The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Turkey opposes Christmas

Posted on November 20, 2011 by

Scottish Viceroy Michael Moore is banging away on the same old drum in the Herald today, demanding that the SNP detail every last conceivable detail of policy in an independent Scotland before the referendum, continuing to rather clumsily miss the entire point of what referenda are for. But as we wearily ploughed through the rhetoric one more time, a thought dawned on us.

The only way Moore's complaints would make any kind of sense would be if a vote for independence was also a vote for an SNP government in perpetuity. Only if the SNP are going to rule an independent Scotland forever would it be incumbent on them to lay out every last line of what they stood for before the referendum, because then (and only then) the electorate would have no opportunity to reject at the ballot box a government implementing policies that voters objected to.

Could it be that Moore believes no other party could ever rise to power in an independent Scotland, and that the nation would in effect become a one-party dictatorship, lost to democracy forever under the iron thistle of the First McReich? (He's at least two-thirds right, after all – the Tories and Lib Dems aren't going to be providing a First Minister any time soon.) If so, we think he should come out and say so instead of beating around the bush. The people deserve to be warned. 

Comment - please read this page for comment rules. HTML tags like <i> and <b> are permitted. Use paragraph breaks in long comments. DO NOT SIGN YOUR COMMENTS, either with a name or a slogan. If your comment does not appear immediately, DO NOT REPOST IT. Ignore these rules and I WILL KILL YOU WITH HAMMERS.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,912 Posts, 1,242,764 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • TimePilot on No Money Back, No Guarantee: “A quick “Google” of Sturgeon signing offical documents fed into AI (see screenshot below) https://i.postimg.cc/jdZMh7yB/Pens.jpg Pen Analysis Images 1, 2,…May 26, 13:57
    • Willie on No Money Back, No Guarantee: “At some stage, and not in the too distant future legal action will I suspect be raised against those who…May 26, 13:45
    • Hobbit on The Final Robbery: “This thieving began while Alex was still the leader. More generally, how could the SNP system have let the thieving…May 26, 13:43
    • Richard Renier on No Money Back, No Guarantee: “No public money was stolen. So who funded the police enquiry, which cost over £1m?May 26, 13:31
    • J Robertson on The Final Robbery: “As so many have said on here your investigation and reporting on this has been nothing short of magnificent Stu.…May 26, 13:12
    • Ian Smith on The Final Robbery: “Didn’t the court say something about living a lifestyle he couldn’t afford. Since he had been on a six figure…May 26, 13:01
    • Bobo bunny on The Final Robbery: “Candidate for being killed by hammers.May 26, 12:46
    • Northcode on The Final Robbery: “You are young, Sam, and hae little knowing in the ways of ‘The Empire’… I am old (189 years last…May 26, 12:44
    • Effijy on No Money Back, No Guarantee: “Sturgeon says that Murrell claimed to have won the £125K Mobile Home on Bullseye. She should have been suspicious as…May 26, 12:41
    • Patrician on No Money Back, No Guarantee: “I wish there was a way to upvote this comment. To paraphrase her statement: “The behaviour complained of was found…May 26, 12:38
    • Rogueslr on No Money Back, No Guarantee: “Some SNP fan was saying St Nic was the queen of Scottish politics, the best Peter can aspire to is…May 26, 12:30
    • Campbell Clansman on No Money Back, No Guarantee: “In Sturgeon, Murrell and Swinney, the Scottish people got what they voted for. The voters could have thrown the corrupt…May 26, 12:16
    • agentx on No Money Back, No Guarantee: “Peter Murrell, the SNP’s chief executive, loaned the party £107,620 in June 2021. Is Sturgeon saying that she knew nothing…May 26, 12:03
    • sam on The Final Robbery: “Naw, Northcode. The amount took is substantial. The impact on the community and wer pretendy pahlmint is substantial. Minimum 5…May 26, 12:02
    • Xaracen on The Final Robbery: “That was a very interesting read, Alf, thanks. That site is now bookmarked, and its name has resonance for obvious…May 26, 11:58
    • Northcode on No Money Back, No Guarantee: ““ever-degenerating capacities of imperialism” Aye, Alf, Orwell could already see it from the very heart of the empire he was…May 26, 11:58
    • Charles Mackay on No Money Back, No Guarantee: “Great article brilliant insight to it all. Bet he gets three years and is out in six months-Scottish establishment right…May 26, 11:42
    • CharlesMackay on No Money Back, No Guarantee: “Great article brilliant insight to it all. Bet he gets three years and is out in six months-Scottish establishment right…May 26, 11:42
    • Luigi on No Money Back, No Guarantee: “Mmmm. Something doesn’t smell right in this case. A lot more to this than meets the eye, methinks. Anyone else…May 26, 11:39
    • Ian on No Money Back, No Guarantee: “The sentence will indicate a lot about what happens next. Meanwhile Alex Salmond’s treatment and the SNP’s lead role in…May 26, 11:39
    • Rev. Spooner on No Money Back, No Guarantee: “On R4’s Today programme this morning, the SNP mouthpiece was at pains to make the point – at least 3…May 26, 11:30
    • Captain Caveman on The Final Robbery: “There is much that could be said in response to this long-running, tawdry affair – and much has been said…May 26, 11:29
    • Northcode on The Final Robbery: “I might as well stick my tuppence worth of pointless verbiage intae this place alang wi the rest o ye…May 26, 11:20
    • J Robertson on No Money Back, No Guarantee: “That “legal letter “ takes the ***ing biscuit “. What have they done to our once proud wee nation?May 26, 11:16
    • Alf Baird on No Money Back, No Guarantee: “Let’s remember that co-opted national party elites are merely the coloniser’s tools. A colony’s “confidential agents pensioned off at high…May 26, 11:15
    • Jay on The Final Robbery: “Frank, what are your reasons for thinking that Murrell expected to “get away with it.”? What better way to undermine…May 26, 11:00
    • agentx on No Money Back, No Guarantee: “What Sturgeon said about Salmond in 2021: “The behaviour complained of was found by a jury not to constitute criminal…May 26, 10:58
    • Sven on No Money Back, No Guarantee: ““Love and loyalty.” Oh Paul, what are you like ! Nearly choked on my morning toast & coffee by chortling…May 26, 10:57
    • Jason Smoothpiece on No Money Back, No Guarantee: “Disappointing that only one thief has been jailed. I will only add the I think Sturgeon has been very lucky.…May 26, 10:42
    • agentx on The Final Robbery: “What Sturgeon said about Salmond in 2021: “The behaviour complained of was found by a jury not to constitute criminal…May 26, 10:41
  • A tall tale



↑ Top