The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Blankety blanks

Posted on June 06, 2013 by

One of the odder quirks about the BBC iPlayer is that it’ll let you rewind live TV broadcasts for up to two hours, but not radio, despite radio using vastly less bandwidth. So at the moment we can’t bring you a verified quote that Liam Byrne really just told Radio 4’s Today programme that the idea of rent controls as a solution to the UK’s housing benefit bill was “going a bit too far”.

liambyrne

But there’s another new Labour welfare policy that’s missing a fairly vital chunk of information this morning, which is even more worrying than the shadow Secretary of State for Work and Pensions having less intelligence, insight, principle and moral courage than a starving weasel.

The BBC News website, along with many other media outlets, carries a piece on Ed Miliband’s imminent speech about welfare. Among other things, it claims that:

“The Labour leader will say ‘people’s faith in the system has been shaken’ by the appearance that a minority of people are getting ‘something for nothing and other people nothing for something.’

He will pledge to restore the ‘contributory principle’ to jobseeker’s allowance, so that only people who have paid in ‘for significantly longer’ than the current minimum of two years will be eligible.”

We scoured the article repeatedly, but fruitlessly, for news of what Labour proposed would happen to everyone without a job who didn’t meet those criteria.

What of school-leavers unable to find work despite what Labour acknowledges to be crippling levels of youth unemployment? What about mothers who hadn’t previously worked but were forced into the job market to help support their family? What of the severely disabled not previously expected to work but now pushed onto the dole queues by Atos and their brutal “Work Capability Assessments” (invented by Labour and continued by the coalition)?

Britain’s pittance of a payment to the unemployed is already the lowest in Europe (see p.9, section 4). Now it seems that Labour plans to take even that away from those who need it the most. But how exactly are those people supposed to live? Are we the only ones interested in even asking the question?

47 to “Blankety blanks”

  1. HandandShrimp says:

    But still we are Better Together.
     
    I think think they would say that even if UKIP was in power and the swivel eyed ones brought back the Workhouse. In fact Labour would probably look to realign its policies so it was more attractive to those who want to skin and eat the poor.  

    Reply
  2. Gordon Hay says:

    Is this simply sound-bite politics of the ‘look how tough we can be’ kind, or is he really saying they would scrap income-based JSA (and other income-related benefits too) which is currently the alternative basis to contribution-based payment for all those groups cited by the Rev.
     
    Do they think these things through or are they being deliberately obtuse? Hmm

    Reply
  3. jr ewen says:

    targeting the weakest again.

    Reply
  4. Doug Daniel says:

    “But how exactly are those people supposed to live? Are we the only ones interested in even asking the question?”
     
    That’s easy, Stu – why do you think Labour are so keen to see a growth in foodbanks? In Labour’s Brave New World, welfare shall be provided by charities. Why waste taxpayers money on something that charities will do for free?
     
    And there’s always perfectly good food sitting in supermarket dumpsters, which is only half-rotten.

    Reply
  5. MajorBloodnok says:

    You know what – someone should create a left wing party demonstrating honesty, integrity and socialists ideas with a vision to reject all these neo-con verities and to create a different and more equitable society.
     
    There’s plenty of room for one on the main-stream political spectrum now and you never know, someone might vote for them.

    Reply
  6. But how exactly are those people supposed to live?
     
    link to twitter.com – clearly!
     
    🙁

    Reply
  7. HandandShrimp says:

    Liam didn’t think there aws any money left back in 2010. The Coalition policies have crippled growth and increased debt. It would seem that despite all the noises made in opposition, Labour would be just as Draconian.
     
    There is no alternative (TINA)
     
    TINA actually refers to Westminster and our political choices not economics. We do have a choice in 2014. Let’s grasp it with both hands because if we vote No hands might be a taxable luxury in a future UK.  

    Reply
  8. HandandShrimp says:

    PS has Ed said anything about Soylent Green yet?

    Reply
  9. Desimond says:

    Labour the Party of Work isnt Working.
    Crazy Stuff. Eevry day it seems its yet another Self-Respect Bison falling over a Cliff…i trust U2’s One is playing at Labour Party Headquarters come election and referendum  time.
    new Labour – Willing to whore itself to anyone for a shot at the prize!

    Reply
  10. Red squirrel says:

    What about basic human decency? Oh silly me, forgetting this was Labour.
    the really scary thing is that this is playing to the voters – just who are these folk & why are their twisted values more important than a more equal society? Oh filthy money, oh I see.
    further proof if any is needed of the evils of the Anglo-American capitalist model. All UK parties should hold their heads in shame for this disgraceful race to see who can screw the poor the most. We have to aspire to better things – on the present evidence, it is quite depressing that we won’t have to try that hard.

