The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Abide with us

Posted on November 11, 2012 by

We read something odd in the Herald yesterday.

“In a joint statement, Labour’s Johann Lamont, Tory leader Ruth Davidson and the Liberal Democrats’ Willie Rennie said: “It is vital that the referendum properly reflects the will of the Scottish people. We look forward to hearing the views of the Electoral Commission and will abide by its ruling.”

In the same spirit of magnanimity, Wings Over Scotland would like to humbly and solemnly announce that from today onwards we will abide by the law of gravity and the requirement for human beings to breathe oxygen in order to respire. Thank you.

12 to “Abide with us”

  1. dadsarmy says:

    They’re wrong anyway. The Electoral Commission can’t and won’t rule – it advises. So much for the knowledge and understanding of the leaders of the three opposition parties in Scotland – they need to get educated in how democracy works. Or how it’s best to put brain into gear before disengaging clutch on vocal reality.

    Reply
  2. Aplinal says:

    And for those who think that the EC’s “advice” is mandatory, just refer them to the Westminster government’s own selective use of the EC recommendations in the past.  The EC offers opinion, which governments can (and in Westminster’s case) do reject.

    Reply
  3. Ron says:

    And as Kevin Pringle pointed out on twitter:
    “UK Govt on English Council Tax referendums: “we disagreed with its [Electoral Commission’s] suggestion for the wording”
    Mickey Moore misled the Holyrood Committee, the Westminister Committee, and Westminister House of Commons when he claimed in all 3 that neither his government or the previous Labour govt had EVER ignored the advice of the EC. Didn’t he?

    Reply
  4. steven Luby says:

    It’s so entertaining to see wanna be leaders struggling to come to terms, with the terms of the Edinburgh Agreement. Between the 3 who had no influence on it’s making and coming together to ‘proclaim’ what they don’t understand. 

    Advice comes in many shapes and forms and most advice is double-edged,for these 3 characters from ‘the land that time may well wish to forget’, trying to highten the Electoral Commissions role to such dizzy heights of moral and law, describes 3 leaders who can’t function within the realms of reality.

    Oh well,another stage being set to discredit democracy,Scottish Gov,SNP and Alex Salmond. One day they may just wake up in 99% of the shite from their own making. But who would want to advise them in ways to avoid such a justifiable end! 

    Reply
  5. Juteman says:

    But what if the EC doesn’t reflect the will of the Scottish people?

    Reply
  6. McHaggis says:

    Unionists are going to have their flabbers gasted when – I would predict anyway – the EC return with confirmation the question is wholly acceptable to them… 

    Reply
  7. dadsarmy says:

    Some interesting stuff here:

    link to electoralcommission.org.uk


    1. Voters

    There should be no barriers to voters taking part. This means:

    ? voters are informed about the possible outcomes, and can easily understand the campaign arguments

    ? the result and its implications should be clear and understood

    ===============

    Ah, so the implications of a YES are that defence, foreign policies etc are either specified or explained – so it’s OK and in fact neccessary for the Scottish Government to commission 13 reports to fulfil this function (as it is for the UK gov to do its 16 reports).

    Oh, and I guess the NO campaign will want to tell all voters what the “implications” are of voting NO. Let me see now:

    1). Constant reduction of Barnett
    2). Eventual end to Universal Benefit
    3). Privatisation of the NHS
    4). Privatisation of Scottish Water
    5). Privatisation of Lamont, Davidson and Rennie
    etc.

    Reply
  8. velofello says:

    From their joint statement above “it is vital that the referendum properly reflects the will of the Scottish people…”.
    So a Devo-Max option, known to be a popular option of the Scottish people, is not available? An option the unionists were anxious not to include in the referendum yet they are now keen to nitpick around the single question of the referendum.

    I’m for independence yet I could recognise that Devo-Max could be a comfort blanket for some and would l believe,lead eventually to independence by a slower route. I suppose the unionists thought so too and so failed to put forward a Devo-Max option that would “the will of the Scottish people”.
    Rubbish, humbug,duplicity, and any swear words you wish to add to describe these tiresome, unscrupulous unionist nonentities. 

    Reply
  9. Jim Campbell says:

    Electoral Commission ?

    Nope, Nada, No Way !   Too many influences emanating from Westminster
    make that commissions decisions not exactly 100% unbiased
    – the C of E maybe or, better still, the UN should be chosen run and oversee
    the independence referendum.

    Maybe I am being  too suspicious or cynical but WESTMINSTER HAVE ALWAYS  LIED about Scottish finances, Scottish culture and our Scottish way of life.    Scotland is an energy rich country with a surplus  of gas, oil, hydro, wind and wave power, yet we have pensioners dying in the winter here from hydrothermia because of the high fuel taxes from Westminster and that includes both Labour and Tory governments.   Scotland puts in more taxes and revenues into the Westminster coffers that we get back in return. 

    VOTE YES AND LET SCOTLAND’S MONEY AND SCOTLAND’S NEEDS
    BE USED TO BENEFIT THE SCOTTISH PEOPLE.

    Reply
  10. Dcanmore says:

    What the Bitter Together lot are trying to say is we’ll use the EC as a stick to beat AS and the Scottish Government with. Any slight apprehension, doubt or concern from the EC regarding the referendum question will be magnified greatly by the Bitter Together and MSM to make AS and the Scottish Government look like shifty crooks treating the Scottish public as fools and the Bitter Together triumvirate will consistently bring up the issue over and over again to be seen as protectors of the Scottish electorate even if the issue is pure fantasy of their own making.

    Reply
  11. Arbroath 1320 says:

    “It is vital that the referendum properly reflects the will of the Scottish people.”
     
    Now would that mean the incompetent numpties who follow the dingbats around like nodding donkeys OR would that mean the people of Scotland who will vote in 2014?
     
