The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


Truth and lies (not in that order)

Posted on March 02, 2013 by

First the lies (from the print-only editions of today’s Daily Mail):

mailpensions

And then the truth, from our own Scott Minto a week ago.

Decide for yourself who to believe.

We’re not sure, incidentally, that we can recall the story which allegedly revealed it would cost an independent Scotland £1 billion to set up a few embassies. That seems an awful lot of money, given that there are only a couple of hundred countries in the world and £50m per office seems a touch high. Even in Kensington or Chelsea you’d get a pretty darned impressive building for that, let alone Angola, Tuvalu or Micronesia.

We wonder if it’s perhaps been arrived at using the same broken calculator Alan Cochrane of the Telegraph used to work out the cost of intelligence services, exaggerating the reality by a breathtaking 900% – an “error” the Telegraph still hasn’t seen fit to correct a month later. What a puzzle.

———————————————————————————————–

27 to “Truth and lies (not in that order)”

  1. Adrian B says:

    Correct me if I am wrong, but has Westminster not spent all of the pension contributions that we have already made to our basic state pensions?
     

    Reply
  2. The Man in the Jar says:

    Astonishing that they print the same old crap time after time. Even more astonishing that people buy the same old crap time after time.
    Anyone know the circulation figures for the Daily Mail in Scotland?

    Reply
  3. Mister Worf says:

    That’s why they call it the Daily Fail!

    Reply
  4. David McCann says:

    Well I know who I would believe, but then I would say that wouldn’t I?
     
    Re the cost of setting up our own embassies; like you I don’t have the answer, but I know someone who probably has, and that is Craig Murray, former Ambassador to Uzbekistan , past Rector of Dundee Uni and a nationalist to boot.
     
    He responded to my request to reply to a query from a unionist troll regarding Scotland’s stolen sea, in your blog ’Pushing at an Open Door’ a few days ago, so Ill get him to answer this one too.
     
    In the meantime perhaps you would put up a link to his excellent and controversial blog at link to craigmurray.org.uk
     
    I like his latest one at the Oxford Union debate,  when his side defeated the motion “This house still dreams the American Dream”.
     
    Note he proudly wears the kilt!  
     

    Reply
  5. AnneDon says:

    “The UK Exchequer absorbs much of the cost [of Scottish rural pensions].  Or, will make you work until you die, of course.
    Who would be a satirist in these days of newspaper idiocy?

    Reply
  6. MajorBloodnok says:

    Only an idiot wouild think that a UK state pension will be worth anything once they retire (if they live that long) but then these are the same idiots that buy the Daily Mail.
     
    The incredible scandal is that the UK is increasing the retirement age knowing full well that, although they’ve contributred all their lives, in certain parts of Scotland people won’t live long enough to be able to collect their state pensions. So yet again Scotland is subsidising the UK though NI contributions and doesn’t get much of it back.

    Reply
  7. Bob Howie says:

    Why would we need embassies, they are BRITISH embassies not UK Embassies. We are becoming an independent Scotland, we are still part of the British Isles and we pay a share for them now, it would only change if Westminster were spiteful.

    This really gets my goat, I wish people would get over this misconception that
    BRITISH=ENGLISH, they do not have a concession on the name.

    Scotland is not sawing along the border and floating off into the Atlantic, we will still be on the map as a part of the British Isles

    Reply
  8. Angus McLellan says:

    The embassy thing. 
    There a handy list of all New Zealand representatives overseas here. A quick count came up with 67 high commissions, embassies and consulates general. Not quite “100”, but not a million miles away.
    As at June 2012, the value of all buildings owned by the NZ Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Trade was NZD 100 million. Even if we assumed all of those buildings were in the form of embassies, diplomatic residences, etc, an assumption which is obviously wrong because there are offices at home in NZ, that’s only £50 million book value and there’s another £50 million in furnishings and equipment. On top of that there is £150 million in land spread around the planet, but unlike the earlier numbers land values are estimates of market prices and not paper valuations.
    I am not inclined to try and figure out what proportion of the UK Foreign Office’s land and buildings are located in the UK and even if I did the figures would not be comparable. A relatively minor problem is that the UK National Asset Register does not distinguish land and buildings. Much more importantly, the NZ Ministry whose accounts we used is responsible for Foreign Affairs and Trade, so we’d have to include some, but not all, of the assets attributed to the UK DTI (and its vast array of quangos and agencies). If we looked at Ireland, we’d have a different problem as Ireland’s foreign ministry does UK DfID stuff too. And so on.
    So is a billion quid just to set up embassies impossible? We can’t be sure that it is, not like we could be certain that the Cochrane number was a blunder, but it doesn’t look at all likely. Anyway, we all know how the Big Lie works. The Daily Mail uses the technique every day, so why be surprised to find it in a story about Scotland rather than in one about “benefit scroungers”, “asylum seekers”, or any of the other DM regulars?

