The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Tyre-kickers and time-wasters

Posted on January 16, 2013 by

We can’t even be bothered linking to Brian Wilson‘s latest load of “will-this-do?” money for old rope in The Scotsman. We also can’t be bothered refuting any of its infantile, defamatory lies, which would all embarrass any grown-up newspaper that retained a shred of pride in its content. And we’re not going to occupy any more of our valuable time demolishing the central argument, when Brian has so helpfully done it for us himself right in the middle of his own article.

HEADLINE
“Shetland has the right to go it alone”

COPY
“There is little evidence that Shetland particularly wants to be independent”

There is? That’s that all sorted out, then. We’ve got a long queue of drivelling eejits to deal with today, Brian – have a lollipop and move along, there’s a good wee lad.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

15 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Seasick Dave

Do you mean this Brian Wilson?

link to havana-energy.com

“Havana Energy’s partnership with Cuba aims to develop the country’s renewable energy resources and contribute to its economic well-being, energy self-sufficiency and environmental objectives. I look forward to a long and successful relationship.” 

Doug Daniel

“We’ve got a long queue of drivelling eejits to deal with today”

I’m guessing every one of them spoke in the House of Commons yesterday in that affront to democracy…?

Craig P

More chance of gaining Berwick than losing Shetland – though I believe all the island areas will thrive with greater autonomy. In fact almost everywhere will. I am hoping for a grassroots local government revolution come independence day!

ianbrotherhood

The Gandhi quote on the right is worth looking at every now and then – we seem to be past the ‘ignore’ and ‘laughing’ stages, and they’ve now come to fight. On the basis of what we heard yesterday, bookies will surely be rejigging the odds.

Luigi

Craig P,
How right you are. Berwick is not properly part oi England, only administered by England under an ancient agreement.
 

Silverytay

Luigi    Hazel Lewry had an interesting article in newsnetscotland on friday 26th August 2011 .
According to Hazel Berwick was annexed to England in 1746 , prior to that it was seemingly an independent city state . In the same article she states that people north of Berwick are still Scots and it would only take one person to demand what we in Scotland take for granted i.e . free prescriptions etc to open a whole can of worms .

Luigi

Silverytay,
I do not think that Berwick was ever fully absorbed by England. For example, there was an interesting article a few years back about how Berwick was still technically at war with Russia. This indicates that Berwick’s position in the UK remains unclear. Since Berwick is neither Scottish nor English, and both Scottish and English at the same time, then surely if the act of union is dissolved, the people of Berwick should be given the opportunity whether they want to be part of rUK, part of an independent Scotland, or a continued special arrangement. Whatever the people of Berwick decide, Scotland will respect them.

naebd

When it comes to annexing territory according to plebiscites, I’d rather not. We’d keep East Lothian and the good bits of Edinburgh against their will but not get  Berwick? Fair trade.

McHaggis

I note The Guardian is reporting on the death of The Scotsman.

Silverytay

Luigi   Sorry for the delay in getting back to you .    According to the hazel Lewry article the mayor of Berwick and a soviet diplomat signed a peace agreement in 1966 .  My view would be that as the unionists broke an internationally recognised agreement by annexing Berwick the treaty of union would be null and void but then again the unionists have been shafting Scotland since before the ink on the treaty of union was dry and they continue to do so to this day .  If my memory serves me right there was an unofficial referendum in Berwick a couple of years back where they voted to rejoin Scotland . 

Luigi

Perhaps Brian Wilson should start his own “Wings over Shetland” blog.
 

Angus McLellan

Derek Bateman did an interview on Newsweek Scotland with Sandy Cluness, a senior Lib Dem on Shetland Council. This is how the interview went:
Newsweek 24 March 2012 @18:27

Sandy Cluness: As far as I am concerned, the relationship which we’ve had with Alex Salmond’s government in the past few years has been quite a good one. It has been a situation where we could get direct contact with ministers if required. So I know that they did create the Christie Commission, and to that commission we make submissions to the effect that the future governance of local authorities like our should be looked at.

Derek Bateman: We got a statement on this from Alistair Carmichael’s office on this, the MP [for Orkney and Shetland] … He says that in the last four years powers have been stripped away from local communities by the Scottish government.

Sandy Cluness: I wouldn’t agree with that. I haven’t been conscious of that happening at all. What has happened is that certainly areas like police and fire have been moved away from a regional system and I don’t think that is a bad thing at all if greater control is given to local areas.

Morag

There’s a perfectly simple answer to all this.  If Shetland and/or Orkney (or the Wee Cumbrae for that matter) wants to be independent, then let them found an independence-supporting party, work away at getting votes, and eventually return sufficient representatives or sufficiently pressurise the country as a whole to secure a devolved assembly.  Then get sufficient support in that devolved assembly to organise an independence referendum.  Then win it.

That’s what we’re doing.  Takes a while, and you have to take a lot of flak along the way.  Why would anyone imagine any group would simply be handed independence without doing the legwork, or even showing any particular sign they want it?

Holebender

The Northern Isles are part of the UK because they are Scottish, and were so in 1707. They joined the union with Scotland and they will leave the union on that basis. If they want to become independent from Scotland after Scotland becomes independent, more power to them. Let them make their arguments and hold a referendum. That’s democracy.
 
What is not democracy is unionist cherry-picking which tries to partition Scotland on the basis of how any particular area votes in the referendum. What if my street votes for independence but the next street over doesn’t? Will my village be partitioned? What if my next-door neighbour votes NO? Will our garden fence become an international border?
 
