodnight from he/him: “Oh please, stop the drivel. My point is clear. None of the manufacturing for American based products will be based…Jun 27, 16:44
    • robertkknight on The Art Of Noise: “Finbarr Swinney & his double entendres… “Fnarr fnarr, yack yack, indy indy, arf arf”Jun 27, 16:39
    • Oneliner on The Art Of Noise: “Spectacleywell of the voteyfold. Ah, deepjoy indeed!Jun 27, 16:35
    • Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh on Holiday Relief: “I’ll try again, Alf. Do you believe that the language which the Picts spoke developed into Scots?Jun 27, 16:20
    • Insider on But Don’t Give Yourself Away: ““James” I see ! Just a “bookkeeper” on a slave plantation! And you think that’s o.k. ?? Good grief !…Jun 27, 16:18
    • Cactus on The Art Of Noise: ““A vote for John the moron is a vote to guarantee Scotland will be in the Union until 2031.” -…Jun 27, 16:17
    • Ian on The Art Of Noise: “The failure to get rid of those favouring the union within the SNP well before 2014 was when the big…Jun 27, 16:02
    • sarah on The Art Of Noise: “A dent could be made in the SNP vote IF the existence of Liberate Scotland was given publicity and IF…Jun 27, 15:58
    • Andy Ellis on And it’s goodnight from he/him: “@Breastplate It’s a complex issue true, but buying defence equipment from American companies often has other benefits, because European countries…Jun 27, 15:50
    • Confused on The Art Of Noise: “An SNP Biker Gang would be interesting : The Sons of Mediocrity or Los TransidosJun 27, 15:40
    • Sven on The Art Of Noise: “Dearie me, who would have thought it. For those of us of a certain mature age it’s truly impressive to…Jun 27, 15:39
    • James on But Don’t Give Yourself Away: “Bollocks. He was offered a job as a book keeper but never went.Jun 27, 15:33
  • A tall tale



↑ Top