The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Legionnaires’ outbreak: Sturgeon to blame

Posted on June 07, 2012 by

At least, that’s the impression you’d get from today’s Guardian. Not one but two pieces by Severin Carrell are both illustrated with pictures of the Deputy FM this morning – one in front of a Saltire for good measure – with very little justification to be found in the text below.

The first piece, which is prominently displayed on the front page of the Guardian website doesn’t even feature a quote from the Health Secretary – she gets just a single passing mention in the fourth paragraph – while the second at least does include a couple, but not until seven paragraphs in.

You can’t avoid pictures of Sturgeon whichever of the paper’s four articles on the outbreak you choose – every single one has her image on either the story or itself or the “related” column, sometimes doubled up. It’s clear that the reader is meant to associate the outbreak with Sturgeon, and while it’s a slightly more nuanced approach than Carrell has adopted previously, there’s no mistaking the intent, especially when it’s backed up by innuendo from reliable Labour rent-a-quotes:

The first case of Legionnaires’ Disease in Edinburgh was identified on Sunday, and the 16 cooling towers thought to be responsible were discovered and sterilised on Sunday night and Monday morning, despite the public holiday. We’re not sure how much more rapidly Lord Foulkes imagines the Scottish Government could have acted, but with the help of friendly media the subtle smear will seep out anyway. The Scotsman’s first “SNP accused” headline can surely only be hours away.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

3 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Scott Minto (Aka Sneekyboy)

Less than 24 hours from discovery to identification and rectifying action and that’s a long time to foulkes?

Man needs to retire!

MajorBloodnok

Mabe he was just tweeting in Beau Geste?

I’ll get my capote.

Dál Riata

Severin Carrell as a journalist is a fraudster. He is allowed to promulgate his version of Scottish ‘news’ by the Guardian which rarely let his reports be opened up to comments. He then goes on Twitter to spout his true feelings on events, doing Scotland and independence down at every opportunity. An MSM Unionist troll is all he is.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a (mainly) Scottish political media digest and monitor, which also offers its own commentary. (More)

    Stats: 6,691 Posts, 1,208,999 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Captain Caveman on A crisis of democracy: ““Maist fowk wha support oor leeberation are Scots language speakers, houver rustit” Quick question, Alf, is your book that you…Jan 16, 13:07
    • John K on A crisis of democracy: ““…That’s pretty much the 21st century Kristallnacht…” Are you serious or just a troll? Your post is a grotesque misuse…Jan 16, 12:37
    • Aidan on A crisis of democracy: “That’s making the rather generous assumption that it’s 267 different people and that those people are Scots. The bigger question…Jan 16, 12:28
    • gregor on A crisis of democracy: “Embrace your invincible power-sword, Braveloch – Your Scotland life survival is your crutch (King)… “The Tao or Dao is the…Jan 16, 11:55
    • Dave Hansell on A crisis of democracy: “Maybe he actually wanted to jump ship?: https://x.com/ABridgen/status/1789726877839405417Jan 16, 11:43
    • Dave Hansell on A crisis of democracy: “The key problem from that survey is that so many of the positions are contradictory in a very practical way.…Jan 16, 11:34
    • gregor on A crisis of democracy: “The Guardian (2015): Welcome to U***ine, the most corrupt nation in Europe: https://archive.ph/iVuqu World Economic Forum and UN Sign Strategic…Jan 16, 11:04
    • gregor on A crisis of democracy: “BBC (2025): Starmer in K**v to pledge more U***ine support: “Sir Keir Starmer has arrived in Kyiv to sign what…Jan 16, 11:00
    • Dan on A crisis of democracy: “As a practically minded person, the only crisis I see is a self-inflicted one created by a pretty dumb electorate…Jan 16, 10:49
    • Marie on A crisis of democracy: “How naive are you? Get off your knees and open your eyes.Jan 16, 10:24
    • Marie on A crisis of democracy: “We have freedom of speech??? Hilarious.Jan 16, 10:20
    • diabloandco on A crisis of democracy: “I quite like your second option.Jan 16, 09:41
    • Mark Beggan on A crisis of democracy: “So she was a Necrophiliac as well.Jan 16, 02:43
    • Cynicus on A crisis of democracy: “Crisis? What Crisis? So long as we have freedom of speech and an electorate with power to remove its political…Jan 16, 02:13
    • Young Lochinvar on A crisis of democracy: “Ha! I thank you for the sentiment, but the pouty look has been crushed by my weight of years and…Jan 16, 01:51
    • Young Lochinvar on A crisis of democracy: “How so? Wrong on this one..Jan 16, 01:37
    • gregor on A crisis of democracy: “As well as the Covid criminals… BBC (2025): Families failed by Covid jabs tell inquiry of pain: “Families of those…Jan 16, 01:17
    • Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh on A crisis of democracy: “Of possible interest: Gaelic Scotland: a brief history Regards.Jan 16, 01:09
    • Young Lochinvar on A crisis of democracy: “A wee story, many won’t be bothered so skip it if you want. Did my bit in the army early…Jan 16, 00:52
    • gregor on A crisis of democracy: “Because I posted it – Scotland’s miserable wretches cannot handle reality and are terrified of freedom. I commend Young Lochinvar…Jan 16, 00:29
    • Young Lochinvar on A crisis of democracy: “Absolutely no arguments but sometimes straightforward non “wanging” posts go straight to moderation, don’t pass go and so on. I’ve…Jan 16, 00:11
    • gregor on A crisis of democracy: “They’ll ALL be exposed and prosecuted… #SystematicPedosChallengeJan 16, 00:05
    • Young Lochinvar on A crisis of democracy: “Powerful.Jan 16, 00:00
    • Confused on A crisis of democracy: “Talking of “hard realpolitik” what to make of our half-scottish golf-nut (HSGN), Trump, with his ambiguous and belligerent talk of…Jan 15, 23:58
    • Young Lochinvar on A crisis of democracy: “Incidentally, St Columbus – from Ulster and therefore able to converse with the Dalriadic Scots and (apparently the Strathclyde “Britons”)…Jan 15, 23:55
    • Young Lochinvar on A crisis of democracy: “Why the down votes to this? Nuts.Jan 15, 23:37
    • Young Lochinvar on A crisis of democracy: “Thanks for the correction.Jan 15, 23:35
    • Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh on A crisis of democracy: “Alf, three or four points maybe. First off I have always appreciated your awareness of the profound link between language…Jan 15, 23:32
    • gregor on A crisis of democracy: “Coincidences.Jan 15, 23:24
    • gregor on A crisis of democracy: “You’ve made a good choice Willie – Wings is where it’s at…Jan 15, 23:20
  • A tall tale



↑ Top
215
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x