The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


The Silence Of The Lamont

Posted on September 19, 2012 by

Alert readers will have noticed that we gave up on maintaining our Scottish media appearance log a while back. With pressures of work and a shortage of help, it was just too much to keep up with by ourselves, requiring hours of monitoring every day even just for the “big three” of Good Morning Scotland, Scotland Tonight and Newsnight Scotland, let alone shows like Call Kaye or anything on commercial radio.

However, we did continue to record appearances for quite a while after our last report, so it seemed remiss not to at least compile the stats to that point, which covered the first five months of 2012. The figures for January 1st to May 31st are as noted below.

14 APPEARANCES

Nicola Sturgeon (SNP)

13 APPEARANCES

Anas Sarwar (LAB)

11 APPEARANCES

Ruth Davidson (CON)
Willie Rennie (LIB)
Patrick Harvie (GRN)

9 APPEARANCES

John Swinney (SNP)
Michael Moore (LIB)

7 APPEARANCES

Alex Salmond (SNP)
Stewart Hosie (SNP)

6 APPEARANCES

Ken Macintosh (LAB)
Johann Lamont (LAB)

5 APPEARANCES

Humza Yousaf (SNP)
Margaret Curran (LAB)

4 APPEARANCES

Cathy Jamieson (LAB)
Shona Robison (SNP)
Willie Bain (LAB)
Derek Mackay (SNP)

3 APPEARANCES

Linda Fabiani (SNP)
Kezia Dugdale (LAB)
Jeremy Purvis (LIB)
Richard Lochhead (SNP)
Lewis Macdonald (LAB)
Stewart Maxwell (SNP)
Douglas Alexander (LAB)
Christine Grahame (SNP)
Hugh Henry (LAB)
Jim Wallace (LIB)

(E&OE. Politicians making fewer than three appearances are not listed.)

So we see that (as for the first quarter) over the entire monitoring period Johann Lamont appeared less often on TV and radio than any other party leader in Scotland – even the First Minister, who has the excuse of a rather busier schedule on account of having a country to run. She appeared fewer than half as many times as her own “deputy” Anas Sarwar, and only fractionally over half as many times as Ruth Davidson, Willie Rennie and Patrick Harvie.

Of course, the reasons for that have become increasingly clear in recent days. But it’s still a startling level of silence from the leader of the Holyrood opposition. It’ll be interesting to see if the frequency of her visits to the studios increases or decreases in the wake of Scottish Labour’s night of the long knives.

.

APPENDIX

Female politicians represented 33% of appearances in our sample, fractionally below their 35% share of MSPs. The pro-independence parties got 46% of slots compared to 54% for the anti-independence parties, despite commanding a comfortable majority of seats, and the Conservatives were the most under-represented party, with far fewer appearances (7%) than the Lib Dems (16%) and the same as the Greens (7%) despite having more than twice as many seats as the other two put together. (Indeed, Ruth Davidson was the only Tory who was seen more than twice in the five-month period.)

Labour were slightly over-represented with 31% of places for their 29% of MSPs, and the SNP substantially under-represented at 39% of appearances for their 53% of seats.

1 Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. 02 10 15 19:48

    Lies And The Lying Liars Who Tell Them | A Wilderness of Peace

21 to “The Silence Of The Lamont”

  1. Al Ghaf says:

    Johan Lamont literally “puts in an appearance” in today’s online coveage of the GMS debate about the Labour meltdown in Scotland. Of course BBC Scotland has gone with the much nicer angle and headline of “Scottish independence: Is Scottish Labour bouncing back?”

    link to bbc.co.uk
     

     

    Reply
  2. Doug Daniel says:

    Here’s Scottish Labour’s official spin doctor, Magnus Gardham, trying to put a positive sheen on that Smyth boy quitting his post as general secretary: link to heraldscotland.com
     
    It’s quite sickening, as was his appearance on Scotland Tonight last night. The guy is completely clueless, and has completely wrecked the Herald as a serious newspaper. Even the Scotsman seems more balanced these days.

    Reply
  3. Doug Daniel says:

    Oh, and I notice the most featured politician from each party is either the leader (Davidson, Rennie and Harvie) or the deputy leader (Sturgeon and Sawar). As you say, the First Minister can hardly be expected to be popping into TV studios every five minutes (in fact we’d be criticising him if he did), so this is exactly the kind of thing a deputy would be doing – deputising for their leader.
     
    I’d love to know what Lamont’s excuse is for leaving Sawar to deputise for her. Of course, we all know the real reason is that Sawar is the real Scottish Labour leader – which is a shame, because he’s a slimey little toad.

    Reply
  4. Kenny Campbell says:

    Maybe Lamont has been told by her spin Dr’s to keep out of the media as she has an adverse affect on Labour. A stealth leader.

