The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Eight green bottles

Posted on May 05, 2013 by

18 to “Eight green bottles”

  1. beachthistle says:

    When I worked at DFID (apparently as a life saving Scot) his Doogieness became Minister/Secretary of State. Outside the East Kilbride office front-door were several flagpoles – the Union Jack was on one, the Saltire on another. The day after Alexander was appointed, the Saltire disappeared…
    Also disingenuous to suggest whole DFID programme is ‘delivered’ by officials in East Kilbride – DFID’s large Whitehall office has almost all the senior officials and ALL the Ministers’ offices – and these days almost everything has to signed off in London before a penny can be spent.

    Reply
  2. Mosstrooper says:

    I bet the poor in India and South Africa will be happy we’re all in this together.

    Reply
  3. southernscot says:

    Another trough for the elite to fill there boots.
    The Department for International Development (DFID) paid almost £500million last year to consultants, mostly British, many of whom earn six, even seven-figure incomes, courtesy of the taxpayer.
    Good article from radical independence org about “foreign  aid” from January this year.

    Reply
  4. pmcrek says:

    Now presumably an independent Scotland could spend more on aid than we do right now as a proportion of the UK’s spending, thus independence would mean more money on international aid being donated from these isles. Lets take a look:
     
    link to en.wikipedia.org
     
    1. Sweeden – 1.45%
    2. Norway – 1.06%
    3. Luxembourg – 1.04%
    4. Denmark – 0.88%
    5. Netherlands – 0.82%
    <SNIP..>
    10. UK – 0.52%
     
    So, if you support higher levels of Brittish spending on international aid, vote yes and collectively we will be donating more than we do now. Of course we could also stipulate that the aid money we provide be spent on well… “aid” as opposed to earmarking some of the aid budget for UK military endeavors abroad:
     
    link to bbc.co.uk
     
    Another reason to vote Yes.
     
    Lastly, perhaps things like this wont happen anymore with our aid money:
     
    link to en.wikipedia.org
    link to en.wikipedia.org
     
     

    Reply
  5. Aplinal says:

    I sem to recall that AS stated that an Independent Scotland would commit to 0.75% to Aid?  Will need to check.  But Scotland can easily afford it if that’s what a future Scottish government decided. 

    EDIT: From Scotsman article
    Mr Yousaf said that the SNP would also seek to exceed UN targets for nations to dedicate 0.7 per cent of their gross national income to overseas development.

    He said: “We’ve already passed a resolution at our last parliamentary conference to say that, not only will we ensure that we meet the 0.7 per cent [UN spending target)] but we’ll look to go to 1 per cent.

    Reply
  6. Galen10 says:

    We should be committing to 1% like our Norwegian friends, and pushing hard to make sure people realise that this and so many other areas will be better if we start to move towards the Reid Foundation style Common Weal; the REAL way to head off unionist charges that nothing will be different if we keep the £, Queen, NATO etc, is to commit to some REALLY socially and politically progressive policies which aim to construct that kind of society!

    Reply
  7. Patrick Roden says:

    Europe by any chance ?
     
     
     
     
     

    Reply
  8. AmadeusMinkowski says:

     
    I thought it might be informative to make a brief comparative study of the rhetoric of those who defended slavery in the US and BitterTogether’s attempts to defend UKplc.
    %%%%%%%%%%%%%%
    The Southern (BitterTogether) Argument for Slavery* (Scots in UK):
    A comparitive study

    Defenders of slavery (Scots in UK) argued that freeing slaves (Scots) would lead to

    i) A profound and killing economic impact (Economic Uncertainty Myth)
    ii) Widespread unemployment and chaos (Economic Uncertainty and Fear)

    Defenders of slavery (Scots in UK) also argued that the status quo was truly better since owners (Westmonster) would protect and assist slaves (Scots) when they were sick and aged (Pensions Scare).
    *Source: link to ushistory.org

    Reply
  9. naebd says:

    Please post more “Amadeus minkovski”. You are not posting enough. More posts.

    Reply
  10. The Man in the Jar says:

    Aye like naebed said or we will take your highlighter away.

    Reply
  11. Dcanmore says:

    Well they certainly don’t give a frig about the poverty in their own back yard which has flourished for decades under their watch.

