The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Scottish Labour’s raw nerve located

Posted on March 05, 2012 by

LabourHame, the Scottish Labour blog set up by Tom Harris, started off with a pretty Stalinist approach to reader comments. It used to be the case that nothing even remotely critical of the party made it through their moderation policy (Harris sometimes deleting entire comment threads even of previously-approved posts if he’d had too much of a cuffing from readers in them), but as the site grew increasingly widely-mocked for its censorship the iron grip relented to a degree.

Since two or three months ago it’s generally been possible to have some sort of debate below the line – indeed, it’s latterly been just about the only place there was a chance of engaging Labour supporters in something vaguely approaching constructive discussion, even if you did have to wait two days to get a comment posted.

So we were slightly surprised when we hit a tender spot with this mildly pointed question, which is the first one we’ve had rejected in a few weeks, and which starts by quoting a line from the Labour leader’s speech to conference on Saturday.

“The question is not what powers should Scotland claw back, but which powers should we share.”

Or put another way, “which powers are we too wee, too poor and too stupid to handle for ourselves”.

It’s a cringing embarrassment that someone who wants people to elect her as the First Minister of Scotland doesn’t think she’s fit to handle all the powers of government. In addition to Corporation Tax, can Johann list for us all the other powers she can’t be trusted to wield, and which should therefore be left to that nice Mr Cameron?

Looks like that one was just a little bit too close to the bone for comfort, eh readers? Still, at least now we know which bits of the speech the loyal comrades were embarrassed by. We can’t say that we blame them.

5 to “Scottish Labour’s raw nerve located”

  1. douglas clark says:

    Frankly, without the cybernat comments, that site would be more or less moribund.

    Reply
    • Rev. Stuart Campbell says:

      True. For a site supposedly set up to promote discussion within Labour, it’s enormously dominated by nationalists and those arguing with them. I’ve seen almost no intra-Labour debate there at all. I suspect that’s actually the other reason they stopped moderating so much.

      Reply
  2. Erchie says:

    Tom Harris

    The Stuart N Hardy of Politics

    Reply
    • Rev. Stuart Campbell says:

      One for the folks at home there 😀

      Reply
  3. Roll_On_2014 says:

    Aye, I put in the following comment on Lamont’s conference speech article:
     
    “ Attacks by Scottish Labour over contracts for the new Forth Crossing have boomeranged after it emerged that the procurement regulations used to award them were actually implemented under the former Labour/LibDem Scottish Executive.
     
    The law, which was introduced in 2006, forbids the Scottish Government from discriminating in favour of Scottish companies when awarding contracts.
     
    Please, please keep Johann; like her predecessor she is serving Labour in Scotland well. “
     
    It never saw the light of day…. I just wonder if it was my ‘handle’ that downed it?