    Reply
  5. Davy says:

    I think you have all got it wrong folks, the main reason Lamont does not go on TV is the damned presenters ask questions for which she does not have a script and that is not fair. How the hell do you expect any leader of a labour party to answer questions without a prepared script, I mean look how good she was in the infamous new forth road bridge FM’s question time incident. Regardless of the answers our First Minster gave about the contract and steel requirments for the new bridge she was able to carryon regardless down that deep deep very deep hole of stupidity, and all because she had a prepared script. So there.

    A little OT but have a little look at labour hame site, Mr Smart & Mr Ruddy are back on with their own version of “truth or dare”. 

    Reply
  6. Appleby says:

    It’s odd that they’d pick Lamont as a leader if they were only going to hide her out of sight. If they were smart enough to see she was poison then you’d think they’d have chosen someone more suitable in the first place.

    Reply
    • Rev. Stuart Campbell says:

      “If they were smart enough to see she was poison then you’d think they’d have chosen someone more suitable in the first place.”

      From which options, though?

      Reply
  7. Davy says:

    “Appleby”, ah but, remember her other main asset was doing what London says, that outweigh’s everything else. 

    Reply
  8. MajorBloodnok says:

    It’s difficult to see what the rationale was behind making her leader.  I use the term rationale loosely.

    My own thought (not original I see, pace Davy) is that they wanted someone that would just toe/parrot the party line – anyone with more ability might have had ideas of their own and go off-message and not follow ‘the plan’ (if there is one) for Labour hegemony in these isles.

    Reply
  9. MajorBloodnok says:

    So you’re saying they didn’t have options and also weren’t smart enough to see she’d be a problem anyway?  I think that sums it up!

    Reply
  10. Gaavster says:

    The reason Lamont was ‘chosen’ to front the Labour Party in Scotland was, in my opinion, to reinforce the ‘pretendy wee parliament’ image in the run up to the referendum

    They have attempted to polarise the debate into an Alex Salmond personality contest, where they want to reinforce their ‘one party state/dictatorship’ mantra on one hand, whilst showing the alternatives (the current Holyrood unionist cabal) as being incapable of competent government in Scotland

    It spreads fear amongst those who dont like Alex Salmond by forcing them to ask the question, ‘what’s the alternative if I vote for separation?’ 

    The politics of despair…. 

    Reply
  11. Alex McI says:

    What about our good freind councillor terry Kelly, surely a man worthy of a promotion for his tireless comedy work.

    Reply
  12. MajorBloodnok says:

    Their obsession with AS has blinded them to the fact that there are plenty of other highly capable people in the SNP.  Appointing Nicola Sturgeon to the Referendum brief will turn out to be a masterstroke as Labour’s strategy of making it a personal campaign against the supposed megalomania of ‘King-Eck’ falls flat.

    Reply
  13. scottish_skier says:

    Rev Stu. From which options, though?

    I imagine Malcolm Chisholm might not have been overly keen on the ‘top’ (ahem) job. Although Ed would have never let that happen anyway as Malcolm has his own opinions on things; that’s considered dangerous for a Labour party politician.

    Interestingly, Malcolm, like Dennis Canavan, left the ‘big boys parliament’ for the one they considered more important?

    Reply
  14. Arbroath 1320 says:

    Labour’s obsession with Alex Salmond i, in my view, a very simple concept to understand.
     
    Labour have NO policies and they are the Tories “front men” in Scotland for the union but have NO arguments FOR the union. As a result of these failings they must find something to help them keep face with the electorate, hence the personality attacks on A.S. The unfortunate thing for Labour with this line of attack is the almost immediate comparison between A.S. and Lamont. As soon as anyone does this they see the benefits of having A.S. as First Minister of Scotland (Independent or otherwise) doing an excellent job and Lamont a wee spokesperson for London who, apparently, has no concept of doing what is RIGHT for Scotland but would rather put Scotland and her people down as per her instructions from London.

    Reply
  15. Dunc says:

    Lamont got the job because both of the other leadership candidates were clear that Labour needed to change quite dramatically, and that’s the thing that they’re least willing to contemplate.

    Reply
  16. Offin says:

    ….and some in Labour say that Anas Sarwar is being groomed to take over from Lamont in the run up to the 2016 Holyrood election.

    Reply
  17. Erchie says:

    Of course, can we be sure that she did win, as the voting figures have never been released

    Reply
  18. MajorBloodnok says:

    They’ll be released when she gives her opinion on whether or not we should keep Trident.  Probably.

    Reply
  19. Erchie says:

    I am told she whispered her opinion on Trident into a box, sealed it and buried it on an island beyond the eighth sea

    Reply
  20. Al Ghaf says:

    It is not just a Labour party problem. None of the Westminster parties can effectively devolve their Scottish branches.

    But conversely the SNP seem to do a good job of maintaining a Holyrood/Westminster operation.