    Reply
  11. Stevie says:

    Stuart – the link when posted on my FB page looks unimpressive and uninviting – it needs a picture in order to make people wish to click the link to the WOS page

    Reply
    • Rev. Stuart Campbell says:

      “Stuart – the link when posted on my FB page looks unimpressive and uninviting – it needs a picture in order to make people wish to click the link to the WOS page”

      Um, it’s got a picture.

      Reply
  12. Max says:

    A line has been drawn.
     
    The UKUNT parties (United Kingdom UNionists Together) are all on one side, alongside various right-wing nut jobs, and we the people are on the other. 
     
    Perhaps its time for our own version of the Arab Spring. Enough is enough.
     

    Reply
  13. Desimond says:

    At which point will someone ask “So if every penny counts…do we really need a replacement for Trident and discussions on an increase in MPs salaries then?”

    Reply
  14. Alex Taylor says:

    I just got the end of Radio 5 Live’s phone-in on the subject of wind power.
    Completely off topic, a clearly very patriotic old Scot based in England claimed that the votes of the Yes side in next year’s referendum will need to be “weighed rather than counted” such is the clamour for an independent Scotland. He further stated, when Nicky Campbell said the polls show the opposite, that the BBC was only giving us the polls they want us to see.
    It was nice to hear even if it’s only one guys opinion. Sometimes you just need a wee bit of sunshine amidst the doom and gloom.
    But oh how I hope he’s right.

    Reply
  15. John Lyons says:

    Max, I’m not an advocate of violence and hope we can achieve independence without bloodshed, but I thouroughly believe it’s peaceful political independence now or bloody revolution later. There’s only so much shit people can take, and this government has dumped a LOT of shit on the people and that’s UK wide, not just Scotland.

    Reply
  16. Max says:

     
    Ed Miliband, “Not a country where people who can work are on benefits.”
     
    Ed I think you’ll find that under both Labour and Coalition governments, far more working people were/are claiming benefits that those who were/are unemployed. 
     
    Why do you think that is Ed? Has a light go ON in that massive brain of yours? FI!

    Reply
  17. Luigi says:

    Max
    Ed’s head does resemble a light bulb. Unfortunately, it is not switched on.

    Reply
  18. ianbrotherhood says:

     
    Someone mentioned, in another thread a while ago, that the bookies were offering a bet that Milliband will never be PM. Anyone know if they’re still doing it?
     
    I’m not a gambler, but you wouldn’t have to be to foresee that this eviscerated scrotum has about as much chance of becoming Prime Minister as Johann Lamont has of being crowned Miss Scotland.

    Reply
    • Rev. Stuart Campbell says:

      “Someone mentioned, in another thread a while ago, that the bookies were offering a bet that Milliband will never be PM. Anyone know if they’re still doing it?”

      11/10 (ie double your money plus a bit) from Ladbrokes that he WON’T be PM before 2020 (effectively never):

      link to oddschecker.com

      Reply
  19. scottish_skier says:

    Survation poll on the EU puts Scotland way in favour (2:1 Yes) whilst England not.

    Interestingly, in this one, Scotland would keep England/the rUK in the EU LOL.

    link to survation.com

    Over 100 subset for Scotland so not a bad indicator.

    Reply
    • Rev. Stuart Campbell says:

      “Over 100 subset for Scotland so not a bad indicator.”

      I have to disagree. Anything below 1000 is unsatisfactory, and below 500 basically a total waste of time.

      Reply
  20. scottish_skier says:

    In theory a 10% error rev. Although that would apply if weighted to Scotland alone, rather than weighted to the UK as is. 16.5% would be needed for neck and neck.

    link to ukpollingreport.co.uk

    link to comres.co.uk

    Either way, it’s just another indicator of Scotland being Yes to the EU as per other polls.

    I expect support for the EU to rise more in Scotland. I mean if lots of Tories want out and UKIP too, there must be something good about it surely?

    😉

    Reply
  21. ianbrotherhood says:

    @Rev-
     
    That link is brilliant.
     
    ‘Ed Miliband Specials’!!
     
    A plausible nickname for crotchless Y-fronts.

    Reply
  22. scottish_skier says:

    Also, probability means the bigger an error is, the less likely it is to occur. Does not prevent one occurring, but make it statistically more unlikely.
    For this reason, it is extraordinarily rare to find an EU poll subset where Scotland wants to leave, even in the case of Yougov which is biased towards unionist parties due to weighting methods.

