The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Quoted for truth #3

Posted on January 07, 2013 by

John Harris in the Guardian today:

“[six years ago] to be living on an estate, and in receipt of benefits, and possibly out of work, was to not just to be fair game for Oxford undergraduates, the future king and a certain kind of TV comedian, but the butt of a huge national joke. Some of us wondered where exactly what was briefly known as ‘The New Snobbery’ was headed.

We now know. Its cultural aspects were merely the tip of the iceberg – as the Labour party engaged in the rebranding of social security as ‘welfare’ and its ministers raged against ‘benefit cheats’, something poisonous was being embedded at the core of our national life.

While the Conservative party grimaced through a fleeting modernisation, it sat there, ready to be picked up by a Tory-led administration and taken to its logical conclusion.”

And, of course, by Scottish Labour.

36 to “Quoted for truth #3”

  1. mogabee says:

    Yes, this hatred being stoked is extremely scary. Imagine having an uncertain job at the moment. The fear of losing your job and being the focus of so much antagonism would be horrendous.
       As this gets worse, we’ll be running to that voting station!

    Reply
  2. Cameron says:

    Anyone remember the Tories bring the “underclass” to our attention, with ample assistance from Labour?

    Total cod science intended to divide society.

    Reply
  3. Dan says:

    Some horrifying evidence of the power of propaganda:
     
    link to channel4.com?
     

    Reply
  4. Cuphook says:

     
    The demonisation of the poor is a necessary weapon in the Neoliberal politics accepted as the norm in the UK; they want you to compare your wealth with that of the underclass and not the elite.
     
    Thatcher told us that in giving the rich tax cuts the poor would benefit as wealth ‘trickled down’. The poor are now poorer and as Cameron gives tax cuts to the rich all the poor can expect is a golden shower.
     
    Independence gives us the opportunity to expand on the social changes brought about by the SNP. A fairer Scotland is worth fighting for.

    Reply
  5. Cameron says:

    @ Cuphook

    “Neoliberal”

    Why not call it what it is mate? Neo-facsism.

    Sucks to Godwin.

    Reply
  6. Cuphook says:

    @Cameron

    I’ll call it that when they all shop for shirts at the same designer outlet. 

    As England moves to the Right you do have to wonder where the Left alternative is. There’s a proud history of radicalism in England but it seems to have lost its voice. It’s certainly not to be found in the Labour Party. 

    The absence of any Left activism to preserve the Union would also suggest that they’ve given up on the UK. The only alternative is independence.

    Reply
  7. JLT says:

    Yes, this hatred being stoked is extremely scary. Imagine having an uncertain job at the moment. The fear of losing your job and being the focus of so much antagonism would be horrendous.
    As this gets worse, we’ll be running to that voting station!

    I‘ve been saying this for a while now. Just wait for Osborne’s cuts to Welfare reallllllly kick in. As you say, Unionist or not Unionist, they’ll be at that Polling station at 7am on Referendum Day!!!

    Reply
  8. Matt says:

     
    Dan says:
     
    7 January, 2013 at 1:43 pm
    Some horrifying evidence of the power of propaganda:
     
    link to channel4.com?

    That story should be the headline story on every newspaper and every TV news bulletin, for as long as it takes to get public perception back in line with reality. How can we have a meaningful public debate when the public don’t have a clue what they are talking about? This is not democracy.

    Reply
  9. Cameron says:

    @ Cuphook
     
    “I’ll call it that when they all shop for shirts at the same designer outlet”
     
    Despite my fear of being portrayed as a swivel-eyed crank by those who do not agree with me, I would like to suggest why the left has proven to be so inadequate.
     
    Firstly, to consider fascism an new phantom (specifically evident during the mid-20th century), conjurers images of right-wing politics, black shirts and funny walks. Sartorial predilection has absolutely nothing to do with fascism, though it does provide an unambiguous message to the onlooker (I associate with this particular party). Fascism is not a set of particular right-wing policies, as many fascist parties throughout Europe have represented a wide range of political positions. Fascism is more accurately considered as a word view, evident in the west as far back as the teachings of Aristotle (check his definition of “natural slaves” and his views on universal sufferage), an outlook which has shaped European society ever since.
     
    Secondly, there appears to be considerable evidence that Karl Marx was an agent of the British empire, be that witting or otherwise. Regardless of the extent to which he was in collusion, his theories have proven to be highly contentious, including his identification of the Lumpenproletariat (probably the first modern description of an underclass). This was a class Marx felt incapable of achieving class consciousness, so could not aid the revolution and were of no value to society. The left is aware of this, but do not want us to be.


    This is my opinion, of course, but just take a look around you and at figures on wealth distribution. Then ask yourself that question I have asked two or three times on this blog, what is fascism?
    Eric Blair a.k.a. George Orwell, provided a usefull fictional description of an unambiguously fascist society in his book 1984’s. Can I suggest you check out Emmanuel Goldstein’s The Theory and Practice of Oligarchical Collectivism.

