The world's most-read Scottish politics website

Wings Over Scotland


The Not-So-England Club

Posted on June 25, 2013 by

A comment from a reader sent us off on a spot of Googling this morning. If you type nothing but the word “Wimbledon” into the search engine, the top result isn’t actually a link, but instead some sort of unclickable wired-in tournament schedule data.

wimbledon

A striking feature of the data is the national flags beside each contestant. We couldn’t help wondering what would happen if we typed in Andy Murray’s name.

wimbledonmurray

Well, there’s a thing. But what about the rest of the Brit contingent?

wimbledonrobson

That’s odd. But as the British women’s No.1 Laura Robson was born in Melbourne, Australia, perhaps there’s a simple explanation – the mysterious Google data is merely listing each player’s nation of birth.

wimbledonbaltacha

Nope, that doesn’t seem to be it. Elena Baltacha was born in Kiev in Ukraine, but she appears under a Union Jack. Curiouser and curiouser.

wimbledonward

James Ward, who would have met Murray in the second round if he hadn’t lost to Taiwan’s Yen-Hsun Lu yesterday, is listed on Wikipedia as an “English tennis player”, although under “Country” he’s given as a citizen of both “Great Britain” and “England”. Google chooses the former.

wimbledonwatson

Just to muddy the ground still further, Heather Watson gets a Union Jack despite being from Guernsey, which is in neither Britain nor the UK.

wimbledonkonta

And finally, Johanna Konta (born in Australia to Hungarian parents but officially representing Britain since 2012) gets an Australian flag. We officially give up.

We couldn’t get the other British players we know of in this year’s tournament, Kyle Edmund and Samantha Murray, to show up in the same results format, and we don’t know what Google’s criteria for assigning nationalities is. (It’s not, for example, from Wikipedia, where Andy Murray’s country is given as “Great Britain”.)

But it’s at least passingly interesting to us that neither the British men’s nor women’s No.1 players are considered by the search giant to be representing Britain at the All-England Club. Why could that be? We’re all ears.

38 to “The Not-So-England Club”

  1. alasdair says:

    maybe they contacted the players personally?

    Reply
  2. Max says:

     
    ‘All England’ is an old term for the Kingdom of England

    Reply
  3. Turnbull Drier says:

    On topic (I hope as I don’t want to feel  the rath of the rev…)
     
    But you got me thinking.. here is Allan McNish’s first line in wiki:
    Allan McNish (born 29 December 1969) is a British racing driver. He is a three-time winner of the 24 Hours of Le Mans, most recently in 2013, and three-time…
     
    but this is how it’s presented in the Google resutls page in a search for Allan McNish:
     
    Allan McNish (born 29 December 1969) is a Scottish racing driver. He is a three-time winner of the 24 Hours of Le Mans, most recently in 2013, and three-time 
     
    Spot the difference?
    Do Google edit their “quoted” presented results, or am I being stoopid somehow?

    Reply
  4. beachthistle says:

    Heather Watson is there with a Union Jack, with Wikipedia informing us that she is a British tennis player. But the same source also informs us that she was born in Guernsey  – which Wikipedia also informs us is officially the ‘Bailiwick of Guernsey’ and that the Bailiwick of Guernseyis not part of the United Kingdom.
    Which is of course all a bit confusing as we are being told by our better(together)s that people born in Scotland will no longer be British if Scotland votes Yes and is no longer part of the United Kingdom….

    Reply
  5. mato21 says:

    As long as Andy is recognised as a Scot I’m happy and I would imagine so is he

    Reply
  6. Doug Daniel says:

    Turnbull Drier – Google trawls the web picking up content, visiting and revisiting pages periodically. It would seem the last time Google trawled McNish’s wikipedia page, he was listed as a Scottish racing driver (http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Allan_McNish&direction=prev&oldid=561346186). However, some busybody has changed it to British. If you look in the revision history, there’s a few arguments about his nationality.
     
    Wouldn’t be a problem if he wasn’t successful, of course…

    Reply
  7. Alasdair Stirling says:

    The term “All England” refers to the English and Welsh counties as single political/geographical unit.  It is commonly used in a legal context because of the english law’s jurisdiction over England and Wales.  It used to also be commonly used in sporting contexts, hence the name ‘All England Lawn Tennis and Croquet Club, but that use is much rarer now.

    Reply
  8. Ciaran McRae says:

    I’m finding quite a lot of Scottish people on wiki have had their nationalities changed to British recently.