    Reply
  23. Ken Johnston says:

    On the Oddschecker site, YES for Independence, 55% NO 45%.
    Need to get another £50 on before the odds shorten.For some reason, I don’t bet, Hill would only take a £50 bet, I wanted £100.
     

    Reply
  24. Brian Ritchie says:

    “Stuart – the link when posted on my FB page looks unimpressive and uninviting – it needs a picture in order to make people wish to click the link to the WOS page”
    Um, it’s got a picture.
    It’s a Facebook thing – sometimes it won’t post a pic.  Best to try again later.

    Reply
  25. Geoff Huijer says:

    Reply
  26. Tonia Wight says:

    I felt sick when I read this morning that Job Seekers allowance would only be available if you had already contributed under Labours plans. We are risking creating a country where people starve on the street, homeless for life. Basically we are talking about going back to Victorian times. Seriously. I feel properly ill at such suggestions.

    Reply
  27. Jamie Arriere says:

    Ed’s head does resemble a light bulb. Unfortunately, it is not switched on….
     
    and the wee wiry filament in it is hanging loose…..

    Reply
  28. Jamie Arriere says:

    BREAKING NEWS!! Labour has just announced a complete reversal of everything they’ve been proposing for the past couple of years.
     
    With a Labour government, the people of Britain are now going to get NOTHING for SOMETHING!!

    Reply
  29. Jamie Arriere says:

    OK no more jokes and smart-arsed comments.
    The welfare state was and still is the glue that unites the kingdom(s) between those people with and those without, the rich and the poor, the able-bodied and the disabled, the healthy and the sick – the fulcrum of the redistribution of wealth. The political heart of Christian values. If Labour, YES LABOUR, who spent the first half of their history campaigning to establish it, are proposing to start compressing the throat of the system (who knows where they’ll stop?) with no details of a safety net below and no details or ideas of how to revive the economy and gather more taxes/prevent avoidance, then there’s no way there’ll ever be a united country, even if everybody voted No.
    YES is the only vote!

    Reply
  30. Robin Ross says:

    Sorry to take issue with you, Stu, but this time you are guilty of the grossest cullumny on starving weasels.
    Jimmy Reid said ‘the rat race is for rats – we’re human’.  The Labour volte face on just about every one of their principles cannot be likened to any activity in the animal kingdom, but increasingly lacks the one essential ingredient required of a civilised society – namely humanity.

    Reply
  31. ianbrotherhood says:

     
    Have been reading American Dynasty by Kevin Phillips. Having to take it very sloooow as it’s got lots of numbers and dates etc…anyway, FWIW, perhaps what we’re seeing here, right now, is the bigger Bush chickens coming home to roost – military-industrial complex/Texanomics, utter corruption, state being forced to cover corporate theft, cronyism gone haywire, the gentrification of inner cities, state-support of all kinds sliced at both ends until they’re chopping thin-air…and perhaps worst of all, the criminalisation of people whose poverty is deemed ‘offensive’ by the guilt-riddled one-per-cent who keep getting richer without lifting a finger. 
     
    They’re laughing, taunting, daring us – Occupy, Anonymous, any ‘active’ sector of society, bloggers generally – to defy them. If we do, we get the full ‘Enemy Within’, ‘Al Qaeda cell’ ‘Pinko Subversives’ labels, along with a face full of pepper-spray followed by a truncheon right across the napper and a couple of taser-blasts for good measure.
     
    They couldn’t make it any more obvious if they tried – they want a showdown.

    Reply
  32. CameronB says:

    @ Ianbrotherhood
    I would appear that Enron style accounting has become the norm. Ken Ley (former head of Enron), was a close friend of the Bushes and a major contributor to the ‘shrub’s’ election funds. It seems as if Enron may even had Federal assistance in their corporate malfeasance, but we will never know as all the evidence collected for the investigation was destroyed on that fateful Autumn day in Manhattan. This documentary is a pretty good place to start, if you want to look in to it yourself.  link to imdb.com
     
    I don’t think ‘they’ want a showdown as they are ‘incremental-ists’. Ever played with a ruler, to see how far it would bend before it broke?

    Reply
  33. drygrangebull says:

    I know this is o/t but please check out press tv …anti independance , prepare to be love bombed….lol I am the biggest luddite out there so don’t know too much about pasting on a tablet

    Reply
  34. scottish_skier says:

    link to bbc.co.uk

    OT but check out the comments on the compensation payouts to people put in concentration camps and tortured by the colonial British in Kenya.

