The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Quoted for truth #4

Posted on January 18, 2013 by

Joyce McMillan in the Scotsman today, as the Scottish press is finally, after three days, shamed into acknowledging what happened on Tuesday.

“What I see at Westminster now is not an alternative politics that avoids the pitfalls of nationalism, but an instinctive, backward-looking British nationalism that is even worse: a farrago of double standards about Westminster and Holyrood, and of reactionary nonsense about the nature of national identity in the 21st century, combined with a complete vacuum of progressive policy, and an instinctive willingness – on the part of the Labour Party – to side in this debate with what is perhaps the most privileged and reactionary government the UK has seen in a century.

The truth is that the tone of the No camp’s response to the independence debate has – in too many cases – been so reactionary, so negative, and so fundamentally disrespectful of the Scottish Parliament as an institution, that I now find it hard to think of voting with them, no matter what my views on the constitution.

And this, for me, is a new experience in politics – to enter a debate with a strongish view on one side of the argument, and to find myself so repelled by the tone and attitudes of those who should be my allies that I am gradually forced into the other camp.”

We’ll have more on that subject later this morning. Don’t miss it.

46 to “Quoted for truth #4”

  1. blunttrauma says:

    Read that this morning, I think the negativity of the NO campaign is bringing a lot of people into the YES camp.

    Reply
  2. Stevie Cosmic says:

    This struck me as no more than a grudging acceptance of the merits of independence; ‘well, Westminster’s worse’. I see no enthusiasm for the myriad of benefits in independence to the Scottish people in this argument.
     
    The positive vision for an independent Scotland, and an addressing of the democratic deficit, is what has driven the movement, not ‘how bad’ Westminster is or is not.

    Reply
  3. Seasick Dave says:

    “Damn with faint praise, assent with civil leer, and, without sneering, teach the rest to sneer.”

    Alexander Pope 

    Reply
  4. Tris says:

    It seemed obvious to me when the latest poll showed no increase in in YES voters, but a decrease in NO voters and a subsequent increase in DON’T KNOWS, that the NO campaign was getting the tone all wrong.

    The clear hatred of Holyrood, something that Scottish people, from all sides, seem to like and respect well enough, from a bunch of people who have a great deal to lose personally, from  any change in the constitution and the negativity and what most people can see as downright lies, and ridiculously obvious lies at that,are clearly putting people off.

    It is getting through to folk that the NO campaign has nothing positive to offer us except WMDs, more embassies than you could shake a stick at, a seat on the UN Security Council, “clout” in the EU (?????) and  some vague promises from David Cameron!!!!! (well we all trust him, don’t we?) about changes in the future (but he’s not telling us what…)

    Not one single thing that will get better… just more cuts, more Tory injustices that Scots vote against.

    You know, sometimes I feel sorry for those charged with selling this crock of shit to the Scots. 

    Reply
  5. blunttrauma says:

    @stevie cosmic

    A yes vote is a yes vote “grudging” or not. 

    Reply
  6. Christian Wright says:

    OT – Talking of NOT shamed into reporting what happened – Glasgow City Council leader Gordon Matheson arrested for performing sex act in public. Did so with someone other than his significant other. 

    And it is treated with compassion and respect in the Unionist press
    heraldscotland.com/…/…

    dailyrecord.co.uk/…/…

    Pathetic that it is not the lead story in these “newspapers”, but it does get a front page lede to an inside page in the Record at least. The Herald, however, once again confirms its status as McPravda.

    Here is the headline as it appears in the Herald:

    “Fears for Glasgow council leader’s future over sex act”

    Here is the headline had it been an SNP council leader:

    “Alex Salmond in crisis as SNP leader arrested for gay sex act in public. ”

    Actually, the Record is even worse than the Herald – this is their headline:

    “Council chief Gordon Matheson issues public apology after being caught cheating on partner”

    No mention of arrest or the sexual offence

    Reply
    • Rev. Stuart Campbell says:

      “No mention of arrest or the sexual offence”

      Perhaps because he doesn’t seem to have been arrested. The Record says:

      “Officers found Matheson committing an “indecent act” with his former partner. They spoke to the pair then reported them to the ­procurator fiscal.”

      Reply
  7. Seasick Dave says:

    You know, sometimes I feel sorry for those charged with selling this crock of shit to the Scots.  

     You must be a real soft touch, Tris 🙂

    Reply
  8. MajorBloodnok says:

    The NO campaign is doing an excellent job of forcing even its natural supporters to look around and think “if this is all the Union has to offer after 300 years surely there must be something better than this”. 