    Reply
  9. Turnbull Drier says:

    @Doug
    Ta for that…
    If only we were all losers, then we’d definitely be Scottish.. 
    No quite the positive campaigning that we are after 😉

    Reply
  10. Well its the “All England ” title that seems to define the country of birth,by being an “All England” club,its themselves that create the division.Not really such a big deal,just the usual befuddled thinking of the British?English swap of identity and telling everybody the world over that Britain is England and vice-versa.

    Reply
  11. mealer says:

    So,if we lose the referendum Duggy Dug will be a Scotty.But if we win,he’ll be a Britty.Or is it the other way around? I’ll need to ponder some more on this conundrum.If,indeed it is a conundrum.

    Reply
  12. Dcanmore says:

    @Doug Daniel
     
    That’s very interesting. Following your lead I just perused Chris Hoy’s Wiki history (I’ve never went through historical entries before and I picked an easy one) … there seems to be a bit of a ding dong battle going on with his national identity. For the first four years he was known as  a ‘Scottish’ track cyclist (2005-09), then that changed to a Track cyclist who represents Britain and Scotland, to now being a ‘British’ track cyclist. There are people trying to change him back to a Scottish cyclist but they seem to be up against Brit-Nats who want him British with the butcher’s apron. I think this is worth investigating to see how many Scots-born sports people have had their biogs changed from Scottish to British over the years (especially the last 5 years or so).

    Reply
  13. pmcrek says:

    Looks like wiki doesnt list Nessie as Scottish either, just resident in Scotland 🙁

    Reply
  14. Yesitis says:

    Ciaran McRae
    I’m finding quite a lot of Scottish people on wiki have had their nationalities changed to British recently
     
    We know what`s coming if we vote No next year – a smothering of one nation ‘Englishness’ disguised as Britishness.
    Scotland will be a worldwide laughing stock, and a sneering, humiliating minority who strangely seem to have a control over our Scottish media, will then use that media to maintain the British illusion/delusion and to humiliate and stir up hatred toward the Yes Campaign/SNP/Alex Salmond/SNP supporters.
    Basically, what is happening already.
    “And we don`t want to go through that again!”
     
    Scotland will, in all but name, be culturally cleansed. There will be no more talk (at least in the MSM) of Scots or Scotland, as we will all be Brits.
    Team GB. British flags. UKOK. Better Together. Rule Britannia. Team GB. British flags. UKOK. Better Together. Rule Britannia…
    Say it. SAY IT!
     
    Sorry, that was very rant-ish. Coffee is now severely needed.
    Arghhhh…

    Reply
  15. Desimond says:

    Aww….now it seems Englands even claiming Glen Michael!
    link to en.wikipedia.org

    🙂

    Reply
  16. Iain says:

    Ciaran McRae says:
    25 June, 2013 at 11:36 am

    ‘I’m finding quite a lot of Scottish people on wiki have had their nationality’s changed to British recently.’

    At last we know what Michael Moore is for.

    Reply
  17. Max says:

    Here is the Sun’s take on Andy Murrray;
     
    “THE Sun today unveils our daily Murrayometer — gauging whether Andy is a great Brit or a sulky Scot at Wimbledon.”
     
     link to thesun.co.uk

    Reply
  18. Dcanmore says:

    Just checked Alan Well’s wiki history, over the last three years he has went to being firstly Scottish and British athlete, then to Scottish athlete, then British athlete and currently reverted to Scottish and British athlete.
     
    I think there IS a bit of a war going on here.

    Reply
  19. Britishness is a concept peddled by the Ruling Classes to keep the restless natives under control. Not least those restless natives who have not yet conceded that there is only England albeit under a different name.
    “An alternative view is that as a matter of international law England continued, albeit under a new name and regardless of the position in domestic law, and was simply enlarged to incorporate Scotland.”
    “It is not necessary to decide between these two views of the union of 1707. Whether or not England was also extinguished by the union, Scotland certainly was extinguished as a matter of international law, by merger into either an enlarged and renamed England or into an entirely new state.”
    (Westminster Government Paper on Scottish Independence: Annex A, Opinion, Section 35)

    Reply
  20. DRD Woodward says:

    And the best is yet to come ….. we have a history of celebrating/commemorating the start of conflicts and wars …… yes??   ……mmmmm Well to be honest, I’m struggling to think of one …. we tend to celebrate/commemorate the end of conflicts ….. like ‘hallelujah thank the Lord its all over!’ …..’lets remember our fallen’ …. etc etc ….. So why, other than in a year when some people with an agenda would like to see the ‘ we fought and died together ‘ sentiment wash over the land …. would we, as we are told we are going to, celebrate the commencement of the most bloody and life costly war in our history! ….. what’s there to celebrate?? 6.5 million killed – 16 million maimed ….yipeee pass the ice cream !
    ? Am I being cynical to think that this is a BT ploy?, because I cant think of any other possible reason for it.