    Reply
  10. Dal Riata says:

    Here also we see the implications and tragedy of failure of any Leveson implementations. For now(!), ‘Celebrity X is cocaine addict’ headlines and ‘stories’ are being replaced in the MSM with trashing a whole sector of society disgracefully termed as the  ‘underclass’ with no chance of being taken to task. 

    What we are getting as policy from the present London government is a complete contradiction and anathema to what is a ‘common weal’ and general plurality of ‘socialism’in Scottish society and culture. It is becoming ever more alien to me. Not in my name. We are lucky to have the opportunity to get away from that and build our own society for the better in 2014. 

    Reply
  11. Malcolm says:

    How much of a leap is this?
    If you are on benefits/have a criminal record/disabled/too fat you are not permitted to vote. 5 years ago that sentence would be electoral suicide. Now I would not be surprised if some thinktanks are churning out ideas like that.
    Demonisation of the unfortunate is designed to shore up the tory vote in 2015. To make it normal to despise those poorer than you, and admire those richer. It is no exaggeration to say the tories do not care if these people live or die, unless they are striving wealth creators™.
    It is, sadly, working, and becoming a popular point of view (one I urge you to challenge if you come across it in real life). Labour (WM flavour) are not stupid and so are hardening their stance in order to gain southern votes, being as they are the victims of the same tactics to the other end of the spectrum at the hands of the SNP and the greens in the north. Which brings me to what I really wanted to say. Once the damage is done, the social security system is gone for a generation. The electoral landscape will have pitched to the right, and there’s no possibility of a tory defeat in 2015 heralding a restoration of all those vicious wrongs we’ve witnessed since 2010.

    Reply
  12. muttley79 says:

    Would it be right in saying that the underclass developed mainly from the 1980s under the old battleaxes’ governments?

    Reply
  13. Cuphook says:

     
    @Cameron
     
    My sentence was obviously facetious.
     
    As to Fascism, it is a label that has been devalued by its popular usage to describe small transgressions of power. It is therefore not a word that I would employ in political discourse. Go around calling Cameron a Fascist and no one will take your arguments seriously.
     
    I’m aware of political theory and history, and Marx’s identification of, and accusations against, the lumpenproletariat (which is a word that I really, really like), but I’m not a Marxist. I try not to be an ist of any order and a good many people on the Left annoy me as much as those on the Right.

    Reply
  14. Cameron says:

    @ Cuphook
     
    I get your point about overuse of the f word, as most people have a very poor understanding of fascism’s philosophical foundations.
     
    Brace yourself now as the tinfoil hat is now firmly back in place. Could this be a fault of the education system?
     

    Reply
  15. Cameron says:

    @ muttley79
     
    Check out Aristotle’s definition of “natural slaves” and see what you think.
    link to en.wikipedia.org
     

    Reply
  16. Vronsky says:

    I’ve seen <a href=”http://twitpic.com/btbpim”>this crap</a> going around on Facebook.  If you see it post <a href=”http://www.hoax-slayer.com/uk-pensioners-asylum-seekers-protest.shtml”>this</a> link.

    Reply
  17. Vronsky says:

    Oh dear, HTML tags don’t work.  Well, you all know what I mean.

    Reply
  18. muttley79 says:

    O/T  I see that useless bugger of a PM, Cameron, has called the No campaign the ‘Alasdair Darling campaign.’  Who would want to be governed by these fools?…Come on No voters don’t be shy…

    Reply
  19. johnnypict says:

    O/T a tad …just tried to take part in Mr. Darlings webcast hosted by the Scotsman.
    Asked two questions. None posed. Got fed up and challenged some answers he gave others. No reply.

    Apparently there are 71 comments on the Q&A. I was logged on from practically the start. Only seen around a dozen possibly 15.

    So we’ll see if they show the other questions …if Darling answers them on line or if it is the farce it looks to be.

    @muttley …Alistair Darlings campaign. We’ve won a Yes vote then …lol 

    Reply
  20. muttley79 says:

    If we cannot get a Yes vote in the face of this stupidity, ignorance and deceit, would the last person in Scotland turn off the lights please?…I pity the fools, I pity the fools…

    Reply
  21. Ysabelle says:

    @johnnypict,

    Do you have to be logged in to see the comments? I can’t see anything other than the article. I clicked on the 71 comments but only the article came up. 