    Personally I think they mean the former, none of the three dingbats give two hoots about the people who will be voting in 2014.

    Reply
  12. Arbroath 1320 says:

    The terrible threesome want the “question” to be acceptable to the Scottish people do they?
     
    Well here’s a question for the Terrible threesome. Should our armed forces be involved, in any way, in ground involvement in Syria?
     
    link to huffingtonpost.co.uk

    Reply


Comment - please read this page for comment rules. HTML tags like <i> and <b> are permitted. Use paragraph breaks in long comments. DO NOT SIGN YOUR COMMENTS, either with a name or a slogan. If your comment does not appear immediately, DO NOT REPOST IT. Ignore these rules and I WILL KILL YOU WITH HAMMERS.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a (mainly) Scottish political media digest and monitor, which also offers its own commentary. (More)

    Stats: 6,748 Posts, 1,216,964 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • joolz on For Children Scotland: “I welcome them dropping the ‘conversion’ bill but one of your headlines says ‘Scottish ministers shelve plans for new misogyny…May 2, 14:02
    • Aidan on For Children Scotland: “We all know conversion practices aimed at changing a person’s sexuality are abhorrent, but as far as I am aware…May 2, 13:55
    • Vivian O’Blivion on For Children Scotland: “The conversion therapy legislation in its fundamentalist drafting was substantially the brain fart of Emma Roddick when she was Meenister…May 2, 13:21
    • I. Despair on For Children Scotland: “A climbdown rooted in snivelling political expediency rather than intelligent principle, but welcome news all the same. Another strange and…May 2, 13:12
    • duncanio on For Children Scotland: “It’s bad news for the gender crazies so John the Vote Swindler trying to bury the bad news so as…May 2, 12:45
    • David on For Children Scotland: “It’s time for the conversation to return to nationalism vs globalism, and the case for the United Kingdom is in…May 2, 12:44
    • David on For Children Scotland: “Gender upsets me so much, because it stole Scottish Independence and it stole friendships at University for me, and in…May 2, 12:37
    • Scott on For Children Scotland: “Also planning to incorporate misogyny into the Hate Crime Act. Now, was that not suggested previously?May 2, 12:36
    • diabloandco on For Children Scotland: “Modest celebration going on here! Chocolate eclair and a cup of coffee!May 2, 12:28
    • James on The Takeover: “Aye, Alf…. Hope the give us a vote in their independence referendum too; we’ll gladly help them over the line…May 2, 11:17
    • Captain Caveman on The Takeover: “@Geri Well, I can’t speak for them, but I suspect they’ll have plenty of things to be getting on with,…May 2, 11:03
    • Geri on The Takeover: “Hold that penny, Cappy… Why would an English liberation political party be heading to Scotland? LOL? What is it they’re…May 2, 10:45
    • Geri on The Takeover: “Aye, the truth is always 180 degrees with Yoons. Since when did R become Greek? The term Oligarch originates from…May 2, 10:37
    • James Cheyne on The Takeover: “Let sleeping dogs lie. Cos at the end of the day there are people born in England that moved to…May 2, 10:11
    • TURABDIN on The Takeover: “You’re possibly referring to Generative Pre-trained Transformer 3 (GPT-3) and its sub variants. The creative element of this which some…May 2, 09:12
    • Captain Caveman on The Takeover: “Glad you agree, Alf! Reform is coming to Scotland too; no doubt your average Scot has had quite enough of…May 2, 09:01
    • Alf Baird on The Takeover: “English national liberation is also a good day for Scots.May 2, 08:21
    • Hatey McHateface on The Takeover: “Anybody determined to spend today hunched over the keyboard in their bedroom, with the curtains closed tightly against the beautiful…May 2, 07:43
    • Hatey McHateface on The Takeover: “Wheesht YS! Barbie & Confused are painting the windows on their mobile gas chamber van even as I write. You…May 2, 07:24
    • Hatey McHateface on The Takeover: “Aye, Confused, it’s da Dews, the shirt lifters and the English. All fighting it out in yer sad, sorry heid.…May 2, 07:19
    • Captain Caveman on The Takeover: “Well, another stellar day beckons for Reform. Another awful day for the Left. Spring in my step!May 2, 06:56
    • Aidan on The Takeover: “In what way did R get rid of its oligarchs? The term oligarch is from that country and used to…May 2, 06:24
    • Aidan on The Takeover: “@James – you’re right I got that wrong, the real figure is actually just over 6,000, with about 4,500 of…May 2, 06:22
    • Yoon Scum on The Takeover: “Geri How are you going to weed out scum like me Born in Scotland BUT Completely and utterly 100% ENGLISH…May 2, 05:58
    • Geri on The Takeover: “The English are still involved. They love a bit of terrorism. Pakistan was all about the Belt & Road &…May 2, 00:35
    • Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh on The Takeover: “NHS TO SCREEN GENDER-CONFUSED YOUNG PEOPLE FOR AUTISM The NHS plans to assess gender-confused children for autism and attention deficit…May 1, 23:53
    • James on The Takeover: ““…Faslane, 5,000 jobs…” big LOLZ. 700 more like and most of them jet home to Bristol/return to barracks every weekend.May 1, 23:16
    • James on The Takeover: ““Aidan” ; Just one loooong paragraph of BS following another. Some things never change. So, Jocks, get used to it;…May 1, 23:12
    • Confused on The Takeover: “It will be an interesting, hard, experimental, test of “civic nationalism” if india-pakistan kicks off for real. – but, but…May 1, 22:48
    • Geri on The Takeover: “Dan It’ll all be reversed when Scotland is independent. Governments should never have resorted to taking out loans from Oligarchies…May 1, 21:16
  • A tall tale



↑ Top