    Reply
  21. Patrick Roden says:

    OT but very powerful stuff:
     
    link to auldacquaintance.wordpress.com

    Reply
  22. Kirriereoch says:

    @Yesitis 
    We know what`s coming if we vote No next year – a smothering of one nation ‘Englishness’ disguised as Britishness.  
     
    There will be no more talk (at least in the MSM) of Scots or Scotland, as we will all be Brits.
     
    And simultaneously people in England are rejecting British identity anyway in favour of identifying as only English.
     
    The 2011 census in England had nearly 60% identifying as only English. Most reports seem to “smother” this aspect (eg BBC) by simply saying 90% or so stated they identified as English, Scottish, Welsh, Irish or British instead of highlighting the increasing rejection of Britishness in England and thus avoided reporting how British identity is declining.
     
    I´ve commented before about wondering how Better Together can square the circe in that respect. Telling people in Scotland they can´t be British and/or saying we´re British together, can be British and Scottish except if we aren´t governed by Westminster and stating some odd combination of these all etc.
     
    Although I´m sure they say it´s the evil people aiming at self-determination in Scotland (or separatists in their parlance) that are somehow creating a kneejerk reaction etc in England. 

    Reply
  23. Ron says:

    The flags google are using are coming this page:
    link to gstatic.com
     
    which is a google domain for such common internal stuff. So I’m guessing the link between the player and the flag can’t be coming from any of the sources you’d expect, ie wiki or ATP etc. It must be manual, someone in google updating a database of the players somewhere before the tournament, then feeding it into their results feed. Lets face it, google can afford to waste a few programmers time on this kind of nonsense!
     
    Still, at least it isn’t evil.

    Reply
  24. Morag says:

    I’ve been following Murray’s tennis career for a while, and he always has the saltire when you Google his name during a tournament.  It was like that when he won the US open too.  I always wondered how the flag was determined.
     
    I just checked my mother’s wiki page to see if anyone had been messing with it, but they haven’t.  She’s still Scottish.

    Reply
  25. Marker Post says:

    Official Wimbledon site has Murray as born in Scotland, country United Kingdom, with the Union Jack beside his name…

    Reply
  26. CameronB says:

    I edited the Scottish Labour wiki page back in February (badly), but the changes didn’t last the day. Childish perhaps, but it was fun. 🙂
    link to en.wikipedia.org

    Reply
  27. Yesitis says:

    CameronB
     
    North of England Labour Party – Scottish Labour 🙂

    Reply
  28. Seasick Dave says:

    I was once asked by an American where I was from and when I replied, “Scotland”, he asked, “Scotland, England?”
     
    How I laughed 🙂
     
    I suppose that I should have asked him if America was near Canada.

    Reply
  29. Big Jock says:

    Two can play that game…check out Wikipedia
     
    link to en.wikipedia.org

    Reply
  30. Simon says:

    If America was in Canada, surely? After all the latter is larger isn’t it?

    Reply
  31. Big Jock says:

    No doubt some pomme will change it back. I have changed McNish as well!

    Reply
  32. Robert Bryce says:

    Out of interest. The sharp eyed petrol heads out their would notice that Alan McNish has the saltire on his car at Le Mans (Not a union flag).
    Paul Di Resta (Formula1 Force India Team) also sports a saltire on his overalls whilst Hamilton & Button both have union flags.
    David Coultard also had a saltire on his helmet as well as is overalls.

    I’m not sure what the great Sir Jackie Stewart’s persuasion is but he did have a tartan helmet in his day 🙂 (absolutely no pun intended!)

    Reply
  33. Big Jock says:

    Checked out Jackie Stewart on Wiki. He had a Union flag and British. It said on the editor please don’t change as he raced under the Union Flag. Very good! But he had a saltire on his car so he has one on Wiki….

    Reply
  34. Robert Bryce says:

    Oh and Paul Di Resta’s big cousin (Indycar Legend) Dario Franchitti who has won 4 Indycar championships and 3 Indy500 titles also sports the saltire on his overalls & helmet.
     