    Reply


Comment - please read this page for comment rules. HTML tags like <i> and <b> are permitted. Use paragraph breaks in long comments. DO NOT SIGN YOUR COMMENTS, either with a name or a slogan. If your comment does not appear immediately, DO NOT REPOST IT. Ignore these rules and I WILL KILL YOU WITH HAMMERS.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,788 Posts, 1,222,256 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • James Cheyne on Points Into Prongs: “What was the Ice Age? Ehmmm, that was the time period before the Climate changed too heating up. Did We…Jul 19, 10:40
    • James Cheyne on Points Into Prongs: “The politicians appear to be idealogical cult crazy,…not the people,Jul 19, 10:28
    • James Cheyne on Points Into Prongs: “Indeed it was the opposite way around as it was the Scottish Stuart dynasty that inherited Englands throne, But were…Jul 19, 10:23
    • agent x on Points Into Prongs: “I wonder if Peter Murrell’s court case will take place before the 2026 election? It has all gone very quiet.Jul 19, 10:11
    • James Cheyne on Points Into Prongs: “Here is another excellent example of a published lie. Being taught to children. Quote from , Kids Britanica .Com. Scotland…Jul 19, 09:55
    • James Cheyne on Points Into Prongs: “I watch as many or all posts, bloggers and government or approved governments information , and peoples opinion from around…Jul 19, 09:47
    • James Cheyne on Points Into Prongs: “Perhaps the SNP, old version and new pretended they had never heard of the right to Self Determination and have…Jul 19, 09:28
    • Northcode on According As We Need Them: ““… I am a lover of the Scots language, our culture and our history” Aye, TH… you and me baith.…Jul 19, 09:25
    • Young Lochinvar on Points Into Prongs: “I read that Bill Clinton (allegedly) said that Hillary had “eaten more pussy than he had”. Sturgeon had her famous…Jul 19, 07:32
    • DaveL on Points Into Prongs: “What is it about the above post that offends you? Maybe you’re just being abusive because you can, is that…Jul 19, 07:00
    • Young Lochinvar on Points Into Prongs: “I suspect the whole thing was a sting/ set up and that he (Upton) was the chosen but willing stalking…Jul 19, 04:57
    • Young Lochinvar on Points Into Prongs: “Begone Unionist foul sprite; your lot are just as bad, just trailing behind a little, but the rot and deviancy…Jul 19, 01:56
    • Hatey McHateface on Points Into Prongs: “Did you press the button too soon, TH, or are the “assistance” boys on a really tight schedule?Jul 19, 01:39
    • Hatey McHateface on Points Into Prongs: “That’s a touch mean spirited, x. You’re forgetting that for many years she held up half the sky (admittedly with…Jul 19, 00:32
    • Hatey McHateface on Points Into Prongs: “Could you be more precise? There have been several useless other ones.Jul 19, 00:25
    • Mark Beggan on Points Into Prongs: “Well put. Couldn’t agree more.Jul 18, 20:57
    • Young Lochinvar on Points Into Prongs: “Meantime NHS Fifes DEI “expert”(sic) Ms Bumba replied when asked to comment on the £9m £6m new (non working) House…Jul 18, 20:38
    • Frank Gillougley on Points Into Prongs: “Having just read all this political bollocks above, the simple thought occurred to me that to compare and contrast what…Jul 18, 19:47
    • Andrew scott on Points Into Prongs: “O/T REV YOU ARE GOING TO HAVE A FIELD DAY WITH THIS SHAMBLES IN FIFEJul 18, 18:45
    • Confused on Points Into Prongs: “Frankly: The revelatory memoir from Scotland’s first female and longest-serving First Minister the greatest living englishmen provides us with much…Jul 18, 18:36
    • twathater on Points Into Prongs: “It just shows the level of contempt this arsehole Swinney and his fellow lying scum noncers have for the people…Jul 18, 18:32
    • Dan on Points Into Prongs: “Sheesh… I only got halfway through the first paragraph and haz concerns Robin is morphing into Kelly Given… https://robinmcalpine.org/scotland-has-no-controlling-intellect/ https://wingsoverscotland.com/the-stupidity-of-vanity/…Jul 18, 18:23
    • twathater on According As We Need Them: “NC I am not a dedicated lover of poetry but I am a lover of the Scots language, our culture…Jul 18, 18:19
    • 100%Yes on Points Into Prongs: “Alf Baird, I would have thought you would have been the best person placed to continue Iain Lawsons blog, Welcome…Jul 18, 18:07
    • socratesmacsporran on Points Into Prongs: “Mark Beggan @ 4.33pm You posted: “Swinney isn’t useless. You are quite correct, Swinney isn’t even competent enough to pass…Jul 18, 17:45
    • Alf Baird on Points Into Prongs: “Swinney and previous SNP leaders since 2015 have been very effective at delaying independence, which is clearly their main purpose,…Jul 18, 17:38
    • Dickie Tea on Points Into Prongs: “VeryJul 18, 17:05
    • joolz on Points Into Prongs: ““the way to deliver independence is only with an emphatic SNP win in 2026”. Goodbye indy. They never learn ?Jul 18, 16:39
    • Mark Beggan on Points Into Prongs: “Swinney isn’t useless. Useless was the other one.Jul 18, 16:33
    • agent x on Points Into Prongs: ““Nicola Sturgeon compared to Barack Obama in ‘sycophantic’ review of new book Nicola Sturgeon was mocked after she was compared…Jul 18, 16:33
  • A tall tale



↑ Top