The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Devo max: not so hard to define after all

Posted on November 13, 2011 by

We hitherto haven't bothered adding the Caledonian Mercury to the Wings over Scotland link bar, because it appeared to be all but dead. After a promising start, updates had slowed to a trickle on Stewart Kirkpatrick's bold attempt at creating a new online-only Scottish quality newspaper staffed by proper journalists from all points on the political spectrum, and most of the ones that did appear – in the politics section at least – were in the form of the toe-curling "Friday song" posts.

However, we may have been a little hasty, as the CalMerc this week ran a really interesting and exclusive piece by Hamish Macdonnell about some parts of the UK which are already governed under arrangements strikingly similar to what most people would describe as "devo max". The Isle Of Man, for example, has full fiscal autonomy and cedes control of only immigration and defence to the UK, a status that you suspect the SNP would consider a very acceptable step along the path to full independence, and which has plainly not resulted in the Isle's sky falling in.

But enough spoilers. You can read the full story here.

Comment - please read this page for comment rules. HTML tags like <i> and <b> are permitted. Use paragraph breaks in long comments. DO NOT SIGN YOUR COMMENTS, either with a name or a slogan. If your comment does not appear immediately, DO NOT REPOST IT. Ignore these rules and I WILL KILL YOU WITH HAMMERS.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,904 Posts, 1,241,521 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh on And Nothing Happened Forever: “LEONARD COHEN: THE PARTISAN (World Tour 2008) www.youtube.com/watch?v=9RYy_8u4blk&list=RD9RYy_8u4blk&start_radio=1May 12, 00:52
    • Young Lochinvar on And Nothing Happened Forever: “FC You have the Protestant church to thank for that. And.. The “cringe”.. I recall speaking with a structural engineer…May 12, 00:05
    • Young Lochinvar on And Nothing Happened Forever: “SB At least you refrained from calling him the “venerable” Bede; father of history rewritten as Anglo Saxon (ie English)…May 11, 23:43
    • Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh on And Nothing Happened Forever: “You two must hate Gaelic very much indeed to obsessively “other” it as you do. You strongly champion the Scots…May 11, 23:16
    • Stevie on And Nothing Happened Forever: “The SNP “wins” : who is voting for these non’entities? I guess desperate still-holding-on-to-the-SNNP-is-an-indy-party fantasy. Detestable squabble of devo-bitches.May 11, 22:38
    • George Ferguson on And Nothing Happened Forever: “I would like to see some integrity in Scottish Institutions. So I am asking the Court of Session to rebuke…May 11, 22:22
    • Geri on And Nothing Happened Forever: “Aye, Transnational Capitalism. Parasites. Death to everything, cult. No borders No nationality. No religion. No biological sex. No working for…May 11, 21:47
    • Bilbo on And Nothing Happened Forever: “Another article from the Scotsman which gives opinion on the pound of flesh that the Greens will extract from Swinney…May 11, 21:08
    • Alf Baird on And Nothing Happened Forever: “Excellent analysis Northcode. Which we might extend further, thanks to the post-referendum survey, which found that those identifying primarily as…May 11, 21:03
    • Bilbo on And Nothing Happened Forever: “Just found this article: https://archive.is/cyZ50 Some good quotes: Both have occurred, but the biggest kick, as expected, the continuation of…May 11, 21:00
    • Bilbo on And Nothing Happened Forever: “https://archive.is/v2cy6 One man, who was 15 at the time, said Linden’s touching on the face or cheek was “relentless” but…May 11, 20:54
    • Aidan on And Nothing Happened Forever: “Oh Northcode by some distance, the long rambling absurd posts with no obvious audience and which don’t communicate any useful…May 11, 20:50
    • Southernbystander on And Nothing Happened Forever: “‘What of Philosopher King of the Picts, Nechtan (706-724, 728-9)?’ I hear you ask. Bede writes that relations between Northumbria…May 11, 20:49
    • Lorncal on And Nothing Happened Forever: “Joined when I was 13, having supported them from age 10/11. Now, it has to be 16, but, in the…May 11, 20:42
    • Chas on And Nothing Happened Forever: “I assume you are putting yourself forward for nomination? You will be hard pressed to usurp the aforementioned candidates. Good…May 11, 20:31
    • Bilbo on And Nothing Happened Forever: “I had posted a comment earlier whether the election of the Indian Trans candidate was valid. It looks like it…May 11, 20:27
    • Sven on And Nothing Happened Forever: “My thanks also, Fearghas for your posts. They’re teaching me a lot, which I do appreciate.May 11, 20:23
    • Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh on And Nothing Happened Forever: “Cynicus @ 5.26pm “ it would surely be more accurate to describe Pictish as a Celtic cousin?” —— Your quibble…May 11, 20:09
    • Ross on And Nothing Happened Forever: “Not the point I was making was it? The point is predictions are predictions only and wings dodnt get that…May 11, 19:59
    • Bilbo on And Nothing Happened Forever: “Swinney has the numbers in parliament where he can pick and choose which of the other political parties he wants…May 11, 19:55
    • Lorncal on And Nothing Happened Forever: “Just been listening to the news. Presenters peeing themselves with excitement at the thought of all the ‘characteristics’ in suits…May 11, 19:47
    • George Ferguson on And Nothing Happened Forever: “I wouldn’t classified support for a political party as faith. Or to be more accurate their manifesto pledges and in…May 11, 19:35
    • diabloandco on And Nothing Happened Forever: “I think I can suggest a few more nominees – very particularly those who offer nothing but snipe stupidly from…May 11, 19:31
    • 100%Yes on And Nothing Happened Forever: “Izzie, The SNP will ask for a section 30 and it will be turned down and you’ll hear nothing more…May 11, 19:29
    • 100%Yes on And Nothing Happened Forever: “Sturgeon joined when she was 14.May 11, 19:17
    • sarah on And Nothing Happened Forever: “2 Independents were on the H&I list – Duncan MacPherson got 4587 votes, 2.3%. Mick Rice got 226 votes. The…May 11, 19:17
    • Chas on And Nothing Happened Forever: “It’s competition time. Who writes the most shite? The learned professor or his chum Northclown? It looks pretty level to…May 11, 19:03
    • Dan on And Nothing Happened Forever: “Talking of Faith (Paloma stylée)… I think you’ll find with regard to your NuSNP; The truth of it is they…May 11, 18:54
    • Northcode on And Nothing Happened Forever: “Exactly so, Alf… succinctly put. It’s a simple notion, the idea that the Picts became what we now think of…May 11, 18:32
    • Izzie on And Nothing Happened Forever: “REV STU@ 5.36. Oh dear you are better than thatMay 11, 18:26
  • A tall tale



↑ Top