    Reply
  9. frankieboy says:

    I read the headline of the Daily Mail article, the first line, scanned, saw the name Danny Alexander and then read the conclusion. I have read this very same thing a hundred times, just a different topic. Tomorrow it will be about square sliced sausage, or wee dugs, or has that been covered already?

    Reply
  10. Dal Riata says:

    @Rev Stu
    I’ve been meaning to ask you for a while about the Daily Mail in that a lot of your articles are based on the guff emanating from the likes of the Scotsman, the Daily Record, the Herald, etc. The Daily Mail comes out with some quite incredible lies, smears and misinformation…every day! Do you usually just ignore it because it is just so far ‘out there’ that it is beyond comment? If it is that, I wouldn’t blame you! Anyway, having seen today’s Mail ‘offerings’ I was going to post something about it on one of your articles no matter what. Great to see that you’ve picked up on the Daily Mail’s behaviour today!

    Reply
    • Rev. Stuart Campbell says:

      “Do you usually just ignore it because it is just so far ‘out there’ that it is beyond comment?”

      A lot of the Mail’s Scottish content either doesn’t appear on the website at all, or is buried very deeply so I just don’t see it.

      Reply
  11. BeamMeUpScotty says:

    What they are not saying of course is stick with Westminster and watch our share of their debt increase exponentially.
    This is the real threat to future welfare and pensions in Scotland and not having all of our affairs managed from Holyrood.They still haven’t explained to the Scottish electorate why they are so desperate to hang on to what they describe as an economic basket case which can only survive with support from Westminster.

    Reply
  12. Angus McLellan says:

    So, Ireland then.

    The Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade combines the functions of the UK FCO, plus DfID and part of DTI, so even more extra stuff than the New Zealand equivalent. It has 71 embassies and the like overseas with permanent staff, slightly more than NZ. The easiest comparable source to use for information on the DFA’s budget and assets is last year’s appropriations for Vote 28 (Foreign Affairs and Trade). The DFA’s other source of funding is Vote 29 (International Cooperation), which corresponds more or less with the DfID except that it doesn’t involve the extra red tape which a separate department does.

    Luckily for us, the Irish government’s land and buildings in Ireland are owned and run by a dedicated works department. So the Vote 28 figures show only those assets located abroad. This is really about as close as we will get to the sort of number we want to compare with the DM’s Big Lie.
     
    As at 31 December 2011, the DFA owned land and buildings worth EUR 160 million and other assets, from cars to coffee machines and from paintings to photocopiers, valued at EUR 126 million. And even adding an extra 30 embassies and consulates to get us to “100″ would make little difference as the total book value of the assets making up an average Irish permanent overseas diplomatic facility comes in at about EUR 4 million.
     
    So there’s no way we could get anywhere close to a billion pounds if we paid any attention to the numbers from Ireland and New Zealand. But even if the DM exaggerated the costs by 300-400%, which seems a conservative guess as to the scale of this particular lie, that shouldn’t come as a surprise. After all, this is a newspaper which appears to be claiming that half of the population of Bulgaria will up sticks and move to S.E. England fairly soon. The Daily Mail does truthiness, not truth.

    Reply
  13. Triskelion says:

    Embassies on countries that have few connections to Scotland could just be small rented offices, it’s like that all over the world between countries that barely “see” each other. Its just the least of countries that would need a full building.