    Reply
  12. This is an extract from the (already out of date?) Judith Hart memorial speech given by Douglas Alexander on Friday, as reproduced on Labourhame.
    “Over recent years, Britain’s Department for International Development has rightly come to be seen as a global leader on aid effectiveness and I am proud that this year the UK will achieve the target set and worked for by Labour to meet the UN goal of committing 0.7% of our GNI on international development.  The road we have travelled is nowhere better exemplified than in our Tory Prime Minister, forced by public opinion, to meet and match Labour’s aid  commitment.”
    There was an article in the Guardian last week about the fact that the MoD were after aid money to fund their “humanitarian” projects.
    link to guardian.co.uk 
    The mixing up of military occupation and humanitarian aid makes Afghanistan a very dangerous place to work for humanitarian aid workers.
    There was a report out recently about the toxic legacy of depleted uranium munitions in Iraq. These were munitions that were fired by UK and US in Iraq and there is increasing evidence that they are causing birth defects and illness in children.  link to ikvpaxchristi.nl When I was reading Douglas Alexander’s Judith Hart “neighbourly – good samaritan” speech on Labourhame I couldnt help but think of the people of Iraq, do they think we have been a good neighbour? 
    Another aspect of UK foreign aid is the fact that DFID only give money to other organisations to do the work, unlike some other european countries DFID have no direct implementation humanitarian aid unit. In some circumstances direct implementation is a far more efficient way to deliver aid. I think that a humanitarian aid unit should be in the plan for an independent Scotland.

    Reply
  13. cynicalHighlander says:

    The BBC is one green bottle that needs complete recycling when they use our TV tax and hide it offshore! c13mins.55s in.
     
    link to zerohedge.com
     
     

    Reply
  14. David says:

    Saw a Bitter Together leaflet the other day. It said “FACT Independence is forever”. Personally I don’t see how they can claim this to be a fact. Surely nobody expects our current model of humans living in separate nation states to carry on for the remainder of human existence?

    Reply
  15. silver19 says:

    OT: Another great video from the folks behind the infamous ‘Top 10 Unionist Myths Debunked’ and ‘Precious Few Heroes’, 


     

    Reply
  16. clachangowk says:

    @David
     
     
    It is a very weak argument by the British nationalists. Let me give you an example of clear thinking on how one generation cannot impose its will on generations that come after it. This is from Immanuel Kant, a German of Scots descent:
     
     
     
    “One age cannot bind itself, and thus conspire, to place a succeeding one in a condition whereby it would be impossible for the later age to expand its knowledge (particularly where it is so very important), to rid itself of errors, and generally to increase its enlightenment. That would be a crime against human nature, whose essential destiny lies precisely in such progress; subsequent generations are thus completely justified in dismissing such agreements as unauthorised and criminal.  The criterion of everything that can be agreed upon as a law by a people lies in this question:  Can a people impose such a law on itself?” 
     
    I would suggest that this generation is trying to ” rid itself of errors” of a previous generation
     
     
     

    Reply
  17. Albert Herring says:

    @David
    If independence is forever, than the treaty of union can’t have happened. Brilliant!

    Reply
  18. G H Graham says:

    We shouldn’t give any other foreign government, institution, charity or person a single penny from public money. Most of it is spent on dignatories, executives, marketing & cocktail parties anyway. And what does get spent is usually countered by civil war, tribalism, murder, theft, cronyism & embezzlement.
    If your heart bleeds though, feel free to send your own money to poor folks in Botswana or Senegal if the act of giving makes you feel good.
    I strongly object to liberal types spending my tax receipts on pointless humanitarian programs when they wont send their own money cos apparently they need the money for a new telly.
     
     
     
     
     
     