    That’s why positive words, actions and a clear vision of the opportunities for social justice (despite Joyce pretending that it’s all vague and not enirely be trusted) from the independence campaign will gently impell the swelling ranks of Don’t Knows to vote YES in 2014.

    Right, where do I sign to nominate Ian Davidson for an OBE for his services in defence of the Empire?

    Reply
  9. Seasick Dave says:

    Ian Davidson for OBE?

    You mean an Old Bell End? 

    Reply
  10. MajorBloodnok says:

    That’s the one.

    Reply
  11. Franklin says:

    Looks like she was just about choking to admit what little she did. Felt like half the piece was her padding and qualifying statements assuring us the the SNP/independence crowd  ain’t all that great and are probably just as bad, etc.

    Pravda behaviour continues all around but maybe this grudging admission of fault for the No campaign is one of the first cracks and a sign of something gathering momentum. 

    Reply
  12. Rev. Stuart Campbell says:

    “Looks like she was just about choking to admit what little she did. Felt like half the piece was her padding and qualifying statements assuring us the the SNP/independence crowd  ain’t all that great and are probably just as bad, etc.”

    Maybe. Or, you could see it as setting our her Unionist credentials in order to illustrate just HOW bad they must have been to be pushing her towards the Yes camp.

    Reply
  13. Kenny Campbell says:

    link to heraldscotland.com
     
    This story was on Herald website but buried and not visible form any of the news segments. I had to find it by searching for Matheson. The Herald has a peculiar love in with wee Gordy and so I had commented that the story was miraculously buried and wondered if that would have happened should he have been in another political party…
     
    An hour later its on home news front page and my comment deleted….

    Reply
  14. Christian Wright says:

    Yes, and as noted in my post the Record seems to have been economical with the truth.

    From the Herald:

    “Glasgow City Council leader Gordon Matheson was apprehended by officers after they witnessed him carrying out the act in a car on the city’s south side.”

     apprehended: Verb

    Arrest (someone) for a crime.

    Merriam-Webster

    Reply
  15. Kenny Campbell says:

    Being reported to Fiscal does not always require arrest.

    Reply
  16. Training Day says:

    Radio Scotland nearly choked on its shortbread breakfast this morning when forced to read out the Record’s and Herald’s coverage of the Matheson story.  It did not, natch, find room for the story in its main news bulletins. 

    Reply
  17. Christian Wright says:

    Kenny Campbell says:
    18 January, 2013 at 9:22 am

    Being reported to Fiscal does not always require arrest.

    If he was apprehended as the Herald insists, then he was indeed arrested.

    Reply
  18. Luigi says:

    I may be reading the signs wrong, but I get the impression that there are a number of prominent “unionists”, possibly devomax supporters, that have just stuck their heads above the trenches and have started looking for an excuse to vote YES in 2014?

    Reply
  19. Marcia says:

     Joyce McMillan won’t be the only one thinking that. She has come a long way in her political thinking to her present position. The anti side are helping. Thank you Darling.

    Re Matheson, I expect a lot of jokes about his ‘Glasgow Kiss’

    Reply
  20. MajorBloodnok says:

    Maybe Matheson was auditioning for an OBE.  And entirely unbidden, the phrase ‘ointment before entry’ just popped into my head there.  Uuurgh.

    Reply
  21. Christian Wright says:

     
    MajorBloodnok says:
    18 January, 2013 at 9:45 am

     the phrase ‘ointment before entry’ just popped into my head there.  

    Seems to me you’re behind the curve with that one, Major. 

    Reply
  22. Macart says:

    @blunttrauma
    “Read that this morning, I think the negativity of the NO campaign is bringing a lot of people into the YES camp.”

    SSHHHHHH! They’re doin’ jist fine. 🙂 

    Reply
  23. Iain says:

    My only concern is that the police took good care of the guide dog belonging to Mr Mathieson’s partner-in-not-quite-a-crime.
     

    Reply
  24. Morag says:

    Joyce McMillan practially worshipped Gordon Brown, I seem to remember from articles from the late 1990s/early 2000s.  She believed the Labour party could do no wrong.  Well well.

    Reply
  25. Ray says:

    The Joyce McMillan comments in the piece above is exactly how my wife feels about the whole situation. She’s not overly political or attached to any one party but she considers herself to be somewhat conservative. She’s voted for the Tories during the last couple of elections that have popped up but, like me, she votes for a party after pondering the present and the near future rather than the past or because of some sort of tribal instinct.