    Reply
  22. Dave Smith says:

    Well having read Aristotle’s definition it is to be hoped that sufficient of our countrymen are next year prepared, to quote Bob Marley, to “emancipate themselves from mental slavery”.
    I’ve found that phrase extremely relevant and powerful since I did the same myself a year ago. If I myself had such a Damascene moment out of the blue then I can only hope that a million other Scots will have the same experience over the next year.
    Oh, I wouldn’t call Cameron a fascist either. I’ve got a more appropriate word for him.
    It’s still got a ‘C’ in it though…
     

    Reply
  23. Simon says:

    And yet still virtually no commentators or politicians are standing up to say that bailing out the banks was wrong! It seems that it is fine to give huge amounts of public money to super-rich bondholders and investors who gambled badly on high finance, but it is morally wrong to give modest handouts to the poor and needy

    Reply
  24. Cameron says:

    George Orwell called it Oligarchical Collectivism, the essence of English Socialism (Ingsoc).

    Reply
  25. Cameron says:

    @ Simon

    Nobody speaks up because it would be a direct challenge to the Party.
     
    Continuing the Orwell theme, consider William Hague’s position on Syria, and who that means we are now allied to (various groups proscribed by the UN as terrorist organizations). Fix in your mind what media themes have been fed to us since that fateful Autumn day in Manhatten, the resulting War (of) Terror and the countless innocent civilian deaths it has caused. Now check out the definitions of Doublethink and Duckspeak.
    link to en.wikipedia.org
     
     
     

    Reply
  26. AnneDon says:

    Since 2011, I’ve been in seasonal employment, after a lifetime of working. 29+years of working doesn’t seem to count for anything – straight on to £65 per week (now £70). Listening to people going on about ‘folk being better off not working’ really annoys me.

    I’ve got over my embarrassment, and I call them out on it.  

    Reply
  27. Cameron says:

    I got my Limited capacity for work questionnaire on the 23rd Dec.

    Reply
  28. Cameron says:

    I forgot to include the “bankers know best” and “we are all in it together”, as prevailing themes earlier.

    Reply
  29. Stuart Black says:

    Slightly off topic, but when Alex Salmond had the Herald debate with Jon Snow at Barony Hall it was posted almost immediately on the Herald site. The second debate was Alistair Darling in conversation with Allan Taylor, a week later. Now, over a month after the event, I can find no trace of this video. Anyone seen it?

    Reply
  30. Rev. Stuart Campbell says:

    I actually dropped INSP a line about that in December. Their reply was:

    “Unfortunately we were not able to film both events. For the Salmond-Snow event, we managed to arrange the filming as in-kind sponsorship, but we were not able to arrange this for both. Sorry to disappoint.”

    In response to a follow-up about attendance, they also said;

    “The second event wasn’t a sell-out (as the Snow Salmond one was), but it was still a big crowd. Unfortunately we don’t have a transcript either – sorry!”

    Reply
  31. Stuart Black says:

    Thanks for that Rev, I have been wondering about it, astonishing that they don’t have a transcript, I wonder if any of your readers attended the event, I would like to know how Darling performed. My suspicious tendencies lead me to think that if he did well there would be a transcript available…

    Reply
    • Rev. Stuart Campbell says:

      I did find it odd that in this day and age when everyone has a high-resolution camera in their pocket in the shape of their phone, not one person thought to take a single picture that included the crowd.

      Reply
  32. Cameron says:

    I am a little surprised at how few posts there have been to this thread, which share personal experience of how Con-Dem benefit policies are affecting people, and making criticism based directly on personal experience.

    This is in no way meant as a criticism of WOS, or its readers, simply an observation.

    Possibly an indication of which demographics are posting to WOS and which are not?

    Reply
  33. DWl says:

    link to guardian.co.uk
     
    Pro-UK camp suffers friendly fire wound in first skirmish of the year
     
     

    Reply
  34. DWl says:

    link to heraldscotland.com
     
    Labour targeting seats of Coalition ministers

    Reply
  35. Camreon says:

    Getting ready to pull up the drawbridge perhaps? If we are really, really lucky.