    Reply


Comment - please read this page for comment rules. HTML tags like <i> and <b> are permitted. Use paragraph breaks in long comments. DO NOT SIGN YOUR COMMENTS, either with a name or a slogan. If your comment does not appear immediately, DO NOT REPOST IT. Ignore these rules and I WILL KILL YOU WITH HAMMERS.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,785 Posts, 1,221,345 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Young Lochinvar on Too Tight To Mention: “Wrong, wrong and just plain wrong again. Factchecker, you aren’t living up to your nom de guerre and really shouldn’t…Jul 4, 22:15
    • Hatey McHateface on The Con Merchant: “Ah, YL Sah! You do us all a power of good. Friday night, middle of summer to boot, lots of…Jul 4, 22:09
    • Hatey McHateface on The Con Merchant: ““So which colonising strand really presents the biggest threat?” It’s not rocket science, Alf. The one with the explosive vests…Jul 4, 21:58
    • Hatey McHateface on Too Tight To Mention: “Ah yes, CM. He was a friend to Scotland once. Not any more. If he’s on your side, Alf, give…Jul 4, 21:49
    • sarah on Too Tight To Mention: “I do support Liberate and would like it if every independence party/grouping came under its umbrella. However I doubt that…Jul 4, 21:45
    • Young Lochinvar on The Con Merchant: “Is that it Penisbreath? Hmmm.. Bit short and off the cuff there, catch you busy at the Gloryhole did the…Jul 4, 21:16
    • sarah on Too Tight To Mention: “It says a lot about Mrs Nicola Murrell’s humanity that she isn’t helping poor old Pete with his legal costs…Jul 4, 21:16
    • sarah on Too Tight To Mention: “@ diabloandco: benign neglect has resulted in me now having 2 raspberry beds instead of one and many outliers! You…Jul 4, 21:12
    • Sven on Too Tight To Mention: “Castoreum comes from Beavers’ Butts, eh. If it’s used in Nutella then perhaps an association of ideas led to Mr…Jul 4, 20:32
    • diabloandco on Too Tight To Mention: “Dan and Sarah , spare a thought for those of us who pick both fruits 2 at a time every…Jul 4, 20:04
    • Alf Baird on The Con Merchant: ““So which colonising strand really presents the biggest threat?” Important question, Hatey. Our friends Memmi, Fanon and Cesaire appear unanimous…Jul 4, 19:58
    • Anthem on Too Tight To Mention: “Lies, deceit, yes, we know.Jul 4, 19:38
    • Anthem on Too Tight To Mention: “Mark. We don’t want you or your ilk. What’s so hard to understand?Jul 4, 19:34
    • Alf Baird on Too Tight To Mention: “Great journalism by Craig Murray, Liberation Scotland’s ambassador to the UN. Meanwhile faux independence ‘leader’ Swinney has signed Scotland up…Jul 4, 19:31
    • Hatey McHateface on The Con Merchant: “He’s back! He’s sober? He’s fretting about shirt lifters! He’s taken near 12 hours to put that effort together :)…Jul 4, 19:06
    • sarah on Too Tight To Mention: “Dan, I think the Rev has shown us over the last few years through his coverage of “Pride” events, that…Jul 4, 19:04
    • Andrew scott on Too Tight To Mention: “#mark Agree he is as boring as fcuk with all his historical dribblings Usually NOTHING TO DO WITH THE REVS…Jul 4, 19:03
    • Alf Baird on Too Tight To Mention: ““A Government created from all the dregs of it’s own community.” We cannae expect much from a colonial administration run…Jul 4, 18:57
    • Young Lochinvar on The Con Merchant: “In reply to P3nisbreath McP3nisbreathface @ 7.30am. Bzzzz- wrong! Do not pass go, do not collect £200. I was going…Jul 4, 18:52
    • Dan on Too Tight To Mention: “OT. I’m fucking sick of eating strawberries. About a pound in weight a day for weeks has really torn the…Jul 4, 18:19
    • Captain Caveman on The Con Merchant: “My word, Northcode, you’ve suffered *three centuries* of oppression…? Crikey, keep quaffing the (still warm) Miso Mushroom Dragon Rolls says…Jul 4, 18:16
    • Hatey McHateface on The Con Merchant: “For you to be repeatedly re-incarnated as the same brutalised, shackled victim, over and over for 300 years, you must…Jul 4, 18:13
    • Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh on The Con Merchant: “Alf, identifying the language you champion with Pictish is semantic porridge stirred backwards and spiked with hallucinogenics. The truth is,…Jul 4, 18:08
    • Northcode on The Con Merchant: ““This permanent victimhood must be so exhausting” I am looking out of my study window here in my NoHo penthouse…Jul 4, 17:53
    • agent x on Too Tight To Mention: “sarah says: So raise the subject with friends and family. Try to keep it positive e.g. “the SNP needs help…Jul 4, 17:49
    • Mark Beggan on Too Tight To Mention: “For he who dwells in the past has no future.Jul 4, 16:56
    • TURABDIN on Too Tight To Mention: “The SNP acknowledged the «authority» of the British state when its mps took their seats in London. That was an…Jul 4, 16:55
    • agent x on Too Tight To Mention: “Chas says: 4 July, 2025 at 4:38 pm A question for Wings supporters-is there any one who actually reads the…Jul 4, 16:52
    • Hatey McHateface on The Con Merchant: “And now, NC, you’re just having a laugh. The only places speaking in Scots was ever banned was in schools.…Jul 4, 16:51
    • Mark Beggan on Too Tight To Mention: “For those who dwell in the Scottish past would do well to remember who won and why.Jul 4, 16:50
  • A tall tale



↑ Top