    Reply


Comment - please read this page for comment rules. HTML tags like <i> and <b> are permitted. Use paragraph breaks in long comments. DO NOT SIGN YOUR COMMENTS, either with a name or a slogan. If your comment does not appear immediately, DO NOT REPOST IT. Ignore these rules and I WILL KILL YOU WITH HAMMERS.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,777 Posts, 1,220,036 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • peter on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “Airtime is worth something. Shame on Scottish MSM for their silence. How much is the “democracy” journalist funding from Scot…Jun 16, 14:46
    • lothianlad on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “SNP have sold out. Anyone who cant see that is daft! Craig Murray has a good article about itJun 16, 14:41
    • Captain Caveman on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “@Sam “The whole thing may be unnecessary (as far as climate change goes) as scientific research “The role of greenhouse…Jun 16, 13:07
    • Captain Caveman on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “@Hatey “We could design and build the things properly, capture the methane produced, and use it to good purpose.” Agree…Jun 16, 11:40
    • sam on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “England has the same intention as Scotland of excluding biodegradeable waste from landfill but is still consulting on policy. The…Jun 16, 11:36
    • sarah on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “George: 1. The umbrella has only just been formed. They welcome all independence supporters including Independent candidates. Contact them for…Jun 16, 11:21
    • Southernbystander on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “It does all sound like one of those Sturgeon era things that Robin McAlpine detailed so well a while back…Jun 16, 11:14
    • Hatey McHateface on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: ““Who should I believe in this situation?” Seek guidance from Scotland’s national animal. The unicorn.Jun 16, 10:57
    • Hatey McHateface on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “I hope he gets in a plug for the humous boys. Or has their revenue stream now dried up, so…Jun 16, 10:54
    • 100%Yes on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “For anyone interested Craig Murray is in New York and speaking to a talk show in USA with Professor Alf…Jun 16, 10:37
    • Hatey McHateface on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: ““Gillian Martin, cabinet secretary for Climate Action and Energy, told the BBC’s Good Morning Scotland programme that temporarily transporting the…Jun 16, 10:36
    • Aidan on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “@Xaracen – so now I’m in a real bind, on the one hand I have an explicit statement from the…Jun 16, 10:29
    • The Flying Iron of Doom on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “I’m leaning towards the assumption that the aforementioned trucks will have to be expensive electric/hybrid affairs sourced from abroad because…Jun 16, 10:08
    • Southernbystander on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “It will just add to the usual crap, hot air and stinking filth coming south across the border, boom boom!…Jun 16, 10:05
    • Xaracen on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “@Aidan; P1- “For Scotland to be added to the list, the United Nations General Assembly (UNGA) must first adopt a…Jun 16, 09:59
    • Hatey McHateface on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “Spot on, CC. And what is particularly ironic about a story like this one, is that as Scotland is just…Jun 16, 09:41
    • gm on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “George, what’s your blog’s web address?Jun 16, 09:24
    • Captain Caveman on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “Surely this laughable virtue signalling – getting someone else to do your dirty work (at a price) whilst simultaneously polishing…Jun 16, 08:39
    • Hatey McHateface on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “BBC Online is reporting the latest wheeze to come out of the airheads, reality deniers and virtue signallers holed up…Jun 16, 07:47
    • George Ferguson on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “@Sarah 1 Well nobody has helped me, so much for the umbrella. The facts. I can spend several hundred pounds…Jun 16, 01:15
    • sarah on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “Pending the Rev unveiling his proposal for ousting the SNP, in order to rekindle some enthusiasm and hope for we…Jun 15, 21:04
    • agent x on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “I notice that Swinney’s calls for peace in the World has had zero effect. But he knows what will happen…Jun 15, 20:44
    • Aidan on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “@Xaracen – You’d have to direct your question at them, you can read from the text below that there is…Jun 15, 20:26
    • Xaracen on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “@Aidan; From the document you linked; “JPTi affirms that the principle of self-determination applies universally—not selectively. It is a legal…Jun 15, 20:06
    • agent x on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: ““Nicola Sturgeon accuses actor of misogyny after he calls her ‘a witch’” https://www.heraldscotland.com/news/25240117.nicola-sturgeon-accuses-actor-misogyny-calls-a-witch/ —————————————— What’s her problem – she pardoned…Jun 15, 19:22
    • twathater on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “Applause for that LochyJun 15, 17:47
    • Aidan on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “@Xaracen – The way that you navigate inconvenient facts by just making things up appears to know no boundaries and…Jun 15, 17:35
    • Young Lochinvar on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “Maybe Liam should join in and get his front teeth punched out – again! Get the popcorn out and book…Jun 15, 16:51
    • Callum on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “John Swinney the modern day John Balliol – ‘Toom Tabard’ (empty coat)Jun 15, 16:42
    • Xaracen on Let’s Not Make Some Plans: “‘The C-24 has very strict rules. Only regions already on the UN’s official list of “Non-Self-Governing Territories” (NSGTs) are allowed…Jun 15, 16:36
  • A tall tale



↑ Top