    Let’s just say the popular ones are not about feeling guilty and trying to make amends for Britain’s crimes.

    You’ve got people saying ‘This was like out great grandparents time..is ancient history’ as excuses. I understood Lizzie was Queen at the time and I imagine there’s a good few in the House of Lords who were around.

    Some folks certainly don’t like being reminded how nasty Britain is at times.

    Reply
  35. john king says:

    “I’m not a gambler, but you wouldn’t have to be to foresee that this eviscerated scrotum has about as much chance of becoming Prime Minister as Johann Lamont has of being crowned Miss Scotland.”

    Oh I dont know? if you get her in a certain light?
     wha? what ? 
    oh what a horrible dream, I just dreamt Joanne Lamont was crowned miss Scotland, and her crown was an eviscerated scrotum
    I really must stop drinking that terrible English wine

    Reply
  36. ianbrotherhood says:

     
    @john king-
     
    I should stress that I wasn’t decrying Johann Lamont’s physical appearance – she is a fine figure of a woman and does have a certain aura when she smiles. But the simple fact is that she would have no chance of winning Miss Scotland because of her extreme political views. 

    Reply
  37. reginald says:

    If Atos deems you fit for work and you toddle along to the DWP to sign up for availability for employment,there are two streams open to a claiment for financial support.ONE==If you have a recent history of work you will have accrued credits but if you have been on benefits for years this stream is not open to you.The other stream is if you are bereft of any means of support you are eligible for help. I forget the parameters that make you qualified for this second stream but healthy savings is obviously  a disqualification. 

    Reply
  38. john king says:

    ” should stress that I wasn’t decrying Johann Lamont’s physical appearance – she is a fine figure of a woman and does have a certain aura when she smiles.”
    really? and not because she looks like a bulldog chewing wasp then? 🙂

    Reply
  39. CameronB says:

    @ ianbrotherhood
    Lambrinied already?

    Reply
  40. ianbrotherhood says:

     
    @CameronB-
     
    Shertainly not.
     
    BTW, what’s this stushie I half-heard about on radio about Lord Strathclyde saying something offensive about Scotland? Haven’t been able to catch the news all night…

    Reply
  41. ianbrotherhood says:

     
    @john king-
     
    Be honest man. Have you ever seen Johann smile? The transformation is incredible – reminds me of my favourite dinner lady at primary school, and she only ever smiled when we protested at finding intact blood vessels in our mince.

    Reply
  42. Alastair Naughton says:

    @ CameronB
    Lord Strathclyde is always saying something offensive – it’s nothing unusual. It was him who said that an rUK government would have to bomb an independent Scotland’s airports if they represented a security risk.
     
    On a separate note, but in keeping with the topic in general, speaking of how far to the extreme right middle England has swung, I saw a headline in the Daily Telegraph yesterday (Wed. 5 June) saying that David Cameron pledged to “drain the swamp of extremism” in Britain. Giving him the benefit of the doubt and assuming that he does in fact mean ALL forms of extremism, from Islamic hate preachers to the English Defence League, it is interesting to see that UKIP obviously does NOT count as an extreme party in England any longer. In fact, many “mainstream” Tories are considering defecting, and if not, then at least openly calling for co-operation with them. Compare and contrast this with the reception Farage received in Edinburgh, and you can see quite clearly that the UK is no longer fit for purpose, if it ever was. 

    Reply
  43. Holebender says:

    The Lord Strathclyde thing; there were reports on Twitter that he had been speaking at the inaugural meeting of Better Together in London and he said (twice) that there was a poison at the heart of Scottish politics and he unambiguously meant the SNP/independence movement. As usual, this got top billing on the BBC… or not.

    Reply


Comment - please read this page for comment rules. HTML tags like <i> and <b> are permitted. Use paragraph breaks in long comments. DO NOT SIGN YOUR COMMENTS, either with a name or a slogan. If your comment does not appear immediately, DO NOT REPOST IT. Ignore these rules and I WILL KILL YOU WITH HAMMERS.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a (mainly) Scottish political media digest and monitor, which also offers its own commentary. (More)