    Dario proudly sports the Saltire on his official Indycar profile page.
     
    link to indycar.com

    Reply
  35. Peter says:

    Super Dario is also represented by a Saltire on the on-screen graphics during the races.  The poor english drivers are stuck not being english.  Maybe in his case it was a presonal request.
    Also why were ebc Scotlandshire  so tardy in mentioning McNish winning Les Mans?  
     

    Reply
  36. Lianachan says:

    I see the Scottish/British nationality for McNish’s wikipedia entry has turned into a bit of a tennis match.  That’s one of the reasons why I retired from editing wikipedia many years ago, the Brit Nats there just about drove me daft.  That plus the racist abuse they used to dish out.  (See http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=User_talk:Lianachan&diff=312459769&oldid=311922298 for example)

    Reply
  37. Robert Peffers says:

    Sorry to disagree, Rev Stuart, but the Bailiwick of Guernsey, Bailiwick of Jersey, Isle of Man and Republic of Ireland are indeed part of Britain, (an archipelago), but none of them are part of the United Kingdom of Great Britain & Northern Ireland (A Kingdom – not a country)

    Incidentally, except for the Republic, they are in the position of being Crown Protectorates – Note: – They ARE NOT United Kingdom Protectorates.

    Reply
  38. Robert Peffers says:

    @Chic macgregor says: 25 June, 2013 at 12:58 pm
    “Britishness is a concept peddled by the Ruling Classes to keep the restless natives under control.

    Well Chic, here’s the legal position in detail.
    Article I of the Treaty of Union establishes a bipartite United Kingdom with only two signatory, Kingdoms. That is the joint Royal Realm only.

    Article II is only about the accession and succession to the throne of the United Kingdom, (realm).

    Article III then sets up a TOTALLY NEW joint parliament. i.e. it is not a continuation of either parliament.

    In 1707 the Kingdom of England was composed of three countries with Wales annexed as part of the Kingdom of England in 1284, (Statute of Rhuddlan), & all Ireland annexed in 1582, (by the Crown of Ireland Act).

    Now for the interesting parts. On 1st May 1707 the Scottish Parliament was legally, ‘Prorogued’, and thus never actually wound up, only thus being in recess until Winnie Ewing, (a lawyer and very shrewd lady), declared the Scottish Parliament, ‘reconvened’. However, the old Westminster Parliament of England sat and ended the English Parliament.

    Now remember that in 1688 there was the English Kingdom’s, “Glorious Revolution”, that made that Kingdom of three countries a, “Constitutional Monarchy”, but Scottish Law has never been changed and has remained based upon the legal fact that the People of Scotland, not the monarchy, are sovereign. Note also the Scottish Claim of Right, 1789 and again in 1989, (incidentally the latter signed by Donald Dewar, Alistair Darling and Gordon Brown, among many other Better Together merchants.

    Reply


Comment - please read this page for comment rules. HTML tags like <i> and <b> are permitted. Use paragraph breaks in long comments. DO NOT SIGN YOUR COMMENTS, either with a name or a slogan. If your comment does not appear immediately, DO NOT REPOST IT. Ignore these rules and I WILL KILL YOU WITH HAMMERS.


  • About

    Wings Over Scotland is a thing that exists.

