The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Cameron misplaces marbles

Posted on January 09, 2012 by

Well, the Prime Minister dropped the hint on the Andrew Marr show, now the Guardian has dropped the bomb – the UK government wants to force the Scottish Government's hand on the timing of an independence referendum, offering the chance to make the referendum "binding", but only if it's held in the next 18 months. It's a dramatic development for sure, but the briefest of glances below the surface suggests that perhaps it's not the apocalypse a lot of pundits on both sides of the debate are presenting it as, for some pretty obvious reasons.

1. It is, so far as we're told, still just an offer. If Salmond says "No thanks, we'll do it in 2015 like we were going to anyway", what will Cameron do? Refuse to accept the result when it comes? Send in the tanks to prevent Scotland leaving if it votes Yes to independence? The idea is ludicrous. Wendy Alexander tried to rush the SNP into a referendum in 2008 and failed, there's no reason to imagine Cameron will have any more success.

2. It's an offer that isn't actually in Cameron's power to offer. ALL referenda in the UK are consultative, not binding. Even if Westminster ran its own referendum it wouldn't be legally binding, so it can't confer that ability on any other authority.

3. The two parties of the coalition both stood on an election platform of opposing a referendum on Scottish independence. They have no mandate whatsoever to bring one forward on behalf of the British people, let alone the Scottish people. (Between them they command a miserable 20% support in Scotland.) The electorate, on the other hand, voted overwhelmingly to give the SNP the power to conduct one whenever it chose.

4. It's a clear show of weakness and fright from the pro-Union camp. Why such a short timespan? What are they scared of? If they were confident that Scots didn't want independence it wouldn't matter when the poll was held. All it will do is fuel the SNP's conviction – and very probably the public perception – that opinion is travelling in the direction of independence, and that they can win the vote on their own terms and in their own time.

All this clumsy intervention is likely to achieve is to anger Scots who don't want to be told by an Eton millionaire how to run their affairs. We're not sure what Cameron's on, but after watching this evening's episode of Sherlock we suspect he might have been strolling in Dewar's Hollow. The name would certainly be appropriate.

2 to “Cameron misplaces marbles”

  1. passing through says:

    use this cool hash tag on twitter. tell all your friends. >
    #cyberfuds

    Reply
  2. Rusty Shackleford says:

    link to thedailymash.co.uk
    I kinda feel this sums things up a bit.

    Reply


Comment - please read this page for comment rules. HTML tags like <i> and <b> are permitted. Use paragraph breaks in long comments. DO NOT SIGN YOUR COMMENTS, either with a name or a slogan. If your comment does not appear immediately, DO NOT REPOST IT. Ignore these rules and I WILL KILL YOU WITH HAMMERS.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,830 Posts, 1,229,099 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh on Courage Calls To None: “Or to be more precise, the following ‘Dictionars o the Scots Leid’ entry: SCOTS: AN OUTLINE HISTORY https://dsl.ac.uk/about-scots/an-outline-history-of-scots/origins/Oct 22, 20:50
    • Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh on The Icarus Folly: “MET POLICE SCRAPS INVESTIGATIONS OF NON-CRIME HATE INCIDENTS The Metropolitan Police has announced that it will no longer investigate allegations…Oct 22, 20:41
    • Northcode on Courage Calls To None: “Good call, Fergus. Thanks for reminding me. Dictionars o the Scots LeidOct 22, 20:26
    • robertkknight on The Icarus Folly: “Well John, can I supply with with an explanatory quote from the Rev, a mere 5 hours ago on X……Oct 22, 20:18
    • Craig on The Icarus Folly: “Independence hasn’t been a live issue since Nicola took over and killed the SNP as a party for Scotland’s independence,…Oct 22, 20:01
    • robertkknight on The Icarus Folly: “Hoisted by his own petard. Bring a tear to a glass eye, so it would. If I had one…Oct 22, 19:58
    • Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh on Courage Calls To None: “« Now what’s so difficult about that to understand? » _____________ Any link to the language you champion.Oct 22, 19:48
    • John Foerster on The Icarus Folly: “Ok, so I can’t help but observing: the main thrust of the entries on this website have morphed into pieces…Oct 22, 19:47
    • Northcode on Courage Calls To None: ““…indigenous Scots are a very exclusive group… Aye, it’s a sad business richt enough fir thaim desperate tae be cawd…Oct 22, 19:26
    • James on The Icarus Folly: “Only 8 posts in and here’s #SP1 shilling for Fish face already. *Yawn*Oct 22, 19:21
    • Aidan on Courage Calls To None: “In your experience counsel are pretty thick – alright well I’m sure someone like yourself would know. I’m sure you’ve…Oct 22, 19:16
    • Hatey McHateface on Courage Calls To None: “Indigenous Scots are the people who voted Yes in 2014. Turns out they’re also the same people as the Sovereign…Oct 22, 18:31
    • Hatey McHateface on The Icarus Folly: “As Rev Stu points out, Scotland will continue to languish in the Dark Ages. That might change if the SNP…Oct 22, 18:15
    • factchecker on Courage Calls To None: “Andy asked a very pertinent question. NC has provided a simplistic reply that presumably excludes all those Scots who are…Oct 22, 18:12
    • Hatey McHateface on Courage Calls To None: “Bye Jay. There’s never a day goes by without nobody missing your contributions.Oct 22, 18:10
    • Dave Hansell on The Icarus Folly: “In terms of the general principle, this is a long overdue development. Let’s hope that this decision is not limited…Oct 22, 18:05
    • joolz on The Icarus Folly: “The piece only mentions England and Wales. I doubt that the Scottish government would do anything so sensible. Euan Sparkles…Oct 22, 17:38
    • Mark Beggan on The Icarus Folly: “Well said Rev.Oct 22, 17:20
    • twathater on Courage Calls To None: “David you may not be aware of it but John Main just morphed eventually into Hatey McHateface he changed his…Oct 22, 17:13
    • sarah on The Icarus Folly: “Hurray! Your quality of life should be hugely improved by this as well, Rev – thank goodness.Oct 22, 16:52
    • Athanasius on The Icarus Folly: “Proper order. Coppers have no business investigating “non crimes.”Oct 22, 16:47
    • Craig on The Icarus Folly: “At long fuckin last, such a shame so many suffered at the hands of the extreme trans activists and shame…Oct 22, 16:46
    • David Holden on Courage Calls To None: “My goodness it is getting a tad messy in here as the troll collective starts to try to muddy the…Oct 22, 16:43
    • Heaver on The Icarus Folly: “Bless him. In the fullness of time he might get some sort of comedy material out of all he’s been…Oct 22, 16:42
    • James on Courage Calls To None: “Who’s “Randy Andy”?Oct 22, 16:22
    • Northcode on Courage Calls To None: “Indigenous: originating or occurring naturally in a particular place; native: Scot: a native of Scotland or a person of Scottish…Oct 22, 15:57
    • Jay on Courage Calls To None: “Where “potty mouthed infantilism” is concerned, no-one can match that hypocrite. Only saw it by accident having virtually given up…Oct 22, 15:48
    • Andy Wiltshire on Courage Calls To None: “Confused again as usual. The ‘indigenous Scots’ get mentioned a lot on here, but who are they? Can you settle…Oct 22, 15:34
    • TURABDIN on Courage Calls To None: “IN THE SCOT.NAT UNIVERSE what has happened to localism and the concept of civil society which in the old days…Oct 22, 15:29
    • Northcode on Courage Calls To None: ““Well, I aims to please…” Way to go, Caveman. This is perhaps the very first time I’ve enjoyed reading any…Oct 22, 15:26
  • A tall tale



↑ Top