    Reply


Comment - please read this page for comment rules. HTML tags like <i> and <b> are permitted. Use paragraph breaks in long comments. DO NOT SIGN YOUR COMMENTS, either with a name or a slogan. If your comment does not appear immediately, DO NOT REPOST IT. Ignore these rules and I WILL KILL YOU WITH HAMMERS.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,991 Posts, 1,253,522 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Confused on Vibecoding A Better World: “it always baffles me that the maddest of the mad yoons are batshit zio nutters as well https://archive.ph/v1Zno – lest…” Nov 6, 22:00
    • Confused on Vibecoding A Better World: “laffing at you www.youtube.com/watch?v=s7CkA0H75oo www.youtube.com/watch?v=iVICfWS-d5M – not with you fast track this lad for the GDP growth and theconomy https://x.com/RMXnews/status/2118617949325906250…” Nov 6, 21:59
    • Confused on Vibecoding A Better World: “this is fucking mental – skip to 1 minute 20 seconds www.youtube.com/watch?v=kJgkEHzkLck – but I prefer the brahan seer myself…” Nov 6, 21:59
    • Confused on Vibecoding A Better World: “evenin’ all (busy week), some random morsels for all the good people and fuck these yoon arseholes who keep stodging…” Nov 6, 21:58
    • 100%Yes on Vibecoding A Better World: “I wished Rev would get rid of this annoying idiot and barr him. People come on here to have a…” Nov 6, 21:10
    • 100%Yes on Vibecoding A Better World: “Independence is the only hope to remove the colonial constraints. Scotland is house bond by house Westminster. With Independence and…” Nov 6, 21:02
    • Connie Davidson on Vibecoding A Better World: “Aye you, Hatey. There’s quite a few insults I could launch at you ‘n’ a’, but nae need. You show…” Nov 6, 20:20
    • Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh on Vibecoding A Better World: “‘The Debate: What’s the best route to Scottish independence?’ (5 Nov 2026) « Robin McAlpine of Common Weal and Professor…” Nov 6, 20:03
    • Hatey McHateface on Vibecoding A Better World: “How odd, Spartan! Your posts get longer and longer as you care less and less.” Nov 6, 18:37
    • Hatey McHateface on Vibecoding A Better World: ““think outside the box constructed for us” As I recall, constructed by no less a personage than the late, great…” Nov 6, 18:31
    • Hatey McHateface on Vibecoding A Better World: “Michty! Friday comes aroond quick. James hame all alane again. Hope yer maw’s left ye a puckle o’ denners in…” Nov 6, 18:04
    • Aidan on Vibecoding A Better World: “Thanks James – really interesting comment.” Nov 6, 17:52
    • Connie Davidson on Vibecoding A Better World: “I watched the debate on the National You Tube channel between Alf Baird and Robin MacAlpine and I was enraged…” Nov 6, 17:33
    • James on Vibecoding A Better World: “But Adrian, as anyone above the age of 6 reading ony of your posts can tell – you lack ony…” Nov 6, 15:40
    • James on Vibecoding A Better World: ““Prick”.” Nov 6, 15:37
    • Spartan 117 on Vibecoding A Better World: “Well Sam, we can look at several factors. The insistence on alignment with the myriad of EU rules, despite being…” Nov 6, 14:41
    • MaryB on Vibecoding A Better World: “Robin is behaving according to Alf’s thesis, as part of the middle class political class who, like the SNP, are…” Nov 6, 14:34
    • Spartan 117 on Vibecoding A Better World: “Ah, so you’re retired then. Or semi? That explains the amount of time you waste on here and why you’re…” Nov 6, 14:24
    • James Che on Vibecoding A Better World: “Agentx, May I refer you to The Law Society of Scotland of ratification of the 1707 treaty of union being…” Nov 6, 14:03
    • 100%Yes on Vibecoding A Better World: “I’ve said for a long time that their are individuals within the YES/Independence movement more interested in Money than the…” Nov 6, 13:47
    • Hatey McHateface on Vibecoding A Better World: ““he’s not daft” Crivens! Where could this possibly lead us if we but had the courage to follow? “it doesn’t…” Nov 6, 13:02
    • Hatey McHateface on Vibecoding A Better World: “Very wise, MH. Too much risk of encountering a muckle, bearded loon self-identifying as a spoon. I’d be a bit…” Nov 6, 12:49
    • Hatey McHateface on Vibecoding A Better World: “Cheers Spartan. My lowly spirits are always uplifted when somebody as important and busy as you takes time out of…” Nov 6, 12:40
    • Hatey McHateface on Vibecoding A Better World: “So true, Mary. Robin needs to extend the olive branch to Lavrov. Maybe praise him as a peacemaker? Perhaps that…” Nov 6, 12:32
    • sarah on Vibecoding A Better World: “Thanks for the heads-up, MaryB. Robin’s attitude is inexplicable – he’s not daft and he is pro-independence so why criticise…” Nov 6, 12:25
    • Captain Caveman on Vibecoding A Better World: “Indeed, Spartan, we are agreed once again. Like you no doubt, if there’s one thing I cannot stand, it is…” Nov 6, 11:40
    • MaryB on Vibecoding A Better World: “Now on Salvo and Liberation Scotland Facebook.” Nov 6, 11:37
    • Spartan 117 on Vibecoding A Better World: “Don’t forget Stormont, which has the full 5 Bananas rating on the Banana Republic scale. While we’re at it, the…” Nov 6, 11:26
    • Spartan 117 on Vibecoding A Better World: “Agreed CC. The Dutch model is the most workable and with the best outcomes. The US is great if you…” Nov 6, 11:23
    • Spartan 117 on Vibecoding A Better World: “No Hatey, I’m not in a strop thanks. Much more important things to worry about than what some random on…” Nov 6, 11:18
  • A tall tale



↑ Top