And why don’t the unionists want the Hebrides? (If they had an ounce of sense they’d realise there’s lots of potential for oil off the west of the Hebrides, but they only ever cite Orkney & Shetland (and maybe Rockall).)

Adrian B

Holebender,

If Lord Steele votes no and his wife votes YES, as she has indicated she might, then Aikwood tower would possibly need to have international borders down the middle of the master Bedroom? Passport control?


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a (mainly) Scottish political media digest and monitor, which also offers its own commentary. (More)

    Stats: 6,672 Posts, 1,203,013 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Astonished on The Unbargain Bin: “Excellent, as always, Chris. Stu, could ye no hide his passport ? My suggestions – “My Life as a Klingon”…Nov 23, 13:17
    • Mia on The Unbargain Bin: ““The man in the back seat” By Neil GrayNov 23, 13:15
    • robertkknight on The Unbargain Bin: “Welcome back Mr Cairns. 🙂Nov 23, 13:15
    • Jon Drummond on The Unbargain Bin: ““The Grifters Almanac” by John Nicholson, Pete Wishart, Alyn Smith, Stephen Flynn, Kirsty Blackman, S.A Somerville et alNov 23, 13:12
    • Morgatron on The Unbargain Bin: “Kezia Dugdales aptly named book 1001 things I do to make my hair look like a helmet.Nov 23, 13:08
    • Jon Drummond on The Unbargain Bin: ““The benefits of grease” by Mhairi Black.Nov 23, 13:08
    • Morgatron on The Unbargain Bin: “Belter Chris . Had a real chuckle at their books.Nov 23, 13:06
    • Jon Drummond on The Unbargain Bin: “Ooft! Harsh but true. 🙂Nov 23, 13:05
    • Jon Drummond on The Unbargain Bin: “Bet you’re a laugh at a party. It’s called satire. And that’s what Chris does every Saturday. it’s his job.…Nov 23, 13:04
    • Jon Drummond on The Unbargain Bin: ““The Enjoyment of being Gormless and Vacuous” by Shona Robison.Nov 23, 12:58
    • Breeks on The Unbargain Bin: ““…writing a memoir.” Sturgeon? A memoir? At least it will be brief…Nov 23, 12:52
    • TURABDIN on The Unbargain Bin: “Jay Rayner has quit the Guardian/Observer with accusations of antisemitism. Pity no one of consequence writes for The National.Nov 23, 12:48
    • Hatey McHateface on Telling the truth by mistake: “The site host supports Scottish Indy. Many of the posters do too. Some of the posters hijack this forum to…Nov 23, 12:46
    • znovak on The Unbargain Bin: “Bankruptcy Basics for Politicians by John Swinney Sense, sensibility and GRC by Mridul WadhwaNov 23, 12:43
    • Mia on The Unbargain Bin: ““My imaginary Y chromosome and I: a journey from space” By K. BlackmanNov 23, 12:36
    • Mac on The Unbargain Bin: “The Life and Times of Peter Murrell By Nicolas BagmanNov 23, 12:35
    • Hatey McHateface on Telling the truth by mistake: “I’ve got a hole in mine, but I only noticed when it started snowing. Defo wasn’t there last winter. And…Nov 23, 12:29
    • Hatey McHateface on The Unbargain Bin: ““This Woman’s Half Of The Sky Has Fallen Down”. Anon. For copyright reasons published overseas as ”The Secret Diary Of…Nov 23, 12:23
    • Mia on The Unbargain Bin: ““The struggle to remain relevant in adverse times” By M. Black, A. Smith & T. ShepphardNov 23, 12:05
    • moixx on Telling the truth by mistake: “I’ve also had an email about the case from Sex Matters: “You can watch the case online on the Supreme…Nov 23, 12:04
    • Dan on The Unbargain Bin: “Re. She/ Her writing a memoir. I believe the title will be a play on a CS Lewis book. The…Nov 23, 12:03
    • Mac on The Unbargain Bin: “King Rat By Nicola MurrellNov 23, 11:54
    • Sven on The Unbargain Bin: “Doubt if I am alone in appreciating the biting satire of these cartoons. Nothing pricks the balloon of pomposity of…Nov 23, 11:48
    • James on Telling the truth by mistake: “Look in a mirror.Nov 23, 11:48
    • Mac on The Unbargain Bin: “A Woman Called Horse By Lorna SlaterNov 23, 11:43
    • Alba Andy on The Unbargain Bin: “This is the second attempt at selling remaindered books. In the first, the table collapsed under the weight of the…Nov 23, 11:25
    • Dan on The Unbargain Bin: “Don’t forget to include Angus Robertson in your ire for various reasons… https://robinmcalpine.org/this-hydrogen-deal-is-another-disaster/ https://robinmcalpine.org/there-are-always-alternatives-to-economic-surrender/Nov 23, 11:23
    • Robert Hughes on The Unbargain Bin: “Is satire not meaningful ? Don’t know where you get the claim ” most of the time no one has…Nov 23, 11:01
    • Effijy on The Unbargain Bin: “Trans Con Mental Journeys. How to win enemies and infuriate people. Snowflake Gate on the road to freedomNov 23, 10:51
    • 100%Yes on The Unbargain Bin: “For me these cartoons are a waste of money. The money could be better spent on achieving something meaningful towards…Nov 23, 10:49
  • A tall tale



↑ Top
212
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x