    Stats: 6,789 Posts, 1,222,338 Comments

  • Recent Posts

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Tags

  • Recent Comments

    • Onlooker on The Pillars Of Sanity: “Name one man executed for being a witch/warlock/whatever pish. Couldn’t, could you? Always totally ignored over the women tragically murdered.…Jul 20, 18:19
    • Onlooker on The Pillars Of Sanity: “Aye, nae bother, likes. https://www.linkedin.com/posts/nhsfife_nhsfifelifechanger-activity-6989148339782963200-BB6uJul 20, 18:14
    • Alf Baird on The Pillars Of Sanity: “The ‘A’ team in charge of Fife NHS, some of whom were also invited here to run St Andrews uni…Jul 20, 17:59
    • Fearghas MacFhionnlaigh on The Pillars Of Sanity: “An Edinburgh University webpage has this: ‘The Survey of Scottish Witchcraft 1563-1736’ https://witches.hca.ed.ac.uk/faq/Jul 20, 17:48
    • sarah on The Pillars Of Sanity: “Thank you for these facts, Robert Mellish. It is appalling that the Scottish Civil Service is officially present – not…Jul 20, 16:16
    • Mark Beggan on The Pillars Of Sanity: “Come on Rev when we getting the low down. I’m starting to argue with James…Jul 20, 15:43
    • Mark Beggan on The Pillars Of Sanity: “Fair point. How many Scots fill the Westminster corridors.Jul 20, 15:35
    • Alf Baird on The Pillars Of Sanity: “Yes James, this is of course the reality in a colonial society which is run by external interests/values, as pointed…Jul 20, 15:34
    • Lorn on The Pillars Of Sanity: “dearieme: accused ‘witches’ were nearly all women (albeit both men and children were also accused) but they were blameless of…Jul 20, 14:59
    • Lorn on The Pillars Of Sanity: ““The transcripts of NHS Fife’s Kate Searle in particular bring into sharp focus how the NHS became a partisan lynch…Jul 20, 14:44
    • James Cheyne on The Pillars Of Sanity: “Most of the Scottish government executors, advisors and Civil Servants are not born and bred backgrounds, I have just spent…Jul 20, 14:31
    • Mark Beggan on The Pillars Of Sanity: “That’s exactly what is not being said but everyone is thinking. Thanks for that sane, refreshing summary of this evil…Jul 20, 14:09
    • Mark Beggan on The Pillars Of Sanity: “You started so well and descended into ‘ how can I blame the British government for every disaster, crime, theft,…Jul 20, 14:05
    • Mark Beggan on The Pillars Of Sanity: “NHS Fife is digging the biggest of all holes in front of the whole World and the Health secretary plays…Jul 20, 13:32
    • Captain Caveman on The Pillars Of Sanity: “@Revstu On behalf of my wife, daughters and granddaughters, heartfelt thanks and gratitude to you and those other brave souls…Jul 20, 13:13
    • James Cheyne on The Pillars Of Sanity: “Rev Stu, Thank you for all you’re constant and hard work that you put in on this issue, and to…Jul 20, 12:33
    • C MacKay on The Pillars Of Sanity: “There’s a multi-coloured bus going round Glasgow with Pride markings all over it. They forget Pride’s a sin. Brilliant in-depth…Jul 20, 11:00
    • C MacKay on The Pillars Of Sanity: “Great stuff- there’s a multi-coloured bus going round Glasgow with Pride markings all over it. They forget Pride’s a sinJul 20, 10:59
    • sarah on The Pillars Of Sanity: “That is excellent, Lorn. Please send to the best newspapers for wider viewing. It makes the topic so clear and…Jul 20, 10:52
    • Grace Green on The Pillars Of Sanity: “Dearieme, Dearieme, you’ve got that all wrong! Witches were neither bad, mad, nor deluded. They were practitioners of natural medicine,…Jul 20, 10:20
    • Willie on The Pillars Of Sanity: “Excellent article Mr Campbell. Summarises very well how the wheels have now been taken off the insanity bandwagon. The transcripts…Jul 20, 08:50
    • stuckdoonhame on The Pillars Of Sanity: “Massive kudos to you, Lorn, not only for your ever sensible analysis of this nonsense but for your correct use…Jul 20, 02:20
    • stuckdoonhame on The Pillars Of Sanity: “Massive kudos to you, Lorn, not only for your ever sensible analysis of this nonsense but for your correct use…Jul 20, 02:13
    • Rob on The Pillars Of Sanity: “Its perfectly obvious that NHS Fife are trying to find something, anything, to blacken Peggies character t try and salvage…Jul 20, 00:26
    • Lorn on The Pillars Of Sanity: “The National is a disgrace as a national newspaper. Its pages are in vested with ‘trans’ dogma and its support…Jul 19, 23:23
    • dearieme on The Pillars Of Sanity: “James VI decided, later in life, that he’d been wrong about witches. They weren’t bad, they were mad. He supported…Jul 19, 22:43
    • Alf Baird on The Pillars Of Sanity: “UKSC, Court of Session and ScotGov and other state institutions all serve the English (as British) Crown, i.e. they do…Jul 19, 20:25
    • agent x on The Pillars Of Sanity: “@ Kelpie If they withdraw their defence then it becomes a default judgment and every point raised by the clamant…Jul 19, 20:03
    • agent x on The Pillars Of Sanity: “Notice also that Upton is described as “she” despite having a cock and bollocks.Jul 19, 19:34
    • Aidan on The Pillars Of Sanity: “@Kelpie – you are exactly right, that is definitely what they are planning to doJul 19, 19:22
  • A tall tale



↑ Top