    Since she’s been made aware of WoS, and the workings of the Scottish/British mainstream media, and after listening to the explanations behind the stories and seeing for herself the utter contempt Westminster politicians have for Scotland, she has gone from a definite No to a probable Yes.

    I think it’s safe to say she’s not the only one.

    Reply
  26. Craig P says:

    If a stone-cold unionist like Joyce McMillan is saying this, Better Together really had better pay attention to how their message is coming across before it is too late for them.
    On the other hand, carry on as you are, B.T. 🙂

    Major, glad you left that one till after breakfast!

    Reply
  27. Christian Wright says:

    Marcia says: The anti side are helping. Thank you Darling.

    Indeed, we are well served by the enemies providence has provided us.

    Reply
  28. Doug Daniel says:

    Looking at the completely ambiguous headline (“No Answer Came The Stern Reply”), am I being paranoid in thinking that if this had been a story about the pro-independence side’s behaviour, it would have been something like “I Can’t Vote For Independence” or something?

    Joyce’s article reads like someone telling the story of a friend they used to be enthralled to, who they felt could do no wrong. But they’ve just witnessed that friend doing something absolutely heinous, and their faith in that friend has been critically shaken. Her eyes have been opened, and from now on she’ll start to see all the faults for what they are.

    Joyce is not the first, and she most certainly won’t be the last. This is one of the reasons why the transfer of votes will only go one way, because a lot of “no” voters simply haven’t been forced to see the union for what it is yet.

    Reply
  29. Christian Wright says:

    Morag says: Joyce McMillan practially worshipped Gordon Brown, I seem to remember from articles from the late 1990s/early 2000s. She believed the Labour party could do no wrong. Well well.

    I think she can convincingly argue that she did not leave the Labour Party, the Labour Party left her,  

    Reply
  30. Kenny Campbell says:

    “Joyce is not the first, and she most certainly won’t be the last. This is one of the reasons why the transfer of votes will only go one way, because a lot of “no” voters simply haven’t been forced to see the union for what it is yet.”
     
    I think that is a critical point, if you are YES today you won’t ever be switching to NO. The same can’t be said for NO voters today.

    Reply
  31. kininvie says:

    The headline over Joyce’s piece….
    link to poetrysoup.com
    A sad little tale. Congratulations to the Scotsman sub who thought of the connection.

    Reply
  32. An Duine Gruamach says:

    My favourite comment on the Scotsman article:

    “Is it unhelpful to point out that National Socialism in post-WW1 Germany was borne out of hope too?”

    I just… I don’t even… ah… [heid slams down in desk] 

    Reply
  33. Amanayeman says:

    Anent trying to get to the bottom of the NO campaign’s policy. Do you think Gordon Matheson knows anything about it. ?

    Reply
  34. I think an awful lot of Unionists now wish they had included a second question in the Referendum.

    Reply
  35. Christian Wright says:

     “trying to get to the bottom of the NO campaign’s policy. Do you think Gordon Matheson knows anything about it. ?”

    I’m sure he’ll consider the issue, have a poke around, and should he discover a void, conduct a probe into it. 

    Reply
  36. David McCann says:

    ‘When the debate is lost, slander becomes the tool of the loser’
    Socrates.
    How true. How very true.

    Reply
  37. muttley79 says:

    I think Joyce McMilllan is doing a Kevin McKenna.  I reckon she could well gradually be coming round to independence in her recent articles.

    Reply
  38. McHaggis says:

    On Matheson, such a breach of trust and illegal activity would normally lead to any public servant tendering their immediate resignation.

    On Joyce, I believe this is the thin end of the wedge. The apparent silence from the YES campaign suggests to me they believe the frantic, negativity of the NO campaign are doing just a grand job. Of course, I expect there will be a tipping point where the YES campaign will swing into full force and many more will be persuaded of the benefits of independence.

    Reply
  39. Dcanmore says:

    I predict, without any research whatsoever and using what is known as gut-feeling, that the NO percentage will gradually and continually fall this year. Those people (to whom Devo-Max is preferable) will at first go into the ‘don’t know’ category and then shift later into the YES camp. The final persuasion will be the publication of the White Paper including the FM’s idea of all-inclusive constitution and the realisation that NO means you get nothing except more misery for years to come. I can see a 20-30% shift to the YES camp bringing out a similar result that led to the YES-YES win of 1997.