    Reply
  14. JLT says:

    Embassies…
     
    To be honest, if Scotland does become Independent, then rather than rush out and buy buildings here and there, in every capital, in every country in the world, I suspect Scotland will initially open up key embassies in the US, Canada, Australia, NZ, China, Japan, Brazil and India, plus all the countries in Western Europe.
    After that, I would wait. It won’t take long for other nations to get in contact with us. The first few nations that will come calling will be from the Middle East (the rich nations such as Saudi, Oman, UAE, etc) and Eastern Europe, followed by South America. In time, we will have a few here and there in Africa. I have no doubt that some nations will offer us incentives, and give us good deals for opening up an embassy in their nation, and likeswise, we will do the same for them.
    To me, I think that is how the embassy situation will start. Have the key few at first, then slowly build them up when needed or required.
    But, all this negativity over embassies, for that is exactly what it is – Negativity. A complete put-down, basically saying Scotland is incapable of setting up relationships with other nations.
    As I said, I think Scotland will do fine when it comes to embassies….

    Reply
  15. Holebender says:

    Scotland in the EU will have access to EU member states’ embassies around the world.

    Reply
  16. cirsium says:

    regarding embassies, the Scandinavian countries have made arrangements to share some of their embassies.  If we were part of the Nordic Circle, we could also be involved in this.

    Reply
  17. deewal says:

    I don’t see any information on the SNP site about their plans for dealing with the change to Public or Private Pensions. There is a piece from 2011 here  link to snp.org with a .pdf attached to show some figures but there are no Articles “devising a credible scenario for dealing with them”
    I can only assume that the plans are secret ?  In my opinion this type of Information is vital and should come from an official SNP source.
    Not just “could be” but “will be and here’s how” 
    Just sayin’.
     

    Reply
  18. Albert Herring says:

    @deewal
    link to wingsland.podgamer.com

    Reply
  19. ScotFree1320 says:

    Or perhaps Scotland could come to an arrangement to share embassies with other states, much like the UK and Canada does? 
    link to guardian.co.uk

    Reply
  20. Gusmac says:

    How’s about we just use the existing UK embassies, each of which we own a piece of?

    Reply
  21. ScotFree1320 says:

    The Yes Scotland site has a Q&A about pensions. It would appear to be a hot topic!
    link to yesscotland.net
     

    Reply
  22. ScotFree1320 says:

    @Gusmac
    Genius!

    Reply
  23. ianbrotherhood says:

    Why not just establish a franchise whereby tastefully-decorated Scottish ‘pubs’ can have ’embassy’ status – that’s where everyone ends up anyway. Isn’t that what the Irish have done to great effect? 

    Reply
  24. Smokeball says:

    Adrian B – National Insurance contributions have been added to current spending ever since the welfare state began in 1948, and have been subsidised by taxes. Outgoings always exceeded NI income and probably will in independent Scotland, especially if we have a generous benefit system. NI is another tax, but paying it does entitle you to certain non means tested ‘contributory’ benefits, including a pension.
    Embassies. I wouldn’t see us sharing British ones – the point of independence is that we have out own. However, they don’t need to be extravagant mansions, modest offices would be fine. 

    Reply
  25. douglas clark says:

    JLT,
     
    Our most important embassy will, probably, be the one in London.

    Reply
  26. Angus McLellan says:

    @Gusmac: But why would we want that many embassies, consulates, etc? And how can you be sure we do own a share of them? Ireland didn’t get any “share” and Westminster may not be any more minded to share today. Writing today, Professor David Shaffer thinks this is a bad thing, but since I agree with his remarks on sharing debt (on page 3) I am not so sure that it is. After all, the value of UK government debts is about ten times greater than the value of UK government assets which might be divided up.

    Reply


Comment - please read this page for comment rules. HTML tags like <i> and <b> are permitted. Use paragraph breaks in long comments. DO NOT SIGN YOUR COMMENTS, either with a name or a slogan. If your comment does not appear immediately, DO NOT REPOST IT. Ignore these rules and I WILL KILL YOU WITH HAMMERS.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a (mainly) Scottish political media digest and monitor, which also offers its own commentary. (More)