    Stats: 6,753 Posts, 1,217,454 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Anna on A Poor Example: “Not for us in Scotland it won’tMay 9, 16:42
    • Yoon Scum on A Poor Example: “There is part of me that wishes the far left get their dream of Scotland becoming an islamic state Would…May 9, 16:24
    • Sven on A Poor Example: “It all just seemed so obvious only a decade ago; Biological men are men. Biological women are women. Anyone gets…May 9, 15:23
    • stonefree on A Poor Example: “It stinks like a Sturgeon-esk Franchise 34 Quid off,Decent people are not welcomeMay 9, 15:11
    • Dunx on The Last Thing They’ll Expect: “@Michael England does generate a lot of wind power. They are not helping themselves. The wind companies pay the SG…May 9, 14:58
    • Vivian O’Blivion on A Poor Example: “YouGov, British attitudes towards discrimination in the workplace, published 9th May. By group, do you think positive discrimination has gone…May 9, 14:19
    • Andrea on A Poor Example: “Would it be allowed to have an event that is for women AND trans woman? I should think so, but…May 9, 14:02
    • Vivian O’Blivion on A Poor Example: “As someone who lives across the road from a Mosque, I can assure you they wouldn’t admit chicks with dicks…May 9, 13:56
    • Aidan on The Last Thing They’ll Expect: “@Michael – you’re talking about the wind here, not some hugely valuable unique energy resources (e.g. oil and gas) which…May 9, 13:52
    • factchecker on The Last Thing They’ll Expect: “Wonderful to see some rationality here. Two comments. You say ‘we believe independence to be a normal situation’. I would…May 9, 13:24
    • 1971Thistle on The Last Thing They’ll Expect: “I would agree. Has there been a drop off in the number of ‘anon’ comments on blog? He seems to…May 9, 13:22
    • Stuart MacKay on The Last Thing They’ll Expect: “The Stalker probably sits all day clicking on the links, with the result that his blog is currently sitting in…May 9, 13:11
    • Michael Laing on The Last Thing They’ll Expect: “@ Dunx: So we’ve to thank England for helping itself to Scotland’s energy and selling it back to us at…May 9, 13:05
    • Lorn on The Last Thing They’ll Expect: “Also, Yon, politicians used to at least try and explain their policies to the people. Now, they just ignore all…May 9, 13:00
    • Confused on All Or Nothing: ““sons of satan” and “enemies of the human race” (*) – do you not read your bible, main? I would…May 9, 12:58
    • Captain Caveman on The Last Thing They’ll Expect: “Reform – and only Reform. Even the Tories can’t be trusted, particularly concerning “net zero” nonsense. (As for the rest…May 9, 12:57
    • Lorn on The Last Thing They’ll Expect: “Yoon, to set up a crowdfunder around like-minded people and build a case to take to the courts. Plenty of…May 9, 12:52
    • sarah on The Last Thing They’ll Expect: “Real independence alternative candidates for constituencies AND list: Indy4Indy and ISP will start announcing names in the next few days,…May 9, 12:23
    • James Cheyne on The Last Thing They’ll Expect: “Simplfied version Controversial but true. Save Scotland first and return it to full independence and automatically it carries a reset…May 9, 12:05
    • Lorn on The Last Thing They’ll Expect: “Hatey, the oil and gas are on the wane, although far from finished. Of course we have been lied to…May 9, 11:02
    • Aidan on The Last Thing They’ll Expect: “@Andy – it is actually a good thing that the Green’s exist in some ways. There are a small but…May 9, 10:55
    • Lorn on The Last Thing They’ll Expect: “Sorry, Yoon, if you are answering me, yet again, none of that makes any sense. I have said consistently try…May 9, 10:50
    • Aidan on All Or Nothing: “@Dan – I don’t think that’s wholly fair, Stu has put forward two alternative approaches in the last 6 months.…May 9, 10:50
    • Dunx on The Last Thing They’ll Expect: “Without the English market Scotland’s wind farms wouldn’t exist at anywhere the current level. After indy I expect England will…May 9, 10:40
    • Sven on The Last Thing They’ll Expect: “100%Yes Wish no more … I’m guessing you’ve just managed to get his back up, more bristly than a stickleback…May 9, 09:36
    • Dan on All Or Nothing: “Aye, good post Robert. I only drop in occasionally now as the latest site change means it’s now back to…May 9, 09:30
    • desimond on The Last Thing They’ll Expect: “It must be so cosy when youre part of ‘The system’. The lovely warm feeling inside as your eyes slowly…May 9, 09:28
    • Andy Ellis on The Last Thing They’ll Expect: “Hardly a surprise surely? As polling consistently shows, you can expect around 10% of those polled to vote for virtually…May 9, 09:17
    • Rich on The Last Thing They’ll Expect: “And the Gaza issue, you didn’t address that part?May 9, 09:09
    • Anthem on The Last Thing They’ll Expect: “OT. Has anyone actually noticed that the English government has provided £600m to support a project that steals energy from…May 9, 08:42
  • A tall tale



↑ Top