    Reply
  40. isleofskye says:

    Extraordinary article by Margaret Curran on 15 Jan – does she have no sense of irony? It’s okay, I do know the answer to that!
    “The debate ahead on the future of Scotland has to be more than an accountancy exercise. The tone and tenor of it has to match the high aspirations that people on all sides have for an event of this significance.
    As we have been doing from the outset, we will continue to grasp the nettle and deal with the difficult and challenging issues that Scotland has to face with rigour and honesty. It has to be a debate that meets the ambition of the generations of Labour advocates for devolution. In the words of Donald Dewar, Scotland’s first First Minister:
    “Introspection will not solve our problems. Nor will preoccupation with constitutional point-scoring. Responding to the needs of the Scottish people is what matters.”
    For those of us who have spent a life time in Scottish politics, this is an important opportunity to settle this question once and for all. When Parliament’s debate concludes this afternoon, we will be one step closer to that end.
    Margaret Curran MP, Shadow Secretary of State for Scotland
    link to labourlist.org

    Reply
  41. Dal Riata says:

    Those who read Kevin McKenna’s articles in the Guardian/Observer will have noticed his change of tone ever since Lamont’s ‘Something for nothing’ speech and subsequent fallout. Now, having ‘followed’ his warblings for quite a while, from his earlier insulting and unfunny jibes against Scottish independence, the SNP, Salmond, etc. to his latest more mature and questioning stuff about the future of Scotland I’m still wary of this volte-face… but I live in hope that its genuine! We haven’t had the full ‘Damascene conversion’ yet, but you can almost taste it!

    As an aside, @Rev Stu: re Kevin McKenna.

    I remember some people questioning your decision to move Kevin McKenna from your Zany Comedy Relief section to the Scottish Politics section. Does this now prove that you have the power of prescience? 

    From Wiki.:
    “Prescience – The power to have instinctive foreknowledge of incoming events. A form of precognition, and a sub-power of precognition.
    Capability: The user has instinctive knowledge of events before they happen, and often knows an enemy’s every move and intention before said enemy even decides them.”

    Well, well. Who knew?!   🙂

    Reply
    • Rev. Stuart Campbell says:

      “I remember some people questioning your decision to move Kevin McKenna from your Zany Comedy Relief section to the Scottish Politics section. Does this now prove that you have the power of prescience?”

      More just the power of reading, really. I based the move on what he actually said, not what I guessed he might say. If I was that smart I’d have also predicted Alex Massie slipping the other way…

      Reply
  42. AnneDon says:

    @The Tree of Liberty: In the early stages of the debate, I wondered why the unionists were so agin Devo-Max, yet insisting Alex Salmond secretly wanted it. I still can’t decide if they were just being stupid, or if wee Eck is a genius. I mean, they were being stupid either way, but if Alex Salmond really put them into that position, he definitely is a genius.  He has been very lucky with his enemies! 

    Reply
  43. Morag says:

    Wee Eck is a genius. That was a masterstroke.

    I remember the day the penny dropped for me, in October 2011. Before that, I couldn’t quite figure out what was going on, with all this stuff about indy-lite and devo-max, and journalists crowing that Salmond was just softening up his supporters to get used to the fact that he wasn’t aiming for independence any more. And nobody in the SNP was denying it. Sillars went on a public strop about it. (Now I wonder if he was privately prompted.) That year’s SNP conference had puzzled little fringe meetings trying to work out what was going on.

    Then a junior MSP explained it all clearly on Newsnight, and I nearly fell off the sofa. I was absolutely struck dumb with admiration when I realised the trap that had been set.

    I thought once it had been explained at least the unionists would figure it out, even though they were in a cleft stick. But they didn’t. They went on walking right into it. They may only be beginning to figure it out now.

    Reply
  44. charlie says:

    Tried to comment to Joyce McMillan’s piece but bloody hell The Hootsmon site is so slow
    Anyhow… embe think the general disillusionment with Scotland Labour will filter down to the Labour Party in England? And mebbe make them realise where they are going wrong as a UK party?