    Stats: 6,718 Posts, 1,214,031 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Tinto Chiel on Off-topic: “Stuart McHardy cuts through the crap re The Jacobites: www.youtube.com/watch?v=lx7fJY1hr98 Remember history is usually written by the victors unless the…Mar 13, 21:18
    • Hatey McHateface on The tint of rose: “Boo hoo, Mia gurnin aboot being “forced oot o the EU agin oor will” again. Hindsight is, of course, a…Mar 13, 20:38
    • Mia on The tint of rose: ““I cannot see anything which would suggest that the treaty intended to retain two separate sovereign states with their respective…Mar 13, 19:30
    • Hatey McHateface on Signal and noise: ““she hates the English with a venom” Are you sure? Has she tried to get them jailed on trumped-up sexual…Mar 13, 18:52
    • Hatey McHateface on Signal and noise: “Good point, Lorn. Still, part of living your best trans life requires somebody to take a (hopefully sharp) knife to…Mar 13, 18:47
    • agent x on Signal and noise: ““what are the odds on Sturgeon running for MP in the UK Parliament at the next opportunity?” Zero chance -…Mar 13, 18:31
    • diabloandco on Signal and noise: “Oops! Sorry Rev!Mar 13, 18:10
    • agent x on Signal and noise: “Eric Trump at Bute House with Swinney today.Mar 13, 17:11
    • sarah on Signal and noise: “Nothing is happening politically – not for independence nor as competent government. Holyrood currently is a toxic puddle – gone…Mar 13, 17:00
    • diabloandco on Signal and noise: “He had a more black and white view of diversity.Mar 13, 16:26
    • diabloandco on Signal and noise: “He had a more black and white view of diversity.Mar 13, 16:21
    • Xaracen on The tint of rose: “Aidan said: “in context of over 300 years of union governance, I think we have to see the fundamental principles…Mar 13, 16:12
    • Sven on Signal and noise: “Charles (non R one) My money would still be on her looking for a post with the EU or UN.…Mar 13, 15:55
    • TURABDIN on Signal and noise: “Signals & Noises in a land far, far away….. RWANDA, new «enriched» kid, thanx2UK, on the neo imperalist block… https://archive.is/k4YGa…Mar 13, 15:24
    • John McGregor on Signal and noise: “Ave no priblem way men dressing as womem but as long as they have awe their bits they are MEN…Mar 13, 15:04
    • Charles (not the R one) on Signal and noise: “Don’t forget this – the only reason the SNP is able to behave like this, is because so many Scottish…Mar 13, 14:58
    • willie on Signal and noise: “Why should we worry about the country that Scotland has become. We allowed it to happen. Economic stagnation over the…Mar 13, 13:37
    • Lorn on Signal and noise: “Well, Hatey, you are going to have to explain that one to the four (at the last count) ‘men’ who…Mar 13, 12:54
    • Aidan on Signal and noise: “In another turn of events Sarah is partially right and Stuart is partially wrong. Designation as a non-self governing territory…Mar 13, 12:29
    • Marie on Signal and noise: “I agree but we need to fight for Scotland’s historical legacy as an epicentre of enlightened thinking. Political parties that…Mar 13, 11:13
    • diabloandco on Signal and noise: “I used to be proud of Scotland but now I see it as a land of misogyny, perverted beyond belief…Mar 13, 09:43
    • Dave G on Signal and noise: ““Scotland’s top gender law specialist” as ITV dubs her is actually an English barrister (she has a Scottish father) who…Mar 13, 09:30
    • TURABDIN on Signal and noise: “«all within the law, none outside the law, none against the law» pace Benito MUSSOLINIMar 13, 09:11
    • 100%Yes on The evolution of fairness: “Sara, Your correct the UN Decolonisation of Scotland is a winner for so many reason. Its progress, when all we…Mar 13, 08:59
    • Frank Gillougley on Signal and noise: “Maggie Chapman was born in the wrong body and she is also a time-traveller. She was born as Lavrenty Pavlovich…Mar 13, 07:26
    • Hatey McHateface on Signal and noise: ““Don’t you want an independent Scotland to be the first islamic country in the EU?” I want the Islamic leader…Mar 13, 07:10
    • Yoon Scum on Signal and noise: “We really need a party in Scotland which is 1 :- Actually sane 2:- ignores the indy issue as it…Mar 13, 06:47
    • Yoon Scum on Signal and noise: “Try and get two facts into your teeny weeny head FACT 1 My number 1 priority is to make scotland…Mar 13, 06:44
    • Hatey McHateface on Signal and noise: ““if we fill Scotland with ‘trans’ people, the climate will be saved. The last one was a joke” Zatso? Then…Mar 13, 06:44
    • Yoon Scum on Signal and noise: “You’re sounding like a far right reform voter there Don’t you want an independent Scotland to be the first islamic…Mar 13, 06:28
  • A tall tale



↑ Top