    All the best

    Charlie

    Reply


Comment - please read this page for comment rules. HTML tags like <i> and <b> are permitted. Use paragraph breaks in long comments. DO NOT SIGN YOUR COMMENTS, either with a name or a slogan. If your comment does not appear immediately, DO NOT REPOST IT. Ignore these rules and I WILL KILL YOU WITH HAMMERS.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,787 Posts, 1,221,981 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Breastplate on According As We Need Them: “John Main, You Unionists seem to routinely register your disapproval on the reliance of 300 year old documentation, but accept…Jul 14, 20:43
    • agent x on According As We Need Them: “@ Northcode I notice there has been minimal, or maybe make that no support or encouragement for your poems on…Jul 14, 20:15
    • Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh on Just Good Friends: “In case you are unaware (and for comparison): WAR O THE WARLDS By H. G. Wells – Owerset intae NOR-EAST…Jul 14, 20:11
    • Hatey McHateface on According As We Need Them: “Enjoying your use of iambic quadrameter, NC. And your random departures from it too. If you’re taking requests, highlights from…Jul 14, 19:49
    • Northcode on According As We Need Them: “I posted one of ma braw poems recently about the demon Nuckelavee being cawd up fae the depths o’ the…Jul 14, 19:38
    • Hatey McHateface on Just Good Friends: ““trying as usual to undermine anything about Scotland” You should read Rev Stu’s articles and not just jump straight to…Jul 14, 18:06
    • Hatey McHateface on According As We Need Them: “In this heat you need to be eating salads.Jul 14, 17:55
    • twathater on Just Good Friends: “Wow the yoonies are out in force trying as usual to undermine anything about Scotland ,they’re like wee yapping dugs…Jul 14, 17:35
    • Dan on According As We Need Them: “In a bid to disrupt mental Main’s posting stream… Related to this article, there’s a fair few quid being spaffed…Jul 14, 17:14
    • Mark Beggan on According As We Need Them: “The Gravy boat is just a woke away. Just a woke away Just a woke away Just a woke away.Jul 14, 16:55
    • Mark Beggan on According As We Need Them: “I’m getting out of here. They’re all mad!Jul 14, 16:54
    • Hatey McHateface on According As We Need Them: ““can a thief be robbed?” Now I’m confused, Confused. You have stated on here many times that when it comes…Jul 14, 16:48
    • Hatey McHateface on According As We Need Them: ““nothing of the colonizer’s is appropriate for the colonized” Stand out post from Professor Baird. Anybody with him on calling…Jul 14, 16:20
    • Hatey McHateface on According As We Need Them: “Nice try, NC, but easily discounted, as you have failed to provide any evidence for your assertion that Scotland’s high…Jul 14, 16:01
    • Hatey McHateface on According As We Need Them: ““Scotland as a Lunatic Asylum” When Confused writes on a subject so aligned with his own, lived experience, it behoves…Jul 14, 15:51
    • Hatey McHateface on Just Good Friends: “Another post from Confused enthusing over the idea of a bankrupt and socially fractured England just south of our unprotected…Jul 14, 15:47
    • Confused on According As We Need Them: “mythology – when Edward 1 stole the stone of destiny it was to make himself legitimate, for a “true king”…Jul 14, 15:21
    • James Cheyne on According As We Need Them: “Northcode. The trouble with ignorance is that it can, if left unfettered become an indoctrination of the mind. Even if…Jul 14, 15:01
    • Insider on Just Good Friends: “James at 2:34 If you know “exactly what they mean” why do you misuse them ?Jul 14, 14:58
    • James on Just Good Friends: “I also recognise the scratchings of a supercilious c**t when I see them…..Jul 14, 14:43
    • sarah on According As We Need Them: “What on earth did she expect?Jul 14, 14:37
    • James on Just Good Friends: “I know exactly what these words mean, smart arse. Knew that highers exam would come in handy someday.Jul 14, 14:34
    • Insider on Just Good Friends: “James 12:47… Do you know what the words “refute” and “bespoke” mean ??? Apparently not !Jul 14, 13:50
    • sarah on According As We Need Them: “I am not quite as pessimistic, Lorn! If enough good people get into Holyrood they will tell the civil servants…Jul 14, 13:41
    • Lorrn on According As We Need Them: “Caveman: because we allowed our common decency and sense of fairness to dominate our older, more innate and evolutionary senses…Jul 14, 13:32
    • Lorn on According As We Need Them: “It is not only the candidate who have to be selected very carefully to weed out the incompetent – and…Jul 14, 13:14
    • Lorn on According As We Need Them: “Indeed, Sarah, and I have stated quite clearly that I would vote for any of them if they were to…Jul 14, 13:04
    • James on Just Good Friends: “Don’t refute them, Alf. These are the geniuses that will tell you that GERS is bespoke economics.Jul 14, 12:47
    • GM on According As We Need Them: “I hope so, they aren’t going to resign – the courts, despite the procurator fiscal being unreliable, is the only…Jul 14, 12:12
    • sam on According As We Need Them: “Rooting out this woke nonsense is Sisyphean. For Women Scotland are taking the EHRC to task over its wokeness. https://forwomen.scot/30/06/2025/ehrc-code-of-practice-2025/…Jul 14, 12:05
  • A tall tale



↑ Top